Arts and cultural journalism have been found in numerous debates during recent decades to struggle in the midst of a crisis. This article traces the recorded discourse of professionalism that considers cultural journalism to be in a state of decline. A literature review on academic research and contributions in public debates provides an insight into the ‘crisis talk’ of the last two decades and unveils general controversies in the development of the professional culture of cultural journalism. By mapping the discourse in terms of the unfavourable directions that the development of cultural journalism has moved in, the analysis constructs a model for the future research of this specialized branch of journalism.
BaldickC (2008a) Metacriticism. In: The Oxford Dictionary of Literary Terms. Oxford Reference Online. Available at: http://www.oxfordreference.com/ (accessed 7 May 2011).
3.
BaldickC (2008b) Criticism. In: The Oxford Dictionary of Literary Terms. Oxford Reference Online. Available at: http://www.oxfordreference.com/ (accessed 7 May 2011).
4.
BaumannS (2002) Marketing, cultural hierarchy, and the relevance of critics: film in the United States, 1935–1980. Poetics30(4): 243–262.
5.
Bech-KarlsenJ (1991) Kulturjournalistikk: Avkobling eller tilkobling? (Cultural Journalism: Attachment or Detachment?) Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.
6.
BélandJ-P (2003) La Crise de l’art contemporain: illusion ou réalité? (The Crisis of Contemporary Art: Illusion or Reality?) Saint-Nicolas, Québec: Les presses de l’université Laval.
7.
BennettO (ed.) (2001) Cultural Pessimism: Narratives of Decline in the Postmodern World. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
8.
BensonR (1999) Field theory in comparative context: a new paradigm for media studies. Theory and Society28(3): 463–498.
9.
BergerM (ed.) (1998) The Crisis of Criticism. New York: New York Press.
10.
BourdieuP (1993) The Field of Cultural Production: Essays on Art and Literature. Cambridge: Polity Press.
11.
BourdieuP (1996) The Rules of Art: Genesis and Structure of the Literary Field. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
12.
BrensonM (1998) Resisting the dangerous journey: the crisis of journalistic criticism. In: BergerM (ed.) The Crisis of Criticism. New York: New York Press.
13.
BrunickP (2010) We have technology – part of the paradigm shift or part of the problem?Film CommentSeptember–October: 34–47.
14.
ChalabyJK (1996) Journalism as an Anglo-American invention: a comparison of the development of French and Anglo-American journalism, 1830s–1920s. European Journal of Communication11(3): 303–326.
15.
ChukriR (2010) Konstnärlig makeover. Kulturjournalistiken måste våga pröva nya format (Artistic makeover: cultural journalism must dare to try out new formats). In: HemerOForsareM (eds) Kulturjournalistikens gränser (The Frontiers of Cultural Journalism). Umeå: Bokförlaget h:ström.
16.
ConnellRW (2006) Core activity: reflexive intellectual workers and cultural crisis. Journal of Sociology42(1): 5–23.
17.
DeuzeM (2005) What is journalism? Professional identity and ideology of journalists reconsidered. Journalism: Theory, Practice and Criticism6(4): 442–464.
18.
DicksteinM (1992) Double Agent – The Critic and Society. New York: Oxford University Press.
19.
DuncanHD (1953) Language and Literature in Society: A Sociological Essay on Theory and Method in the Interpretation of Linguistic Symbols with a Bibliographical Guide to the Sociology of Literature. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
20.
DuncanM (2006) Buggy-making in tulip time. In: RubinsteinR (ed.) Critical Mess: Art Critics on the State of their Practice. Lenox, MA: Hard Press Editions.
21.
EkelundBG (2002) ‘The age of criticism’: debating the decline of literature in the US, 1940–2000. Poetics30(5–6): 327–340.
22.
ElkinsJ (2003) What Happened to Art Criticism?Chicago: Prickly Paradigm Press.
23.
ElkinsJNewmanM (eds) (2008) The State of Art Criticism. New York: Routledge.
24.
EntmanRM (1993) Framing: toward clarification of a fractured paradigm. Journal of Communication43(4): 51–58.
25.
EsserF (1998) Editorial structures and work principles in British and German newsrooms. European Journal of Communication13(3): 375–405.
