According to David Miller, immigration is not a human right. Conversely, Kieran Oberman makes a case for immigration as a human right. We agree with the latter view, but we show that its starting point is mistaken. Indeed, both Miller and Oberman discuss the right to immigration within the liberal paradigm: it is a right or not depending on the correct balance between the interests of the citizens of a given national state and the interests of the immigrants. Instead, we claim that public justification can underpin immigration as a human right. That said, the public justification of the right to immigration has several counterarguments to rebut. Before we deal with that issue, relying on Jürgen Habermas’s social theory, we examine the legal structures that could support the right to immigration in practice. To be sure, this does not provide the normative justification needed, instead it shows the framework that allows the institutional realization of this right. Then, through a combination of civic and cosmopolitan forms of solidarity, the article discusses the formation of a public sphere, which could provide the justification of the right to immigration.
BeitzC. (2004). Human rights and the law of peoples. In ChatterjeeD. K. (Ed.), The ethics of assistance: Morality and the distant needy. Cambridge University Press.
3.
BohmanJ. (2018). The constitutionalization of international law and politics: Does the constitutionalization of international law still have a chance? (2004). In BrunkhorstH.KreideR.LafontC. (Eds.), The Habermas handbook (pp. 474–486). Columbia University Press. https://doi.org/10.7312/brun16642.46
4.
BosniakL. (2007). Being here: Ethical territoriality and the rights of immigrants. Theoretical Inquires in Law, 8(2), 389–410.
5.
CarensJ. H. (1987). Aliens and citizens: The case for open borders. The Review of Politics, 49, 251–273.
6.
CarensJ. H. (2013). The ethics of immigration. Oxford University Press.
7.
CarensJ. H. (2014). An overview of the ethics of immigration. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy, 17(5), 538–559.
8.
CherniloD. (2007). A social theory of the nation-state: The political forms of modernity beyond methodological nationalism. Routledge.
9.
CohenJ. (2004). Minimalism about human rights. The Journal of Political Philosophy, 12(2004), 190–213.
10.
DelantyG. (2017). The European heritage: A critical re-interpretation. Routledge.
11.
EspejoP. O. (2016). Taking place seriously: Territorial presence and the rights of immigrants. The Journal of Political Philosophy, 24(1), 67–87.
12.
FineR. (2009). Cosmopolitanism and human rights: Radicalism in a global age. Metaphilosophy, 40(1), 8–23.
13.
FlynnJ. (2003). Habermas on human rights: Law, morality, and intercultural dialogue. Social Theory and Practice, XXIX(3), 431–457.
14.
FlynnJ. (2009). Human rights, transnational solidarity, and duties to the global poor. Constellations16(1): 59–77.
15.
ForstR. (2010). The justification of human rights and the basic right to justification: A reflexive approach. Ethics, 120(4), 711–740.
16.
FraserN. (2005). Reframing justice in a globalizing world. New Left Review, 36, 69–88.
17.
GriffinJ. (2008). On human rights. Oxford University Press.
HabermasJ. (1987). The theory of communicative action. Lifeworld and system: A critique of functionalist reason (McCarthyT., Trans.). Polity Press.
20.
HabermasJ. (1990). Justice and solidarity: On the discussion concerning stage 6. In WrenT. E. (Ed.), The moral domain. MIT Press.
21.
HabermasJ. (1996). Between facts and norms: Contributions to a discourse theory of law and democracy (RehgW., Trans.). Polity Press.
22.
HabermasJ. (1998). The inclusion of the other: Studies in political theory (CroninC., Trans.). Polity Press.
23.
HabermasJ. (2001). The postnational constellation – Political essays (PenskyM., Trans.). MIT Press.
24.
HabermasJ. (2005). Equal treatment of cultures and the limits of postmodern liberalism. The Journal of Political Philosophy, 13(1), 1–28.
25.
HabermasJ. (2006). The divided West (CroninC., Trans.). Polity Press.
26.
HabermasJ. (2008). Between naturalism and religion (CroninC., Trans.). Polity Press.
27.
HabermasJ. (2012). The crisis of the European Union: A response. Polity Press.
28.
HabermasJ. (2014). Plea for a constitutionalization of international law. Philosophy and Social Criticism, 40(1), 5–12.
29.
IgnatieffM. (2001). Human rights as politics and idolatry. Princeton University Press.
30.
LafontC. (2008). Alternate visions of a new global order: What should cosmopolitans hope for?Ethics & Global Politics1(1-2): 1–20.
31.
LoickD. (2019). Juridification. In AllenA.MendietaE. (Eds.), The Cambridge Habermas Lexicon (pp. 208–211). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781316771303.056
32.
MillerD. (2013). Border regimes and human rights. Law and Ethics of Human Rights, 7(1), 1–24.
33.
MillerD. (2016). Strangers in our midst – The political philosophy of immigration. Harvard University Press.
34.
NickelJ. (2006). Making sense of human rights. Blackwell.
35.
ObermanK. (2011). Immigration, global poverty and the right to stay. Political Studies, 59, 253–268.
36.
ObermanK. (2016). Immigration as a human right. In FineS.YpiL. (Eds.), Migration in political theory: The ethics of movement and membership (pp. 32–56). Oxford University Press.
37.
ObermanK. (2017). Immigration, citizenship, and consent: What is wrong with permanent alienage?The Journal of Political Philosophy, 25(1), 91–107.
38.
OffeC. (2011). From migration in geographic space to migration in biographic time: Views from Europe. The Journal of Political Philosophy, 19(3), 333–373.
39.
PenskyM. (2008). The ends of solidarity: Discourse theory in ethics and politics. State University of New York Press.
40.
PierceA. (2017). Justice without solidarity? Collective identity and the fate of the ‘ethical’ in Habermas’ recent political theory. European Journal of Philosophy, 26(1), 546–568.
RawlsJ. (1999). The law of peoples. Harvard University Press.
43.
RazJ. (2010). Human rights without foundations. In BessonS.TasioulasJ. (Eds.), The philosophy of international law (pp. 321–338). Oxford University Press.
44.
RosenfeldR.AratoA. (Eds.). (1998). Habermas on law and democracy: Critical exchanges. University of California Press.
45.
ScheuermanW. (2008). Global governance without global government? Habermas on postnational democracy. Political Theory36(1): 133–151.
46.
StraehleC. (2017). Justice in migration. Canadian Journal of Philosophy, 48(2), 245–265.
47.
TasioulasJ. (2007). The moral reality of human rights. In PoggeT. (Ed.), Freedom from poverty as a human right (pp. 75–101). Oxford University Press.
48.
WalzerM. (1983). Spheres of justice: A defence of pluralism and equality. Basic Books.
