The shifting landscape of prime ministerial accountability to parliament: An analysis of Liaison Committee scrutiny sessions

Abstract

Prime ministerial power is always contingent, based on the utilisation of personal and institutional resources, subject to various formal and informal constraints. Parliament is both a political resource to be utilised, but also a veto-player. In the absence of formal mechanisms setting out the requirements for the UK prime ministerial accountability to parliament, a fluid and essentially personalised relationship has developed. Regular prime ministerial appearances before the House of Commons Liaison Committee, begun in 2002, have added to parliament’s scrutiny toolkit. This article considers the accountability of the prime minister to parliament by analysing the emergence and development of the Liaison Committee evidence sessions, and draws on interviews with participants and examination of the session transcripts, in order to assess the value of this scrutiny mechanism within the broader framework of prime ministerial-legislative relations.

Keywords

executive scrutiny Liaison Committee prime minister UK parliament

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barber

(2007) Instruction to Deliver: Fighting to Transform Britain’s Public Service. London: Methuen.

Bates

Kerr

Byrne

. (2014) Questions to the prime minister: A comparative study of PMQs from Thatcher to Cameron. Parliamentary Affairs 67(2): 253–280.

Bennister

Heffernan

(2012) Cameron as prime minister: The intra-executive politics of Britain’s coalition government. Parliamentary Affairs 65(4): 778–801.

Bennister

Heffernan

(2015) The limits to prime ministerial autonomy: Cameron and the constraints of coalition. Parliamentary Affairs 68(1): 25–41.

Bercow

(2012) Prime ministers questions in the UK. Canadian Parliamentary Review 35(2): 6–9.

Blair

(2010) A Journey. London: Hutchinson.

Bovens

(2007) Public accountability. In: Ferlie

Lynne

Pollitt

(eds) Oxford Handbook of Public Management. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 182–208.

Cook

(2003) The Point of Departure. London: Pocket Books.

Cowley

(2007) Parliament. In: Seldon

(ed.) Blair’s Britain, 1997–2007. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 16–34.

10.

Cowley

Stuart

(2014) How watching PMQs makes you more interested in politics (sort of). Available at: http://revolts.co.uk/?p=736 (accessed 5 June 2015).

11.

Diamond

(2014) Governing Britain: Power, Politics and the Prime Minister. London: I.B. Tauris.

12.

Dowding

(2013) The prime ministerialisation and the British prime minister. Parliamentary Affairs 66(3): 617–635.

13.

Dunleavy

Jones

(1993) Leaders, politics and institutional change: The decline of prime ministerial accountability to the House of Commons, 1868–1990. British Journal of Political Science 23(3): 267–298.

14.

Foley

(2013) Prime ministerialisation and presidential analogies: A certain difference in interpretive evolution. Parliamentary Affairs 66(3): 655–662.

15.

Hansard Society (2014) Tuned in or Turned off? Public attitudes to Prime Minister’s Questions. London: Hansard Society.

16.

Hazell

Yong

(2012) The Politics of Coalition: How the Conservative Liberal Democrat Government Works. Oxford: Hart Publishing.

17.

HC 192-i (2007) Oral Evidence: Rt Hon Gordon Brown MP: 13 December 2007. London: TSO.

18.

HC 192-ii (2007) Oral Evidence: Rt Hon Gordon Brown MP: 3 July 2008. London: TSO.

19.

HC 200 (2013) Outcomes of the UN Rio+20 Earth Summit, Second Report from the Environmental Audit Committee. London: TSO.

20.

HC 235 (2001) The Ministerial Code, Improving the Rule Book, Third Report from the Public Administration Select Committee. London: TSO.

21.

HC 257-i (2009) Oral Evidence: Rt Hon Gordon Brown MP: 12 February 2009. London: TSO.

22.

HC 257-ii (2009) Oral Evidence: Rt Hon Gordon Brown MP: 16 July 2009. London: TSO.

23.

HC 321 (2000) Shifting the Balance: Unfinished Business, First Report from the Liaison Committee. London: TSO.

24.

HC 334-i (2003) Oral Evidence: Evidence Presented by the Rt. Hon. Tony Blair MP, Prime Minister, Tuesday 21 January 2003. London: TSO.

25.

HC 334-ii (2003) Oral Evidence: Evidence Presented by the Rt. Hon. Tony Blair MP, Prime Minister, Tuesday 8 July 2003. London: TSO.

26.

HC 351 (2014) The Role and Powers of the Prime Minister, First Report of Political and Constitutional Reform Committee. London: TSO.

27.

HC 346-i (2010) Oral Evidence: Rt Hon Gordon Brown MP: 2 February 2010. London: TSO.

28.

HC 468-i (2013) Oral Evidence from the Prime Minister: 3 July 2012. London: TSO.