26.
FinkH (1988) Et hyperkomplekst begreb – kultur, kulturbegreb og kulturrelativisme (A hypercomplex concept: culture, culture concept and cultural relativism). In: HaugeHHorstbøllH (eds) Kulturbegrebets kulturhistorie (The Cultural History of the Concept of Culture). Aarhus: Aarhus Universitetesforlag.
27.
FreidsonE (2001) Professionalism: The Third Logic. Cambridge: Polity Press.
GrimsmoI (1991) Utdanning av kulturjournalister: ei behovsundersøkning (Education of Cultural Journalists: A Needs Assessment). Oslo: University of Oslo.
30.
HaackeW (1951–3) Handbuch des Feuilletons (Handbook of the Feuilleton). Emsdetten: Lechte.
31.
HabermasJ (1962) Strukturwandel der Öffentlichkeit (Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere). Darmstadt and Neuwied: Hermann Luchterhand Verlag.
32.
HajduD (2009) Condition critical. Columbia Journalism Review47(5): 48–52.
33.
HallinDCManciniP (2004) Comparing Media Systems: Three Models of Media and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
HanuschV (2009) A product of their culture: using a value systems approach to understand the work practices of journalists. International Communication Gazette71(7): 613–626.
36.
HarriesGWahl-JorgensenK (2007) The culture of arts journalists: elitists, saviors or manic depressives?Journalism: Theory, Practice and Criticism8(6): 619–639.
37.
HellmanHJaakkolaM (2012) Cultural journalists in news apprentice: the paradigm shift in arts journalism in Finland. Journalism: Theory, Practice and Criticism13(6): 783–801.
38.
HeppA (2013) Cultures of Mediatization. Cambridge: Polity Press.
39.
HobermanJ (1998) The film critic of tomorrow. In: BergerM (ed.) The Crisis of Criticism. New York: New York Press.
40.
HohendahlPU (1982) Institution of Criticism. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
41.
HurriM (1993) Kulttuuriosasto. Symboliset taistelut, sukupolvikonflikti ja sananvapaus viiden pääkaupunkilehden kulttuuritoimituksissa 1945–80 (Culture Department: Symbolic Struggles, Generational Conflict and Freedom of Speech in Five Capital Based Dailies, 1945–80). Tampere: Tampere University Press.
42.
JaakkolaM (2012) Promoting aesthetic tourism: transgressions between generalist and specialist subfields in cultural journalism. Journalism Practice6(4): 482–496.
43.
JanewayMSzántóA (2003) Arts, culture, and media in the United States. Journal of Arts Management, Law, and Society32(4): 279–292.
44.
JanssenS (1999) Art journalism and cultural change: the coverage of the arts in Dutch newspapers 1965–1990. Poetics26(5–6): 329–348.
45.
JanssenSKuipersGVerboordM (2008) Cultural globalization and arts journalism: the international orientation of arts and culture coverage in Dutch, French, German, and U.S. newspapers, 1955 to 2005. American Sociological Review73(5): 719–740.
46.
JonesSFeatherlyK (2002) Re-viewing rock writing: narratives of popular music criticism. In: JonesS (ed.) Pop Music and the Press. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
47.
JowettGLintonJM (1989) Movies as Mass Communication. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
48.
JørgensenJC (1991) Kultur i avisen. En grundbog i kulturjournalistik (Culture in the Newspaper: Basics in Cultural Journalism). Copenhagen: Gyldendal.
49.
KauffmannKSchützE (ed) (2000) Die lange Geschichte der Kleinen Form. Beiträge zur Feuilletonforschung (Long History of the Small Form: Proceedings in the Studies of the Feuilleton). Berlin: Weidler Buchverlag.
50.
KnapskogKLarsenLO (eds) (2008) Kulturjournalistikk: Pressen og den kulturelle offentligheten (Cultural Journalism: The Press and the Cultural Public Sphere). Oslo: Scandinavian Academic Press.
51.
KristensenNN (2004) Journalister og kilder: slinger i valsen? Udfordringen af journalistikken i lyset af kildernes professionalisering (Journalists and Sources: Without a Hitch? Demands for Journalism from the Light of the Professionalization of the Sources). Århus: Center for Journalistik og efteruddannelse.
