The aim of this exploratory study was to understand the negotiation of care as
experienced by the parents of technology-dependent children in a hospital context.
Qualitative semi-structured interviews were undertaken with a group of six parents.
Parents felt that their roles as parents were not considered enough by nurses and
they tended to be seen as carers, not parents. Negotiation of care was not always
apparent. Instead, nurses often made assumptions about parental involvement in care.
Parents wanted to carry out care when in hospital, but were not always given
choices. Parents also reported a desire for more confident nurses. This study
highlights the need to gain insight into parents' experiences, in order
that nurses can provide care in a way negotiated to suit the individual family.
Suggestions for further research in this area are offered.
Baker, S.
(1995)
‘Family-centred Care: a Theory–Practice Dilemma’
, Paediatric Nursing7 (6):
17–20
.
3.
Banonis, B.
(1989)
‘The Lived Experience of Recovering from Addiction: a
Phenomenological Study’
, Nursing Quarterly2 (1):
37–42
.
4.
Beale, H.
(2002)
Respite Care for Technology-dependent Children and Their Families'
, Paediatric Nursing14 (7):
18–19
.
5.
Brown, J.
and
Ritchie, J.
(1990)
‘Nurses’ Perception of Parents and Nurses'
Roles in Caring for Hospitalised Children’
, Children's Health Care19 (1):
28–36
.
6.
Bruce, B.
and
Ritchie, J.
(1997)
‘Nurses’ Practices and Perceptions of Family-centred Care’
, Journal of Paediatric Nursing12 (2):
214–222
.
7.
Callery, P.
(1997)
‘Maternal Knowledge and Professional Knowledge and Professional
Knowledge: Co-operation and Conflict in the Care of Sick Children’
, International Journal of Nursing Studies34 (1):
27–34
.
8.
Callery, P.
and
Smith, L.
(1991)
‘A Study of Role Negotiation between Nurses and Parents of
Hospitalised Children’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing16 (7):
772–781
.
9.
Casey, A.
(1995)
‘Partnership Nursing: Influences on Involvement of Informal Carers’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing22 (6):
1058–1062
.
10.
Christensen, J.
(1993) Nursing Partnership: a Model for Nursing
Practice.
Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone
.
11.
Clarke, A.
(1999)
‘Qualitative Research: Data Analysis Techniques’
, Professional Nurse14 (8):
531–532
.
12.
Coyne, I.
(1995a)
‘Partnership in Care: Parents’ Views of Participation
in Their Hospitalised Child's Care’
, Journal of Clinical Nursing4 (2):
71–79
.
13.
Coyne, I.
(1995b)
‘Parents’ Participation in Care: a Critical Review of
the Literature’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing21 (4):
716–722
.
14.
Darbyshire, P.
(1993)
Parents, Nurses and Paediatric Nursing: a Critical Review'
, Journal of Advanced Nursing18 (11):
1670–1680
.
15.
Darbyshire, P.
(1994) Living with a Sick Child in Hospital: the Experiences
of Parents and Nurses.
London: Chapman and Hall
.
16.
Davies, H.
(2002)
‘Understanding Organisational Culture in Reforming the National
Health Service’
, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine95 (3):
140–142
.
17.
Dearmun, A.
(1992)
‘Perceptions of Parental Participation’
, Paediatric Nursing4 (7):
6–9
.
18.
Department of Health
(2003) Getting the Right Start. National Service Framework
for Children.
London: Department of Health
.
19.
Espezel, H.
and
Canam, C.
(2003)
‘Issues and Innovations in Nursing Practice.
Parent–Nurse Interactions: Care of Hospitalised Children’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing44 (1):
34–41
.
20.
Evans, M.
(1994)
‘An Investigation into the Feasibility of Parental Participation
in the Nursing Care of Their Children’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing20:
477–482
.
21.
Gardner, G.Barrett, T.
,
Coonan, K.
,
Cox, H.
,
Kirk, H.
and
Roberson, B
(2002)
‘Parent Support Programs in Neonatal Intensive Care: Researching
the Issues’
, Neonatal, Paediatric and Child Health Nursing5 (1):
20–25
.
22.
Gibson, C.
(1995)
‘The Process of Empowerment in Mothers of Chronically Ill Children’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing21 (6):
1201–1210
.
23.
Glendinning, C.
(1999) The Community-based Care of Technology Dependent
Children in the UK.
Manchester: National Primary Care Research and
Development Centre
.
24.
Hallstrom, I.
,
Runeson, I.
and
Elander, G.
(2002)
‘An Observation Study of the Level at which Parents Participate
in Decisions During Their Child's Hospitalization’
, Nursing Ethics9 (2):
202–214
.
25.
Hayes, V.
and
Knox, J.
(1984)
‘The Experience of Stress in Parents of Children Hospitalised
with Long-term Disabilities’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing9 (4):
333–341
.
26.
Kawik, L.
(1996)
‘Nurses' and Parents' Perceptions of
Participation and Partnership in Caring for a Hospitalised Child’
, British Journal of Nursing5 (7):
430–434
.
27.
Kirk, S.
(1999)
‘Caring for Children with Specialised Health Care Needs in the
Community: the Challenges for Primary Care’
, Health and Social Care in the Community24 (3):
350–357
.
28.
Kirk, S.
(2001)
‘Negotiating Lay and Professional Roles in the Care of Children
with Complex Health Care Needs’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing34 (5):
593–602
.
29.
Kuzel, A.
(1992) ‘Sampling in Qualitative
Enquiry’, in
B. Crabtree
and
W. Muller
(eds) Doing Qualitative Research, pp.
31–44.
London: Sage
.
30.
Macleod-Clark, J.
and
Bridge, W.
(1981) Communication in Nursing Care.
London: HM&M Publishers
.
31.
Miles, M.
(2003)
‘Parents of Children with Chronic Health Problems: Programs of
Nursing Research and Their Relationship to Developmental Science’
, Annual Review of Nursing Research21:
247–277
.
32.
Newton, M.
(2000)
‘Family Centred Care: Current Realities in Parent Participation’
, Paediatric Nursing26 (2):
164–168
.
33.
Parahoo, K.
(1997) Nursing Research: Principles, Process and
Methods.
London: Macmillan
.
34.
Polgar, S.
and
Thomas, S.
(2000) Introduction to Research in the Health Sciences
(4th edn).
London: Churchill Livingstone
.
35.
Porter, S.
(1991)
‘A Participant Observation Study of Power Relations between
Nurses and Doctors in a General Hospital’
, Journal of Advanced Nursing16 (6):
728–735
.
36.
Robinson, C.
and
Thorne, S.
(1984)
‘Strengthening Family Interference’
, Journal of Social Issues35 (6):
60–81
.
37.
Shields, L.
,
Kristensson-Hallstrom, I.
and
O'Callaghan, M.
(2003)
‘An Examination of the Needs of Parents of Hospitalized Children:
Comparing Staff's and Parents' Perceptions’
, Scandinavian Journal of Caring Science17 (2):
176–184
.
38.
Smith, L.
,
Coleman, V.
and
Bradshaw, M.
(2002) Family-centred Care: Concept, Theory and
Practice.
Aldershot: Palgrave
.
39.
Thomas, R.
(1990)
‘A Foundation for Clinical Family Assessment’
, Children's Health Care19 (4):
244–250
.
40.
Totka, J.
(1996)
‘Exploring the Boundaries of Paediatric Practice: Nurse Stories
Related to Relationships’
, Paediatric Nursing22 (3):
896–899
.
