Comparative performance study of traditional unidirectional airflow and novel variable temperature and velocity air supply systems on thermal comfort of medical staff in operating room
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2026
Comparative performance study of traditional unidirectional airflow and novel variable temperature and velocity air supply systems on thermal comfort of medical staff in operating room
Thermal comfort of medical staff in operating room can affect the work efficiency and have an impact on the success of surgeries. Due to the varying thermal comfort requirements of medical staff with different responsibilities, unidirectional airflow system cannot meet the thermal needs of all personnel. Therefore, a novel variable temperature and velocity air supply (VTVA) system has been introduced to investigate its impact on thermal comfort of medical staff. Since direct measurement of indoor thermal environment parameters during actual surgeries is impractical and difficult, Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulation method was adopted for this study. The distribution of thermal environment parameters and PMV-PPD indicators between unidirectional airflow and the VTVA systems were compared. It indicates that the VTVA system can create multiple thermal environment zones in the operating room, significantly improving the thermal comfort level of medical staff. When the air supply temperature on both lateral sides was within the range of 21.0–23.0°C, satisfactory thermal comfort was attained for the surgeon and the anaesthetist. CFD numerical method is an effective tool for predicting the thermal comfort of medical staff in operating room. This study provides a theoretical basis for optimizing the design of air supply systems in operating rooms.
ChenYWLiNPHeYDAYGDuYJ. Experimental study on the influence of air flow on thermal comfort in transitional spaces. Build Sci2022; 38(12): 67–75. (In Chinese).
2.
VilainRPereiraMLFelixVTribessA. Thermal comfort and local discomfort in an operating room ventilated with spiral diffuser jet. HVAC&R Res2013; 19(8): 1016–1022.
3.
DeianaGArghittuADettoriMDeriuMGPalmieriAAzaraACastigliaPMasiaMD. Ten-year evaluation of thermal comfort in operating rooms. Healthcare2022; 10(2): 307.
4.
WyonDPLidwellOMWilliamsRE. Thermal comfort during surgical operations. J Hyg1968; 66(2): 229–248.
5.
Van GaeverRJacobsVADiltoerMPeetersLVanlanduitS. Thermal comfort of the surgical staff in the operating room. Build Environ2014; 81: 37–41.
6.
ZengLJWeiXBGaoJLiuYMYeWCaoGYLiuZJCaoGQ. Factors influencing air distribution effect in clean operating rooms: a comprehensive review. J HV&AC2024; 54(5): 1–12. (In Chinese).
7.
SadrizadehSAganovicABogdanAWangCAfshariAHartmannACroitoruCKhanAKriegelMLindMLiuZMelikovAMoJRotheudtHYaoRZhangYAboualiOLangvatnHSkoldenbergOCaoG. A systematic review of operating room ventilation. J Build Eng2021; 40: 102693.
8.
CaoBZhuYOuyangQZhouXHuangL. Field study of human thermal comfort and thermal adaptability during the summer and winter in Beijing. Energy Build2011; 43(5): 1051–1056.
9.
MickoPNosekRHrabovskyPHeckoD. The effect of airflow velocity through a laminar airflow ceiling (LAFC) on the assessment of thermal comfort in the operating room. Appl Sci Basel2023; 13(8): 4860.
10.
FanMCaoGPedersenCLuSStenstadLISkogasJG. Suitability evaluation on laminar airflow and mixing airflow distribution strategies in operating rooms: a case study at St. Olavs Hospital. Build Environ2021; 194: 107677.
11.
VerheyenJTheysNAllonsiusLDescampsF. Thermal comfort of patients: objective and subjective measurements in patient rooms of a Belgian healthcare facility. Build Environ2011; 46(5): 1195–1204.
12.
MeketeGGebeyehuGJemalSFentieY. Magnitude and associated factors of intra-operative hypothermia among pediatric patients undergoing elective surgery: a multi-center cross-sectional study. Ann Med Surg2022; 75: 103338.
13.
MatosJRMcswainJRWolfBJDotyJWWilsonSH. Examination of intra-operative core temperature in joint arthroplasty: a single-institution prospective observational study. Int Orthop2018; 42(11): 2513–2519.
14.
