This study proposes a novel carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP)-steel strip hybrid stirrup to enhance the ductility of reinforced concrete (RC) beams. To investigate its effectiveness, three-point bending tests on 11 RC beams were conducted, comparing the proposed hybrid stirrups with conventional steel and CFRP strip stirrups. The effects of stirrup spacing and number of CFRP layers were also examined. Results showed obvious advantages of the proposed hybrid stirrups. Compared to the beam reinforced with only CFRP strip stirrups, the inner steel strip of the hybrid stirrups enhanced the rigidity and crack control, enhancing the reinforcing efficiency by up to 45%. In comparison with the beam reinforced with only steel strip stirrups, the outer CFRP strip of the hybrid stirrups can maintain the load in the later loading stages, thereby effectively improving the ultimate deflection by 1.7 times. For beams with CFRP strip stirrups, neither decreasing the stirrup spacing nor increasing the layers of CFRP contributed obviously to the shear capacity and ductility. However, for beams with hybrid stirrups, while the ductility increased significantly as the layers of CFRP, both shear capacity and ductility decreased with the stirrup spacing. Finally, a formula to calculate the shear capacity of the beams with hybrid stirrups was proposed and the calculated results agreed well with the experimental findings, which validated its applicability.
ACI 440.1R (2001) Guide for the Design and Construction of Concrete Reinforced with FRP Bars. Farmington Hills: American Concrete Institute.
2.
ACI 440.1R (2015) Guide for the Design and Construction of Structural Concrete Reinforced with Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (FRP) Bars. Farmington Hills: American Concrete Institute.
3.
ACI 440.3R (2012) Guide Test Methods for Fiber-Reinforced Polymers (FRPs) for Reinforcing or Strengthening Concrete and Masonry Structures. Farmington Hills: American Concrete Institute.
4.
AhmedEAEl-SayedAKEl-SalakawyE, et al. (2010) Bend strength of FRP stirrups: Comparison and evaluation of testing methods. Journal of Composites for Construction14(1): 3–10.
5.
AhmedEAEl-SalakawyEFBenmokraneB (2010) Performance evaluation of glass fiber-reinforced polymer shear reinforcement for concrete beams. ACI Structural Journal107(01): 53–62.
6.
Al-HamraniAAlnahhalW (2021) Shear behavior of basalt FRC beams reinforced with basalt FRP bars and glass FRP stirrups: experimental and analytical investigations. Engineering Structures242: 112612.
7.
BentzECMassamLCollinsMP (2010) Shear strength of large concrete members with FRP reinforcement. Journal of Composites for Construction14(6): 637–646.
8.
CapozuccaR (2007) Analysis of the experimental flexural behaviour of a concrete beam grid reinforced with C-FRP bars. Composite Structures79(4): 517–526.
9.
ChenCLiCZhouY, et al. (2022) Applying Flax FRP in an innovative closed-shape stirrup for concrete beams. Materials15(8): 2927.
10.
CSA S806 (2017) Design and Construction of Building Structures with Fiber Reinforced Polymers. Toronto: Canadian Standards Association.
11.
DeifallaAHamedMSalehA, et al. (2014) Exploring GFRP bars as reinforcement for rectangular and L-shaped beams subjected to significant torsion: an experimental study. Engineering Structures59: 776–786.
12.
El-MogyMEl-RagabyAEl-SalakawyE (2011) Effect of transverse reinforcement on the flexural behavior of continuous concrete beams reinforced with FRP. Journal of Composites for Construction15(5): 672–681.
13.
FahmyMFMAbd-ElShafyZEWuZ (2017) Experimental and numerical evaluation of the shear behavior of reinforced concrete T-Beams with hybrid Steel-FRP stirrups. Journal of Composites for Construction21(4): 04017007.
14.
FakharifarMDalvandASharbatdarMK, et al. (2016) Innovative hybrid reinforcement constituting conventional longitudinal steel and FRP stirrups for improved seismic strength and ductility of RC structures. Frontiers of Structural and Civil Engineering10(1): 44–62.
15.
FanXZhouZTuW, et al. (2021) Shear behaviour of inorganic polymer concrete beams reinforced with basalt FRP bars and stirrups. Composite Structures255: 112901.
16.
GB 50010 (2010) Code for Design of Concrete Structures. Beijing: Standards Press of China.
17.
GB 50608 (2020) Technical Code for Infrastructure Application of FRP Composites. Beijing: Standards Press of China.
18.
GB/T 228.1 (2021) Metallic Materials — Tensile Testing — Part 1: Method of Test at Room Temperature. Beijing: Standards Press of China.
19.
GB/T 3354 (2014) Test Method for Tensile Properties of Oriented Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (FRP) Matrix Composite Materials. Beijing: Standards Press of China.
20.
GB/T 50081 (2002) Standard for Test Method of Mechanical Properties on Ordinary Concrete. Beijing: Standards Press of China.
21.
GravinaRJSmithST (2008) Flexural behaviour of indeterminate concrete beams reinforced with FRP bars. Engineering Structures30(9): 2370–2380.
22.
HakeemIYOsamaBLiW, et al. (2024) Restoration of load capacity and stiffness of continuous steel–concrete composite beams having web openings using externally applied FRP strips. Structural Concrete25(5): 3505–3530.
23.
HaoQWangYOuJ (2008) Design recommendations for bond between GFRP/Steel wire composite rebars and concrete. Engineering Structures30(11): 3239–3246.
24.
HaoX-KFengQZhengJ-J (2021) A passive stress-strain model for concrete prisms reinforced by a combination of confinement reinforcement. Engineering Structures246: 112981.
25.
