Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2020-10
On the construction of an artificial paradox: A critical commentary on Diefendorf and Bridges’ ‘On the enduring relationship between masculinity and homophobia’
The social trend of decreasing homophobia and liberalizing attitudes toward homosexuality is a contentious sociological issue. In a recent article in this journal, Diefendorf and Bridges contend that differences in findings of quantitative and qualitative research related to masculinities and homophobia demand new theories and methods to chart the enduring relationship between homophobia and masculinity. In this critical commentary, I demonstrate the flaws of the methodological framing and refute the characterization of qualitative literature provided. I argue that the theoretical errors in the original article are a result of inattention to social and historical context. Drawing attention to problematic citation practices, I call for critical approaches that recognize both positive social change and contexts where problematic dynamics persist.
AdamsA (2011) ‘Josh wears pink cleats’: Inclusive masculinity on the soccer field. Journal of Homosexuality58(5): 579–596.
2.
AndersonE (2009) Inclusive Masculinity: The Changing Nature of Masculinities, London: Routledge.
3.
AndersonE (2014) 21st Century Jocks, Basingstoke: Palgrave.
4.
AndersonEAdamsA (2011) ‘Aren't we all a little bisexual?’ The recognition of bisexuality in an unlikely place. Journal of Bisexuality11(1): 3–22.
5.
AndersonEMcCormackM (2015) Cuddling and spooning: Heteromasculinity and homosocial tactility among student-athletes. Men and Masculinities18(2): 214–230.
6.
AndersonEMcCormackM (2016) The Changing Dynamics of Bisexual Men's Lives, New York: Springer.
7.
AndersonEMcCormackM (2018) Inclusive masculinity theory: Overview, reflection and refinement. Journal of Gender Studies27(5): 547–561.
8.
BarrettT (2013) Friendships between men across sexual orientation. The Journal of Men's Studies21(1): 62–77.
9.
BeasleyC (2015) Libidinal heterodoxy: Heterosexuality, hetero-masculinity, and ‘transgression’. Men and Masculinities18(2): 140–158.
10.
BlanchardCMcCormackMPetersonG (2017) Inclusive masculinities in a working-class sixth form in north-east England. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography46(3): 310–333.
11.
BorkowskaK (2016) Joining the conversation on inclusive masculinity theory: A response to Rachel O’Neill's ‘Whither critical masculinity studies?’. Men and Masculinities19(5): 545–549.
12.
BradyS (2005) Masculinity and Male Homosexuality in Britain, 1861–1913, Basingstoke: Palgrave.
13.
BridgesT (2019) The costs of exclusionary practices in masculinities studies. Men and Masculinities22(1): 16–33.
14.
BridgesTPascoeCJ (2014) Hybrid masculinities: New directions in the sociology of men and masculinities. Sociology Compass8(3): 246–258.
15.
BrodynAGhazianiA (2018) Performative progressiveness: Accounting for new forms of inequality in the gayborhood. City & Community17(2): 307–329.
16.
CarusoARobertsS (2018) Exploring constructions of masculinity on a men's body-positivity blog. Journal of Sociology54(4): 627–646.
17.
CashmoreEClelandJ (2012) Fans, homophobia and masculinities in association football. British Journal of Sociology63(2): 370–387.
18.
ChannonAMatthewsCR (2015) ‘It is what it is’: Masculinity, homosexuality, and inclusive discourse in mixed martial arts. Journal of Homosexuality62(7): 936–956.
19.
ChaunceyG (1995) Gay New York, New York: Basic Books.
20.
ClelandJ (2015) Discussing homosexuality on association football fan message boards: A changing cultural context. International Review for the Sociology of Sport50(2): 125–140.
21.
ClelandJ (2018) Sexuality, masculinity and homophobia in association football: An empirical overview of a changing cultural context. International Review for the Sociology of Sport53(4): 411–423.
22.
ClementsBFieldCD (2014) Public opinion toward homosexuality and gay rights in Great Britain. Public Opinion Quarterly78(2): 523–547.
23.
Coleman-FountainE (2014) Understanding Narrative Identity Through Lesbian and Gay Youth, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
24.
DashperK (2012) ‘Dressage is full of queens!’ Masculinity, sexuality and equestrian sport. Sociology46(6): 1109–1124.
25.
DeanJJ (2014) Straights: Heterosexuality in Post-Closeted Culture, New York: New York University Press.
26.
DeitcherD (2001) Dear Friends: American Photographs of Men Together, 1840–1918, New York: Harry Abrams.
27.
Diefendorf S and Bridges T (n.d.) On the enduring relationship between masculinity and homophobia. Forthcoming in Sexualities. DOI: 10.1177/1363460719876843.
28.
ElliottK (2016) Caring masculinities: Theorizing an emerging concept. Men and Masculinities19(3): 240–259.
29.
FrankK (2008) Not gay, but not homophobic: Male sexuality and homophobia in the lifestyle. Sexualities11(4): 435–454.
30.
GhazianiA (2014) There Goes the Gayborhood?, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
31.
GiddensA (1992) The Transformation of Intimacy: Sexuality, Love and Intimacy in Modern Societies, Cambridge: Polity.
32.
GottzénLKremer-SadlikT (2012) Fatherhood and youth sports: A balancing act between care and expectations. Gender & Society26(4): 639–664.
HaltomTMWorthenMG (2014) Male ballet dancers and their performances of heteromasculinity. Journal of College Student Development55(8): 757–778.
35.
HaywoodCMac an GhaillM (2012) ‘What's next for masculinity?’ Reflexive directions for theory and research on masculinity and education. Gender and Education24(6): 577–592.
