Some 15-66% of children in western countries talk about imaginary playmates; in India only 0.2% of children are said to remember a previous life. Both phenomena occur from the age of 30 months to 60-90 months. This article explores whether the two phenomena are cross-culturally comparable categories. The article describes a study of the psychological characteristics of a sample of 15 children said to remember a previous life in India, compared with a matched sample; and compares it with a sample of 15 children with imaginary playmates and a matched sample from Charlottesville, Virginia. No significant differences between the target group and the comparison group were found in either culture, suggesting that both phenomena are normal. One case of an American child with an imaginary playmate and one case of a child in India who is said to remember a previous life are described, using a video-recording of the child's dialogue.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ames, L. B., & Learned, J. (1946). Imaginary companions and related phenomena . Journal of Genetic Psychology, 69, 147-167 .
2.
Avis, J., & Harris, P. L. (1991). Belief-desire reasoning among Baka children: Evidence for a universal conception of the mind . Child Development, 62, 460-467 .
3.
Barker, D. S., & Pasricha, S. (1979). Reincarnation cases in Fatehabad: A systematic survey of North India . Journal of Asian and African Studies, 4, 231-240 .
4.
Beals, A. R., & Eason, M.A. (1993). Siblings in North America and South Asia. In C. W. Nuckolls (Ed.), Siblings in South Asia: Brothers and sisters in cultural context (pp. 77-101). New York: Guilford Press .
5.
Cook, E., Pasricha, S., Samararatne, G., U Win Maung, & Stevenson, P. (1983). A review and analysis of `unsolved' cases of reincarnation type: II. A comparison of features of solved and unsolved cases . Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research, 7, 115-135 .
6.
Derne, S. (1993). Equality and hierarchy between adult brothers: Culture and sibling relations in north Indian urban joint families. In C. W. Nuckolls (Ed.), Siblings in South Asia: Brothers and sisters in cultural context (pp. 165-189). New York: Guilford Press .
7.
Dunn, J. (1993). Perspectives on siblings: A developmentalist psychologist's view. In C. W. Nuckolls (Ed.), Siblings in South Asia: Brothers and sisters in cultural context (pp.235-240). New York: Guilford Press .
8.
Ernst, C., & Angst, J. (1983). Birth order. Its influence on personality. New York: Springer .
9.
Fivush, R. (1991). Gender and emotion in mother-child conversations about the past . Journal of Narrative and Life History, 1 (4), 325-341 .
10.
Flavell, J. H., Green, F. L., & Flavell, E. R. (1993). Children's understanding of the stream of consciousness . Child Development, 64, 387-398 .
11.
Haraldsson, E. (1995). Personality and abilities of children claiming previous-life memories . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 183, 445-451 .
12.
Haraldsson, E. (1997). A psychological comparison between ordinary children and those who claim previous-life memories . Journal of Scientific Exploration, 11, 323-335 .
13.
Haraldsson, E., Fowler, P. C., & Periyannanpillai, V. (2000). Psychological characteristics of children who speak of a previous life: A further field study in Sri Lanka . Transcultural Psychiatry, 37(4), 525-544 .
14.
Harter, S., & Chao, C. (1992). The role of competence in children's creation of imaginary friends . Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 38(3), 350-363 .
15.
Hilgard, J. (1970). Personality and hypnosis: A study in imaginative involvement. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
16.
Hobson, R. P. (1990). On acquiring knowledge about people and the capacity to pretend: Response to Leslie 1987 . Psychological Review, 97(1), 114-121 .
17.
Hurlock, E. B., & Burnstein, M. (1932). The imaginary playmate: A questionnaire study . Journal of Genetic Psychology, 41, 380-391 .
18.
Jacobson, D. (1974). The women of north and central India: Goddesses and wives. In C. J. Matthiasson (Ed.), Many sisters (pp. 99-175). New York: Free Press .
19.
Johnson, M. K. (1988). Reality monitoring: An experimental phenomenological approach . Journal of Experimental Psychology, General, 117, 490-494 .
20.
Johnson, M. K. (1991a). Reality monitoring: Evidence from confabulation in organic brain disease patients. In G. P. Prigatano, & D. L. Schacter (Eds.), Awareness of deficit after brain injury (pp. 176-197). New York: Oxford .
