Peer mediation is a popular way to manage conflict in schools. Typically, a school
trains a small group (cadre) of pupils who offer mediation services to other pupils
at break and lunchtime. The article examines research published in the last 10 years
and concludes that this is likely to be a disappointing approach. The author argues,
from the literature, that schools are more likely to reduce bullying and low-level
disruption by making the study of conflict a central part of the curriculum of the
school – for parents, for teachers and for pupils.
Anderson, D.
(1982) Detecting Bad Schools: A Guide for Normal
Parents.
London: The Social Affairs Unit
.
2.
Aubrey-Hopkins, J.
&
James, C.
(2002)
The use of tangible rewards in the management of pupils in comprehensive
secondary schools in Wales
. Welsh Journal of Education, 11(2),
91–108
.
3.
Bell, S.
,
Coleman, J.
,
Anderson, A.
,
Whelan, J.
&
Wilder, C.
(2000)
The effectiveness of peer mediation in a low-SES rural elementary school
. Psychology in the Schools, 37(6),
505–516
.
4.
Bickmore, K.
(2001)
Student conflict resolution, power ‘sharing’ in
schools, and citizenship education
. Curriculum Inquiry, 32(2),
137–162
.
5.
Bickmore, K.
(2002)
Good training is not enough: research on peer mediation program implementation
. Social Alternatives, 21(1),
33–38
.
6.
Carter, C.
&
Osler, A.
(2000)
Human rights, identities, and conflict management: a study of school
culture as experienced through classroom relationships
. Cambridge Journal of Education, 30(3),
335–357
.
7.
Chetkow-Yanoov, B.
(1996)
Conflict-resolution skills can be taught
. Peabody Journal of Education, 71(3),
12–28
.
8.
Cohen, P.
,
Kulik, J.
&
Kulik, C.-L.
(1982)
Educational outcomes of tutoring: a meta-analysis of findings
. American Educational Research Journal,
19(2),
237–248
.
9.
Cremin, H. (2000) An investigation into whether the
‘Iceberg’ system of peer mediation training, and peer mediation,
reduce levels of bullying, raise self-esteem, and increase pupil empowerment amongst
upper primary age children. Unpublished PhD thesis. Leicester, University of Leicester.
10.
Cremin, H.
(2002)
Pupils resolving disputes: successful peer mediation schemes share their secrets
. Support for Learning, 17(3),
138–142
.
11.
Curwin, R.
(1995)
Ahumane approach to reducing violence in schools
. Educational Leadership, 52(5),
72–75
.
12.
Daunic, A.
,
Smith, S. W.Robinson, T. R.
,
Miller, M. D.
&
Landry, K. L.
(2000)
School-wide conflict resolution and peer mediation programmes: experiences
in three middle schools
. Intervention in School and Clinic,
36(2),
94–101
.
13.
Deci, E.
,
Koestner, R.
&
Ryan, R.
(2001)
Extrinsic rewards and intrinsic motivation in education: reconsidered once again
. Review of Educational Research, 71(1),
1–27
.
14.
D'Oosterlinck, F.
&
Broekaert, E.
(2003)
Integrating school based and therapeutic conflict management at schools
. Journal of School Health, 73(6),
222–226
.
15.
Farrell, A.
,
Myer, A.
&
White, K.
(2001)
Evaluation of responding in peaceful and positive ways (RIPP): a
school-based prevention program for reducing violence among urban adolescents
. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology,
30(4),
451–463
.
16.
Fitz-Gibbon, C. T.
(2000) Cross-age tutoring: should it be required in order
to reduce social exclusion? In
G. Walraven
,
C. Parsons
,
D. van Veen
&
C. Day
(eds) Combating Social Exclusion Through Education: Laissez-Faire,
Authoritarianism or Third Way?, pp.
307–315.
Leuven: Garant
.
17.
Flecknoe, M.
(2004a)
Challenging the orthodoxies: putting a spoke into the vicious cycle
. Educational Management, Administration and Leadership,
32(4),
405–422
.
18.
Flecknoe, M.
(2004b)
An editor visits... Challenge College, Bradford
. Improving Schools, 7(3),
213–216
.
19.
Gajda, R.