29.

HC 484-ii (2013) Oral Evidence from the Prime Minister: 11 December 2012. London: TSO.

30.

HC 608-i (2010) The Prime Minister: 18 November 2010. London: TSO.

31.

HC 608-ii (2011) The Prime Minister: 17 May 2011. London: TSO.

32.

HC 608-iv (2012) The Prime Minister: 8 November 2011. London: TSO.

33.

HC 647 (2013) Oral Evidence from the Prime Minister: 10 September 2013. London: TSO.

34.

HC 683 (2014) Oral Evidence: Evidence from the Prime Minister: 20 November 2014. London: TSO.

35.

HC 697 (2012) Select Committee Effectiveness, Resources and Powers, Second Report from the Liaison Committee. London: TSO.

36.

HC 813 (2003) The Decision to go to War in Iraq: Ninth Report from the Foreign Affairs Select Committee. London: TSO.

37.

HC 887 (2014) Oral Evidence from the Prime Minister: 16 December 2014. London: TSO.

38.

HC 939 (2014) Oral Evidence from the Prime Minister: 14 January 2014. London: TSO.

39.

HC 954 (2014) Legacy Report: First Report from the Liaison Committee. London: TSO.

40.

HC 984 (2002) Evidence from the Prime Minister, First Special Report from the Liaison Committee. London: TSO.

41.

HC 1015 (2015) Oral Evidence: Evidence from the Prime Minister: 24 February 2015. London: TSO.

42.

HC 1095 (2002) Oral Evidence: Evidence Presented by the Rt. Hon. Tony Blair MP, Prime Minister. London: TSO.

43.

Heffernan

(2003) Prime ministerial predominance? Core executive politics in the UK. British Journal of Politics and International Relations 5: 347–372.

44.

Heffernan

(2005) Exploring (and explaining) the prime minister. British Journal of Politics and International Relations 7(4): 605–620.

45.

Heffernan

(2013) There is no need for -isation: The prime minister is merely prime ministerial. Parliamentary Affairs 66(3): 634–645.

46.

Hennessy

(2000) The Prime Minister: The Office and Its Holders Since 1945. London: Penguin Press.

47.

Hoggart

(2002) Savaged by a feather duster. The Guardian, 17 July. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2002/jul/17/houseofcommons.politicalcolumnists (accessed 12 June 2015).

48.

Institute for Government (2011) Government by explanation: The future of select committees. In: Conference, London, 7 March. Available at: http://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/events/government-explanation-future-select-committees (accessed 2 June 2015).

49.

Jogerst

(1993) Reform in the House of Commons: The Select Committee System. Lexington, KY: University of Kentucky Press.

50.

Kelso

(2009) Parliamentary Reform at Westminster. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

51.

Kumarasingham

(2013) Exporting executive accountability? Westminster legacies of executive power. Parliamentary Affairs 66(3): 579–596.

52.

Mackintosh

(1962) The British Cabinet. London: Stevens.

53.

Mulgan

(2003) Holding Power to Account: Accountability in Modern Democracies. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

54.

Poguntke

Webb.

(2013) The presidentialisation of politics thesis defended. Parliamentary Affairs 66(3): 646–654.

55.

Rhodes

RAW

(1997) Shackling the leader? Coherence, capacity and the Hollow Crown. In: Weller

Bakvis

Rhodes

RAW

(eds) The Hollow Crown—Countervailing Trends in Core Executives. London: Macmillan, pp. 198–223.

56.

Rhodes

RAW

Weller

(2005) Westminster transplanted and Westminster implanted: Exploring political change. In: Patapan

Wanna

Weller

(eds) Westminster Legacies: Democracy and Responsible Government in Asia and the Pacific. Sydney, NSW, Australia: UNSW Press, pp. 1–12.

57.

Rush

(2014) Engaging with the enemy: The parliamentary participation of party leaders, 1945–2010. Parliamentary Affairs 67(4): 751–766.

58.

Seldon

(2007) Blair Unbound. London: Simon & Schuster.

59.

Shephard

(2009) Parliamentary scrutiny and oversight of the British ‘War on Terror’: From accretion of executive power and evasion of scrutiny to embarrassment and concessions. The Journal of Legislative Studies 15(2–3): 191–218.

60.

Strøm

(2003) Delegation and Accountability in Parliamentary Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

61.

Thomas

(2004) United Kingdom: The prime minister and parliament. The Journal of Legislative Studies 10(2–3): 4–37.

62.

White

(2014) Sex and the tale of two cities: Cameron appears before committee chair MPs. The Guardian, 14 January. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/jan/14/sex-and-tale-of-two-cities-cameron-liaison-committee (accessed 8 June 2015).