This hermeneutic phenomenological study explores the relationship between health
professionals and families who have a child with a chronic illness. Study
participants included 10 family groups who had a child with a chronic illness and 12
practitioners from the disciplines of nursing, medicine, dietetics, physiotherapy
and speech therapy. Data were collected by narrative audiotaped interviewing. The
results of this study revealed that chronic childhood illness
‘throws' families and practitioners together into a web of
relationships, which must work for the sake of the child. However, children are
usually excluded from the relationship. To understand and manage the
child's illness, practitioners and families ‘go around’
and act ‘in-between’ relationships. While the quality of the
relationship from the family perspective is not essential, relationships are more
successful when practitioners recognize the uniqueness of each family web. The
nature of the relationship is often simple, yet it coexists with complexity.
Angst, D.B.
and
Deatrick, J.A.
(1996)
‘Involvement in Health Care Decisions: Parents and Children with
Chronic Illness’
, Journal of Family Nursing2(2):
174–184
.
2.
Arendt, H.
(1998[1958]) The Human Condition (2nd edn).
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
3.
Benner, P.
(1984) From Novice to Expert: Excellence and Power in
Clinical Nursing Practice.
Menlo Park, CA: Addison-Wesley
.
4.
Benner, P.
(1994) ‘The Tradition and Skill of Interpretive
Phenomenology in Studying Health, Illness and Caring
Practices’, in
P. Benner
(ed.) Interpretive Phenomenology, pp.
99–127.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
5.
Bircher, G.
(2000)
‘Children in Hospital: Issues of Power and Vulnerability’
, Paediatric Nursing26(3):
277–282
.
6.
Bishop, A.H.
and
Scudder, J.R.
(1990) The Practical, Moral and Personal Sense of Nursing: a
Phenomenological Philosophy of Practice.
New York: State University of New York Press
.
7.
Bishop, A.H.
and
Scudder, J.R.
(1991) Nursing: the Practice of Caring.
New York: National League for Nursing Press
.
8.
Brock, D.W.
(1991) ‘Facts and Values in the
Physician–Patient Relationship’, in
E.D. Pellegrino
,
R.M. Veatch
and
J.P. Langan
(eds) Ethics, Trust and the Professions: Philosophical and Cultural
Aspects, pp. 113–131.
Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press
.
9.
Buber, M.
(2002) Between Man and Man (trans. R. Gregor-Smith).
London: Routledge Classics
.
10.
Burke, S.
,
Kauffmann, E.
,
Costello, E.
and
Dillon, M.
(1991)
‘Hazardous Secrets and Reluctantly Taking Charge: Parenting a
Child with Repeated Hospitalisations’
, IMAGE: Journal of Nursing Scholarship23(1):
203–210
.
11.
Caelli, K.
(2000)
‘The Changing Face of Phenomenological Research: Traditional and
American Phenomenology in Nursing’
, Qualitative Health Research10(3):
366–377
.
12.
Campbell, T.
(1998)
‘Caring for the Technology Dependent Child–a Case Study’
, Nursing Praxis in New Zealand13(2):
5–10
.
13.
Casey, A.
(1988)
‘A Partnership with Child and Family’
, Senior Nurse8(4):
8–9
.
14.
Children's Health Liaison Group
(1993) Principles of Health Care for Children and Young
People.
Auckland: Children's Health Liaison Group
.
15.
Cohen, M.H.
(1993)
‘The Unknown and the Unknowable: Managing Sustained Uncertainty’
, Western Journal of Nursing Research15(1):
77–96
.
16.
Dew, K.
and
Kirkman, A.
(2002) Sociology of Health in New Zealand.
Melbourne: Oxford University Press
.
17.
Dixon, D.M.
(1996)
‘Unifying Concepts in Parents' Experiences with Health
Care Providers’
, Journal of Family Nursing2(2):
110–132
.
18.
Embrey, D.G.
,
Guthrie, M.R.
,
White, O.R.
and
Dietz, J.
(1996)
‘Clinical Decision Making by Experienced and Inexperienced
Physical Therapists for Children with Diplegic Palsy’
, Physical Therapy76(1):
20–33
.
19.
Epstein, R.M.
,
Campbell, T.L.
,
Cohen-Cole, S.A.
,
Mcwhinney, I.R.
and
Smilkstein, G.
(1993)
‘Perspectives on Patient–Doctor Communication’
, Journal of Family Practice37(4):
377–389
.
20.
Ford, K.
and
Turner, D.
(2001)
‘Stories Seldom Told: Paediatric Nurses' Experiences of
Caring for Hospitalized Children with Special Needs and Their Families’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing33(3):
288–295
.
21.
Gadamer, H.
(1982[1960]) Truth and Method.
