Assessment of Nasal Swab Samples,Environmental Microbiological Analyses and Respiratory Function Tests of Bakery Workers Working Under Modern Conditions: A Brief Report

Abstract

Studies have shown that bakery workers may develop asthma and rhinitis as a result of their occupation and approximately 30% of bakery workers and wheat farmers will become sensitised. This ratio can change depending on the exposure time and a history of atopy. The present study has looked at the relationship between nasal and environmental flora and pulmonary function in such workers to see if it can explain the occurrence of asthma and rhinitis. Workers from three of the largest bakery companies in Istanbul were recruited, a total of 372 people; 223 bakery workers and 149 administrative employees of the same companies as a control group. Face to face interviews were conducted to determine asthma status and all were given physical examinations with nasal flora samples collected by sterile swabs. Aerial samples were taken from administrative and product departments for microscopic examination. Compared to administrative staff, bakery workers had insignificantly more asthma symptoms (p> 0.05).C. albicanswas isolated from four (1.9%) nasal samples from bakery workers and one (0.7%) from the control group (p> 0.05). A statistically significant level of wheeze (X²= 4.65, p= 0.03, OR= 2.32 95% CI (1.06–5.07)), suggesting bronchial obstruction, was detected in 28 (13.1%) bakery workers and in nine people (6.1%) from the control group. Looking at smoking and non-smoking groups, a significant decrease was observed for PEF (%) in the smokers and FEV1/FVC (%) in the non-smokers. These results suggest that pulmonary function of bakery workers is slightly impaired even with modern engineering controls.

Keywords

Bakery workers Lung function Environmental microbiology FVC FEV1 FEF25–75 PEF

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Houba R , Doekes G , Heederik D : Occupational Respiratory Allergy in Bakery Workers : A Review of the Literature: Am J Indust Med. 1998;34(6): 529–546 .

Baur X , Degens PO , Sander I : Baker's Asthma: Still Among the Most Frequent Occupational Respiratory Disorders : Allergy Clin Immunol. 1998;102(6 Pt 1): 984–997 .

Droste J , Myny K , Van Sprundel M , Kusters E , Bulat P , Braeckman L , Vermeire P , Vanhoorne M : Allergic Sensitization, Symptoms, and Lung Function Among Bakery Workers as Compared with a Non-exposed Work Population : J Occup Environ Med 2003;45(6): 648–655 .

Ige OM , Awoyemi OB : Respiratory Symptoms and Ventilatory Function of the Bakery Workers in Ibadan, Nigeria : West Afr J Med 2002;21(4): 316–318 .

Shamssain MH : Respiratory Symptoms and Pulmonary Function in Flour Processing Workers in the Baking Industry : Am J Indust Med 1995;27(3): 359–365 .

Bohadana AB , Massin N , Wild P , Kolopp MN , Toamain JP : Respiratory Symptoms and Airway Responsiveness in Apparently Healthy Workers Exposed to Flour Dust : Europ Respir J 1994;7(6): 1070–1076 .

Baur X , Degens P , Sander I : Baker's Asthma: Still Among the Most Frequent Occupational Respiratory Disorders : J Allergy Clin Immunol 1998; 102: 984–997 .

Zotti De R , Bovenzi M , Negro C : Specific Inhalation Challenge with Wheat Flour in Workers with Suspected Baker's Asthma : Int Arch Occup Environ Hlth 1999;72: 335–337 .

Xu X , Christiani C , Dockery DW , Wang L : Exposure Response Relationships Between Occupational Exposures and Chronic Respiratory Illness : A Community-based Study: Am Rev Respir Dis 1992;146: 413–418 .

10.

Heederik D , Kromhout H , Kromhout D , Burema J , Biersteker K : Relations Between Occupation, Smoking, Lung Function, and Incidence and Mortality of Chronic Non-specific Lung Disease : The Zutphen Study: Br J Indust Med 1992;49: 299–308 .

11.

Zuskin E , Kanceljak B , Schachter E.N , Godnic-Cvar J , Mustajbegovic J , Budak A : Respiratory Function and Immunological Status in Cocoa and Flour Processing Workers : Am J Indust Med 1998;33: 24–32 .

12.

Thiel H : Problems of Occupationally Induced Respiratory Allergies as Exemplified by Bakers' Asthma : Derm Beruf Umwelt 1987;35(3): 81–91 .

13.

Bergmann VI , Rebohle E , Wallenstein G , Gemeinhardt H , Thrumer H : Frequency and Importance of Mold Sensitization in Bakery Workers : Allerg Immunol (Leipz) 1976;22(3): 297–301 .

14.

Nittner-Marszalska M , Wojcicka-Kustrzeba I , Bogacka E , Patkowski J , Dobek R : Skin Prick Test Response to Enzyme Enolase of the Baker's Yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) in Diagnosis of Respiratory Allergy : Med Sci Monit 2001;7(1): 121–124 .

15.

Smith TA , Smith PW : Respiratory Symptoms and Sensitization in Bread and Cake Bakers : Occup Med (London) 1998;48(5): 321–328 .

16.

Çetin ET , TÖreci K , Vural T : Results of Microbiological Controls of the Sterilization Equipment and Operating-room Performed Between January 1976 and June 1977 in Surgical Clinics in Istanbul : Turkish J Microbiol (Turkish) 1978;8: 39–56 .

17.

Dawson B , Trapp RG : Research Questions About Two Separate or Independent Groups: Basic and Clinical Biostatistics, 3rd edn. New York, McGraw Hill , 2001, pp. 132–161.

18.

Williams REO , Blowers R , Garod LP , Shooter RA : Hospital Infection: Causes and Prevention, 2nd edn. London, Lloyd–Luke Ltd , 1966.

19.

Chia KS , Chia SE , Tan WC , Jeyaratnam J : Baker's Asthma: A Case Report : Ann Acad Med Singapore 1990;19(3): 407–409 .

20.

Murphy TR , Sheffer AL : Occupational Asthma: A Case of Baker's Asthma : Allergy Asthma Proc 2004;25(3): 151–156 .