21.
Johnson, M. K. (1991b). Reflection, reality monitoring, and the self. In R. G. Kunzendorf (Ed.), Mental imagery (pp. 3-16). New York: Plenum Press .
22.
Johnson, M. K., & Foley, M. A. (1984). Differentiating fact from fantasy: The reliability of children's memory . Journal of Social Issues, 40(2), 33-50 .
23.
Johnson, M. K., Foley, M. A., Suengas, A. G., & Raye, C. L. (1988). Phenomenal characteristics of memories for perceived and imagined autobiographical events . Journal of Experimental Psychology. General, 117, 371-376 .
24.
Kakar, S. (1981). The inner world: A psychoanalytic study of childhood and society in India (2nd ed.) Oxford: Oxford University Press .
25.
Kessen, W. (1993). A developmentalist's reflections. In G. H. Elder, Jr., J. Modell, & R. D. Parke (Eds.), Children in time and place: Developmental and historical insights (pp. 226-229). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
26.
Khare, R. (1993). The seen and the unseen: Hindu distinctions, experience and cultural reasoning . Contributions to Indian Sociology, 27(2), 191-212 .
27.
Kluft, R. P. (1985). Childhood antecedents of multiple personality. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press .
28.
Lillard, A. S. (1993). Pretend play skills and the child's theory of mind . Child Development, 64, 348-371 .
29.
Manosevitz, M., Fling, S., & Prentice, N. M. (1977). Imaginary companions in young children: Relationships with intelligence, creativity and waiting ability . Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 18, 73-78 .
30.
Marcus, G. E., & Fisher, M. M. J. (1986). Anthropology as cultural critique: An experimental moment in the human sciences. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
31.
Mayes, L. C., & Cohen, D. J. (1992). The development of a capacity for imagination in early childhood . The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child, 47, 23-47 .
32.
Miller, P. J. (1982). Amy, Wendy, and Beth: Learning language in South Baltimore. Austin: University of Texas Press .
33.
Miller, P. J., Potts, R., Fung, H., Hoogstra., L., & Mintz, J. (1990). Narrative practices and the social construction of self in childhood . American Ethnologist, 17, 292-311 .
34.
Mills, A. (1989). Three cases suggestive of reincarnation in northern India: A replication study . Journal of Scientific Exploration, 3, 133-184 .
35.
Mills, A. (1990a). Moslem cases of the reincarnation type in northern India: A test of the hypothesis of imposed identification. Part I: Analysis of 26 cases . Journal of Scientific Exploration, 4, 189-202 .
36.
Mills, A. (1990b). Moslem cases of the reincarnation type in northern India: A test of the hypothesis of imposed identification. Part II: Reports of three cases . Journal of Scientific Exploration, 4, 189-202 .
37.
Mills, A. (1992). Are children with imaginary playmates and children said to remember previous lives cross-culturally comparable categories? Paper presented at the American Anthropological Association, San Francisco.
38.
Mills, A. (1993). Invisible companions: Perception and projection of `related' paradigms from the U.S. and from Northern India . Paper presented to the American Anthropological Association Conference, Washington, DC.
39.
Mills, A. (1994a). Nightmares in western children: An alternative interpretation suggested by data in three cases . Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research, 88, 309-325 .
40.
Mills, A. (1994b) Rebirth and identity: Three cases of pierced ear birthmarks among the Gitksan. In A. Mills, & R. Slobodin (Eds.), Amerindian rebirth: Concepts of reincarnation among North American Indians and Inuit (pp. 211-241). Toronto: University of Toronto Press .
41.
Mills, A. (2002). Inferences from the case of Ajendra: The effect of parental questioning, of meeting the `previous life' family, and an attempt to quantify probabilities. Manuscript submitted for publication.
42.
Mills, A., & Lynn, J. (2000). Past-life experience. In E. Cardena, S. J. Lynn, & S. Krippner (Eds.), Varieties of anomalous experience (pp. 283-313). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association .
43.
Minturn, L., & Hitchcock, J. (1966). The Rajputs of Khalapur, India. New York: Wiley .
