Bisexual citizenship in the Netherlands: On homo-emancipation and bisexual representations in national emancipation policies

Abstract

Studies in sexual citizenship have been successful in revealing heteronormative assumptions that underlie most mainstream models on sexual citizenship and contemporary sexual politics. Discussions about sexual citizenship, however, focus on heterosexuals and homosexuals, and less on bisexual citizenship. This article aims to discuss the in/exclusion of bisexuals in Dutch sexual citizenship as described in Dutch national LGBT emancipation policies (known as ‘homo-emancipation’). The analysis of policy documents shows that bisexuality is rendered invisible in multiple ways. Based on this analysis I argue that bisexual representation within sexual citizenship discourses and public policy documents is important to realize claims of self-identification, self-expression, and self-realization for bisexual citizens.

Keywords

Bisexuality bisexual citizenship emancipation the Netherlands sexual citizenship

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderlini-D’Onofrio

Alexander

(2009) Introduction to the special issue: Bisexuality and queer theory: Intersections, diversions, and connections. Journal of Bisexuality 9(3–4): 197–212.

Asher

(2009) Ireland, the same-sex partnership debate, and the normal sexual citizen. Journal of Bisexuality 9(3–4): 477–489.

Attwood

(2006) Sexed up: Theorizing the sexualization of culture. Sexualities 9(1): 77–94.

Ault

(1996) Ambiguous identity in an unambiguous sex/gender structure: The case of bisexual women. Sociological Quarterly 37(3): 449–463.

Balsam

Mohr

(2007) Adaptation to sexual orientation stigma: A comparison of bisexual and lesbian/gay adults. Journal of Counseling Psychology 54(3): 306–319.

Barker

Richards

Jones

Bowes-Catton

Plowman

Yockney

Morgan

(2012) The Bisexual Report: Bisexual Inclusion in LGBT Equality and Diversity, Milton Keynes: The Open University, Centre for Citizenship, Identities and Governanceand Faculty of Health and Social Care.

Bell

(1995a) Pleasure and danger: The paradoxical spaces of sexual citizenship. Political Geography 14(2): 139–153.

Bell

(1995b) Bi-sexuality: A place on the margins. In: Whittle

(ed.) The Margins of the City: Gay Men’s Urban Lives, Aldershot: Ashgate, pp. 129–141.

Bell

Binnie

(2006) Geographies of sexual citizenship. Political Geography 25(8): 869–873.

10.

Bereket T and Brayton J (2008) ‘Bi’ NO Means: Bisexuality and the influence of binarism on identity. Journal of Bisexuality 8(1–2): 51–61.

11.

Bergen D van Lisdonk J van (2010a) Acceptatie en negatieve ervaringen van homojongeren [Acceptance and negative experiences of non-heterosexual young people]. In: Keuzenkamp

(ed.) Steeds gewoner, nooit gewoon: acceptatie van homoseksualiteit in Nederland [Increasingly normal, never the norm. Acceptance of homosexuality in the Netherlands], The Hague: Sociaal en Cultureel Planbureau [The Netherlands Institute for Social Research], pp. 154–173.

12.

Bergen D van Lisdonk J van (2010b) Psychisch welbevinden en zelfacceptatie van Homojongeren [Mental well-being and self-acceptance of non-heterosexual young people]. In: Keuzenkamp

13.

Bergen D van Lisdonk J van (2010c) Een blik op homojongeren. Huidig beeld en de toekomst [Non-heterosexual young people: Current situation and the future]. In: Keuzenkamp

14.

Betts

Wilmot

Taylor

(2008) Developing Survey Questions on Sexual Identity: Exploratory Focus Groups, Newport: Office for National StatisticsAvailable at: http://www.ons.gov.uk/about-statistics/measuringequality/sexual-identity-project/sexual-identity-focus-group-report.pdf.

15.

Binnie

(1997) Invisible Europeans: Sexual citizenship in the New Europe. Environment and Planning A 29(2): 237–248.

16.

Bos

Ehrhardt

(2010) Ervaringen van lesbische en biseksuele vrouwen [Experiences of lesbian and bisexual women]. In: Keuzekamp

(ed.) Steeds gewoner, nooit gewoon: acceptatie van homoseksualiteit in Nederland [Increasingly normal, never the norm. Acceptance of homosexuality in the Netherlands], The Hague: The Netherlands Institute for Social Research, pp. 94–103.

17.

Bowes-Catton

(2007) Resisting the binary: Discourses of identity and diversity in bisexual politics 1988–1996. Lesbian and Gay Psychology Review 8(1): 58–70.

18.

Bradford

(2004) The bisexual experience. Journal of Bisexuality 4(1–2): 7–23.

19.

Brown

(2000) Closet Space: Geographies of Metaphor from the Body to the Globe, London: Routledge.

20.

