Field maturation in journalism: The role of hackademics as a ‘motley crew’

Abstract

The academization of journalism is dependent on faculty in the field embracing critical research evidenced by publishing in relevant peer reviewed journals. This involves a four-step process, beginning with recognizing that critical research is central to determining the field, which presents a specific challenge to the majority of journalism faculty who transfer to the academy from practice. Journalism faculty who were or had been practicing journalists were asked how they valued critical research. Their responses indicated that, while generally viewing critical research as purposeful, they held it to be weakly integral to their roles in the academy. It is suggested that this reflects their prior experiences as journalists in a particular moment in time; uncertainty about what constitutes ‘research’, and a failure to translate external impetuses to build research into an internal research culture, caused by their shifting and uncertain roles in motley crews of creative and academic production.

Keywords

academization creative industries faculty journalism motley crews research

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

Duffield

(2005) Profiles of journalism education: what students are being offered in Australia. Paper presented to the JEA conference: Griffith University, Australia.

Anderson

(2009) Arts business practice or practice based research? RealTime 92: 4.

Askew

Clavarino

Glasziou

Del Mar

(2002) General practice research: attitudes and involvement of Queensland general practitioners. Medical Journal of Australia 77(2): 74–77.

Australia Council (2010) Stragetic Directions. Surry Hills, NWS: Australia Council for the Arts.

Australian Research Council (2010) Discovery projects funding rules for funding commencing in 2012. Canberra: Australian Government.

Australian Research Council (2011) Linkage projects funding rules for funding commencing in 2011 variation (No. 1). Canberra: Australian Government.

Bacon

(1998) Engaging theory and practice in journalism education. Asia Pacific Media Educator 4: 79–83.

Bacon

(2006) Journalism as research. Australian Journalism Review 28(2): 147–157.

Barnhurst

(2003) The makers of meaning: National Public Radio and the new long journalism, 1980–2000. Political Communication 20: 1–22.

10.

Biggs

MAR

Bülcher

(2007) Rigour and practice-based research. Design Issues 23(3): 62–69.

11.

Bilton

(2010) Manageable creativity. International Journal of Cultural Policy 16(3): 255–269.

12.

Bossio

(2010) Defining ‘professionalism’ within tertiary journalism studies. Paper presented to the ANZCA conference: University of Canberra. Available at: http://www.canberra.edu.au/anzca2010/attachments/pdf/Defining-professionalism-within-tertiary-journalism-studies.pdf (accessed 28 September 2011).

13.

Breed

(1955) Social control in the newsroom: a functional analysis. Social Forces 33(4): 326–335.

14.

Bromley

(1997) The end of journalism? Changes in workplace practices in the press and broadcasting in the 1990s. In: Bromley

O’Malley

(eds) A Journalism Reader. London: Routledge, pp. 330–350.

15.

Bromley

(2011) iPhones and eyeshades: journalism and the university’s role in promoting a dynamic public sphere. In: Zelizer

(ed.) Making the University Matter. Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 104–112.

16.

Bromley

Neal

(2011) Publishing participation and productivity among journalist-academics in the era of ERA. Australian Journalism Review 33(1): 55–72.

17.

Bromley

(2013, forthcoming) The ‘new majority’ and the academization of journalism. Journalism: theory, practice and criticism. DOI 10.1.1177/1464884912453285.

18.

Burns

(2003) Reflections: development of Australian journalism education. Asia Pacific Media Educator 14: 57–75.

19.

Callaghan

McManus

(2010) Building the perfect graduate: what news employers want in their new hires. Asia Pacific Media Educator 20: 9–22.

20.

Candy

(2006) Practice based research: a guide. Creative & Cognition Studios Report 1. Available at: http://www.mangold-international.com/fileadmin/Media/References/Publications/Downloads/Practice_Based_Research_A_Guide.pdf (accessed 29 September 2011).

21.

