National Healthcare Planning and the Internal Market: A Conceptual View on the Impact of EU Law on Member States' Regulatory Autonomy in the Field of Healthcare
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online March, 2015
National Healthcare Planning and the Internal Market: A Conceptual View on the Impact of EU Law on Member States' Regulatory Autonomy in the Field of Healthcare
Public healthcare is a fundamental task of welfare states. Its real character is ambiguous though as, on the one hand, healthcare is a cornerstone of social security while, on the other, it is an enormous economic sector. At the same time, maintenance of healthcare services constitutes one of the biggest financial burdens on public budgets and will remain so for the foreseeable future.
In order to cope with this challenging subject matter, Member States have evolved a wealth of healthcare regulations. Considering the potential cross-border economic activity in the healthcare sector by patients and healthcare providers, the question of the compatibility of national healthcare planning with European Union Law arises. This article analyses how Member States' healthcare planning is both limited and preserved by European primary law and by the CJEU's case law. The study reveals a surprising result.
AbbingH.R. (2010) ‘Social Justice and Healthcare Systems in Europe’, European Journal of Health Law, 17, 217–22.
2.
AbbingH.R. (2013) ‘Sustainability of Healthcare Systems: Aligning the Safety and Quality Debate with the Debate on the Financing Systems and Mechanisms’, European Journal of Health Law, 20, 253–259.
3.
BaetenR. and PalmW. (2011) ‘The Compatibility of Health Care Capacity Planning Policies with EU Internal Market Rules’, in: van de GrondenJ.W. (eds.) Health Care and EU law, The Hague, Asser Press, 389–411.
4.
BarnardC. (2013) The Substantive Law of the EU – The Four Freedoms, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
5.
BrooksE. (2012) ‘Crossing borders: A critical review of the role of the European Court of Justice in EU health policy’, Health Policy, 105(1), 33–37.
6.
CousinsM. (2007) ‘Patient Mobility and National Health Systems’, Legal Issues of Economic Integration, 34(2), 183–93.
7.
DaviesG. (2004) ‘Health and Efficiency: Community Law and National Health Systems in the Light of Müller-Fauré’, Modern Law Review, 67(1), 94–107.
8.
DawesA. (2006) ‘Bonjour Herr Doctor: National Healthcare Systems, the Internal Market and Cross-border Medical Care within the European Union’, Legal Issues of Economic Integration, 33(2), 167–82.
9.
European Hospital and Healthcare Federation (2011) The Crisis, Hospitals and Healthcare.
10.
GreerS. (2013) ‘Avoiding another Directive: The unstable politics of European Union cross-border health care law’, Health Economics, Policy and Law, 8(4), 415–421.
11.
GreerS.L. and RauscherS. (2011) ‘Destabilization rights and restabilization politics: Policy and political reactions to European Union healthcare services law’, Journal of European Public Policy, 18(2), 220–240.
12.
van de GrondenJ. (2008–2009) ‘Cross-border Health Care in the EU and the Organization of the National Health Care Systems of the Member States: The Dynamics Resulting from the European Court of Justice's Decisions on Free Movement and Competition Law’, Wisconsin International Law Journal, 26(3), 705–760.
13.
HancherL. and SauterW. (2010) ‘One Step beyond? From Sodemare to Docmorris: The EU's Freedom of Establishment Case Law Concerning Healthcare’, Common Market Law Review, 47, 117–146.
14.
HartleyM. (2010) ‘Diversity and Harmonisation. Trends and Challenges in European Health Law’, European Journal of Health Law, 17, 37–50.
15.
HatzopoulosV. (2008–2009) ‘Financing National Health Care in a Transnational Environment: The Impact of the European Community Internal Market’, Wisconsin International Law Journal, 26(3), 761–803.
16.
HatzapoulosV. and HerveyT. (2013) ‘Coming into line: The EU's Court softens on cross-border health care’, Health Economics, Policy and Law, 8, 1–5.
HerveyT. and McHaleJ. (2005) ‘Law, Health and the European Union’, Legal Studies, 25, 228–259.
19.
HerveyT. and TrubekL. (2006–2007) ‘Freedom to provide health care services within the EU: An opportunity for a transformative Directive’, Columbia Journal of European Law, 13, 623–647.
20.
KeuneM.J. (2012) ‘The Social Dimension of European Integration’, in BurroniL.KeuneM. and MeardiG. (eds.) Economy and Society in Europe: A Relationship in Crisis, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar, 19–39.
21.
KrajewskiM. (2010) ‘Grenzüberschreitende Patientenmobilität in Europa zwischen negativer und positiver Integration der Gesundheitssysteme’, Europarecht, 165–189.
22.
van NuffelP. (2005) ‘Patients' Free Movement Rights and cross-border access to healthcare’, Maastricht Journal European & Comparative Law, 12(3), 253–70.
23.
NysH. (2014) ‘The Transposition of the Directive on Patients' Rights in Cross-Care Healthcare in National Law by the Member States: Still a Lot of Effort to Be Made and Questions to Be Answered’, European Journal of Health Law, 21, 1–14.
24.
PeetersM. (2012) ‘Free Movement of Patients: Directive 2011/24 on the Application of Patients' Rights in Cross-Border Healthcare’, European Journal of Health Law, 19, 29–60.
25.
PenningsF. (2015) European Social Security Law, Antwerp, Intersentia.
26.
PenningsF. (2011) ‘The Cross-border Health Care Directive: More Free Movement for Citizens and More Coherent EU Law?’, European Journal of Social Security, 13(4), 424–52.
27.
de la RosaS. (2012) ‘The Directive on cross-border healthcare or the art of codifying complex case law’, Common Market Law Review, 49, 15–46.
28.
StögerK. (2006) ‘The Freedom of Establishment and the Market Access of Hospital Operators’, European Business Law Review, 17(6), 1545–1558.
29.
WollenschlägerF. (2012) ‘Patientenmobilität in der Europäischen Union – von der Rechtsprechung des EuGH zur neuen Richtlinie 2011/24/EU über die Ausübung der Patientenrechte in der grenzüberschreitenden Patientenversorgung’, Europarecht, 149–184.
