A New Method for Investigating the Relation between Change and Initial Value in Longitudinal Blood Pressure Data: I. Description and Application of the Method

Abstract

The relation between change and initial value is of great interest in longitudinal studies. With variables containing random errors (short-term intra-individual variations and measurement errors) the directly computed relation is however, biased by the regression towards the mean phenomenon. Earlier proposed solutions of the problem are unsatisfactory. In this paper the regression towards the mean phenomenon is described and a new method is proposed by which the error caused by the regression towards the mean is avoided. The method is applied to a set of longitudinal blood pressure data. It is shown that the observed, biased relation in this case is significantly negative, while the correct relation obtained with this method is significantly positive. Since random errors are present in most biological variables, similar erroneous conclusions may easily be drawn also in other cases if the regression towards the mean phenomenon is not corrected for. In this analysis, random errors constitute 65–80% of the observed blood pressure change. To reduce this dominance, recommendations about study design for future studies of change/initial value relationships are given.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Armitage, P. : Statistical Methods in Medical Research. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, 1971.

2. Armitage, P. , Fox, W. , Rose, G. A. & Tinker, C. M. : The variability of measurements of casual blood pressure. II. Survey experience. Clin Sci 30:337-344, 1966.

3. Bevan, A. T. , Honour, A. J. & Stott, F. H. : Direct arterial pressure recording in unrestricted man. Clin Sci 36:329-344, 1969.

4. Blomqvist, N. : On the relation between change and initial value. J Am Stat Ass 72, dec 1977.

5. Blomqvist, N. & Svärdsudd, K. : A new method for investigating the relation between change and initial value from longitudinal blood pressure data. II. Comparison with other methods. Scand J Soc Med. To be published.

6. Evans, J. G. & Rose, G. : Hypertension. Br Med Bull 27:37-42, 1971.

7. Feinleib, M. Halperin, M. & Garrison, R. J.: Relationship between blood pressure and age. Regression analysis of longitudinal data. Paper presented at the 97th Annual Meeting of the American Public Health Association, Philadelphia, November 10-14, 1969.

8. Garside, R. F. : Letters to the editor. On the analysis of repeated measurements of the same subjects. J Chron Dis 16:445-146, 448-449, 1963.

9. Garside, R. F. : Letters to the editor. On the analysis of repeated measurements of the same subjects. J Chron Dis 16:1219-1220, 1963.

10.

10. Gerende, L. J. : Some methodological problems in the study of the natural history of blood pressure: an examination of the Framingham Study data. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor, Mich., 1962.

11.

11. Grimby, G. , Bjure, J. , Aurell, M. , Ekström-Jodal. B. , Tibblin, G. & Wilhelmsen, L. : Work capacity and physiologic responses to work. Am J Card 30:37-41, 1972.

12.

12. Grimby, G. , Wilhelmsen, L. , Ekström-Jodal, B. , Aurell, M. , Bjure, J. & Tibblin, G. : Aerobic power and related factors in a population study of men aged 54. Scand J Clin Lab Invest 26:289-294, 1970.

13.

13. Kihlberg, J. K.: An inquiry on the distribution of arterial blood pressure in groups of middle-aged male Caucasians. Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, 1962. Cited by Labarthe (14).

14.

14. Labarthe, D. : Variation in serial blood pressure readings of individuals in defined population: description and relation to subsequent mortality. Ph.D. Thesis. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor, Mich., 1974.

15.

15. Miall, W. E. & Lovell, H. G. : Relation between change of blood pressure and age. Br Med J ii: 660-664, 1967.

16.

16. Oldham, P. D. : A note on the analysis of repeated measurements of the same subjects. J Chron Dis 15:969-977, 1962.

17.

17. Oldham, P. D. : Letters to the editor. On the analysis of repeated measurements of the same subjects. J Chron Dis 16:447-448, 449-450, 1963.

18.

18. Oldham, P. D. : Letters to the editor. On the analysis of repeated measurements of the same subjects. J Chron Dis 16:1217-1219, 1963.

19.

19. Ragland, R. & Costiloe, J. P. : Letters to the editor. On the repeated measurements of the same subjects. J Chron Dis 16:1215-1216, 1963.

20.

20. Richardson, D. W. , Honour, A. J. , Fenton, G. W. , Stott, F. H. & Pickering, G. W. : Variation in arterial pressure throughout the day and night. Clin Sci 26:445-460, 1964.

21.

21. Rose, G. : Seasonal variation in blood pressure in man. Nature 189:235, 1961.

22.

22. Snedecor, G. W. & Cochran, W. G. : Statistical Methods. The Iowa State University Press, Ames, Iowa, 1967.

23.

23. Sokolow, M. , Werdegar, D. , Perloff, D. B. , Cowan, R. M. & Brenenstuhl, H. : Preliminary studies relating portably recorded blood pressures to daily life events in patients with essential hypertension. In Psycho-somatics in Essential Hypertension. Bibl Psychiat 144:164-189, 1970.

24.

24. Thomson, G. H. : A formula to correct for the effect of errors of measurement on the correlation of initial values with gains. J Exp Psychol 7:321-324, 1924.

25.

25. Thorndike, E. L. : The influence of the chance imperfections of measures upon the relation of initial score to gain or loss. J Exp Psychol 7:225-232, 1924.

26.

26. Thorner, R. M. : A cohort study of the blood pressure of 444 healthy white males. J Chron Dis 15:117-130, 1962.

27.

27. Tibblin, G. : High blood pressure-men aged 50. A population study of Men Born in 1913. Acta Med Scand. Suppl. 470, 1976.

28.

28. Tibblin, G. : A population study of 50-year-old men. An analysis of the non-participant group. Acta Med Scand 178:453, 1965.

29.

29. Wilder, J. : Das “Ausgangswert-Gesetz”, ein unbeachtetes biologisches Gesetz und seine Bedeutung für Forschung und Praxis. Ztscr f. d. Ges. Neurolog. u. Psychiat. 137:317-338, 1931.

30.

30. Wilder, J. : Stimulus and Response. The Law of Initial Value. John Wright & Sons, Bristol, 1967.

31.

31. Wilhelmsen, L. , Berglund, G. & Werkö, L. : Prevalence and management of hypertension in a general population sample of Swedish men. Preventive Medicine 2:57-66, 1973.