KimmelMS (1994) Masculinity as homophobia: Fear, shame and silence in the construction of gender identity. In: BrodHKaufmanM (eds) Theorizing Masculinities, Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
38.
LalorTRendle-ShortJ (2007) ‘That's so gay’: A contemporary use of gay in Australian English. Australian Journal of Linguistics27(2): 147–173.
39.
Mac an GhaillM (1994) The Making of Men, Buckingham: Open University Press.
40.
MagrathR (2017) Inclusive Masculinity and the Beautiful Game, London: Routledge.
41.
MagrathR (2018) ‘To try and gain an advantage for my team’: Homophobic and homosexually themed chanting among English football fans. Sociology52(4): 709–726.
42.
McCormackM (2011) Mapping the terrain of homosexually-themed language. Journal of Homosexuality58(5): 664–679.
43.
McCormackM (2012) The Declining Significance of Homophobia: How Teenage Boys are Redefining Masculinity and Homophobia, New York: Oxford University Press.
44.
McCormackM (2014) The intersection of youth masculinities, decreasing homophobia and class: An ethnography. British Journal of Sociology65(1): 747–767.
45.
McCormackMAndersonE (2014) The influence of declining homophobia on men's gender in the United States: An argument for the study of homohysteria. Sex Roles71(3–4): 109–120.
46.
McCormackMWignallLAndersonE (2015) Identities and identifications: Changes in Metropolitan bisexual men's attitudes and experiences. Journal of Bisexuality15(1): 3–20.
47.
McCormackMWignallLMorrisM (2016) Gay guys using gay discourse: Friendship, shared values and the intent-context-effect matrix. British Journal of Sociology67(4): 747–767.
48.
MervisJ (2014) Why null results rarely see the light of day. Science345(6200): 992.
49.
MichaelB (2015) ‘Just don't hit on me and I’m fine’: Mapping high school wrestlers’ relationship to inclusive masculinity and heterosexual recuperation. International Review for the Sociology of Sport50(8): 912–928.
50.
MoralesLE (2018) The impact of gay friendly cultures on religious expression: A study of inclusive attitudes and behaviours among religious adolescent American male athletes. Journal of Gender Studies27(3): 323–334.
51.
MorrisM (2018) ‘Gay capital’ in gay student friendship networks: An intersectional analysis of class, masculinity, and decreased homophobia. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships35(9): 1183–1204.
52.
MorrisMAndersonE (2015) ‘Charlie is so cool like’: Authenticity, popularity and inclusive masculinity on YouTube. Sociology49(6): 1200–1217.
53.
PascoeCJ (2007) Dude, You're a Fag, Berkeley: University of California Press.
54.
PlummerD (2014) The ebb and flow of homophobia: A gender taboo theory. Sex Roles71(3–4): 126–136.
55.
PlummerK (2010) Generational sexualities, subterranean traditions, and the hauntings of the sexual world: Some preliminary remarks. Symbolic Interaction33(2): 163–190.
56.
Ralph B and Roberts S (2018) One small step for man: Change and continuity in perceptions and enactments of homosocial intimacy among young Australian men. Men and Masculinities. Published online first, 3 June. DOI: 1097184X18777776.
57.
RasmussenML (2004) ‘That's so gay!’ A study of the deployment of signifiers of sexual and gender identity in secondary school settings in Australia and the United States. Social Semiotics14(3): 289–308.
58.
RipleyM (2018) The integration of British undergraduate men's public and private masculinities. Journal of Gender Studies27(3): 288–300.
59.
RobardsB (2018) ‘Totally straight’: Contested sexual identities on social media site reddit. Sexualities21(1–2): 49–67.
60.
RobertsS (2013) Boys will be boys … won't they? Change and continuities in contemporary young working-class masculinities. Sociology47(4): 671–686.
61.
RobertsS (2018) Young Working-Class Men in Transition, London: Routledge.
62.
RobinsonSAndersonEWhiteA (2018) The bromance: Undergraduate male friendships and the expansion of contemporary homosocial boundaries. Sex Roles78(1–2): 94–106.
63.
RumensN (2018) Age and changing masculinities in gay–straight male workplace friendships. Journal of Gender Studies27(3): 260–273.
64.
Savin-WilliamsRC (2005) The New Gay Teenager, Boston, MA: Harvard University Press.
65.
Savin-WilliamsRC (2017) Becoming Who I Am, Boston, MA: Harvard University Press.
66.
ScoatsRJosephLAndersonE (2018) ‘I don't mind watching him cum’: Heterosexual men, male-male-female threesomes, and the erosion of the one-time rule of homosexuality. Sexualities21(1–2): 30–48.
67.
SeidmanS (2002) Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life, London: Routledge.
68.
SextonSS (2017) The intersection of self and school: How friendship circles influence heterosexual and self-identified queer teenagers. Gender and Education29(3): 299–312.
69.
SmithTWSonJKimJ (2014) Public Attitudes Towards Homosexuality and Gay Rights Across Time and Countries, Chicago, IL: The Williams Institute, University of Chicago.
70.
ThorneBLuriaZ (1986) Sexuality and gender in children's daily worlds. Social Problems33(3): 176–190.
71.
TwengeJM (2014) Generation Me, London: Simon and Schuster.
72.
WeeksJ (2007) The World We Have Won, London: Routledge.
73.
Wignall L, Scoats R. Anderson E and Morales L (2019) A qualitative study of heterosexual men's attitudes toward and practices of receiving anal stimulation. Culture, Health & Sexuality. Published online first, 28 June: 1–15. DOI: doi.org/10.1080/13691058.2019.1627584.
74.
WorthenMG (2014) The cultural significance of homophobia on heterosexual women's gendered experiences in the United States: A commentary. Sex Roles71(3–4): 141–151.