ShenYLChenLZhouLLiuYMShenJM. Analysis and verification of the wide-mouth low-speed air curtain air supply device in operating room. Chin Hosp Archit Equip2023; 24(5): 67–71. (In Chinese).
15.
ShenYLShenJMZhuL. Research on multi-mode level I clean operating room air supply device. Chin Hosp Archit Equip2024; 25(10): 17–20. (In Chinese).
16.
ZhouBWangARenHXiaJPengFWangSCWangYCZhaoHYLiWJTanMLKosonenR. Experimental study of thermal comfort by variable temperature and velocity air supply system in operating room. Build Environ2025; 277: 112927.
17.
D’AlicandroACMauroA. Air change per hour and inlet area: effects on ultrafine particle concentration and thermal comfort in an operating room. J Aerosol Sci2023; 171: 106183.
18.
MassarottiNMauroAMohamedSNowakAJSainasD. Fluid dynamic and thermal comfort analysis in an actual operating room with unidirectional airflow system. Build. Simul-China2021; 14(4): 1127–1146.
19.
LiuCHZhouGLiH. Analysis of thermal environment in a hospital operating room. Procedia Eng2015; 121: 735–742.
20.
HoSHRosarioLRahmanMM. Three-dimensional analysis for hospital operating room thermal comfort and contaminant removal. Appl Therm Eng2009; 29(10): 2080–2092.
21.
RodriguesNJOOliveiraRFTeixeiraSFCFMiguelASTeixeiraJCBaptistaJS. Thermal comfort assessment of a surgical room through computational fluid dynamics using local PMV index. Work2015; 51(3): 445–456.
22.
GB 50333: 2013. Architectural technical code for hospital clean operating department. Beijing: China Architecture & Building Press, 2013, (In Chinese).
23.
XinLSongQJZhangYHYanTWSongPWangQM. The temperature rise of the surgeon's head and the area of the surgical field of LED surgical luminaire. China Light & Lighting2021; 6: 35–37. (In Chinese).
KhalilABassuoniMMElsamadonyMORaslanMA. Assessment of thermal comfort in operating rooms using PMV-PPD model. J Eng Res2020; 4(2): 51–62.
26.
HusainHMohd SamidiMZMeonMS. CFD Analysis of thermal comfort in hospital operation room with different air distribution design and operative temperature. J Appl Eng Des Simul2021; 1(1): 59–73.
27.
ZhaiZJOsborneAL. Simulation-based feasibility study of improved air conditioning systems for hospital operating room. Front Archit Res2013; 2(4): 468–475.
28.
WangAWangSCPengFXiaJRenHTanMLZhouB. Field questionnaire survey on thermal comfort of medical personnel in operating rooms for hospitals in Nanjing. Energy Build2025; 332: 115423.
29.
OoGMKotmoolKMongkolwongrojnM. Case study on the design optimization of the positive pressure operating room. Sci Rep2024; 14(1): 18671.
30.
CosgunAGunduztepeO. CFD-Based Lagrangian multiphase analysis of particulate matter transport in an operating room environment. Processes2025; 13(8): 2507.
31.
NielsenPV. Fifty years of CFD for room air distribution. Build Environ2015; 91: 78–90.
32.
ISO 7730: 2025. Ergonomics of the thermal environment – Analytical determination and interpretation of thermal comfort using calculation of the PMV and PPD indices and local thermal comfort criteria. Geneva: International Organization for Standardization, 2025.
33.
ISO 8996: 2021. Ergonomics of the thermal environment – Determination of metabolic rate. Geneva: International Organization for Standardization, 2021.
34.
ISO 7726: 1998. Ergonomics of the thermal environment – Instruments for measuring physical quantities. Geneva: International Organization for Standardization, 1998.
35.
ASHRAE 55: 2023. Thermal environmental conditions for human occupancy. Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, 2023.
36.
SantanaEGFSuzukiEHPradoRTAKurokawaFA. Thermal comfort and indoor air quality in hospitals in the subtropics: analysis of operating rooms and waiting rooms conditions. Indoor Built Environ2024; 33(5): 916–928.
37.
ZhouBDingLLLiFXueKNielsenPVXuY. Influence of opening and closing process of sliding door on interface airflow characteristic in operating room. Build Environ2018; 144: 459–473.
