For Max Weber, modernity is characterized by a tragic conflict among value spheres, each claiming to possess the ‘true meaning’ of human life. In particular, Weber argues that while the political sphere is dominated by the unifying, exclusionary, power-driven, and war-prone nation state, the ethical sphere is characterized by the universalization of individually based, deontological norms. For Weber, I argue, the modern separation between the ethical and political spheres originates in ancient Judaism. His work on Judaism, mostly neglected by political theorists, describes the emergence of politics as an autonomous, naturalistic sphere with the establishment of kingship. Biblical prophets, simultaneously, were the inventors of an idealistic, mulish, universal ethics Weber termed the ‘ethics of ultimate ends’. Thus, against the Greek model harmonizing ethics and politics, Judaism invented an antagonistic model of the two. This Jewish imagination lay dormant for almost two millennia but returned to the stage in secularized modernity.
AbrahamG. (1992). Max Weber and the Jewish question. UI Press.
2.
Aristotle. (2016). Nicomachean ethics. Translated by Roger Crisp. Cambridge UP.
3.
BaronS. (1952). A social and religious history of the Jews. Columbia UP.
4.
BartonJ. (1980). Amos’s oracles against the nations. Cambridge UP.
5.
BellahR, (1999). Max Weber and world-denying love. Journal of the American Academy of Religion, 67(2), 277–304.
6.
BenjaminW. (1968). Critique of violence. In DemetzP., (Ed.). Reflections. Schocken Books, pp. 277–300.
7.
BerlinI. (2013). Against the current. Princeton UP.
8.
BermanJ. (2011). Created equal: How the bible broke with ancient political thought. OUP.
9.
BlenkinsoppJ. (1996). A history of prophecy in Israel. Westminster John Knox Press.
10.
BomanT. (1970). Hebrew thought compared with Greek. Translated by Moreau Jules. W. W. Norton.
11.
BrubakerR. (1984). The limits of rationality. Routledge.
12.
CarrD. M. (2011). The formation of the Hebrew Bible. Oxford University Press.
13.
ChernissJ. (2016). An ethos of politics between realism and idealism: Max Weber’s enigmatic political ethics. The Journal of Politics, 78(3), 705–718.
14.
ChowersE. (2004). The modern self in the labyrinth. Harvard UP.
15.
EdelmanD.Ben ZviE (Eds). (2014). The production of prophecy. Routledge.
16.
EisenstadtS. N. (2004). Explorations in Jewish historical experience. Brill.
17.
FaheyT. (1982). Max Weber’s ancient Judaism. American Journal of Sociology. 88(1), 62–87.
18.
FrankfortH. (1948). Kingship and the gods. Chicago University Press.
19.
FrazerE. (2006). Max Weber on ethics and politics. Politics and Ethics Review. 2(1), 19–37.
20.
GeussR. (2008). Philosophy and real politics. Princeton University Press.
21.
GirardR. (1977). Violence and the sacred. Translated by Patrick Gregory. Johns Hopkins University Press.
22.
GoldbergC. (2017). Modernity and the Jews in western social thought. Chicago University Press.
23.
GoldmanH. (1991). Politics, death, and the devil. University of California Press.
24.
GoodblattD. (2006). Elements of ancient Jewish nationalism. CUP.
25.
GrosbyS. (2002). Biblical ideas of nationality. Eisenbrauns.
26.
HabermasJ. (2001). On the pragmatics of social interaction. MIT Press.
27.
HalbertalM.HolmesS. (2017). The beginning of politics: Power in the biblical book of Samuel. Princeton UP.
28.
HazoniY. (2012). The philosophy of Hebrew scripture. CUP.
29.
HegelG. W. F. (1991). Elements of the philosophy of right. CUP.
30.
HennisW. (1987). Personality and life orders: Max Weber’s theme. In LashS.WhimsterS. (Eds.), Max weber, rationality and modernity. Allen & Unwin. pp. 52–74.
31.
HonigsheimP. (2000). The unknown Max Weber. SicaA. (Ed.). Routledge.
32.
HutchinsonJ. (1994). Modern nationalism. Fontana Press.
33.
KantI. (1838). Religion within the boundary of pure reason. Translated by J. Semple. Thomas Clark.
34.
KantI. (1983). Perpetual peace and other essays. Hackett.
35.
KauffmannY. (1962). The religion of Israel. University of Chicago Press.
36.
KoselleckR. (1988). Critique and crisis. MIT Press.
37.
LesterG.NissinenM (Ed.). (2011). Constructs of prophecy in the former and latter prophets. Society of Biblical Literature.
38.
LiebeschützH. (1964). Max Weber’s historical interpretation of Judaism. Leo Baeck Inst. Yearb. 9(1), 41–68.
39.
LevinasE. (2012). Totality and infinity. Duquesne University Press.
40.
MichelsonM. (2011). Reconciling violence and kingship. Pickwick Publications.
41.
NothM. (2002 [1943]). The Deuteronomistic History. UK: UNKNO.
OttoE. (2017). Max Weber’s sociology of ancient Judaism as part of his project on the economic ethic of the world religions. In ErtmanT. (Ed.), Max Weber’s economic ethic of the world religion. Cambridge University Press, pp. 307–348
44.
RiesebrodtM. (2010). The promise of salvation. Chicago University Press.
45.
RothG.SchluchterW. (1979). Max Weber’s vision of history. University of California Press.
46.
RousseauJ. J. (1762). The social contract. Prometheus Books.
47.
SatkunanandanS. (2014). Max Weber and the ethos of politics beyond calculation. American Political Science Review, 108(1), 169–181.
48.
ScaffL. (1989). Fleeing the iron cage. California UP.
49.
Schäfer-LichtenbergerC. (1991). The pariah: Some thoughts on the genesis and presuppositions of Max Weber’s ancient Judaism. Journal for the Study of the Old Testament, 51, 85–113.
50.
SchluchterW. (1979). The rise of western rationalism. California UP.
51.
SchluchterW. (2004). The approach of Max Weber’s sociology of religion as exemplified in his study of ancient Judaism. Archives De Sciences Sociales Des Religions, 127(3), 33–56.
52.
SchmidK. (2012). The old testament: A literary history. Fortress Press.
53.
SchmittC. (2007). The concept of the political. Translated by G. Schwab. University of Chicago Press.
54.
ShmueliE. (1968). The pariah-people and its charismatic leadership: A revaluation of Max Weber’s ancient Judaism. Proceedings of the American Academy for Jewish Research, 36, 167–247.
55.
SimonU. (2002). Seek peace and pursue it. Yedioth. (Hebrew).
56.
SymondsM. (2015). Max Weber’s theory of modernity. Routledge.
57.
The Bible (The Koren Tanakh, Zion Edition). 2010. Jerusalem: Koren (Hebrew).
58.
TroeltschE. (1992). The social teaching of the Christian churches. Translated by Olive Wyon. University of Chicago Press.
59.
TurnerB. (Ed). (2013). War and peace. Anthem Press.
60.
TurnerC. (1992). Modernity and politics in the work of Max Weber. Routledge.
61.
WalzerM. (2012). In God’s shadow: Politics in the Hebrew bible. Yale University Press.
62.
WeberM. (1994). Weber: Political Writings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