Browne

Bakshi

(2013) Insider activists: The fraught possibilities of LGBT activisms from within. Geoforum 49: 253–262.

21.

Buijs

Hekma

Duyvendak

(2011) ‘As long as they keep away from me’: The paradox of antigay violence in a gay-friendly country. Sexualities 14(6): 632–652.

22.

Butler

(2008) Sexual politics, torture, and secular time. British Journal of Sociology 59(1): 1–29.

23.

Cooper

(2006) Active citizenship and the governmentality of local lesbian and gay politics. Political Geography 25(8): 921–943.

24.

Cossman

(2002) Sexing citizenship, privatizing sex. Citizenship Studies 6(4): 483–506.

25.

Duncan

(1996) Renegotiating gender and sexuality in public and private spaces. In: Duncan

(ed.) BodySpace: Destabilizing Geographies of Gender and Sex, London: Routledge, pp. 127–145.

26.

Eliason

(2001) Binegativity. Journal of Bisexuality 1(2–3): 137–154.

27.

Felten

Hoof J van Schuyf

(2010) ‘Wees jezelf, maar wees niet anders’: Heterojongeren over homo- en biseksualiteit [‘Be yourself, but do not dare to be different’: Young straight people on homosexuality and bisexuality]. In: Keuzenkamp

(ed.) Steeds gewoner, nooit gewoon: Acceptatie van homoseksualiteit in Nederland [Increasingly normal, never the norm. Acceptance of homosexuality in the Netherlands], The Hague: Sociaal en Cultureel Planbureau [The Netherlands Institute for Social Research], pp. 54–75.

28.

Flyvbjerg

(2006) Five misunderstandings about case-study research. Qualitative Inquiry 12(2): 219–245.

29.

Green H, Payne N and Green J (2011) Working bi: Preliminary findings from a survey on workplace experiences of bisexual people. Journal of Bisexuality 11(2–3): 300–316.

30.

Gurevich

Bailey

Bower

(2009) Querying theory and politics: The epistemic (dis)location of bisexuality within queer theory. Journal of Bisexuality 9(3–4): 235–257.

31.

Hemmings

(2002) Bisexual Spaces: A Geography of Gender and Sexuality, London: Routledge.

32.

Hekma

Duyvendak

(2011) Queer Netherland: A puzzling example. Sexualities 14(5): 625–631.

33.

Herek

Norton

Allen

Sims

(2010) Demographic, psychological, and social characteristics of self-identified lesbian, gay, and bisexual adults in a US probability sample. Sexuality Research and Social Policy 7(3): 176–200.

34.

Hospers

Keuzenkamp

(2010) Ervaringen van homoseksuele en biseksuele mannen [Experiences of gay and bisexual men]. In: Keuzenkamp

(ed.) Steeds gewoner, nooit gewoon: acceptatie van homoseksualiteit in Nederland [Increasingly normal, never the norm. Acceptance of homosexuality in the Netherlands], The Hague: The Netherlands Institute for Social Research, pp. 79–93.

35.

Hubbard

(2001) Sex zones: Intimacy, citizenship and public space. Sexualities 4(1): 51–71.

36.

Jivraj

Jong A de (2011) The Dutch homo-emancipation policy and its silencing effects on queer Muslims. Feminist Legal Studies 19(2): 143–158.

37.

Keuzenkamp

(2010) Steeds gewoner, nooit gewoon: acceptatie van homoseksualiteit in Nederland [Increasingly normal, never the norm. Acceptance of homosexuality in the Netherlands], The Hague: Sociaal en Cultureel Planbureau [The Netherlands Institute for Social Research].

38.

Keuzenkamp

(2012) Niet te ver uit de kast [Not too far out of the closet], The Hague: Sociaal en Cultureel Planbureau [The Netherlands Institute for Social Research].

39.

Lipperts

Oosterhuis

(2010) Tussen Wal en Schip: De moeizame emancipatie van Biseksualiteit. Tijdschrift voor Seksuologie 34(1): 3–18.

40.

Lipperts

Oosterhuis

(2013) Falling between two stools: The difficult emancipation of bisexuality in the Netherlands [Falling Between Two Stools: The Difficult Emancipation of Bisexuals in the Netherlands]. Journal of Bisexuality [Dutch Scientific Journal on Sexology] 13(2): 245–272.

41.

Lisdonk J van Bergen D van (2010a) SameFeelings: Een onderzoek onder homojongeren [Same Feelings: A study amongst non-heterosexual young people]. In: Keuzenkamp

42.

Lisdonk J van Bergen D van (2010b) Homojongeren en hun seksuele voorkeur: Invulling en uiting [Non-heterosexual young people and their sexual preferences: Meaning and expression]. In: Keuzenkamp

43.

McLean

(2008) Inside, outside, nowhere: Bisexual men and women in the gay and lesbian community. Journal of Bisexuality 8(1–2): 63–80.