44.
Nelson, K. (Ed.). (1989a). Narratives from the crib. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
45.
Nelson, K. (1989b). Monologue as the linguistic construction of self in time. In K. Nelson (Ed.), Narratives from the crib (pp. 284-308). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
46.
Nelson, K. (1991). Remembering and telling: A developmental story . Journal of Narrative and Life History, 1(2/3), 109-127 .
47.
Nelson, K. (1993). The psychological and social origins of autobiographical memory . Psychological Science, 4(1), 7-14 .
48.
Nuckolls, C. W. (Ed.). (1993a). Siblings in South Asia: Brother and sisters in cultural context. New York: Guilford Press .
49.
Nuckolls, C. W. (1993b). An introduction to the cross-cultural study of sibling relations. In C. W. Nuckolls (Ed.), Siblings in South Asia: Brothers and sisters in cultural context (pp. 19-41). New York: Guilford Press .
50.
Schaefer, C. E. (1969). Imaginary companions and creative adolescents . Developmental Psychology, 1(6), 747-749 .
51.
Seymour, S. (1993). Sociocultural contexts: Examining sibling roles in South Asia. In C. W. Nuckolls (Ed.), Siblings in South Asia: Brothers and sisters in cultural context (pp. 45-69). New York: Guilford Press .
52.
Shweder, R. A. (1990a). Cultural psychology: What is it? In J. W. Stigler, R. A. Shweder, & G. Herdt (Eds.), Cultural psychology: Essays on comparative human development (pp. 1-43) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
53.
Shweder, R. A. (1990b). Thinking through cultures. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
54.
Singer, D. G., & Singer, J. L. (1990). The house of make-believe. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
55.
Spiro, M. E. (1993). Is the Western conception of the self `peculiar' within the context of the world cultures? Ethos, 21(2), 107-153 .
56.
Stevenson, I. (1974). Twenty cases suggestive of reincarnation (2nd rev. ed.). Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia .
57.
Stevenson, I. (1975). Cases of the reincarnation type. Vol. 1, Ten cases in India. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia .
58.
Stevenson, I. (1983). American children who claim to remember previous lives . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 171, 742-748 .
59.
Stevenson, I. (1986). Characteristics of the cases of reincarnation type among the Igbo of Nigeria . Journal of Asian and African Studies, 21, 240-216 .
60.
Stevenson, I. (1987). Children who remember previous lives: A question of reincarnation. Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia .
61.
Stevenson, I. (1997). Biology and reincarnation: A contribution to the etiology of birthmarks and birth defects. Westport, CT: Praeger .
62.
Stevenson, I. (2000). Unusual play in young children who claim to remember previous lives . Journal of Scientific Exploration, 14, 557-570 .
63.
Stevenson, I., & Chadha, N. K. (1990). Can children be stopped from speaking about previous lives? Some further analyses of features in cases of the reincarnation type . Journal of the Society for Psychical Research, 56, 82-90 .
64.
Stevenson, I., & Samararatne, G. (1988). Three new cases of the reincarnation type in Sri Lanka with written records before verification . Journal of Scientific Exploration, 2(2), 217-239 .
65.
Taylor, M. (1999). Imaginary companions and the children who create them. New York: Oxford University Press .
66.
Taylor, M., Cartwright, B. S., & Carlson, S. M. (1993). A developmental investigation of children's imaginary companions . Developmental Psychology, 29(2), 276-283 .
67.
Tellegan, A., & Atkinson, G. (1974). Openness to absorbing and self-altering experiences (`absorption'), a trait related to hypnotic susceptibility . Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 83(3), 268-277 .
68.
Trawick, M. (1990). Notes on love in a Tamil family. Berkeley: University of California Press .
69.
Wellman, H. M., & Estes, D. (1986). Early understanding of mental entities: A reexamination of childhood realism . Child Development, 57, 910-923 .
70.
Zuckerman, M. (1993). History and developmental psychology, a dangerous liaison: A historical perspective. In G. H. Elder, Jr., J. Modell, & R. D. Parke (Eds.), Children in time and place: Developmental and historical insights (pp. 230-240). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
