Recent research suggests that a time-varying indoor thermal environment can lead to energy savings and contribute to boost buildings' energy flexibility. However, thermal comfort standardization has so far considered thermal comfort criteria as constant throughout the day. In general, very little attention has been given to the ‘time of day' variable in the context of thermal comfort research. In this paper, we show some evidence of a time-varying thermal perception by using: (1) data from about 10,000 connected Canadian thermostats made available as part of the ‘Donate Your Data' dataset and (2) about 22,000 samples of complete (objective + ‘right-here-right-now' subjective) thermal comfort field data from the ASHRAE I and SCATs datasets. We observe that occupants prefer colder thermal conditions at 14:00 and progressively warmer ones in the rest of the day, indistinctively in the morning and evening. Neutral temperature differences between 08:00 and 14:00 and 14:00 and 20:00 are estimated to be of the order of 2°C. We hypothesize that the human circadian rhythm is the cause of this difference. Nevertheless, the results of this study are only based on observational data. Thermal comfort experiments in controlled environmental chambers are required to confirm these findings and to better elucidate the effects of light and circadian timing and their interaction on thermal perception.
ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2017.Thermal environmental conditions for human occupancy. Atlanta: ASHRAE, 2017.
2.
EN 16798-1.Energy performance of buildings – ventilation for buildings – part 1: indoor environmental input parameters for design and assessment of energy performance of buildings addressing indoor air quality, thermal environment, lighting and acoustics. Brussels: CEN, 2019.
3.
FangerPOOstbergOMcK. NichollAGBreumNOJerkingE.Thermal comfort conditions during day and night. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol1974; 33: 255–263.
4.
FangerPOHojbjerreJThomsenJOB.Thermal comfort conditions in the morning and in the evening. Int J Biometeorol1974; 18: 16–22.
5.
RohlesFH.The effect of time of day and time of year on thermal comfort. Proc Hum Factors Soc Annu Meet1979; 23: 129–132.
6.
RohlesFH.Thermal sensations of sedentary man in moderate temperatures. Hum Factors J Hum Factors Ergon Soc1971; 13: 553–560.
7.
ShoemakerJA, Refinetti R.Day-night difference in the preferred ambient temperature of human subjects. Physiol Behav1996; 59: 1001–1003.
8.
KakitsubaNWhiteMD.Effect of change in ambient temperature on core temperature during the daytime. Int J Biometeorol2014; 58: 901–907.
9.
NgarmpornprasertSKoetsinchaiW.The effect of air-conditioning on worker productivity in office buildings: a case study in Thailand. Build Simul2010; 3: 165–177.
10.
MishraAKLoomansMGLCHensenJLM.Thermal comfort of heterogeneous and dynamic indoor conditions – an overview. Build Environ2016; 109: 82–100.
11.
ZittingKMVujovicNYuanRKIsherwoodCMMedinaJEWangWBuxtonOMWilliamsJSCzeislerCADuffyJF.Human resting energy expenditure varies with circadian phase. Curr Biol2018; 28: 3685–3690.e3.
12.
KräuchiK.How is the circadian rhythm of core body temperature regulated?Clin Auton Res2002; 12: 147–149.
13.
HavenithG.Individual differences in thermoregulatory control, a review. Technical report number: IZF 1985-26, TNO Institute for Perception, Soesterberg, 1985.
14.
SmithRE.Circadian variations in human thermoregulatory responses. J Appl Physiol1969; 26: 554–560.
15.
WengerCBRobertsMFStolwijkJANadelER.Nocturnal lowering of thresholds for sweating and vasodilation. J Appl Physiol1976; 41: 15–19.
16.
StephensonLAWengerCBO’DonovanBHNadelER.Circadian rhythm in sweating and cutaneous blood flow. Am J Physiol Integr Physiol1984; 246: R321–R324.
17.
SmolanderJHarmaMLindgvistAKolariPLaitinenLA.Circadian variation in peripheral blood flow in relation to core temperature at rest. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol1993; 67: 192–196.
18.
GierseA.Quaemiam sit ratio caloris organii. Dissertation, Martin Luther University of Halle-Wittenberg, Halle, Saxony-Anhalt, 1842.
19.
CabanacMHildebrandtGMassonnetBStrempelH.A study of the nycthemeral cycle of behavioural temperature regulation in man. J Physiol1976; 257: 275–291.
20.
AttiaMEngelPHildebrandtG.Thermal comfort during work. Int Arch Occup Environ Health1980; 45: 205–215.
21.
HardingECFranksNPWisdenW.The temperature dependence of sleep. Front Neurosci2019; 13: 336.
22.
DuffyJFDijkD-JKlermanEBCzeislerCA.Later endogenous circadian temperature nadir relative to an earlier wake time in older people. Am J Physiol Integr Physiol1998; 275: R1478–R1487.
23.
TeraiYAsayamaMOgawaTSugenoyaJMiyagawaT.Circadian variation of preferred environmental temperature and body temperature. J Therm Biol1985; 10: 151–156.
24.
GrivelFCandasV.Ambient temperatures preferred by young European males and females at rest. Ergonomics1991; 34: 365–378.
25.
PöllmannL.Circadian and circannual variations in the evaluation of thermal comfort in a constant climate. Indoor Built Environ1994; 3: 145–148.
26.
MiuraTTachibanaT.Optimal office temperature for telephone operators. J Sci Labour1949; 25: 220–226 (in Japanese).
27.
KimHETokuraH.Effects of time of day on dressing behavior under the influence of ambient temperature fall from 30°C to 15°C. Physiol Behav1994; 55: 645–650.
