Research and Policy Implications of IARC's Classification of Silica as a Group 1 Carcinogen

Abstract

In 1997 the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classified crystalline silica dust exposure as a known human carcinogen, group 1. In Western countries this change in status has not resulted in any immediate shift to reduce workplace exposure, adopt new occupa tional standards, nor to marked changes in environmen tal hazard assessments. The one place where crystalline silica has been treated as an environmental carcinogen is under California's Proposition 65, which has required quantitative risk assessment to determine if exposures to carcinogens could result in greater than 1 in 100,000 excess cancer risk. There have been several peer- reviewed cancer risk assessments for silica based on ani mal, human and threshold extrapolations. This paper reviews and contrasts those determinations, discusses the impact of IARC's reassessment on research, and sug gests where future policy may lead.

Keywords

Silica International Agency for Research on Cancer Carcinogen Risk assessment California's Proposition 65

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Thoracic Society: Adverse effects of crystalline silica exposure. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1997;155:761-768.

Goldsmith DF : Risk assessment applied to environmental medicine; in Brooks SM , et al. (eds): Environmental Medicine: Concepts and Practice. St. Louis, Mosby-Year Book, 1995, pp 30-36.

Goldsmith DF, Gift JS, Grant LD (eds): Silica risk assessments. J Expo Anal Environ Epidemiol 1997;7:265-395.

Niosh : Work-Related Diseases Surveillance Report 1991, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control, US Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Cincinnati, 1991.

Abraham JL , Wiesenfeld SL : Two cases of fatal PMF in an ongoing epidemic of accelerated silicosis in oilfield sandblasters: Lung pathology and mineralogy. Ann Occup Hyg 1997; 41(suppl 1):440-447.

Weisenfeld SL , Perotta DM , Abraham JL : Epidemic of accelerated silicosis in West Texas sandblasters. 2nd Int Symp on Silica, Silicosis, and Cancer. San Francisco, Western Consortium for Public Health, 1993 , p 1.

Proposition 65 : Chemicals known to the State (of California) to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity. Scientific Advisory Board, Proposition 65, State of California Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, 1988.

CAPCOA (California Air Pollution Control Officers Association) : Air Toxics 'Hot Spots' Program, Risk Assessment Guidelines for AB 2588. California Air Pollution Control Officers Association, Risk Assessment Committee of CAPCOA, Sacramento, California 1991.

Collins JF , Marty MA : Cancer risk assessment for crystalline silica to implement California's Hot Spots Act. Scand J Work Environ Health 1995 ;21(suppl 2):99-103.

10.

Goldsmith DF , Ruble RP , Klein CO : Comparative cancer potency for silica: Human and animal extrapolations. Scand J Work Environ Health 1995;21(suppl 2):104-107.

11.

Klein AK , Christopher JP : Evaluation of crystalline silica as a threshold carcinogen: Current perspective . Scand J Work Environ Health 1995;21(suppl 2):95-98.

12.

Nurminen M. , Corvalen C. , Leigh J. , Baker G. : Prediction of silicosis and lung cancer in the Australian labour force exposed to silica. Scand J Work Environ Health 1992; 18:393-399.

13.

Worksafe Australia : Draft Technical Report on Crystalline Silica Completed in July 1992. National Occupational Health and Safety Commission, Commonwealth Information Services, Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra 1993.

14.

Leigh J. , Macaskill P. , Nurminen M. : Revised quantitative risk assessment for silicosis and silica related lung cancer in Australia. Ann Occup Hyg 1997;41(suppl 1):480-484.

15.

Dagle GE , Wehner AP , Clark ML , Buschbom RL : Chronic inhalation exposure of rats to quartz; in Goldsmith DF , Winn DM , Shy CM (eds): Silica, Silicosis, and Cancer: Controversy in Occupational Medicine. New York, Praeger, 1986, pp 255-266.

16.

