A simulation-based investigation of the robustness of sequences of operation to zone-level faults in single-duct multi-zone variable air volume air handling unit systems
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online November, 2024
A simulation-based investigation of the robustness of sequences of operation to zone-level faults in single-duct multi-zone variable air volume air handling unit systems
High-performance sequences of operation for variable air volume (VAV) air handling units (AHUs) respond to requests from zones, leaving these sequences vulnerable to faults that occur at the zone level. While prior research has shown that ASHRAE Guideline 36 reduces energy consumption, its ability to withstand zone-level faults is understudied. This paper investigates the fault tolerance of supply air temperature (SAT) setpoint, duct static pressure (DSP) setpoint and mode of operation (MOP) in single-duct multi-zone VAV AHUs. First, customized sequences were defined for different scenarios in EnergyPlus in this study. Then, common actuator/sensor faults were injected into one zone to identify the most efficient fault-tolerant scenario. The results indicate that trim and respond reset logic is the most fault-tolerant scenario for this paper’s case study, with a 12% energy use intensity (EUI) increase for the SAT setpoint and an 11% increase for the DSP setpoint. Moreover, implementing an average temperature–based control for MOP significantly reduces the setup/setback mode activation, resulting in a lower EUI.
TorabiNGunayHBO’BrienWMoromisatoR. Inverse model-based virtual sensors for detection of hard faults in air handling units. Energy Build. 2021; 253: 111493.
2.
McHughMKIsaksonTNagyZ. Data-driven leakage detection in air-handling units on a university campus. ASHRAE Trans2019; 125: 381–388.
3.
TorabiNGunayBO’BrienWBartonT. Common human errors in design, installation, and operation of VAV AHU control systems – a review and a practitioner interview. Build Environ2022; 221: 109333.
4.
NarayanaswamyBBalajiBGuptaRAgarwalY. Data-driven investigation of faults in HVAC systems with model, cluster and compare (MCC). In BuildSys 2014 - Proceedings of the 1st ACM Conference on Embedded Systems for Energy-Efficient Buildings. Memphis, TN, USA, 3–6 November 2014, pp. 50–59.
5.
QinJWangS. A fault detection and diagnosis strategy of VAV air-conditioning systems for improved energy and control performances. Energy Build2005; 37(10): 1035–1048.
6.
KatipamulaSBrambleyM. Automated Proactive fault isolation: a key to automated commissioning. Build Eng2007; 113(Part 2): 40–51.
7.
SilvaPMBecerraVMKhooICaladoJMF. Multiple-model fault tolerant control of terminal units of HVAC systems. IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics2006; 4: 2896–2901.
8.
PritoniMLinGChenYVittiRWeyandtCGrandersonJ. From fault-detection to automated fault correction: a field study. Build Environ2022; 214: 108900.
9.
ZhangYJiangJ. Bibliographical review on reconfigurable fault-tolerant control systems. Annu Rev Control2008; 32(2): 229–252.
10.
LiuXFDexterA. Fault-tolerant supervisory control of VAV air-conditioning systems. Energy Build2001; 33(4): 379–389.
11.
YuYWoradechjumroenDYuD. A review of fault detection and diagnosis methodologies on air-handling units. Energy Build2014; 82: 550–562.
12.
PritoniMPrakashABlumDZhangKTangRGrandersonJ. Advanced control sequences and FDD technology. Just shiny objects, or ready for scale? In: Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings. Berkeley, California, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Energy Technologies Area, 2020; Chapter 3: pp300–312.
13.
ASHRAE Guideline 36-2021. High-performance sequences of operation for HVAC systems. Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-conditioning Engineers, 2021.
14.
ZhangKBlumDHGrahovacMHuJGrandersonJWetterM. Development and verification of control sequences for single-zone variable air volume system based on ASHRAE Guideline 36. In Proceedings of the American Modelica Conference. Boulder, Colorado, USA, 23-25 March 2020, vol 169, pp. 81–90.
15.
ZhangKBlumDChengHPaliagaGWetterMGrandersonJ. Estimating ASHRAE Guideline 36 energy savings for multi-zone variable air volume systems using spawn of energy plus. J Build Perform Simul2022; 15(2): 215–236.
16.