28.
de DearRJBragerGS.Developing an adaptive model of thermal comfort and preference. ASHRAE Trans1998; 104: 145–167.
29.
McCartneyKJNicolFJ.Developing an adaptive control algorithm for Europe. Energy Build2002; 34: 623–635.
30.
HuchukBO’BrienWSannerS.A longitudinal study of thermostat behaviors based on climate, seasonal, and energy price considerations using connected thermostat data. Build Environ2018; 139: 199–210.
31.
KaneMBSharmaK. Data-driven identification of occupant thermostat-behavior dynamics. ArXiv:1912.06705, 2019, http://arxiv.org/abs/1912.06705 (accessed 13 July 2021).
32.
StoppsHTouchieMF.Managing thermal comfort in contemporary high-rise residential buildings: using smart thermostats and surveys to identify energy efficiency and comfort opportunities. Build Environ2020; 173: 106748
33.
HuchukBSannerSO’BrienW.Comparison of machine learning models for occupancy prediction in residential buildings using connected thermostat data. Build Environ2019; 160: 106177.
34.
Földváry LičinaVCheungTZhangHde DearRParkinsonTZhouX, et al. Development of the ASHRAE Global Thermal Comfort Database II. Build Environ2018; 142: 502–512.
35.
TartariniFSchiavonSPythermalcomfortA Python package for thermal comfort research. SoftwareX2020; 12: 100578.
36.
SchweikerMSchakib-EkbatanKFuchsXBeckerS.A seasonal approach to alliesthesia. Is there a conflict with thermal adaptation?Energy Build2020; 212: 109745.
37.
de DearR.Revisiting an old hypothesis of human thermal perception: alliesthesia. Build Res Inf2011; 39: 108–117.
38.
CheungTBragerGParkinsonTLiPSchiavonS.Analysis of the accuracy on PMV – PPD model using the ASHRAE Global Thermal Comfort Database II. Build Environ2019; 153: 205–217.
39.
ParkinsonTde DearRBragerG.Nudging the adaptive thermal comfort model. Energy Build2020; 206: 109559.
40.
GaggeAPFobeletsAPBerglundLG.A standard predictive index of human response to the thermal environment. ASHRAE Trans1986; 92: 709–731.
41.
GonzalezRRNishiYGaggeAP.Experimental evaluation of standard effective temperature a new biometeorological index of man’s thermal discomfort. Int J Biometeorol1974; 18: 1–15.
42.
GaggeAPStolwijkJAJHardyJD.Comfort and thermal sensations and associated physiological responses at various ambient temperatures. Environ Res1967; 1: 1–20.
43.
YanHMaoYYangL.Thermal adaptive models in the residential buildings in different climate zones of Eastern China. Energy Build2017; 141: 28–38.
44.
KimJTartariniFParkinsonTCooperPde DearR.Thermal comfort in a mixed-mode building: are occupants more adaptive?Energy Build2019; 203: 109436.
45.
de DearRBragerGCooperD.Developing an adaptive model of thermal comfort and preference. SF-98-7-3 (4106) (RP-884). ASHRAE Trans1998; 104: 145–167.
46.
Ole FangerPToftumJ.Extension of the PMV model to non-air-conditioned buildings in warm climates. Energy Build2002; 34: 533–536.
NicolFRoafS.Pioneering new indoor temperature standards: the Pakistan project. Energy Build1996; 23: 169–174.
49.
DuffyJFCzeislerCA.Effect of light on human circadian physiology. Sleep Med Clin2009; 4: 165–177.
50.
KimSJeongW.Influence of illumination on autonomic thermoregulation and choice of clothing. Int J Biometeorol2002; 46: 141–144.
51.
Te KulveMSchellenLSchlangenLJMvan Marken LichtenbeltWD.The influence of light on thermal responses. Acta Physiol (Oxf)2016; 216: 163–185.
52.
ChangA-MSanthiNSt HilaireMGronfierCBradstreetDSDuffyJFLockleySWKronauerRECzeislerCA.Human responses to bright light of different durations. J Physiol2012; 590: 3103–3112.
53.
FialaDLomasKJStohrerM.First principles modeling of thermal sensation responses in steady-state and transient conditions. ASHRAE Trans2003; 109: 179–186.
54.
KrauchiKWirz-JusticeA.Circadian rhythm of heat production, heart rate, and skin and core temperature under unmasking conditions in men. Am J Physiol Integr Physiol1994; 267: R819–R829.
55.
KräuchiKKonieczkaKRoescheisen-WeichCGompperBHauensteinDSchoetzauAFraenklSFlammerJ.Diurnal and menstrual cycles in body temperature are regulated differently: a 28-day ambulatory study in healthy women with thermal discomfort of cold extremities and controls. Chronobiol Int2014; 31: 102–113.
56.
CuestaMBoudreauPCermakianNBoivinDB.Skin temperature rhythms in humans respond to changes in the timing of sleep and light. J Biol Rhythms2017; 32: 257–273.
57.
KräuchiK.Circadian clues to sleep onset mechanisms. Neuropsychopharmacology2001; 25: S92–S96.
58.
KräuchiKCajochenCWerthEWirz-JusticeA.Functional link between distal vasodilation and sleep-onset latency?Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol2000; 278: R741–R748.
59.
HaghayeghSKhoshnevisSSmolenskyMHDillerKRCastriottaRJ.Before-bedtime passive body heating by warm shower or bath to improve sleep: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sleep Med Rev2019; 46: 124–135.