Holland LM , Gonzales M. , Wilson JS , Tillery MI : Pulmonary effects of shale dusts in experimental animals; in Wagner WL , Rom WN , Merchant JA (eds): Health Issues Related to Metal and Non-Metal Mining. Boston, Butter-worth, 1983, pp 485-496.

17.

Holland LM , Wilson JS , Tillery MI , Smith DM : Lung cancer in rats exposed to fibrogenic dusts; in Goldsmith DF , Winn DM , Shy CM (eds): Silica, Silicosis, and Cancer: Controversy in Occupational Medicine. New York, Praeger, 1986, pp 267-279.

18.

Muhle H. , Takenaka S. , Mohr U. , Dasenbrock C. , Marmelstein R. : Lung tumor induction upon long-term low-level inhalation of crystalline silica . Am J Ind Med 1989; 15:343-346.

19.

Hnizdo E. , Sluis-Cremer GK : Silica exposures, silicosis, and lung cancer: A mortality study of South African gold miners. Br J Ind Med 1991; 48:53-60.

20.

Checkoway H. , Heyer NJ , Demers PA , Breslow NE : Mortality among workers in the diatomaceous earth industry. Br J Ind Med 1993;50: 586-597.

21.

Epa : US Environmental Protection Agency. Guidelines for Carcinogen Risk Assessment. Fed Register 1986;51:33992-34003.

22.

Newton PE , Pfledderer C. : Measurement of the deposition and clearance of inhaled radiolabeled particles from rat lungs. J Appl Toxicol 1986;6:113-119.

23.

Howe RB , Crump KS , Van Landingham C. : GLOBAL 86: A computer Program to Extrapolate Quantal Animal Toxicity Data to Low Doses. K.S. Crump Company, Ruston, Louisiana, 1986.

24.

Ruble R. , Goldsmith DF : A technique for estimation of silica cancer potency from occupational epidemiology studies. 2nd Int Symp on Silica, Silicosis, and Cancer. San Francisco, Western Consortium for Public Health, 1993, pp 51-58.

25.

Goldsmith DF , Hertz-Picciotto I. : Criteria for conducting quantitative risk assessments for silica. J Expo Anal Environ Epidemiol 1997;7: 376-375.

26.

Goldsmith DF , Goldsmith JR : Joint cancer risks among workers having silica, smoking, and radon exposures must be examined. Int Conf on Radiation and Health, Beer Sheva, Nov 1996.

27.

Checkoway H. , Heyer NJ , Seixas NS , Welp Eae , Demers PA , Hughes JM , et al: Dose-response associations of silica with non-malignant respiratory mortality in the diatomaceous earth industry . Am J Epidemiol 1997;145:680-688.

28.

Goldsmith DF , Wagner GR , Saffiotti U. , Rabovsky J. , Leigh J. : Future research needs in the silica, silicosis, and cancer field. Scand J Work Environ Health 1995;21(suppl 2):115-117.

29.

Salisbury AA , Melius JM , Greeley L. : Health Hazard Evaluation Report, Harbison-Walker Refractories, Fairfield Alabama, Bessemer, Alabama 1980. Cincinnati, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 1980.

30.

Burkhart JE : Health Hazard Evaluation Report, West Virginia University Pottery Shop, Morgantown, West Virginia. Morgantown, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 1991.

31.

McGlothlin JD : Health Hazard Evaluation Determination Report, LRI Industries, Chelsea, Michigan . Cincinnati, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 1980.

32.

Pryor P. , Lilis R. : Health Hazard Evaluation Determination Report, Du Co Ceramics Company, Saxonburg , Pennsylvania. Cincinnati, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 1979.

33.

Daniels WJ : Health Hazard Evaluation Report, East Leyden High School, Franklin Park, Illinois. Cincinnati , National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health , 1983.

34.

Rapiti E. , Sperati A. , Miceli M. , Forastiere F. , DiLallo D. , Cavariani F. , Goldsmith DF , Perucci CA : End-stage renal disease among silica-exposed ceramic workers. Occup Environ Med 1999;56:559-561.