Differences in injury mortality between the Nordic countries - with special reference to differences in coding practices

Abstract

The aims of the study are to analyse the incidence and patterns in injury mortality in the Nordic countries, and to assess the extent to which any differences found can be explained in terms of either variation in statistical validity or the existence of genuine differences. The study considers the entire injury panorama, and is performed between certain categories of injuries. Analysis is applied to all ages, and also to certain specific age categories. Finland appears as the Nordic country with the highest injury mortality. While examining potential source of errors, nothing was found to merit an adjustment of Finland's rate. All potential correction would bring the rates of the other Nordic countries closer to that of Finland. Poisoning was found to be a diagnosis that varies in application between the Nordic countries. Falling is the diagnosis with the greatest problems of sensitivity, and cannot be recommended for comparative purposes.

Keywords

cause of death Finland ICD injuries Scandinavia sensitivity.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Nomesko , Health Statistics in the Nordic Countries 1966-91. Helsestatistik for de nordiske lande 1966-91. Copenhagen, 1991.

Yearbook of Nordic Statistics. The Nordic Council, The Nordic Statistical Secretariat 1972-90.

Nomesko , Nordisk dösårsagsstatistsk. Analyse af kodepraksis (Nordic cause-of-death statistics. Analysis of coding practice). Copenhagen: 1985 (in Norwegian).

Moyer LA , Boyle CA , Pollock DA Validity of death certificates for injury-related causes of death . Am J Epidemiol 1989; 130: 1024-32.

WHO-collaborating Centre for the Classification of Diseases in the Nordic Countries. A bibliography on literature on ICD and other health-related classifications. 3rd ed. Uppsala, 1994.

Sainsbury P. Validity and reliability of trends in suicide statistics. World Health Statistics Q 1983 ; 36: 339-48.

Kolmos L. Selvmordsregistreringens pålidelighed i de nordiske lande. En analyse av dödsårsagsstatistiken i et år (Validity of registrations of suicides in the Nordic countries. An analysis of cause-of-death statistics over one year) . Odense: Odense University: Psykiatrisk Institut, 1981 (in Danish).

Giertsen JC , Morild I. Påliteligheten av den norske selvmordsstatistikken (Reliability of Norwegian suicide statistics). Nord Med 1993 ; 108: 58-9 (in Norwegian).

Allebeck P. , Allgulander C. , Henningsohn L. , Jakobsson SW Causes of death in a cohort of 50,465 young men - validity of recorded suicide as underlying cause of death. Scand J Soc Med 1991; 19: 242-7.

10.

Guldvog B. , Thorgersen A. , Ueland Ö. Ulykker, vold og selvpåfört skade. Personskaderapport (Accidents, violence and self-inflicted injuries). Oslo: Statens Institutt for Folkehelse, 1992 (in Norwegian).

11.

Poikolainen K. Dödligheten i alkoholförgiftning i Dan-mark, Finland, Norge och Sverige (Deaths from alcohol poisoning in Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden). Nord Med 1979; 94: 90-2 (in Swedish).

12.

Honkanen R. , Koivumaa-Honkanen H. , Smith G. Males as a high-risk group for trauma: the Finnish experience. J Trauma 1990; 30: 155-62.

13.

Lindahl Bib , Johansson LA Multiple cause-of-death data as a tool for detecting artificial trend in the underlying cause statistics: a methodological study. Scand J Soc Med; 22: 145-58.

14.

Jansson B. , Johansson LA , Rosén M. , Svanström L. National adaptions of the ICD Rules for Classification - a problem in the evaluation of cause-of-death trends. J Clin Epidemol 1997; 50: 367-75.

15.

Reports from conferences.

16.

Sundhetsstyrelsen , Dödsårsagerne. Cause of death in Denmark. Copenhagen: 1960-93.

17.

Statistics Finland. Cause of death. Helsinki: 1964-93.

18.

Norges offisielle stastitikk. Causes of death. Oslo: 1964-93.

19.

Statistiska centralbyrån. Causes of death. Stockholm: 1960-93.

20.

Who. International Classification of Diseases. 1975 revision. Vol. 1. Geneva, 1977.

21.

Rättsmedicinalverket. Underlag för riktlinjer inom rättsmedicin och rättskemi vid dödsorsaksutredningar. (A foundation for national guiding principles in forensic medicine and the chemistry of cause-of-death analysis). Stockholm, RMV-rapport 1993: 2.