Comparison between blood analysis and police assessment of drug and alcohol use by injured drivers

Abstract

Official statistics for alcohol/drug use by drivers can influence the introduction of intervention measures against impaired driving. Thus, the validity of official statistics is important. Since official statistics are based on police assessment of inebriation, the present study was aimed at investigating this issue by comparing blood analysis with the rate of police detection of alcohol/drug use by injured drivers. All injured motor vehicle drivers who were hospitalized (HD) (Umeå: n = 104) and all fatally-injured drivers (FD) who were autopsied (Umeå, Northern Sweden: n = 110; Gothenburg, Western Sweden: n= 133) from May 1991 through Dec 1993 were tested for alcohol and both licit and illicit drugs. The findings of the blood analyses were compared with police assessment of inebriation. In the HD, the police suspected inebriation in 13% (n= 13) whilst blood analyses showed drug and/or alcohol in 18% (n = 19) of the drivers (sensitivity 69%; specificity 97%). In the FD, the police suspected inebriation in 7% (n = 16) of the drivers whilst blood analyses showed drug and/or alcohol in 23% (n = 57) of the drivers (sensitivity 53%; specificity 100%). The blood alcohol-positive HD who the police suspected to be inebriated had significantly higher mean blood alcohol concentrations than those not suspected. To avoid biased statistics, official statistics on inebriation of injured drivers should be based on blood analysis of drug/alcohol and not on police assessment.

Keywords

drugs alcohol crashes police injuries fatally-injured official statistics inebriation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Holmgren P , Loch E , Schuberth J. Drugs in motorists travelling Swedish roads: on-the-road-detection of intoxicated drivers and screening for drugs in these offenders . Forensic Sci Int 1985; 27: 57–65.

Official Statistics of Sweden . Traffic injuries. Statistics Sweden ,; 1992.

Öström M , Eriksson A , Björnstig U. Reliability of Swedish alcohol statistics in traffic fatalities: a comparison between official statistics and blood analysis . J Traffic Med 1993; 21: 171–6.

Sjögren H , Björnstig U , Eriksson A , Öhman U , Solarz A. Drug and alcohol use among injured motor vehicle drivers in Sweden- Prevalence, driver, crash and injury characteristics . Alcoholism: Clin & Expt Res. 1997; 21: (in press).

Eklund A , Jonsson J , Schubert J. A procedure for simultaneous screening and quantification of basic drugs in liver, utilizing capillary gas chromatography and nitrogen sensitive detection . J Anal Toxicol 1983; 7: 24–8.

Committee on Injury Scaling . The Abbreviated Injury Scale. AIS-90. Arlington Heights, IL: American Association Automotive Medicine; 1990.

Altman D. Practical Statistics for Medical Research. London: Chapman & Hall; 1994.

Colton T. Statistics in Medicine. Boston: Little Brown; 1974.

Webb G. A filter model to describe bias in official statistics on alcohol-related injuries . Accid Anal Prev 1995; 27: 687–97.

10.

Rosman D , Knuiman MW. A comparison of hospital and police road injury data . Accid Anal Prev. 1994; 26: 215–22.

11.

Barancik J , Fife D. Discrepancies in vehicular crash injury reporting: Northeastern Ohio Trauma Study IV . Accid Anal Prev 1985; 17: 147–54.

12.

Bull J , Roberts BJ. Road accident statistics: a comparison of police and hospital information . Accid Anal Prev 1973; 5: 45–53.

13.

Öström M , Huelke DF , Waller PF , Eriksson A , Blow F. Some bias in the alcohol investigative process in traffic fatalities . Accid Anal Prev 1992; 24: 539–45.

14.

Orsay E , Doan-Wiggins L , Lewis R , Lucke R , RamaKrishnan V. The impaired driver: Hospital and police detection of alcohol and other drugs of abuse in motor vehicle crashes . Ann Emerg Med 1994; 24: 51–5.

15.

Maull K , Kinning LS , Hickman JK. Culpability and accountability of hospitalized injured alcohol-impaired drivers . JAMA 1984; 252: 1880–3.

16.

Hansen A , Popkin CL , Campbell BJ , Burton JH , Waller PF. Comparison of police and physician judgements of injury severity and inebriation in motor vehicle crash victims. 35th Annual Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, Toronto, Canada, 1991; 249–60.

17.

McLaughlin J , Smith RJ , Mattice CR , Scholten DJ. Hospitalization and injury influence on the prosecution of drunk drivers . Am Surg 1993; 59: 488–9.

18.

van Wyngaarden M , Cushing B , Kerns T , Dischinger P. Police perception of intoxication among injured pedestrians . J Emerg Med 1995; 13: 21–6.

19.

Soderstrom C , Cowley RA. A national alcohol and trauma center survey: missed opportunities, failures of responsibility . Arch Surg 1987; 122: 1067–71.

20.

Soderstrom C , Birschbach J , Dischinger PC. Injured drivers and alcohol use: culpability, convictions, pre-and post-crash driving history . J Trauma 1990; 30: 1208–14.

21.

Lillis R , Good RG , States JD. Correlates of detection of injured drinking drivers . J Traffic Med 1993; 21: 147–52.

22.

Lillis R , Good RG , States JD. Post treatment driving records of injured impaired drivers. 39th Annual Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, Chicago, Illinois, 1995; 79–86.

23.

US Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration . Drug evaluation and classification training. 1993.

24.

Soderstrom C , DuPriest RW , Benner C , Maekawa K , Cowley RA. Alcohol and roadway trauma: problems in diagnosis and management . Am Surg 1979; 45: 129–36.

25.

Waller P , Stewart RJ , Hansen AR , Stutts JC , Popkin CL , Rodgman EA. The potientiating effects of alcohol on driver injury . JAMA 1986; 256: 1461–6.

26.

Chang G , Astrochan B , Weil U , Bryant K. Reporting alcohol-impaired drivers: results from a national survey of emergency physicians . Ann Emerg Med 1992; 21: 284–90.