52.
KristensenNN (2010a) The historical transformation of cultural journalism. Northern Lights: Film and Media Studies Yearbook8(1): 69–92.
53.
KristensenNN (2010b) Kulturjournalistikken fra et offentlighedsperspektiv – men uden at væra en forfaldshistorie (Cultural journalism from the perspective of the public sphere – but without being a history of degeneration). Norsk medietidsskrift17(2): 208–211.
54.
KristensenNNFromU (2011) Kulturjournalistik: journalistik om kultur (Cultural Journalism: Journalism on Culture). Copenhagen: Samfundslitteratur.
55.
LarsenLO (2008) Forskyvninger: Kulturdekningen i norske dagsaviser 1964–2005 (Displacements: cultural coverage in Norwegian dailies, 1964–2005). In: KnapskogKLarsenLO (eds) Kulturjournalistikk: Pressen og den kulturelle offentligheten (Cultural Journalism: The Press and the Cultural Public Sphere). Oslo: Scandinavian Academic Press.
56.
LindbergUGudmundssonGMichelsenMWeisethaunetH (2005) Rock Criticism from the Beginning: Amusers, Bruisers and Cool-headed Cruisers. New York: Peter Lang.
57.
LundC (2005) Kritikk og kommers (Criticism and Commerce). Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.
58.
McChesneyRWPickardV (eds) (2011) Will the Last Reporter Please Turn Out the Lights: The Collapse of Journalism and What Can Be Done To Fix It. New York: The New Press.
59.
McDonaldR (2007) The Death of the Critic. London: Continuum.
60.
MikkolaK (ed.) (1972) Kulttuuritoimittaja (The Cultural Journalist). Oulu: Suomen kulttuurirahasto.
61.
MoratóAR (2003) The culture society: a new place for the arts in the twenty-first century. Journal of Arts Management, Law, and Society32(4): 243–256.
62.
OatesJC (1998) Confronting head-on the face of the afflicted. In: BergerM (ed.) The Crisis of Criticism. New York: New York Press.
63.
OlmsteadKJ (1986) Twenty years of cultural journalism. Journal of Experiential Education9(3): 4–8.
64.
PoolG (2007) Faint Praise: The Plight of Book Reviewing in America. Columbia: University of Missouri Press.
65.
ReusGHardenL (2005) Politische ‘Kultur’: Eine Längsschnittanalyse des Zeitungsfeuilletons von 1983 bis 2003 (Political ‘culture’: a longitudinal analysis of the newspaper feuilleton from 1983 to 2003). Publizistik50(2): 153–172.
66.
RubinsteinR (ed.) (2006) Critical Mess: Art Critics on the State of Their Practice. Lenox, MA: Hard Press Editions.
67.
SchmutzVVenrooijAJanssenSVerboordM (2010) Change and continuity in newspaper coverage of popular music since 1955: evidence from the United States, France, Gemany, and the Netherlands. Popular Music and Society33(4): 501–515.
68.
SchönDA (1984) The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action. Aldershot: Avebury.
69.
SzántóALevyDSTyndallA (eds) (2004) Reporting the Arts II: News Coverage of Arts and Culture in America. New York: National Arts Journalism Program, Columbia University.
70.
TitchenerCB (1998) Reviewing the Arts. New York: Lawrence Erlbaum.
71.
TyndallA (2004) The dailies: old formats, new challenges. In: SzántóALevyDSTyndallA (eds) Reporting the Arts II: News Coverage of Arts and Culture in America. New York: National Arts Journalism Program, Columbia University.
72.
VenrooijA (2009) The aesthetic discourse space of popular music: 1985–86 and 2004–05. Poetics37(4): 315–332.
73.
WassermanH (2004) Revisiting reviewing: the need for a debate on the role of arts journalism in South Africa. Literator25(1): 139–157.
74.
WilliamsR (1983 [1976]) Keywords. New edition. New York: Oxford University Press.
75.
WitschgeTNygrenG (2009) Journalism: a profession under pressure?Journal of Media Business Studies6(1): 37–59.
