Presidential speeches and the online politics of belonging: Affective-discursive positions toward refugees in Finland and Estonia

Abstract

The so-called ‘refugee crisis’ has added urgency to the social dynamics of inclusion and exclusion in European societies. This study explores how emotions figure in this politics of belonging by studying their discursive mobilization in Finnish and Estonian public debates on asylum seekers. Focusing on presidential speeches addressing the refugee issue, on the one hand, and their reception by online commenters on popular tabloid news sites, on the other, the comparative analysis highlights both similarities and differences in how emotional expressions are employed in these two countries with very different experiences of taking refugees. Despite employing common discursive elements in their speeches, the diverging national contexts prompted the two presidents to emphasize contrasting emotional positions: the insecure Finn, threatened by abusive asylum seekers, and the compassionate Estonian, capable of identifying with the plight of refugees. In contrast, the reactions to speeches by Finnish and Estonian citizens on tabloid news sites demonstrated highly converging emotional positions. Online comments in both countries revealed deep anger and distrust of political elites among tabloid news audiences, articulating a complex relationship with the nation as a divided and exclusive political community.

Keywords

Belonging elites emotions European refugee crisis immigration populism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahmed

(2004) The Cultural Politics of Emotion. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

Benski

Langman

(2013) The effects of affects: The place of emotions in the mobilizations of 2011. Current Sociology 61(4): 525–540.

Brader

(2006) Campaigning for Hearts and Minds: How Emotional Appeals in Political Ads Work. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

Bucy

(2000) Emotional and evaluative consequences of inappropriate leader displays. Communication Research 27(2): 194–226.

Burkitt

(2005) Powerful emotions: Power, government and opposition in the ‘war on terror’. Sociology 39(4): 679–695.

De Castella

McGarty

(2011) Two leaders, two wars: A psychological analysis of fear and anger content in political rhetoric about terrorism. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy 11(1): 180–200.

Edwards

Herder

(2012) Melding a new immigration narrative? President George W. Bush and the immigration debate. The Howard Journal of Communications 23(1): 40–65.

Erisen

Villalobos

(2014) Exploring the invocation of emotion in presidential speeches. Contemporary Politics 20(4): 469–488.

Eurobarometer (2015) Public Opinion in the European Union, National Report Estonia. Brussels: European Union.

10.

Eurobarometer (2016a) Public Opinion in the European Union, First Results. Brussels: European Union.

11.

Eurobarometer (2016b) Public Opinion in the European Union, National Report: Finland. Brussels: European Union.

12.

Eurostat (2016) Record number of over 1.2 million first time asylum seekers registered in 2015. Eurostat News Release, 4 March. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-press-releases/-/3-04032016-AP

13.

Goodwin

Jasper

Polletta

(eds) (2001) Passionate Politics: Emotions and Social Movements. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

14.

Harrison

(2016) Mediations of ‘the refugee crisis’: The (ir)reconciliation of ideological contradictions in Fortress Europe. Networking Knowledge 9(4). Available at: http://ojs.meccsa.org.uk/index.php/netknow/article/view/449/271

15.

Holmes

Castañeda

(2016) Representing the ‘European refugee crisis’ in Germany and beyond: Deservingness and difference, life and death. American Ethnologist 43(1): 12–24.

16.

Horsti

(2007) Asylum seekers in the news: Frames of illegality and control. Observatorio 1(1): 145–161.

17.

Ilves

(2015a) Let us renew Estonia, 25 August. Available at: https://vp2006-2016.president.ee/en/official-duties/speeches/11552-let-us-renew-estonia/index.html (accessed 18 May 2017).

18.

Ilves

(2015b) New Year’s Eve greetings from the President of the Republic, 31 December. Available at: https://vp2006-2016.president.ee/en/official-duties/speeches/11887-new-years-eve-greetings-from-the-president-of-the-republic-on-31-december-2015/index.html (accessed 18 May 2017).

19.

Ilves

(2016) President Ilves at the Republic of Estonia Independence Day celebration, 24 February. Available at: https://vp2006-2016.president.ee/en/official-duties/speeches/12047-president-ilves-at-the-republic-of-estonia-independence-day-celebration-on-24-february-2016-at-the-estonia-concert-hall/index.html (accessed 18 May 2017).

20.

Inglehart

Norris

(2016) Trump, Brexit, and the rise of populism: Economic have-nots and cultural backlash. HKS Faculty Research Working Paper 16-026. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Kennedy School.

21.

Laclau

(2005) On Populist Reason. London: Verso.

22.

Lähdesmäki

Saresma

Hiltunen

et al . (2016) Fluidity and flexibility of ‘belonging’: Uses of the concept in contemporary research. Acta Sociologica 59(3): 233–247.

