Social Rights of Non-European Illegal Immigrants in France

Abstract

Non-European immigrants in an illegal situation in France¹ – sans papiers – are considered very differently under labour law and social security legislation. In labour law, they are treated, at least partially, like legally-employed workers. However, the extreme vulnerability of these workers in dealings with their employers can only be remedied by the recognition of residency rights based on their actual employment situation. This is not a controversial legal issue at present in France. As far as social coverage is concerned (health, maternity, disablement, and retirement), illegal immigrants were excluded from the scope of application of social security legislation in 1993 and relegated to social assistance, with all the perverse effects that entailed. The radical change in French legislative policy on the right to social protection for foreigners since 1993, initially by imposing legal residence as a condition for access to social security systems and benefits, then instituting a minimum, continuous residency requirement for access to a reduced ‘selection of care, obviously raises the issue of the incompatibility between national positive law and international laws adopted by France.

Keywords

non-European nationals residency conditions employment social protection right to health international law French law

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Daugareilh

(1998), ‘La loi du 11 mai 1998 relative à l'entrée et au séjour des étrangers en France. Les modifications du droit de la sécurité sociale’, Revue de droit sanitaire et social, pp. 634–645.

Daugareilh

(2001), ‘La convention européenne de sauvegarde des droits de l'homme et des libertés fondamentales et la protection sociale’, Revue trimestrielle de droit européen, No. 1, pp. 123–137.

Daugareilh

(2005), ‘L'audace retenue du Comité européen des droits sociaux’, Revue de droit sanitaire et social, p. 555.

Dupeyroux

, and Pretot

, (1994), ‘Le droit de l'étranger à la protection sociale’, Droit social, pp. 69–74.

Devys

(2006), ‘La réforme de l'aide médicale d'Etat censurée par le Conseil d'Etat’, Conclusions, Droit social, p. 1037.

Gay

(2006), ‘L'affirmation d'un droit aux soins du mineur étranger ou l'inconventionnalité partielle d'une loi jugée conforme à la Constitution’, Revue de droit sanitaire et social, p. 1047.

ILO (2004), Towards a fair deal for migrant workers in the global economy (International Labour Conferences, 92nd session, Report VI), Geneva.

Médecins du Monde (2006), Coordination Mission France, Paris, November.

Médecins du Monde (2007a), ‘European survey on undocumented migrants' access to health care’ (European Observatory on access to health care), June, Paris.

10.

Médecins du Monde (2007b), Mission France, Observatory on access to health care, October, Paris.

11.

Morice

Quiminal

and Fassin

(1997), Les lois de l'inhospitalité. Les politiques de l'immigration à l'épreuve des sans-papiers, La Découverte, col. Cahiers Libres, Paris.

12.

OECD (2007), International Migration Outlook, SOPEMI Annual Report 2007.

13.

Savatier

(1986), ‘Les sanctions civiles de l'emploi de travailleurs en situation irrégulière’, Droit social, p. 424.

14.

Terray

(1999), ‘Le travail des étrangers en situation irrégulière’, in Balibar

Chemillier-Gendreau

Costa-Lascoux

and Terray

, Sans papiers: L'archaïsme fatal, La Découverte, Paris.

15.

Toulier

(2005), ‘Aide médicale d'Etat: Les droits sociaux fondamentaux bafoués’, Droit social, pp. 1011–1021.