Ventilation Rates and Unsatisfied Percentage from Indoor CO 2 Concentration

Abstract

This work reports the results of a survey carried out on a hall in a historic building in Palermo (Italy) with the aim of assessing the air quality by means of objective measurement of carbon dioxide (CO₂) concentration and its subjective evaluation through a questionnaire. The measured values of CO₂ concentration were compared with those evaluated using the Meckler equation under steady-state conditions, having verified necessary parameters such as the constancy of the indoor and outdoor CO₂ levels and the uniformity of the CO₂ generation rate for all the occupants. The positive correspondence between measured and calculated results allowed us to utilise, under differing circumstances, the values of the natural ventilation rates achieved in steady-state conditions. By using measured and calculated data, an experimental assessment of the relationships between the CO₂ concentration levels and the number of occupants and their level of satisfaction was performed. The indoor air quality level in the hall, evaluated by means of the experimental data, was compared with the subjective responses expressed through a specific multiple choice questionnaire handed out to the occupants. A comparison between the calculated ventilation rates and those required by the main American and European standards shows that natural ventilation in the hall is often insufficient according to these standards which have regard for the minimum requirements for air acceptability. In addition, some general observations on the thermal condition of the hall have been drawn from a comparison between microclimate parameters and the subjective opinions provided by the occupants.

Keywords

Building occupancy Carbon dioxide Demand-controlled ventilation Indoor air quality Natural ventilation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aghemo C. , Filippi M. , Prato E. : Environmental Conditions for the Conservation of Relevant Historical and Artistic Artworks. Torino, Comitato Giorgio Rota, 1994.

Filippi M. , Lombardi C. , Silvi C. : On the conservation of historical and artistic artworks: CDA Condizionamento , Riscaldamento, Refrigerazione 1994;4:487-493.

Filippi M. : Ambient conditions for the conservation of artworks: CDA Condizionamento, Riscaldamento, Refrigerazione 1996;6:719-733.

UNI 10829 : Works of Art of Historical Importance - Ambient Conditions for the Conservation - Measurement and Analysis . Milano, UNI Ente Nazionale Italiano di Unificazione , 1999.

UNI 10969 : General Principles for the Choice and the Control of the Microclimate to Preserve Cultural Heritage in Indoor Environments. Milano, UNI Ente Nazionale Italiano di Unificazione, 2002.

Ansi /ASHRAE Standard 62-2001: Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality. Atlanta GA, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers , 2001.

EN 13779 : Ventilation for Non-Residential Buildings - Performance Requirements for Ventilation and Room-Conditioning Systems, 2003.

Ansi /ASHRAE Standard 62.1-2004: Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality. Atlanta GA, American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers , 2004.

Columba M. , Costanzo S. , Pietrafesa M. , Rizzo G. : Annotations on the applicability to residential buildings of the E.U. ventilation rates for acceptable IAQ: in Proceedings of International Congress Healthy Indoor Air’94, Anacapri, Napoli , 1994, pp. 39-44.

10.

Emmerich SJ , Persily AK : State-of-the-Art review of CO2 demand controlled ventilation technology and application: National Institute of Standards Technical Report NISTIR 6729, Building and Fire Research Laboratory, Architectural Energy Corporation, Boulder Colorado, USA, 2001.

11.

Emmerich SJ , Persily AK : A literature review on CO2-based demand controlled ventilation: ASHRAE Tran 1997;103(2):229-243.

12.

ASTM Designation D 6245-98 Standard: Guide for Using Indoor Carbon Dioxide Concentrations to Evaluate Indoor Air Quality and Ventilation. American West Conshohocken, PA, Committee D-22 and Subcommittee D22.05, American Society for Testing Materials, 1998.

13.

Bencko V. : Health risk of indoor air pollutants: a central European perspective : Indoor Environ 1994;3:213-223.

14.

Lawrence TM , Braun JE : A methodology for estimating occupant CO2 source generation rates from measurements in small commercial buildings : Build Environ 2007;42: 623-639.

15.

Costanzo S. , Cusumano A. , Milone D. , Giaconia G. : A survey for the preservation of the wooden ceiling of the Hall of Barons of the Steri : in Proceedings of International Conference on ‘‘Conservation of the Historic Wooden Structures’’ , Firenze, Vol. 1, 2005, pp. 335-343.

16.

Costanzo S. , Cusumano A. , Di Maio F. , Giaconia C. , Giaconia G. : Monitoring in heritage buildings: in Proceedings of Indoor Air Conference’ 05, Beijing, China, 2005, pp. 942-946.

17.

Costanzo S. , Cusumano A. , Giaconia C. , Giaconia G. : Preservation of the artistic heritage within the seat of the chancellorship of the University of Palermo: a proposal on a methodology regarding an environmental investigation according to Italian standards: Build Environ 2006;4:1847-1859.

18.

Bologna F. : The Ceiling of the Sala Magna of the Steri Palace in Palermo. Palermo, Ed. Flaccovio, 1975.

19.

Hummelgaard J. , Juhl P. , Sæbjörnsson KO , Clausen G. , Toftum J. , Langkilde G. : Indoor air quality and occupant satisfaction in five mechanically and four naturally ventilated open-plan office buildings: Build Environ 2007;42:4051-4058.

20.

Meckler M. : Evaluating IAQ compliance in buildings utilizing carbon dioxide level monitoring : in Proceedings of IAQ’92, San Francisco CA, 1993.

21.

Leephakpreeda T. , Thitipatanapong R. , Grittiyachot T. , Yungchareon V. : Occupancy-based control of indoor air ventilation: a theoretical and experimental study: Sci Asia 2001;27:279-284.

22.

Jokl MV : New units for indoor air quality: decicarbdiox and decitvoc: Int J Biometeorol 1998;42:93-111.

23.

Buratti C. , Ricciardi P. , Simoncini C. : The thermo-hygrometrical well being in classrooms: first results of an experimental survey carried out at the Universities of Perugia and Pavia according to a new adaptive model: in Proceedings of 5th National Congress CIRIAF, Perugia, 2005.