Modern day risks from asbestos, especially in environmental settings, have been questioned. The concerns associated with stringent regulation of asbestos are mostly no longer voiced in regulatory communities. As a result of the World Trade Center (WTC) event in 2001, issues relating to the actual risks of asbestos in building materials have re-surfaced. Regulatory agencies, through their policy statements, have downplayed the risks associated with the WTC event of asbestos in debris and dust which covered the surrounding area. These statements now question past practices and requirements associated with asbestos as mandated by these same agencies. It is suggested that such statements by asbestos regulatory agencies will reduce and lower the current regulatory requirements, and change the direction of regulatory policy. This paper discusses risks from asbestos and the possible future direction of regulatory standards for these minerals in the United States. Future risks from ‘‘hazardous’’ materials, it is suggested, should be based on actual scientific facts, with less influence from social and political factors.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
1 Jaffery SAMT, Burdett GJ, Rood AP: An investigation of airborne asbestos concentrations in two U.K. buildings: before, during and after removal of asbestos . Int J Environ Studies1988;32: 169–180 .
2.
2 Dobrovolsky L: Asbestos in the countries of Central and Eastern Europe . Indoor Built Environ1998;7: 122–123 .
3.
3 Hoskins JA: Mineral fibres and health . Indoor Built Environ2001;10: 244–251 .
4.
4 Maltoni C: Call for an international ban on asbestos . Toxicol Indust Hlth2000;15: 529–531 .
5.
5 Health Effects Institute – Asbestos Research: Asbestos in Public and Commercial Buildings: A Literature Review and Synthesis of Current Knowledge. MA, Cambridge , 1991.
6.
6 Mossman GT, Gee JBL: Asbestos-related diseases . New Eng J Med. 1989;320: 1721–1730 .
7.
7 Mossman GT, Bignon J, Corn M, Seaton A, Gee JBL: Asbestos: scientific developments and implications for public policy . Science1990;247: 294–301 .
8.
8 Ross M: The schoolroom asbestos abatement program: a public policy debacle . Environ Geology1995;26: 182–188 .
9.
9 Lange JH: Airborne asbestos concentrations during abatement of floor tile and mastic: evaluation of two different containment systems and discussion of regulatory issues . Indoor Built Environ2001;10: 193–199 .
10.
10 Lange JH, Thomulka KW: An evaluation of personal airborne asbestos exposure measurements during abatement of drywall and floor tile/mastic . Intl J Environ Hlth Res2000;10: 5–19 .
11.
11 Lange JH: Impact of asbestos concentrations in floor tile on exposure during removal . Intl J Environ Hlth Res2002;12: 293–300 .
12.
12 Lange JH, Kaiser G, Thomulka KW: Environmental site assessments and audits . Environ Manag1994;18: 151–160 .
13.
13 Lange JH: Has the World Trade Center Tragedy established a new standard for asbestos? Indoor Built Environ2001;10: 346–349 .
14.
14 US Department of Labor: OSHA National News Release – OSHA, EPA, Update asbestos data. Continue to reassure public of contamination fears. September 14, 2001. www.epa.gov and www.OSHA.gov. Washington, DC .
15.
15 US Department of Labor: OSHA National News Release – EPA and OSHA web sites provide environmental monitoring data from World Trade Center and surrounding areas, data confirms no significant public health risks; rescue crews and nearby residents should take appropriate precautions. October 3, 2001. www.epa.gov and www.OSHA.gov, Washington, DC .
16.
16 US Environmental Protection Agency: EPA response to September 11, 2001; Through September 30, 2001; www.epa.gov, Washington, DC.
17.
17 New York City Department of Health, Bureau of Environmental Investigations: Asbestos (ACM) Fact Sheet. 2001; New York, NY .
18.
18 Jenkins C: World Trade Center Asbestos, memorandum. December 3, 2001, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC .
19.
19 Environmental Protection Agency: Asbestoscontaining materials in schools: final rule and notice. 40 CFR 763 appendix A to subpart E. (Federal Register October 30, 1987;52:41825– 41905), Washington, DC .
20.
