‘Alcohol-related violence’, especially among young people participating in the night-time economy (NTE), has been the subject of intense public and policy debate in Australia. Previous sociological work has highlighted the relationship between men, masculinities and violence, but this relationship has received little attention in the research that tends to garner policy attention. In this article, we focus on the treatment of gender in Australian quantitative research on alcohol and violence in the NTE. We identify four ‘gendering practices’ through which such research genders alcohol and violence: de-gendering alcohol and violence through obscuring gender differences; displacing men and masculinities via a focus on environmental, geographical and temporal factors; rendering gender invisible via methodological considerations; and addressing gender in limited ways. We argue that these research practices and the policy recommendations that flow from them reproduce normative understandings of alcohol effects and lend support to gendered forms of power.
BacchiC. (2017) ‘Policies as Gendering Practices: Re-viewing Categorical Distinctions’, Journal of Women, Politics and Policy38(1): 20–41.
3.
BacchiC.GoodwinS. (2016) Poststructural Policy Analysis. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
4.
BaradK. (2007) Meeting the Universe Halfway. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
5.
BeasleyC. (2015) ‘Caution! Hazards Ahead: Considering the Potential Gap between Feminist Thinking and Men/Masculinities Theory and Practice’, Journal of Sociology51(3): 566–81.
6.
BurgessM.MoffatS. (2011) ‘The Association between Alcohol Outlet Density and Assaults on and around Licensed Premises’, Crime and Justice Bulletin147: 1–15.
CarrabineE.IganskiP.SouthN.LeeM.PlummerK. (2004) Criminology: A Sociological Introduction. London. Routledge.
9.
CarringtonK.McIntoshA.ScottJ. (2010) ‘Globalization, Frontier Masculinities and Violence: Booze, Blokes and Brawls’, British Journal of Criminology50: 393–413.
10.
CoomberK.PennayA.DrosteN.MayshakR.MartinoF.BoweS.J.MillerP.G. (2016) ‘Observable Characteristics Associated with Alcohol Intoxication within Licensed Entertainment Venues in Australia’, International Journal of Drug Policy36: 8–14.
11.
CoomberK.DrosteN.PennayA.MayshakR.MartinoF.MillerP.G. (2017) ‘Trends across the Night in Patronage, Intoxication, and Licensed Venue Characteristics in Five Australian Cities’, Substance Use and Misuse52(9): 1185–95.
12.
CoomberK.ZahnowR.FerrisJ.DrosteN.MayshakR.CurtisA., et al. (2018) ‘Short-term Changes in Nightlife Attendance and Patron Intoxication Following Alcohol Restrictions in Queensland, Australia’, BMC Public Health18(1185): 1–5.
13.
CurtisA.CoomberK.DrosteN.HyderS.MayshakR.LamT., et al. (2017) ‘Consumption Plans for the Rest of the Night among Australian Nightlife Patrons’, International Journal of Alcohol and Drug Research6(1): 19–25.
14.
De AndradeD.HomelR.TownsleyM. (2016) ‘Trouble in Paradise: The Crime and Health Outcomes of the Surfers Paradise Licensed Venue Lockout’, Drug and Alcohol Review35: 564–72.
15.
DevillyG.AllenC.BrownK. (2017) ‘SmartStart: Results of a Large Point of Entry Study into Preloading Alcohol and Associated Behaviours’, International Journal of Drug Policy43: 130–9.
16.
DonnellyN.PoyntonS.WeatherburnD. (2017) ‘The Effect of Lockout and Last Drinks Laws on Non-domestic Assaults in Sydney: An Update to September 2016’, Crime and Justice Bulletin201.
17.
DrosteN.MillerP.KaestleC.E.CurtisA.HyderS.CoomberK., et al. (2018) ‘Comparing Levels of Blood Alcohol Concentration and Indicators of Impairment in Nightlife Patrons’, Drug and Alcohol Review37(S1): S348–56.
18.
DrosteN.MillerP.PennayA.ZinkiewiczL.LubmanD.I. (2016) ‘Environmental Contexts of Combined Alcohol and Energy Drink Use: Associations with Intoxication in Licensed Venues’, International Journal of Drug Policy36: 58–66.
19.
DuffC. (2013) ‘The Social Life of Drugs’, International Journal of Drug Policy24: 167–72.
20.
FlynnA.HalseyM.LeeM. (2016) ‘Emblematic Violence and Aetiological Cul-de-sacs: On the Discourse of “One-punch” (Non) Fatalities’, British Journal of Criminology56(1): 179–95.
21.
