Third-Country Nationals and the European Coordination of Social Security

Abstract

The Community Regulations on the coordination of social security systems provide a high standard of protection for people moving within the EU. For a long time, third country national workers have been excluded from this protection. This article shows that the explanation for this exclusion is to be found in the legal basis of the Community Regulations. The article also demonstrates how recent developments in the legal basis and in the case law of the Court have paved the way for the extension of the current Regulation 1408/71 to third-country nationals. Regulation 859/2003 offers third-country nationals, in the field of social security, the same protection as EU citizens moving within the EU. However, this extension is subject to two conditions. For this reason, a considerable number of third-country nationals legally residing in a Member State do not benefit from equal treatment as nationals in the host State. The article clarifies why some categories of third-country nationals do have a EU level guarantee of equal treatment, even when there is no cross-border element between two Member States, while other categories have not. Regulation 883/2004 will soon replace regulation 1408/71, which is currently in place. One of the main improvements of the latter is its personal scope: it will apply all EU nationals who are insured under national law, including non-active people. Special attention is paid to the consequences of the replacement of Regulation 1408/71 by Regulation 883/2004 for third-country nationals.

Keywords

coordination free movement of workers principle of equal treatment stateless persons and refugees members of the family Treaty of Amsterdam

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bergmann

and Lenz

. (eds) (1998), The Treaty of Amsterdam. A commentary on the innovations of the EU and EC Treaty, Stuttgart, Omnia Verlag.

Cornelissen

(1996), ‘The principle of Territoriality and the Community Regulations on Social Security (Regulations 1408/71 and 574/72)’, Common Market Law Review 33, 439–471.

Jorens

and Schulte

(1998), European Social Security Law and Third-Country Nationals. Brugge, die Keure.

Plender

(1976), in Jacobs

F.G.

(ed), European Law and the Individual, Amsterdam and New York, North-Holland.

Staples

(1999), The Legal Status of Third-country nationals Resident in the European Union, The Hague, Kluwer.

Verschueren

(1997), ‘EC social security coordination excluding third-country nationals: Still in line fundamental rights after the Gaygusuz judgment?’, Common Market Law Review, 34, 991–1017.

Verschueren

(2006), ‘Sociale zekerheid en detachering binnen de Europese Unie. De zaak Herbosch Kiere: Een gemiste kans in de strijd tegen grensoverschrijdende sociale dumping en sociale fraude’, Belgisch Tijdschrift voor sociale zekerheid, 403–449.

Watson

(1980), Social Security Law of the European Communities. London, Mansell.