20 Langer A, Morse R: The World Trade Center Catastrophe: was the type of spray fire proofing a factor in the collapse of the Twin Towers? Indoor Built Environ2001;10: 350–360 .
21.
21 Ilgren EB: Health risks from Exposures to asbestos and inorganic metals due to collapse of the World Trade Center: An environmental residential survey . Indoor Built Environ2001;10: 361–383 .
22.
22 New York City Department of Health, 2002, Response to the World Trade Center disaster: environmental health questions following the World Trade Center disaster. New York, NY , February, 2001. (www.nyc.gov/html/doh/html/alerts/allpress.html).
23.
23 US Environmental Protection Agency: Lower Manhattan dust cleanup: comprehensive plan to address the concerns of lower Manhattan residents about the impacts of the WTC collapse on indoor air quality. (May 8, 2002), www.epa.gov, Washington, DC .
24.
24 US Environmental Protection Agency: EPA and Colonial school district settle alleged violations of asbestos inspection and management rules. October 26, 2001, EPA Region 3, Press Release, Philadelphia, PA .
25.
25 Attorney General of Massachusetts: Attorney General Reilly files $30K settlement for asbestos violations in Worchester. December 20, 2001, Press Release.
26.
26 Sunday Gazette-Mail Online: State safety inspectors monitor WTC. October 28, 2001, Charleston, WX .
27.
27 Chippewa Hazardous Waste Remediation & Energy, Inc. and Trustees of the Ohio Valley Christian Center of the Assemblies of God vs. United States Environmental Protection Agency, Administrative Complaint and Notice of Opportunity for Hearing, Docket No.: CAA-3-2002-0144, Region III, Philadelphia, PA.
28.
28 John H. Lange vs. Wilmington Area School District, Complaint in Mandamus, United States Federal Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, Civil Action, U.S.D.C. No. 00-2278, Pittsburgh, PA. (Citizen Suit under the Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act, 40CFR 763).
29.
29 USA Today, 2002. Anxieties over toxins rise at ground zero. Page one-one and six-six, February 7, 2002, Gannett Co., Inc.
30.
30 US Occupational Safety and Health Administration: Occupational Safety and Health Standards, Title 29 Code of Federal Regulations 1910 and 1926. US Department of Labor , 1996, Washington, DC .
31.
31 American Conference of Industrial Hygienists. Documentation of the TLVs and BEIs. Cincinnati, OH , 2001.
32.
32 US Environmental Protection Agency: Asbestos EPA model training manual. Washington, DC , 2001.
33.
33 Ilgren E, Chatfield E: Coalinga fibre – a short, amphibole-free chrysotile part 2: evidence for lack of tumourigenic activity . Indoor Built Environ2001;7: 18–31 .
34.
34 Allegheny County Health Department: HealthBeat, Teen Smoking, July/August, 2000, Pittsburgh, PA .
35.
35 Morbidity Mortality Weekly Report: Youth tobacco surveillance – United States, 2000, November 2, 2001;50(SS04): 1–84 .
36.
36 Morbidity Mortality Weekly Report: Cigarette smoking among adults – United States, 1999, October 12, 2001;50(40): 869–873 .
37.
37 Morbidity Mortality Weekly Report: Reducing tobacco use, a report of the Surgeon General. December 22, 2000;49(RR16): 1–27 .
38.
38 Lee PN, Thornton AJ: A critical commentary on views expressed by IARC in relation to environmental tobacco smoke and lung cancer . Indoor Built Environ1998,7:3: 129–145 .
39.
39 Fry JS, Lee PN: Revisiting the association between environmental tobacco smoke exposure and lung cancer risk . Indoor Built Environ2000;9: 303–316 .
40.
40 Bernard J, Gee L: Smoking and occupational lung disease epidemiology . Indoor Built Environ1999;8: 132–135 .
41.
41 Witorsch P: Effects of environmental tobacco smoke exposure on pulmonary function and respiratory health in adults: Update 1997 . Indoor Built Environ1998;7: 4–17 .
42.
42 Thornton AJ, Lee PN: Parental smoking and risk of childhood cancer: A review of the evidence . Indoor Built Environ1998;7: 65–86 .
