Evaluation of Simplified Procedure for Indoor Daylight Illuminance Determination against Data in Scale Model Measurements

Abstract

An accurate estimation of the amount of daylight entering a building is the key step in evaluating daylighting designs. The concept of the daylight coefficient (DC), which considers changes in the luminance of the sky elements, offers an effective way of computing indoor daylight illuminances under various sky conditions and solar positions. We currently propose a numerical procedure in the form of nomograph to compute the interior daylight illuminance using the DC concept. This paper presents the work to validate this method via scale model measurements under different actual sky patterns. It was shown that daylight illuminances calculated by the proposed method were in reasonably good agreement with measured results. The findings will hopefully provide building professionals and students with a reliable and simple alternative to current practices that incorporate sky luminance variations to predict the indoor daylight illuminance and assess visual performance under various real sky conditions.

Keywords

Daylight factor Daylight coefficient CIE standard skies Sky luminance Scale model

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Escuyer S , Fontoynont M : Lighting Controls : A Field Study of Office Workers’ Reactions : Lighting Res Technol 2001;33(2): 77-96 .

Lam JC , Li DHW , Cheung SO : An Analysis of Electricity End-use in Air-conditioned Office Buildings in Hong Kong : Building Environ 2003;38(3): 493-498 .

Hopkinson GR , Petherbridge P , Longmore J : Daylighting. London, UK, Heinemann , 1966.

Littlefair PJ : Predicting Hourly Internal Daylight Illuminances for Dynamic Building Energy Modeling. Garston, UK, Building Research Establishment, Garston , 1989.

Tregenza PR , Waters IM : Daylight Coefficients : Lighting Res Technol 1983; 15(2): 65-71 .

Li DHW , Lam JC , Lau CCS : A Study of Solar Radiation Daylight Illuminance and Sky Luminance Data Measurement for Hong Kong : Architectural Sci Rev 2002;45(1): 21-30 .

CIE : S 011/E. Spatial distribution of daylight - CIE standard general sky. Standard, CIE Central Bureau, Vienna , 2003.

Kittler R , Darula S , Perez R : A Set of Standard Skies. Bratislava, Polygrafia , 1998.

Galasiu AD , Atif MR : Applicability of Daylighting Computer Modelling in Real Case Studies : Comparison Between Measured and Simulated Daylight Availability and Lighting Consumption: Building Environ 2002; 37(4): 363-377 .

10.

Mansy K : A User-friendly Procedure to Visualize the hourly Quantitative Performance of Daylighting Systems : Solar Energy 2004; 77(4): 373-380 .

11.

Betman E : Daylight Calculations Using Constant Luminance Curves : Renewable Energy 2005;30(2): 241-257 .

12.

Aizlewood ME , Littlefair PJ : Daylight Prediction Methods: A Survey of their Use . Proceedings of the CIBSE national Lighting Conference 1996, Bath, UK, 1996, 126-140 .

13.

Jones PJ , Alexander D , Marsh A , Burnett J : Evaluation of Methods for Modelling Daylight and Sunlight in High Rise Hong Kong Residential Buildings : Indoor Built Environ 2004;13(4): 249-258 .

14.

Li DHW , Lau CCS , Lam JC : A Simplified Procedure Using Daylight Coefficient Concept for Sky Component Prediction : Architectural Sci Rev 2004;47(3): 287-294 .

15.

Li DHW , Cheung GHW , Lau CCS : A Simplified Procedure for Determining Indoor Daylight Illuminance Using Daylight Coefficient Concept : Building Environ 2006;41(5): 578-589 .

16.

Li DHW , Lau CCS , Lam JC : A Study of 15 Sky Luminance Patterns Against Hong Kong Data : Architectural Sci Rev 2003;46(1): 61-68 .

17.

Kittler R , Darula S , Perez R : Advantages of New Sky Standards: More Realistic Modelling of Daylight Conditions in Energy and Environmental Studies : International J Energy, Environ Econ 1999;8: 65-71 .

18.

Cesarano A , Bellia A , Minichiello L , Sibilio S : Sky Luminance Models: Sensitivity to Skydome Subdivision : Lighting Res Technol 1996;28(3): 131-140 .

19.

Tregenza PR : Subdivision of the Sky Hemisphere for Luminance Measurements : Lighting Res Technol 1987;19(1): 13-14 .

20.

Tregenza PR : The Sensitivity of Room Daylight to Sky Brightness : Architectural Sci Rev 1999;42(2): 129-132 .

21.

CIE - Commission Internationale de l’E-clairage: Guide to recommended practice of daylight measurement. Wien, CIE, 1994.

22.

Tregenza PR , Sharples S : New Daylight Algorithms. University of Sheffield , 1995.

23.

Waldram PJ : A Measuring Diagram for Daylight Illumination. London, Batsford , 1950.

24.

Tregenza PR : Analysing Sky Luminance Scans to Obtain Frequency Distributions of CIE Standard General Skies : Lighting Res Technol 2004;36(4): 271-281 .

25.

Li DHW , Lam, JC : An Analysis of All-sky Zenith Luminance Data for Hong Kong : Building Environ 2003;38(5): 739-744 .

26.

Oteiza P , Soler A : Experimental analysis for Madrid, Spain, of a Simple Graphic Daylight Calculation Method Based on the CIE Standard Overcast Sky : Building Environ 1997;32(4): 363-366 .

27.

Gugliermetti F , Grignaffini S : Shafts for Daylighting Underground Spaces : Sizing Guidelines: Lighting Res Technol 2001; 33(3): 183-195 .

28.

Li DHW , Lau CCS , Lam JC : Predicting Daylight Illuminance by Computer Simulation Techniques : Lighting Res Technol 2004; 36(2): 113-129 .

29.

Navvab M : Scale Model Photometry . Proceedings of Istanbul 2001 - International Lighting Congress, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey, 12-14 September 2001, pp. 299-306 .

30.

Lam JC , Li DHW : Daylight Availability in Hong Kong and Energy Implications : Intl J Ambient Energy 1996;17(2): 79-88 .

31.

Gugliermetti F , Grignaffini S , Bisegna F : Computer Simulations, Full and Scale Model Measurements as Design Tools to Assess Daylight Factors in Underground Open Space . Proceedings of Istanbul 2001 - International Lighting Congress, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey, 12-14 September 2001, pp. 519-526 .

32.

Greenup P : SSLD Sky Model, www.radiance-online.org/patches/ssld/SSLDalgorithmwithPDF.zip, 2003.

33.

Li DHW , Lau CCS , Lam JC : Predicting Daylight Illuminance on Inclined Surfaces Using Sky Luminance Data : Energy - The Intl J 2005;30(9): 1649-1665 .