IssaMAOvitigalaTIbrahimM (2016) Shear behavior of basalt fiber reinforced concrete beams with and without basalt FRP stirrups. Journal of Composites for Construction20(4): 04015083.
26.
IStructE (1999) Interim Guidance on the Design of Reinforced Concrete Structures Using Fibre Composite Reinforcement. London: SETO Ltd.
27.
JSCE (1997) Recommendation for Design and Construction of Concrete Structures Using Continuous Fiber Reinforcing Materials. Tokyo: JSCE.
28.
KrallMPolakMA (2019) Concrete beams with different arrangements of GFRP flexural and shear reinforcement. Engineering Structures198: 109333.
29.
LeeCKimJ-YHeoS-Y (2010) Experimental observation on the effectiveness of fiber sheet strip stirrups in concrete beams. Journal of Composites for Construction14(5): 487–497.
30.
LeeCKoMLeeY (2014) Bend strength of complete closed-type carbon fiber-reinforced polymer stirrups with rectangular section. Journal of Composites for Construction18(1): 04013022.
31.
LiPJinLZhangR, et al. (2022) Static bond performance between BFRP bars and concrete with stirrup confinement: a refined modelling. Engineering Structures262: 114379.
32.
LiuYZhouCChenL, et al. (2024) Experimental study on bond behavior between CFRP and concrete with longitudinal grooves. Structures65: 106654.
33.
LuYLiWZhouY, et al. (2024) Comparative analysis of shear behavior and mechanism of concrete beams with strip-shaped CFRP or conventional steel stirrups. Case Studies in Construction Materials20: e03140.
34.
MachidaA (1997) Recommendations for design and construction for concrete structures using continuous fibre reinforcing materials. Japanese Society of Civil Engineers (JSCE) Concrete Engineering Series, Vol. 23.
35.
NasrollahzadehKAghamohammadiR (2018) Reliability analysis of shear strength provisions for FRP-Reinforced concrete beams. Engineering Structures176: 785–800.
36.
NehdiMEl ChabibHSaidA (2006) Evaluation of shear capacity of FRP reinforced concrete beams using artificial neural networks. Smart Structures and Systems2(1): 81–100.
37.
NehdiMEl ChabibHSaïdAA (2007) Proposed shear design equations for FRP-reinforced concrete beams based on genetic algorithms approach. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering19(12): 1033–1042.
38.
SaidMAdamMAMahmoudAA, et al. (2016) Experimental and analytical shear evaluation of concrete beams reinforced with glass fiber reinforced polymers bars. Construction and Building Materials102: 574–591.
39.
SaikiaBThomasJRamaswamyA, et al. (2005) Performance of hybrid rebars as longitudinal reinforcement in normal strength concrete. Materials and Structures38(10): 857–864.
40.
ShehataEMorphyRRizkallaS (2000) Fibre reinforced polymer shear reinforcement for concrete members: behaviour and design guidelines. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering27(5): 859–872.
41.
TranTTPhamTMHuangZ, et al. (2021) Impact response of fibre reinforced geopolymer concrete beams with BFRP bars and stirrups. Engineering Structures231: 111785.
42.
UriayerFAAlamM (2015) Steel-CFRP composite and their shear response as vertical stirrup in beams. Steel and Composite Structures18(5): 1145–1160.
43.
WangLFanLFuF, et al. (2022) Cracks width prediction of steel-FRP bars reinforced high-strength composite concrete beams. Structures43: 424–433.
44.
WangYSurahmanRZhouC, et al. (2024) Analytical study on flexural strengthening of narrow RC beams with hybrid anchored CFRP sheets. Journal of Building Engineering88: 109095.
45.
WangYJiaQSurahmanR, et al. (2024) Static and seismic strengthening of RC frame joints by using CFRP sheets with various anchoring methods. Journal of Building Engineering82: 108309.
46.
WangYJiangYSurahmanR, et al. (2025) Flexural performance of RC beams using hybrid anchored CFRP sheets with bond defects. Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology39(3): 401–433.
47.
WeiwenLFangWLuY, et al. (2025) Bonding properties of embedded fiber reinforced polymer strip-engineered cementitious composite joints. Polymers17(8): 1049.
48.
WhiteheadPAIbellTJ (2005) Novel shear reinforcement for fiber-reinforced polymer-reinforced and prestressed concrete. ACI Structural Journal102(2): 286–294.
49.
WuGWuZ-SLuoY-B, et al. (2010a) Mechanical properties of Steel-FRP composite bar under uniaxial and cyclic tensile loads. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering22(10): 1056–1066.
50.
WuY-FYanJ-HZhouY-W, et al. (2010b) Ultimate strength of reinforced concrete beams retrofitted with hybrid bonded fiber-reinforced polymer. ACI Structural Journal107(4): 451–460.
51.
XiaoYZhouCSurahmanR, et al. (2025) Flexural strengthening of reinforced concrete beams with FRP enveloped steel plate. Engineering Structures335: 120409.
52.
ZengJ-JChenS-PZhugeY, et al. (2021) Three-dimensional finite element modeling and theoretical analysis of concrete confined with FRP rings. Engineering Structures234: 111966.
53.
ZhaoDPanJZhouY, et al. (2020) New types of steel-FRP composite bar with round steel bar inner core: mechanical properties and bonding performances in concrete. Construction and Building Materials242: 118062.
54.
ZsuttyTC (1968) Beam shear strength prediction by analysis of existing data. ACI Journal Proceedings65(11): 943–951.
55.
ZsuttyT (1971) Shear strength prediction for separate catagories of simple beam tests. ACI Journal Proceedings68(2): 138–143.