43.
43 Witorsch RJ, Witorsch P: Environmental tobacco smoke and respiratory health in children: A critical review and analysis of the literature from 1969 to 1998 . Indoor Built Environ2000;9: 246–264 .
44.
44 Environ Corporation: Evaluation of worker exposure to airborne fibers during the removal of resilient floor coverings and asphaltic cutback adhesives using recommended work practices. (May 1, 1992), Prepared for Resilient Floor Covering Institute and Armstrong World Industries, Inc., Arlington, VA , 1992.
45.
45 Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Area and personal airborne exposure during abatement of asbestos-containing roofing material . Bull Environ Contamination Toxicol2000;64: 673–678 .
46.
46 Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Occupational exposure to airborne asbestos during abatement of asbestos-containing pipe and boiler insulation . Fresenius Environ Bull2000;9: 477–482 .
47.
47 Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Air sampling during asbestos abatement of floor tile and mastic . Bull Environ Contamination Toxicol2000;64: 497–501 .
48.
48 Lange JH, Sites SLM, Thomulka KW: Airborne lead exposure to workers during activity as part of a building demolition project . Indoor Built Environ1998;7: 210–216 .
49.
49 Lange JH, Sites SLM, Thomulka KW: Personal sample measurements of airborne lead during abatement procedures . Bull Environ Contam Toxicol1997;58: 659–666 .
50.
50 Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Effectiveness of engineering controls for airborne lead exposure during renovation/demolition of a commercial building . Indoor-Built Environ2000;9: 207–215 .
51.
51 Davis JMG, Addison J, Bolton RE, Donaldson K, Jones AD, Smith T: The pathogenicity of long versus short fiber samples of amosite asbestos administered to rats by inhalation and intraperitoneal injection . Br J Exp Path1986;67: 415–430 .
52.
52 Wagner JC, Griffiths DM, Hill RJ: The effect of fibre size after inoculation with UICC crocidolite . Br J Cancer1984;49: 455–458 .
53.
53 Ilgren E: Mesotheliomas of animals: a comprehensive tabular compendium of the world’s literature, CRC Press, Boca Ratan, FL , 1993.
54.
54 Ilgren E, Chatfield E: Coalinga fibre – A short, amphibole – free chrysotile. Part 1: Evidence for a lack of fibrogenic activity . Indoor Built Environ1997;6: 264–276.
55.
55 Walton WH: The nature, hazards and assessment of occupational exposure to airborne asbestos dust: a review . Ann Occup Hyg1982;25: 117–247 .
56.
56 Timbrell V: Deposition and retention of fibers in the human lung . Ann Occup Hyg26: 347–369 .
57.
57 Wright A, Cowie H, Gormley IP, Davis JMG: The in vitro cytotoxicity of asbestos fibers: I. P388D1 cells . Am J Ind Med9: 371–384 .
58.
58 Mlynarek S, Corn M, Blake C: Asbestos exposure of building maintenance personnel . Regulatory Toxicol Pharmacol1999;23: 213–224 .
59.
59 Yeung P, PatienceK, Apthorpe L, Willocoks D: An Australian study to evaluate worker exposure to chrysotile in the automotive service industry . Appl Occup Environ Hyg1999;14: 448–457 .
60.
60 Massey DG, Fournier-Massey G: Asbestos removal from buildings: a review . Hawaii Med J1987;46: 153–157 .
61.
61 Bozzelli JW, Russell JF: Airborne asbestos levels in several schools before and after bulk asbestos removal . Int J Environ Studies1982;20: 27–30 .
62.
62 Savolainen H, Cosca-Sliney R, Guillemin M: Detection of occupational exposure to inorganic fibres by urinary fibre analysis . Occup Hyg1996;3: 351–357 .
63.
63 Wong O: Malignant mesothelioma and asbestos exposure among auto mechanics: appraisal of scientific evidence . Regulatory Toxicol Pharmacol2001;34: 170–177 .
64.
64 Lange JH: A statistical evaluation of asbestos air concentrations . Indoor Built Environ1999:8: 293–303 .
65.