FraserS.MooreD. (2011) ‘Governing through Problems: The Formulation of Policy on Amphetamine-type Stimulants (ATS) in Australia’, International Journal of Drug Policy22(6): 498–506.
22.
HearnJ.McKieL. (2008) ‘Gendered Policy and Policy on Gender: The Case of “Domestic Violence”’, Policy & Politics36(1): 75–91.
23.
HomanS. (2019) ‘“Lockout” Laws or “Rock Out” Laws? Governing Sydney’s Night-time Economy and Implications for the “Music City”’, International Journal of Cultural Policy25(4): 500–14.
24.
HyderS.CoomberK.PennayA.DrosteN.CurtisA.MayshakR., et al. (2018) ‘Correlates of Verbal and Physical Aggression among Patrons of Licensed Venues in Australia’, Drug and Alcohol Review37: 6–13.
25.
JayneM.ValentineG. (2016) ‘Alcohol-related Violence and Disorder: New Critical Perspectives’, Progress in Human Geography40(1): 67–87.
26.
JayneM.ValentineG.HollowayS.L. (2010) ‘Emotional, Embodied and Affective Geographies of Alcohol, Drinking and Drunkenness’, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers35(4): 540–54.
27.
KypriK.JonesC.McElduffP.BarkerD. (2011) ‘Effects of Restricting Pub Closing Times on Night-time Assaults in an Australian City’, Addiction106: 303–10.
28.
KypriK.McElduffP.MillerP. (2014) ‘Restrictions in Pub Closing Times and Lockouts in Newcastle, Australia Five Years On’, Drug and Alcohol Review33: 323–6.
29.
KypriK.McElduffP.MillerP. (2016) ‘Night-time Assaults in Newcastle 6–7 years after Trading Hour Restrictions’, Drug and Alcohol Review35: E1–2.
30.
LancasterK.RitterA. (2014) ‘Examining the Construction and Representation of Drugs as a Policy Problem in Australia’s National Drug Strategy Documents 1985–2010’, International Journal of Drug Policy25: 81–7.
31.
LatourB. (2004) ‘Why Has Critique Run Out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of Concern’, Critical Inquiry30: 225–48.
32.
LawJ. (2004) After Method. London: Routledge.
33.
Legal and Constitutional Affairs References Committee (2016) Need for a Nationally-consistent Approach to Alcohol-fuelled Violence: Interim Report. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.
34.
LiangW.ChikritzhsT. (2011) ‘Revealing the Link between Licensed Outlets and Violence: Counting Versus Measuring Alcohol Availability’, Drug and Alcohol Review30: 524–35.
35.
LindsayJ. (2012) ‘The Gendered Trouble with Alcohol: Young People Managing Alcohol Related Violence’, International Journal of Drug Policy23: 236–41.
36.
LivingstonM. (2011) ‘Alcohol Outlet Density and Harm: Comparing the Impacts on Violence and Chronic Harms’, Drug and Alcohol Review30: 515–23.
37.
McCarryM. (2007) ‘Masculinity Studies and Male Violence: Critique or Collusion?’, Women’s Studies International Forum30: 404–15.
38.
MacLeanS.DemantJ.RoomR. (2020) ‘Who or What Do Young Adults Hold Responsible for Men’s Drunken Violence?’, International Journal of Drug Policy81: 102520.
39.
MantonE.MooreD. (2016) ‘Gender, Intoxication and the Developing Brain: Problematisations of Drinking among Young Adults in Australian Alcohol Policy’, International Journal of Drug Policy31: 153–62.
40.
MazerolleL.WhiteG.RansleyJ.FergusonP. (2012) ‘Violence in and around Entertainment Districts: A Longitudinal Analysis of the Impact of Late-night Lockout Legislation’, Law and Policy34(1): 55–79.
41.
MenéndezP.TusellF.WeatherburnD. (2015a) ‘The Effects of Liquor Licensing Restriction on Alcohol-related Violence in NSW, 2008–13’, Addiction110: 1574–82.
42.
MenéndezP.WeatherburnD.KypriK.FitzgeraldJ. (2015b) ‘Lockouts and Last Drinks: The Impact of the January 2014 Liquor License Reforms on Assaults in NSW, Australia’, Crime and Justice Bulletin183.
43.
MillerP.DrosteN.de GrootF.PalmerD.TindallJ.BusijaL., et al. (2016) ‘Correlates and Motives of Pre-drinking with Intoxication and Harm around Licensed Venues in Two Cities’, Drug and Alcohol Review35: 177–86.
44.