Caves

(2000) Creative Industries: Contracts between Art and Commerce. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

22.

Caves

(2006) Organization of arts and entertainment industries. In: Ginsburgh

Throsby

(eds) Handbook on the Economics of Art and Culture, Vol. 1. Mayland Heights, MO: Elsevier, pp. 533–566.

23.

Cole

Harcup

(2010) Newspaper Journalism. London: SAGE.

24.

Cole

Bowers

(1973) Research article productivity of US journalism faculties. Journalism Quarterly 50(2): 246–254.

25.

Cole

Bowers

(1975) An exploration of factors related to journalism faculty productivity. Journalism Quarterly 52(4): 638–644.

26.

Cowan

Westphal

(2011) The Washington-Madison solution. In: McChesney

Pickard

(eds) Will the Last Reporter Please Turn Out the Lights: The Collapse of Journalism and What Can be Cone to Fix It. New York: The New Press, pp. 133–137.

27.

Crow

(2011) Demonstrating quality in higher education. Proceedings of the Australian Quality Forum, AUQA Occasional Publication 24. Melbourne, Vic: Australian Universities Quality Agency, pp. 1–6.

28.

Cullen

Callaghan

(2010) Promises, promises: are Australian universities deceiving journalism students? Australian Journalism Review 32(2): 117–129.

29.

De Beer

(2008) South African journalism research: challenging paradigmatic schisms and finding a foothold in an era of globalization. In: Löffelholtz

Weaver

(eds) Global Journalism Research: Theories, Methods, Findings, Future. Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 185–196.

30.

De Beer

(2010) Looking for journalism education scholarship in some unusual places: the case of Africa. Communicatio 36(2): 213–226.

31.

De Fleur

(2007) Raising the question #5: what is tenure and how do I get it? Communication Education 56(1): 106–112.

32.

Denison

(1996) What is the difference between organization culture and organizational climate? A native’s point of view on a decade of paradigm wars. Academy of Management Review 21(3): 619–654.

33.

Deuze

(2006) Global journalism education: a conceptual approach. Journalism Studies 7(1): 19–34.

34.

Duffield

(2009) A news story as big as a doctoral thesis? Displaying journalistic methodology in academic research. Communication, Creativity and Global Citizenship, proceedings of ANZCA09. Available at: http://www.cpe.qut.edu.au/conferences/2009/anzca/proceedings/Duffield_ANZCA09.pdf (accessed 18 February 2011).

35.

Edge

(2000) And the ‘wall’ came tumbling down in Los Angeles. In: Greenwald

Bernt

(eds) The Big Chill: Investigative Reporting in the Current Media Environment. Ames, IO: Iowa State University Press, pp. 197–210.

36.

Eikof

Haunschild

(2006) Lifestyle meets market: bohemian entrepreneurs in creative industries. Creativity and Innovation Management 15(3): 234–241.

37.

Erman

Todorovski

(2009) Mapping the e-government research with social network analysis. Lecture Notes in Computer Science 5693: 13–25.

38.

Errigo

Franklin

(2004) Surviving in the hackademy. British Journalism Review 15(2): 43–48.

39.

Flew

Sternberg

Adams

(2007) Revisiting the ‘media wars’ debate. Australian Journal of Communication 34(1): 1–27.

40.

French

(2007a) Journalism education in Ireland. Irish Communications Review 10: 41–49.

41.

French

(2007b) Professional knowledge, professional education and journalism. Paper presented to the IAMCR conference: Paris (July). Available at: http://arrow.dit.ie/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1044&context=aaschmedart (accessed 28 September 2011).

42.

Fröhlich

Holtz-Bacha

(1994) Structures of inhomogeneity – dilemmas of journalism training in Europe. Paper presented to IAMCR conference: Seoul, July. Available at: http://eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED377537.pdf (accessed 28 September 2011).

43.