65 Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Airborne exposure concentrations during asbestos abatement of ceiling and wall plaster . Bull Environ Contam Toxicol2002;69: 712–718 .
66.
66 Lange JH: Occupational exposure during removal of windows with lead-based paint and asbestos caulking . Bull Environ Contam Toxicol2001;66: 146–149 .
67.
67 Lange JH, Thomulka KW: Personal airborne exposure to asbestos during removal of asbestos-containing window caulking and floor tile/ pipe insulation . Fresenius Environ Bull2001;10: 688–691 .
68.
68 Lange JH, Kuhn BD, Thomulka KW, Sites SLM: A study of matched area and personal airborne asbestos samples: evaluation for relationship and distribution . Indoor Built Environ2000;9: 192–200 .
69.
69 Spencer JW, Plisko MJ, Ralzer JL: Asbestos fiber release from the brake pads of overhead industrial cranes . Appl Occup Environ Hyg1999;14: 397–402 .
70.
70 BBC News: NY firefighters report illness. October 31, 2001, http://news.bbc.co.uk
71.
71 Trout D, Nimgade A, Mueller C, Hall R, Earnest GS: Health effects and occupational exposures among workers near the World Trade Center Disaster site . J Occup Environ Med2002;44: 601–605 .
72.
72 Prezant DJ, Weiden M, Banauch GI et al. Cough and bronchial responsiveness in firefighters at the World Trade Center Site . N Engl J Med2002;347: 806–815 .
73.
73 Lange JH (2002) Letter to the Editor to Prezant DJ, Weiden M, Banauch GI et al. Cough and bronchial responses in firefighters at the World Trade Center site . N Engl J Med348: 76–77 .
74.
74 Chippewa Hazardous Waste, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, Environmental hearing Board Dicket Number 2002-295L 10-22-02 Assessment of Civil Penalty, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.
75.
75 Maremont M, Sandberg J: Weighing risks: tests say air is safe, but some people feel ill near ground zero-irritants causing symptoms are not known dangers: much remains uncertainfearful, the luckers leave . The Wall Street Journal, 2001: CCXXVIII (December 26, 2001).
76.
76 Oliver LC, Sprice NL, Greene R: Asbestos related disease in public school custodians . Am J Indust Med1991;19: 303–316 .
77.
77 Garcia-Closas M, Christiani DC: Asbestosrelated diseases in construction carpenters . Am J Indust Med1995;27: 115–125 .
78.
78 John H. Lange v. Allegheny County Health Department, Case Number GD99-14638 (Complaint), Violation by County under the EPA Asbestos Worker Protection Rule, Pittsburgh, PA, 1999.
79.
79 Armstrong BG: Confidence intervals for arithmetic means of lognormality distribution exposures . Am Indust Hyg Assoc J1992;53: 481–485 .
80.
80 Seixas NS, Robins TG, Moulton LH: Use of geometric and arithmetic mean exposures in occupational epidemiology . Am J Indust Med1998;14: 465–477 .
81.
81 Letters to the Editor: A log-normal distribution-based exposure assessment method for unbalanced bias . Ann Occup Hyg1998;42: 413–422 .
82.
82 Lange JH: Health effects of respirator use at low airborne concentrations . Medical Hypotheses2000;54: 1005–1007 .
83.
83 Allegheny County Health Department: Toxic hazardous air pollutants, asbestos abatement. Pittsburgh, PA , 1996.
84.
84 United States Court of Appeals: American iron and steel Institute and Bethlehem Steel Corporation vs. Occupational Safety and Health Administration . Federal Reporter Second Series (DC Cir.), 1991;939: 975–1010 .
85.
85 National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health: Manual of Analytical Methods, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Cincinnati, Ohio , 1977.
86.
86 Spence SK, Rocchi PSJ: Exposure to asbestos fibres during gasket removal . Ann Occup Hyg1996;40: 583–588 .
87.
87 New York City Transit Authority, Respondent v. New York State Department of Labor et al., Appellants, 88 N.Y. 2d 225, 666 N.E. 1336, 644 N.Y.S.2d 463, 1996.
88.