MillerP.PennayA.DrosteN.ButlerE.JenkinsonR.HyderS., et al. (2014) ‘A Comparative Study of Blood Alcohol Concentrations in Australian Night-time Entertainment Districts’, Drug and Alcohol Review33: 338–45.
45.
MolA. (2002) The Body Multiple. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
46.
MooreD.FraserS.KeaneH.SeearK.valentinek. (2017) ‘Missing Masculinities: Gendering Practices in Australian Alcohol Research and Policy’, Australian Feminist Studies32: 309–24.
47.
MooreD.KeaneH.DuncanD. (2020) ‘Enacting Alcohol Realities: Gendering Practices in Australian Studies on “Alcohol-related Presentations” to Emergency Departments’, Sociology of Health and Illness42(1): 3–19.
48.
MurphyD.A.WilsonJ.C.MooreD. (2017) ‘Playing Hard: Young Men’s Experiences of Drinking in Inner-city Melbourne’, Journal of Sociology53(2): 398–412
49.
NepalS.KypriK.PurseyK.AttiaJ.ChikritzhsT.MillerP. (2018) ‘Effectiveness of Lockouts in Reducing Alcohol-related Harm: Systematic Review’, Drug and Alcohol Review37: 527–36.
50.
PalkG.R.M.DaveyJ.D.FreemanJ.E. (2010) ‘The Impact of Lockout Policy on Levels of Alcohol-related Incidents in and around Licensed Premises’, Police Practice and Research11(1): 5–15.
51.
PalkG.DaveyJ.FreemanJ.MorganH. (2012) ‘Perspectives on the Effectiveness of the Late Night Liquor Trading Lockout Legislative Provision’, Criminal Justice Policy Review23(4): 465–92.
52.
PienaarK.MurphyD.A.RaceK.LeaT. (2018) ‘Problematising LGBTIQ Drug Use, Governing Sexuality and Gender: A Critical Analysis of LGBTIQ Health Policy in Australia’, International Journal of Drug Policy55: 187–94.
53.
RaceK. (2014) ‘Complex Events: Drug Effects and Emergent Causality’, Contemporary Drug Problems41: 301–34.
54.
ShawR. (2010) ‘Neoliberal Subjectivities and the Development of the Night-time Economy in British Cities’, Geography Compass4(7): 893–903.
55.
ShawR. (2014). ‘Beyond Night-time Economy: Affective Atmospheres of the Urban Night’, Geoforum51(1): 87–95.
56.
ShoreC.WrightS. (2011) ‘Conceptualising Policy: Technologies of Governance and the Politics of Visibility’, in ShoreC.WrightS.PeroD. (eds) Policy Worlds. Oxford: Berghahn.
57.
TaylorN.MillerP.CoomberK.MayshakR.ZahnowR.PatafioB., et al. (2018) ‘A Mapping Review of Evaluations of Alcohol Policy Restrictions Targeting Alcohol-related Harm in Night-time Entertainment Precincts’, International Journal of Drug Policy62: 1–13.
58.
The Men’s Project and FloodM. (2018) The Man Box: A Study on Being a Young Man in Australia. Melbourne: Jesuit Social Services.
59.
TomsenS. (1997) ‘A TOP NIGHT: Social Protest, Masculinity and the Culture of Drinking Violence’, British Journal of Criminology37: 90–102.
60.
TomsenS. (2008). ‘Masculinities, Crime and Criminalisation’, in AnthonyT.CuneenC. (eds) The Critical Criminology Companion. Annandale: Hawkins Press.
61.
TownsleyM.GrimshawR. (2013) ‘The Consequences of Queuing: Crowding, Situational Features and Aggression in Entertainment Precincts’, Crime Prevention and Safety15(1): 23–47.
WaittG.JessopL.Gorman-MurrayA. (2011) ‘“The Guys in There Just Expect to be Laid”: Embodied and Gendered Socio-spatial Practices of a “Night Out” in Wollongong, Australia’, Gender, Place and Culture18(2): 255–75.
64.
WalbyS.TowersJ.FrancisB. (2014) ‘Mainstreaming Domestic and Gender-based Violence into Sociology and the Criminology of Violence’, Sociological Review62: 187–214.
65.
WilkinsonC.LivingstonM.RoomR. (2016) ‘Impacts of Changes to Trading Hours of Liquor Licences on Alcohol-related Harm: A Systematic Review 2005–2015’, Public Health Research & Practice26(4): e2641644.
66.
ZinkiewiczL.CurtisA.MeurerH.MillerP. (2016) ‘Demographic Risk Factors for Alcohol-related Aggression in and around Licensed Venues’, Alcohol and Alcoholism51(2): 196–200.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