44.

Mepschen

Duyvendak

Tonkens

(2010) Sexual politics, orientalism and multicultural citizenship in the Netherlands. Sociology 44(5): 962–979.

45.

Mohr

Rochlen

(1999) Measuring attitudes regarding bisexuality in lesbian, gay male, and heterosexual populations. Journal of Counseling Psychology 46(3): 353–369.

46.

Monro

(2005) Gender politics: Activism, citizenship and sexual diversity, London: Pluto Press.

47.

Monro

(2010) Sexuality, space and intersectionality: The case of lesbian, gay and bisexual equalities initiatives in UK local government. Sociology 44(5): 996–1010.

48.

Monro

Richardson

(2010) Intersectionality and sexuality: The case of sexuality and transgender equalities work in UK local government. In: Taylor

(ed.) Theorizing Intersectionality and Sexuality, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 99–118.

49.

Monro

Richardson

(2012) Sexuality, Equality and Diversity, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

50.

Mulick

Wright

Jr (2002) Examining the existence of biphobia in the heterosexual and homosexual populations. Journal of Bisexuality 2(4): 45–64.

51.

OCW (2007) Gewoon Homo Zijn: lesbische en homo-emancipatiebeleid 2008–2013 [Just being gay: Lesbian and homo-emancipation policy 2008–2013], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

52.

OCW (2010a) Voortgangsrapportage deel 1: algemeen lesbisch- en homo-emancipatiebeleid [Progress review: Lesbian and homo-emancipation policy I], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

53.

OCW (2010b) Voortgangsrapportage deel 2: stand van zaken [Progress review: Lesbian and homo-emancipation policy II], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

54.

OCW (2010c) Overdrachtsdocument Directie Emancipatie [Transfer document: Section emancipation], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

55.

OCW (2010d) Kerncijfers 2005–2009 [Core Figures 2005–2009: Section emancipation], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

56.

OCW (2011a) Hoofdlijnen emancipatiebeleid: vrouwen- en homo-emancipatie 2011–2015 [Main issues emancipation policy: Women and homo-emancipation 2011–2015], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

57.

OCW (2011b) Voortgangsrapportage emancipatiebeleid [Progress document emancipation policy 2011], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

58.

OCW (2011c) Kerncijers 2006–2010 [Core figures 2006–2010: Section emancipation], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

59.

OCW (2012a) Overdrachtsdossier: Emancipatie [Transfer document: Section emancipation], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

60.

OCW (2012b) Kerncijfers 2007–2011 [Core figures 2007–2011: Section emancipation], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

61.

OCW (2013a) Voortgangsrapportage emancipatiebeleid 2012 [Progress document emancipation policy 2012], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

62.

OCW (2013b) Hoofdlijnen emancipatiebeleid 2013–2016 [Main issues emancipation policy 2013–2016], The Hague: OCW [Ministry of Education, Culture, and Science].

63.

Pakulski

(1997) Cultural citizenship. Citizenship Studies 1(1): 73–86.

64.

Plummer

(2001) The square of intimate citizenship: Some preliminary proposals. Citizenship Studies 5(3): 237–253.

65.

Richardson

(1998) Sexuality and citizenship. Sociology 32(1): 83–100.

66.

Richardson

(2000) Constructing sexual citizenship: Theorizing sexual rights. Critical Social Policy 20(1): 105–135.

67.

Richardson D (2004) Locating sexualities: from here to normality. Sexualities 7(4): 391–411.

68.

Richardson

(2005) Desiring sameness? The rise of a neoliberal politics of normalisation. Antipode 37(3): 515–535.

69.

Robinson

(2012) Is this what equality looks like? How assimilation marginalizes the Dutch LGBT Community. Sexuality Research and Social Policy 9(4): 327–336.

70.

Seidman

(2001) From identity to queer politics: Shifts in normative heterosexuality and the meaning of citizenship. Citizenship Studies 5(3): 321–328.

71.

Stychin

(2001) Sexual citizenship in the European Union. Citizenship Studies 5(3): 285–301.

72.

Valentine

Sporton

Nielsen

(2008) Language use on the move: Sites of encounter, identities and belonging. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 33(3): 376–387.

73.

Waaldijk

(2012) The Right to Relate: On the Importance of ‘Orientation’ in Comparative Sexual Orientation Law, Leiden: Universiteit Leiden.

74.

Waaldijk

Clapham

(1993) Homosexuality: A European Community Issue: Essays on Lesbian and Gay Rights in European Law and Policy, Dordrecht: Nijhoff.

75.

Waites

(2005) The fixity of sexual identities in the public sphere: Biomedical knowledge, liberalism and the heterosexual/homosexual binary in late modernity. Sexualities 8(5): 539–569.

76.

Weeks

(1998) The sexual citizen. Theory, Culture and Society 15(3): 35–52.