New York: Crossroad
.
22.
Gibson, C.H.
(1999)
‘Facilitating Critical Reflection in Mothers of Chronically Ill Children’
, Journal of Clinical Nursing8(3):
305–312
.
23.
Heidegger, M.
(1996[1927]) Sein und Zeit [Being and Time] (trans J.
Stambaugh).
Albany, NY: State University of New York Press
.
24.
Horner, S.D.
(1997)
‘Uncertainty in Mothers' Care for Their Ill Children’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing26(4):
658–663
.
25.
Jackson, P. (2001) ‘The Meaning of Expert Practice to the Parents
of Children Receiving Physiotherapy’, Master of Health Science thesis,
Auckland University of Technology, Auckland.
26.
Jensen, G.M.
,
Lorish, C.
and
Shepard, K.F.
(1997) ‘Understanding Patient Receptivity to
Change: Teaching for Treatment Adherence’, in
K.F. Shepard
and
G.M. Jensen
(eds) Handbook for Teaching for Physical Therapists, pp.
241–269.
Boston, MA: Butterworth-Heinemann
.
27.
Jensen, G.M.
,
Gwyer, J.
,
Shepard, K.F.
and
Hack, L.M.
(2000)
‘Expert Practice in Physical Therapy’
, Physical Therapy80(1):
28–43
.
28.
Johns, J.L.
(1996)
‘A Concept Analysis of Trust’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing24(1):
76–83
.
29.
Kirk, S.
(2001)
‘Negotiating Lay and Professional Roles in the Care of Children
with Complex Health Care Needs’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing34(5):
593–602
.
30.
Levinas, E.
(1969[1961) Totality and Infinity (trans. A. Lingis).
Pittsburgh, PA: Duquesne University Press
.
31.
Levinas, E.
(1998) Thinking-of-the-Other, ‘Entre
Nous’(trans. M.B. Smith and B. Harshav).
London: Athlone Press
.
32.
Levinas, E.
(2002) ‘Ethics and the Face’,
in
D. Moran
and
T. Mooney
(eds) The Phenomenology Reader, pp.
515–528.
London: Routledge
.
33.
Lynn-McHale, D.J.
and
Deatrick, J.A.
(2000)
‘Trust Between Family and Health Care Provider’
, Journal of Family Nursing6(3):
210–230
.
34.
McKinlay, R.
(1981) The Care of Children in New Zealand Hospitals.
Wellington: National Children's Health
Research Foundation
.
35.
Mechanic, D.
(1998)
‘The Functions and Limitations of Trust in the Provision of
Medical Care’
, Journal of Health Policitics, Policy and Law23(4):
661–686
.
36.
Mitchell, A.
(2001) Right Side Up: Building Brands in the Age of the
Organized Consumer.
London: Harper Collins Business
.
37.
Murphy, G.
(2001)
‘The Technology-dependent Child at Home. Part 2: the Need for Respite’
, Paediatric Nursing13(8):
24–28
.
38.
Nethercott, S.
(1993)
‘A Concept for All the Family. Family-centred Care: a Concept Analysis’
, Professional Nurse8(12):
794–797
.
39.
New Zealand Paediatric Society and Health Funding Authority
(1997) Through the Eyes of a Child: a National Review of
Pediatric Specialty Services.
Wellington: Health Funding Authority Paediatric
Society of New Zealand
.
40.
O'Brien, M.E.
and
Wegner, C.B.
(2002)
‘Rearing the Child Who Is Technology Dependent: Perceptions of
Parents and Home Care Nurses’
, Journal of Specialist Pediatric Nursing7(1):
7–15
.
41.
O'Neil, M.E.
,
Palisano, R.J.
and
Westcott, S.L.
(2001)
‘Relationship of Therapists' Attitudes,
Children's Motor Ability and Parenting Stress to Mothers'
Perceptions of Therapists' Behaviors During Early Invervention’
, Physical Therapy81(8):
1412–1424
.
42.
O'Sullivan, P.
,
Mahoney, G.
and
Robinson, C.A.
(1992)
‘Perceptions of Pediatricians' Helpfulness: a National
Study of Mothers of Young Disabled Children’
, Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology34(12):
1064–1071
.
43.
Robinson, C.A.
(1996)
‘Health Care Relationships Revisited’
, Journal of Family Nursing2(2):
152–163
.
44.
Sartain, S.A.
,
Clarke, C.L.
and
Heyman, R.
(2000)
‘Hearing the Voices of Children with Chronic Illness’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing32(4):
913–921
.
45.
Scott, C.M.
(2003)
‘The Impact of the Consumer on Healthcare Delivery’
, Frontiers of Health Services Management19(4):
41–44
.
46.
Shapiro, J.