23.

Leitner

(2012) Spaces of encounters: Immigration, race, class, and the politics of belonging in small-town America. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 102(4): 828–846.

24.

Loseke

(2009) Examining emotion as discourse: Emotion codes and presidential speeches justifying war. Sociological Quarterly 50(3): 497–524.

25.

Lyman

(2004) The domestication of anger: The use and abuse of anger in politics. European Journal of Social Theory 7(2): 133–147.

26.

McConville

McCreanor

Wetherell

et al . (2017) Imagining an emotional nation: The print media and Anzac Day commemorations in Aotearoa New Zealand. Media, Culture & Society 39: 94–110.

27.

McKee

(2005) The Public Sphere: An Introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

28.

Matthews

Brown

(2011) Negatively shaping the asylum agenda? The representational strategy and impact of a tabloid news campaign. Journalism 13(6): 802–817.

29.

Nightingale

Quayle

Muldoon

(2017) ‘It’s just heart breaking’: Doing inclusive political solidarity or ambivalent paternalism through sympathetic discourse within the ‘refugee crisis’ debate. Journal of Community & Applied Psychology 27(2): 137–146.

30.

Niinistö

(2015) Speech by President of the Republic Sauli Niinistö at the Ambassador Seminar, 25 August. Available at: https://www.presidentti.fi/en/speeches/speech-by-president-of-the-republic-sauli-niinisto-at-the-ambassador-seminar-25-august-2015/ (accessed 7 January 2019).

31.

Niinistö

(2016a) New Year Speech by President of the Republic Sauli Niinistö, 1 January. Available at: https://www.presidentti.fi/en/speeches/new-year-speech-by-president-of-the-republic-sauli-niinisto-on-1-january-2016/ (accessed 7 January 2019).

32.

Niinistö

(2016b) Speech by President of the Republic Sauli Niinistö at the Opening of Parliament, 3 February. Available at: https://www.presidentti.fi/en/speeches/speech-by-president-of-the-republic-sauli-niinisto-at-the-opening-of-parliament-on-3-february-2016/ (accessed 7 January 2019).

33.

Ojala

Kaasik-Krogerus

(2016) Popular geopolitics in the shadow of Russia: The Ukraine conflict in Finnish and Estonian newspaper editorials. In: Pantti

(ed.) Media and the Ukraine Crisis: Hybrid Media Practices and Narratives of Conflict. New York: Peter Lang, pp.139–155.

34.

Pantti

Wahl-Jorgensen

(2011) ‘Not an act of God’: Anger and citizenship in press coverage of British man-made disasters. Media, Culture & Society 33(1): 105–122.

35.

Papacharissi

(2015) Affective Publics: Sentiment, Technology, and Politics. New York: Oxford University Press.

36.

Pellander

(2016) Gatekeepers of the family: Regulating family migration to Finland. Publications of the Faculty of Social Sciences 20. Helsinki: University of Helsinki.

37.

Silveira

(2016) The representation of (illegal) migrants in the British news. Networking Knowledge 9(4). Available at: http://ojs.meccsa.org.uk/index.php/netknow/article/view/449/271

38.

Skeggs

(2004) Class, Self, Culture. London: Routledge.

39.

Skey

(2014) ‘How do you think I feel? It’s my country’: Belonging, entitlement and the politics of immigration. The Political Quarterly 85(3): 326–332.

40.

Skilling

(2012) Immigration policy in New Zealand: Divergent narratives, shared assumptions and national identity. Critical Policy Studies 6(4): 363–378.

41.

Staiger

Cvetkovich

Reynolds

(eds) (2010) Political Emotions: New Agendas in Communication. London and New York: Routledge.

42.

Stuckey

(1991) The President as Interpreter-in-Chief. Chatham, NJ: Chatham House Publishers.

43.

Tyler

(2006) ‘Welcome to Britain’: The cultural politics of asylum. European Journal of Cultural Studies 9(2): 185–202.

44.

Veebel

(2015) Balancing between solidarity and responsibility: Estonia in the EU refugee crisis. Journal on Baltic Security 1(2): 28–61.

45.

Wetherell

(2013) Affect and discourse – What’s the problem? From affect as excess to affective/discursive practice. Subjectivity 6: 349–368.

46.

Wetherell

McCreanor

McConville

et al . (2015) Settling space and covering the nation: Some conceptual considerations in analysing affect and discourse. Emotion, Space and Society 16: 56–64.

47.

Yuval-Davis

(2006) Belonging and the politics of belonging. Patterns of Prejudice 40(3): 197–214.