Greenberg

Salwen

M.B

(1996) Mass communication theory and research: concepts and models. In Salwen

Stacks

(eds) An Integrated Approach to Communication Theory and Research. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp. 63–78.

44.

Hallin

(1994) We Keep America on Top of the World: Television Journalism and the Public Sphere. London: Routledge.

45.

Hannis

(2010) Journalism research and ERA: observations from New Zealand’s experience with the PBRF. ejournalist 10(1). Available at: http://ejournalist.com.au/v10n/Hannis.pdf (accessed 12 January 2011).

46.

Harcup

(2011a) Hackademics at the chalkface. Journalism Practice 5(1): 34–50.

47.

Harcup

(2011b) Research and reflection: supporting journalism educators in becoming scholars. Journalism Practice 5(2): 161–176.

48.

Harcup

(2011c) Questioning the ‘bleeding obvious’: what’s the point of researching journalism? Journalism 13(1): 1–17.

49.

Haundschild

(2003) Managing employment relationships in flexible labour markets: the case of German repertory theatres. Human Relations 56(8): 899–929.

50.

Henningham

(1998) Australian journalists. In: Weaver

with Wu

(eds) The Global Journalist: News People Around the World. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press, pp. 91–107.

51.

Herbert

(2000) The changing face of journalism education in the UK. Asia Pacific Media Educator 8: 113–123.

52.

Hickson

Boden

Turner

(2004) Research productivity in communication: an analysis, 1915–2001. Communication Quarterly 52(4): 323–333.

53.

Hickson

Turner

Boden

(2003) Research productivity in communication: an analysis, 1996–2001. Communication Research Reports 20(4): 308–319.

54.

Hickson

Stacks

Amsbary

(1989) An analysis of prolific scholarship in speech communication, 1915–1985: toward a yardstick for measuring research productivity. Communication Education 38(3): 230–236.

55.

Hickson

Stacks

Amsbary

(1992) Active prolific female scholars in communication: an analysis of research productivity, II. Communication Quarterly 40(4): 350–356.

56.

Hickson

Stacks

Amsbary

(1993) Active prolific scholars in communication studies: analysis of research productivity, II. Communication Education 42(3): 224–233.

57.

Hickson

Stacks

Boden

(1999) The status of research productivity in communication: 1915–1995. Communication Monographs 66(2): 178–197.

58.

Hodder

APW

Hodder

(2010) Research culture and New Zealand’s performance-based research fund: some insights from bibliographic compilations of research outputs. Scientometrics 84(3): 887–901.

59.

James

(2003) A working model for postgraduate practice-based research across the creative arts. Paper presented to DED3, 14–17 July, Tsukuba, Japan. Available at: http://www.designresearchsociety.org/docs-procs/ded3/d_final_paper/d_02.pdf (accessed 29 September 2011).

60.

Journalism Education Association of Australia (2011) Associated courses. Available at: http://jeaa.org.au/courses.htm (accessed 29 September 2011).

61.

Katz

(1989) Journalists as scientists: notes towards an occupational classification. American Behavioral Scientist 33(2): 238–246.

62.

Le May

Mulhall

Alexander

(1998) Bridging the research-practice gap: exploring the research cultures of practitioners and managers. Journal of Advanced Nursing 28(2): 428–437.

63.

Leung

KWY

Chu

Lee

PSN

(2006) Journalism and communication education and research in Hong Kong. In Leung

KWY

Kenny

Lee

PSN

(eds) Global Trends in Communication Education and Research. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton, pp. 189–209.

64.

McChesney

Nichols

(2010) The Death and Life of American Journalism: The Media Revolution that will Begin the World Again. Philadelphia, PA: Nation Books.

65.

Macdonald

(2006) Mindset and skillset: the persistence of division in media education. Journal of Media Practice 7(2): 135–142.

66.

Machin

Niblock

(2006) News Production: Theory and Practice. Abingdon: Routledge.

67.