WetterMEhrlichPGautierAGrahovacMHavesPHuJRobinDZhangK. OpenBuildingControl: Digitizing the control delivery from building energy modeling to specification, implementation and formal verification. Energy2022; 238: 121501.
17.
WetterMHuJGrahovacMEubanksBHavesP. OpenBuildingControl: modeling feedback control as a step towards formal design, specification, deployment and verification of building control sequences. In: ASHRAE and IBPSA-USA building simulation conference. Chicago, IL, USA, 26-28 September 2018, pp. 775–782.
18.
ASHRAE Standard 231P. A control description language for building environmental control sequences. Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-conditioning Engineers, 2021.
19.
NassifN. Field and simulation testing and Improvement of ASHRAE Guideline 36 duct static pressure resetting algorithm. ASHRAE Trans2022; 128(1): 253–261.
20.
YoonYLiYImPBaeY. Implementation of ASHRAE Guideline 36 control logic into Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL)’s Flexible Research Platform (FRP). ORNL/TM-2022/2434. April 22, Office of Scientific and Technical Information, PO Box 62, Oak Ridge, TN 37831https://info.ornl.gov/sites/publications/Files/Pub176163.pdf
21.
LuXFuYO’NeillZ. Benchmarking high-performance HVAC rule-based controls with advanced intelligent controllers: a case study in a multi-zone system in Modelica. Energy Build2023; 284: 112854.
22.
LuXFuYO’NeillZWenJ. A holistic fault impact analysis of the high-performance sequences of operation for HVAC systems: Modelica-based case study in a medium-office building. Energy Build2021; 252: 111448.
23.
GunayBTorabiNShillinglawS. Classification of sequencing logic faults in multiple zone air handling units: a review and case study. Sci Technol Built Environ2022; 28(5): 577–594.
24.
FanW. Optimization of supply air temperature reset Schedule for single duct Vav systems. Master of Science Thesis. College Station, Texas: Texas A&M University, 2008.
25.
GunayHBNewshamGAshouriAWiltonI. Deriving sequences of operation for air handling units through building performance optimization. J Build Perform Simul2020; 13(5): 501–515.
26.
ParkMKLeeJMKangWHKimCHLeeKH. Air-handling-unit Discharge air temperature reset based on outdoor air temperature and cooling energy performance in an office building. J Energy Eng2020; 146(3): 04020013.
27.
WeiGClaridgeDETurnerWDLiuM. Choosing the right parameter for single-duct constant air volume system supply air temperature reset. J Archit Eng2005; 11(3): 76–80.
28.
Trane. Multiple-zone VAV systems: finding the right Balance for VAV energy savings. Trane Engineers Newsletter2016; 45(1): 1–8.
29.
LeeRLYChowTT. Performance of variable-air-volume air-conditioning system under reduced static pressure control in an occupied office. Archit Sci Rev2004; 47: 63–70.
30.
LiuMFengJWangZWuLZhengKPangX. Impacts of static pressure reset on VAV system air leakage, fan power, and thermal energy. ASHRAE Trans2010; 116: 428–436.
31.
ASHRAE Standard 90.1-2022. Energy standard for buildings except low-rise residential buildings. Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-conditioning Engineers, 2022.
32.
RahnamaSAfshariABergsøeNCSadrizadehS. Experimental study of the pressure reset control strategy for energy-efficient fan operation: Part 1: variable air volume ventilation system with dampers. Energy Build2017; 139: 72–77.
33.
User’s Manual. TRACE 700 building energy and economic analysis. Version 6.2, 2010. Published by Trane, Swords, Dublin, Ireland.
34.
TaylorST. Increasing efficiency with VAV system static pressure setpoint reset. ASHRAE J2007; 49(6): 24–32.
35.
RostamiMGreen-MignaccaSBuckingS. Weather data analysis and building performance assessment during extreme climate events: a Canadian AMY weather file data set. Data Brief2024; 52: 110036.
36.
GunayHBOufMNewshamGO’BrienW. Sensitivity analysis and optimization of building operations. Energy Build2019; 199: 164–175.
37.
ASHRAE Standard 62.1-2022. Ventilation for Acceptable indoor air quality. Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-conditioning Engineers, 2022.