(2000) Becoming a school teacher in the wake of
violence. Research and Development Centre for Student Learning,
Colorado State University
.
20.
Gajda, R.
(2002)
School shooting case studies: lessons in prevention, response and long-term resolution
. Paper presented at the American Educational Research
Association, New Orleans.
21.
Gaymond, S.
,
Sheedy, J.
&
Flecknoe, M.
(2004)
Cross-age tutoring; investigation and use: a tale of two schools
. Paper presented at the 7th International BELMAS Research
Conference in partnership with SCRELM, St Catherine's
College, Oxford.
22.
Hart, J.
&
Gunty, M.
(1997)
The impact of a peer mediation program on an elementary school environment
. Peace and Change, 22(1),
76–92
.
23.
Hart, S.
&
Hodson, V. K.
(2004) The Compassionate Classroom: Relationship Based
Teaching and Learning.
San Francisco, CA: PuddleDancer
.
24.
Hidi, S.
&
Harackiewicz, J.
(2000)
Motivating the academically unmotivated: a critical issue for the 21st Century
. Review of Educational Research, 70(2),
151–179
.
25.
Holt, J.
(1971) The Underachieving School.
Harmondsworth: Pelican
.
26.
Humphries, T.
(1999)
Improving peer mediation programs: student experiences and suggestions
. Professional School Counseling, 3(1),
13–21
.
27.
Johnson, D.
&
Johnson, R.
(1996a)
Effectiveness of conflict managers in an inner-city elementary school
. Journal of Educational Research, 89(5),
280–285
.
28.
Johnson, D.
&
Johnson, R.
(1996b)
Training elementary school students to manage conflict
. Journal of Group Psychotherapy, Psychodrama and Sociometry,
49(1),
24–39
.
29.
Johnson, D.
&
Johnson, R.
(1997)
The impact of conflict resolution training on middle school students
. Journal of Social Psychology, 137(1),
11–22
.
30.
Lewin, R.
(1992) Complexity: At the Edge of Chaos.
New York: Macmillan
.
31.
MacBeath, J.
,
Boyd, B.
,
Rand, J.
&
Bell, S.
(1996) Schools Speak for Themselves.
Glasgow: National Union of Teachers
.
32.
MacGilchrist, B.
,
Myers, K.
&
Reed, J.
(2004) The Intelligent School.
London: SAGE
.
33.
Neil, A. S.
(1969) Summerhill.
New York: Harold Hart
.
34.
Postman, N.
(1996) The End of Education: Redefining the Value of
School.
New York: Vintage Books
.
35.
Reimer, E.
(1971) School is Dead.
Harmondsworth: Penguin
.
36.
Rosenberg, M.
(2002) Nonviolent Communication: A Language of
Compassion.
Encinitas, CA: PuddleDancer
.
37.
Schmitz, R.
(1994)
Teaching students to manage their conflicts
. Social Work in Education, 16(2),
125–129
.
38.
Sellman, E.
(2002)
Peer mediation, school culture and sustainability
. Pastoral Care in Education, 20(2),
7–11
.
39.
Shulman, H.
(1996)
Using developmental principles in violence prevention
. Elementary School Guidance and Counseling,
30(3),
170–180
.
40.
Smith, S. W.
,
Daunic, A.Miller, D.
&
Robinson, T. R.
(2002)
Conflict resolution and peer mediation in middle schools: extending the
process and outcome knowledge base
. Journal of Social Psychology, 142(5),
567–587
.
41.
Starratt, R.
(2002)
Moral issues in the test-driven accountability agenda: implications for
learner-centered ed leadership programs
. Paper presented at the American Educational Research
Association, New Orleans.
42.
Stenhouse, L.
(1975) An Introduction to Curriculum Research and
Development.
London: Heinemann
.
43.
Stevahn, L.
(2004)
Integrating conflict resolution training into the curriculum
. Theory into Practice, 43(1),
50–60
.
44.
Theberge, S.
&
Karan, O.
(2004)
Six factors inhibiting the use of peer mediation in a junior high school
. Professional School Counseling, 7(4),
283–291
.
45.
Tomlinson, K.
&
Bender, R.
(1997)
The Kimmie's Kids Plan: a response to violence in secondary schools
. Intervention in School and Clinic,
32(4),
244–250
.