(2001)
‘Using Triangulation Concepts to Understand the
Doctor–Patient–Family Relationship’
, Families, Systems and Health19(2):
203–210
.
47.
Shelton, T.L.
and
Stepanek, J.S.
(1995)
‘Excerpts from Family Centred Care for Children Needing
Specialized Health and Developmental Services’
, Paediatric Nursing21(4):
362–364
.
48.
Shelton, T.L.
,
Jeppson, E.S.
and
Johnson, B.
(1987) Family-centred Care for Children with Special
Healthcare Needs.
Bethesda: Association for the Care of
Children's Health
.
49.
Smith, A.B.
and
Taylor, N.J.
(2000) ‘The Sociocultural Context of Childhood:
Balancing Dependency and Agency’, in
A.B. Smith
,
N.J. Taylor
and
M.M. Gollop
(eds) Children's Voices: Research, Policy and Practice,
pp. 1–17.
Auckland: Longman
.
50.
Stubberfield, C.
and
Murray, R.L.
(1999)
‘Parents Call for Concerned and Collaborative Care’
, Western Journal of Nursing Research21(3):
356–371
.
51.
Swallow, V.M.
and
Jacoby, A.
(2001)
‘Mothers' Evolving Relationship with Doctors and Nurses
During the Chronic Childhood Illness Trajectory’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing36(6):
755–764
.
52.
Tapp, P.
(1998) ‘Parenting, a Private Responsibility or a
Collaborative Partnership? A Perspective Based on the United Nations Convention
on the Rights of the Child’, in
V. Adair
and
R. Dixon
(eds) The Family in Aotearoa, New Zealand, pp.
1–56.
Auckland: Longman
.
53.
Tates, K.
,
Elbers, E.
,
Meeuwesen, L.
and
Bensing, J.
(2002)
‘Doctor–Parent–Child Relationships: a
“Pas De Trois”’
, Patient Education and Counseling48(1):
5–14
.
54.
Thomlinson, E.H.
(2002)
‘The Lived Experience of Families of Children Who Are Failing to Thrive’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing39(6):
537–545
.
55.
Thomsen, S.
(1999)
‘Making Family-centred Care a Reality’
, Kai Tiaki Nursing New Zealand4:
14–18
.
56.
Thorne, S.
and
Robinson, C.A.
(1988)
‘Health Care Relationships: the Chronic Illness Perspective’
, Research in Nursing and Health11(3):
293–300
.
57.
Thorne, S.
and
Robinson, C.A.
(1989)
‘Guarded Alliance: Health Care Relationships in Chronic Illness’
, IMAGE: Journal of Nursing Scholarship21(3):
153–157
.
58.
Titchen, A.
(2001) ‘Skilled Companionship in Professional
Practice’, in
J. Higgs
and
A. Titchen
(eds) Practice Knowledge and Expertise in the Health Professions,
pp. 69–79.
Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann
.
59.
Totka, J.P.
(1996)
‘Exploring the Boundaries of Pediatric Practice: Nurses Stories
Related to Relationships’
, Pediatric Nursing22(3):
191–197
.
60.
Turner, J.
and
Shanks, G.
(1996) We Just Want Our Daughter to Live! The Kelly Turner
Story.
Auckland: Penguin Books
.
61.
van Manen, M.
(1990) Researching Lived Experience: Human Science for an
Action Sensitive Pedagogy.
London, Ontario: State University of New York Press
.
62.
Veatch, R.M.
(1991) ‘Is Trust of Professionals a Coherent
Concept?’, in
E.D. Pellegrino
,
R.M. Veatch
and
J.P. Langan
(eds) Ethics, Trust and the Professions: Philosophical and Cultural
Aspects, pp. 159–173.
Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press
.
63.
Vogel, A.M.
,
Lennon, D.
,
Ameratunga, S.N.
and
Holyoake, J.
(1996)
‘Prevalence and Impact of Chronic Childhood Conditions in
Auckland, New Zealand’
, Journal of Paediatric Child Health32(6):
484–490
.
64.
Weaver, S.
(1999) Looking the Other Way: Raising Children with Special
Needs in Aotearoa/New Zealand.
Auckland: Harper Collins Publishers
.
65.
Wuest, J.
(2000)
‘Negotiating with Helping Systems: an Example of Grounded Theory
Evolving Through Emergent Fit’
, Qualitative Health Research10(1):
51–70
.
66.
Zaner, R.M.
(1991) ‘The Phenomenon of Trust and the
Patient–Physician Relationships’, in
E.D. Pellegrino
,
R.M. Veatch
and
J.P. Langan
(eds) Ethics, Trust and the Professions: Philosophical and Cultural
Aspects, pp. 45–63.
Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press
.