McKee

(2004) Why do we need research? Library and Information Research 28(88): 3–12.

68.

MacLeod

(2004) RAE overhaul to produce research ‘premier league’. Guardian, 10 February. Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2004/feb/11/highereducation.researchassessmentexercise1 (accessed 29 September 2011).

69.

McVicker

(2005) Journalism education in the posthistorical university. In: Skinner

Crompton

Gasher

(eds) Converging Media, Diverging Politics: A Political Economy of News Media in the United States and Canada. Oxford: Lexington, pp. 223–248.

70.

Marshall

Newton

(2000) Scholarly design as a paradigm for practice-based research. Working Papers in Art and Design 1. Available at: http://sitem.herts.ac.uk/artdes_research/papers/wpades/vol1/marshall2.html (accessed 30 September 2011).

71.

Medsger

(2005) The evolution of journalism education in the United States. In: De Burgh

(ed.) Making Journalists. London: Routledge, pp. 205–226.

72.

Mellado

(2010) Examining professional and academic culture in Chilean journalism and mass communication education. Journalism Studies 12(3): 375–391.

73.

Mensing

(2011) Realigning journalism education. In: Mensing

Frankin

(eds) Journalism Education, Training and Employment. New York: Routledge, pp. 15–32.

74.

Mensing

Franklin

(2011) Journalism education, training, and employment. In: Franklin

Mensing

(eds) Journalism Education, Training and Employment. New York: Routledge, pp. 1–10.

75.

Moeran

(2009) The organization of creativity in Japanese advertising production. Human Relations 62(7): 963–985.

76.

Morton

Beard

(2005) Faculty productivity and Carnegie institutional characteristics within AEJMC programs. Journalism & Mass Communication Educator 60(2): 176–189.

77.

Niblock

(2007) From ‘knowing how’ to ‘being able’. Journalism Practice 1(1): 20–32.

78.

North

(2010) The gender ‘problem’ in Australian journalism education. Australian Journalism Review 32(2): 103–115.

79.

O’Donnell

(2007) Journalism and philosophy: remembering Clem Lloyd. Australian Media Traditions conference, 22–23 November. Bathurst, NSW: Charles Sturt University.

80.

Oplatka

(2010) The Legacy of Educational Administration: A Historical Analysis of an Academic Field. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang.

81.

Performance Based Research Fund (nd) Sector Reference Group Review: Evaluating Applied and Practice-Based Research. Available at: http://www.tec.govt.nz/Documents/Reports%20and%20other%20documents/pbrf-pa-research.pdf (accessed 29 September 2011).

82.

Perloff

(1976) Journalism research: a 20-year perspective. Journalism Quarterly 53(1): 123–126.

83.

Pink

Bascand

(2008) Australian and New Zealand Standard Research Classification (ANZSRC), ABS Catalogue No. 1297.0. Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics.

84.

Porter

Umbach

(2001) Analyzing faculty workload data using multilevel modeling. Research in Higher Education 42(2): 171–196.

85.

Prophet

(2011) Re-addressing practice based research: funding and recognition. Centre for Arts Research Technology and Education: University of Westminster, UK. Available at: http://goldsmiths.academia.edu/JaneProphet/Papers/639428/Re-addressing_practice-based_research_funding_and_recognition (accessed 29 September 2011).

86.

Rahkonen

(2007) Mapping Media and Communication Research: Australia. Department of Communication Research Report 7/2007, University of Helsinki.

87.

Roggenkamp

(2005) Narrating the News: New Journalism and Literary Genre in Late Nineteenth-Century American Newspapers and Fiction. Kent, OH: Kent State University Press.

88.

Schramm

(1957) Twenty years of journalism research. Public Opinion Quarterly 21(1): 91–107.

89.

Schweitzer

(1989) Factors affecting scholarly research among mass communications faculty. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 66(2): 410–417 and 452.

90.

