Exposure to Carbon Monoxide in Enclosed Multi-Level Parking Garages in the Central Athens Urban Area

Abstract

This study is a first attempt concerning the estimation of carbon monoxide (CO) levels in enclosed parking ga rages in the Athens urban area. Indoor air monitoring was conducted on randomly selected days, in autumn 1999, at six downtown enclosed garages. In each garage, different sites were chosen in relation to garage configu ration for the monitoring of CO levels, and all sites were monitored concurrently. A portable electrochemical CO monitor was used to record the CO concentration every 15 s. It was found that there were excesses for both short- and long-term exposure limits to CO. The results showed that CO levels varied significantly over site, time and day of measurement. Mean exit site/indoor site ratios of CO levels ranged from 0.2 to 0.8. Indoor CO con centration patterns at different sites are discussed, and the main variables affecting CO levels are explained. Descriptive statistics and graphical displays are present ed.

Keywords

Carbon monoxide Air quality monitoring Indoor air quality .Enclosed parking garage Occupational exposure limits

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Touloumi G. , Katsouyanni K. : Air pollution in the Athens Basin: Secular trends, daily fluctuations and correlation between air pollutants. Arch Hellen Med 1990;7:97-103.

Katsouyanni K. , Kalandidi A. , Tomos P. , Trichopoulos D. : Atmospheric pollution and lung cancer. Arch Hellen Med 1990;7:145-149.

Pantazopoulou T. , Kremastinou T. , Katsouyianni K. : Short-term effects of atmospheric pollution on emergency hospital out-patient visits and admissions in the Greater Athens area. Arch Hellen Med 1990;7:139-144.

Duci A. , Chaloulakou A. , Spyrellis N. : Exposure of city residents to CO in Athens urban area: Microenvironmental studies of personal CO exposures. Environmental Science and Technology, Proc 6th Int Conf, Samos, August-September 1999, vol A, pp 156-163.

Vellopoulou AV , Ashmore MR : Personal exposures to carbon monoxide in the city of Athens. 1. Commuters' exposures. Environ Int 1998; 24:713-720.

Flachsbart PG : Methodological trends in the design of recent microenvironmental studies of personal CO exposure. Atmos Environ 1988; 22:2093-2099.

Rossi RJ : Evaluating carbon monoxide impacts from enclosed parking garages. Air & Waste Management Association 1991;1-16. 84th Annu Meet Exhibition, Vancouver, June 1991.

Chan MY , Burnett J. , Chow WK : Personal exposure to carbon monoxide in underground car parks in Hong Kong . Indoor Built Environ 1997;6:350-357.

Wallace LA : Carbon monoxide in air and breath of employees in an underground office. J Air Pollut Control Assoc 1983;33:678-682.

10.

Chow WK : On ventilation design for underground car parks. Tunneling Underground Space Technol 1995;10:225-245.

11.

Chow WK : Simulation of carbon monoxide level in enclosed car parks using an air flow network program. Tunneling Underground Space Technol 1996;11:237-240.

12.

Papakonstantinou K. , Duci A. , Chaloulakou A. , Markatos N. : Numerical approach and experimental measurements of CO concentrations in enclosed garages. 3th Natl Conf Chem Eng, Athens, May-June 2001.

13.

Coburn RF , Foster RE , Kane PB : Consideration of the physiological variables that determine the blood carboxy-hemoglobin concentration in man. J Clin Invest 1965 ;44:1899-1910.

14.

Peterson JE , Stewart RD : Predicted the carboxy-hemoglobin levels result from carbon monoxide exposure. J Appl Physiol 1975;39: 633-638.

15.

EPA: Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide. External Review Draft, 1999.

16.

Chaloulakou A. , Fili N. , Spyrelis N. : Occupational exposure to CO concentrations in enclosed garages: Estimation of blood COHb levels. Environmental Pollution, Proc 5th Int Conf, Thessaloniki , August-September 2000, pp 934-940.

17.

Wadden RA , Scheff PA : Indoor Air Pollution: Characterization, Prediction, Control. New York, Wiley & Sons, 1983 .

18.

Who : Air Quality Guidelines for Europe. Geneva, WHO, 1987.

19.

Who : Update Revision of Air Quality Guidelines for Europe. Geneva, WHO, 1994.

20.

Heckerling P. , Leikin J. , Maturen A. , Terzian C. , Segarra D. : Screening hospital admissions from the emergency department for occult carbon monoxide poisoning. Am J Emerg Med 1990;8: 301-304.

21.

Gasman J. , Varon J. , Gardner J. : Revenge of the barbecue grill - Carbon monoxide poisoning. West J Med 1990; 153:656-657.

22.

Thom S. , Keim L. : Carbon monoxide poisoning: A review - Epidemiology, pathophysiology, clinical findings, and treatment options including hyperbaric therapy. Clin Toxicol 1989;27: 141-156.

23.

Schwar M. , Booker J. , Tait L. : Car park pollution exposure of operatives and the general public. Clean Air 1999;27:129-138.

24.

Kolb H. , Werner R. , Mohnl H. , Pechinger U. : Observation of carbon monoxide concentrations in the vicinity of a multi-story urban garage with a single roof level source. Atmos Environ 1982; 16:2625-2630.