88 OSHA: Standards Interpretation and Compliance letters, OSHA’s jurisdiction over volunteer fire fighters. December 30, 1991, Washington, DC .
89.
89 Lange JH, Weyel DA, Rosato LM, Tucker D, Malek DE, Mayernick JA, Ryan L: Preliminary results of smoking patterns for workers attending an asbestos abatement course . Scand Journal Work Environ Hlth1987;62: 459-459 .
90.
90 Lange JH: A survey of cigarette smoking patterns among asbestos abatement workers attending an initial training course . Intl J Environ Studies1992;42: 73–79 .
91.
91 Lange JH: A questionnaire survey during asbestos abatement refresher training for frequency of respirator use, respirator fit testing and medical surveillance . J Occup Med Toxicol1993;2: 65–74 .
92.
92 Osinubi OY, Afilaka AA, Doucette J, Golden A, Soriano T, Rovner E, Anselm E: Study of smoking behavior in asbestos workers . Am J Ind Med2002;41: 62–69 .
93.
93 Bang KM, Kim JH: Prevalence of cigarette smoking by occupation and industry in the United States . Am J Indust Med2001;40: 233–239 .
94.
94 Lange JH, Thomulka KW: (2002) Smoking prevalence of asbestos workers – a comment – Letter to the Editor – Am J Indust Med44: 218–219 .
95.
95 Ravenholt, RT: Tobacco impact on twentieth-century US mortality patterns . Am J Preventative Med1986;1: 4–15 .
96.
96 Hilt B, Langard S, Lund-Larsen PG, Lien JT: Previous asbestos exposure and smoking habits in the country of Telemark, Norway – a cross sectional population study . Scand J Work Environ Health1986;12: 561–566 .
97.
97 Roe FJC: How much cancer is occupationally derived . Indoor Environ1993;2: 38–42 .
98.
98 Godish, T: Sick Buildings: Definition, Diagnosis and Mitigation, Lewis Press , 1995.
99.
99 Vitel C: The quality of the air in our buildings . Indoor Built Environ2001;10: 266–270 .
100.
100 Brown SK: Air toxics in a New Australian dwelling over an 8-month period . Indoor Built Environ2001:10: 160–166 .
101.
101 Singh J: Occupational exposure to moulds in buildings . Indoor and Built Environ2001;10: 172–178 .
102.
102 Saphir A: Jekyll and Hyde: a new license for thalidomide . J Natl Cancer Institute1997:89: 1480–1481 .
103.
103 Custer WV, Kertsscher ET: The development of judicial policy on the phenomenon of multiple chemical sensitivity in the post-Daubert era . Tox Ind Hlth1999;15: 428–431 .
104.
104 Brautbar N: Science and the law: scientific evidence, causation, admissibility, reliability ‘‘Daubert’’ decision revisited . Tox Ind Health1999;15: 532–551 .
105.
105 Weetman DF: Who can tell? Indoor Environ1993;2: 1–3 .
106.
106 Levin S, Herbert R, Skloot G, Szeinuk J, Teirstein A, Fischler D, Milek D, Piligian G, Wilk-Rivard E, Moline J: Health effects of the World Trade Center site workers . Am J Ind Med2002;42: 545–547 .
107.
107 Malievskaya E, Rosenberg N, Markowitz S: Assessing the health of immigrant workers near ground zero: preliminary results of the World Trade Center day laborer medical monitoring project . Am J Ind Med2002:42: 548–549 .
108.
108 US Environmental Protection Agency. EPA Response to Sept 11, New scheduling and cancellation policies announced airborne asbestos testing data now available deadline for assistance requests extended to December 28 residential cleaning and testing is underway contract consumer warning: beware phony contractors work begins on pilot cleaning study remaining exterior cleanup work underway sign up now for cleanup and/or testing. Washington, DC (http://www.epa.gov)
109.
109 Shufro J: Perspective on the tragedy at the World Trade Center . Am J Ind Med2002:42: 557–559 .
110.
110 European Environmental Agency (2001). Late lesions from early warnings: the precautionary principle 1896–2000. Environmental Issues Report 22, European Environmental Agency, Copenhagen, Denmark (Internet www.eea.eu.int).