Servaes

(2009) Epilogue: back to the future? Re-inventing journalism education in the age of globalization. In: Terzis

(ed.) European Journalism Education. Bristol: Intellect, pp. 519–539.

91.

Shipman

(2006) Knowledge Monopolies: The Academisation of Society. Exeter: Societas.

92.

Sloan

(1990) In search of itself: a history of journalism education. In: Sloan

(ed.) Makers of the Media Mind: Journalism Educators and their Ideas. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp. 1–22.

93.

CYK

(2010) The rise of Asian communication research: a citation study of SSCI journals. Asian Journal of Communication 20(2): 230–247.

94.

Splichal

Sparks

(1994) Journalists for the 21st Century. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.

95.

Stark

Lowther

Hargerty

BMK

(1986) Faculty roles and role preferences in ten fields of professional study. Research in Higher Education 25(1): 3–30.

96.

Stephen

(2009) Clustering research activity in communication doctoral programs: relationship of publication productivity and department size to disciplinary reputation and prestige. Journal of Communication 59(4): 768–787.

97.

Stephen

Geel

(2007) Normative publication productivity of communication scholars at selected career milestones. Human Communication Research 33(1): 103–118.

98.

Stock

(2010) Approaches to acquiring ‘graduateness’ in the creative industries: an Australian perspective. Tirai Panggung: Performing Arts Journal 10: 20–45.

99.

Švab

(2004) Changing research culture. Annals of Family Medicine 2(2): 530–534.

100.

Tankard

(1990) The theorists. In: Sloan

(ed.) Makers of the Media Mind: Journalism Educators and their Ideas. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp. 227–288.

101.

Temple

(2009) The future of journalism education in the United Kingdom: a personal view from the academy. Medianali 3(5): 241–257.

102.

Ton

(2009) What are the learning styles of ‘creatives’ and ‘suits? MSocSci thesis, Copenhagen Business School.

103.

Townley

Beech

McKinlay

(2009) Managing in the creative industries: managing the motley crew. Human Relations 62(7): 939–962.

104.

Turner

(2011a) The ERA and journalism research. Australian Journalism Review 33(1): 5–7.

105.

Turner

(2011b) Talk at University of Technology Sydney, 15 September. Available at: http://alanknight.wordpress.com/2011/09/30/recognising-journalism-and-creative-writing-as-research/ (accessed 3 October 2011).

106.

Turner

(2012) What’s Become of Cultural Studies? London: Sage.

107.

Wahl-Jorgensen

Franklin

(2008) Journalism research in the UK: from isolated efforts to an established discipline. In: Löffelholtz

Weaver

(eds) Global Journalism Research: Theories, Methods, Findings, Future. Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 172–184.

108.

Weaver

(1998) Journalists around the world: commonalities and differences. In: Weaver

with Wu

(eds) The Global Journalist: News People Around the World. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press, pp. 455–480.

109.

Weaver

Gray

(1980) Journalism and mass communication research in the United States: past, present and future. In: Wilhoit

De Bock

(eds) Mass Communication Review Yearbook. Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE, pp. 124–151.

110.

Weaver

McComb

(1980) Journalism and social science: a new relationship? Public Opinion Quarterly 44: 477–494.

111.

Weaver

Wilhoit

(1988) A profile of JMC educators: traits, attitudes and values. Journalism Educator 43(3): 4–41.

112.

Wilson

Kennan

Willard

Boell

(2010) Fifty years of LIS education in Australia: academization of LIS educators in higher education institutions. Library & Information Science Research 32: 246–257.

113.

Withnall

Harris

(1998) Principles for further education in professional communication: continuing education or postgraduate degrees? AsiaPacific Media Educator 5: 24–37.

114.

Xenitidou

Gilbert

(2009) Innovations in Social Science Research Methods. Guildford: University of Surrey.

115.

Zelizer

(2005) Definitions of journalism. In: Overholser

Hall Jamieson

(eds) The Press. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 66–80.