Lesbian mothers internationally have negotiated informal donor insemination arrangements with gay men since the earliest days of planned lesbian parenthood. In recent years, the relational status to children of these men has been subject to increasing legal and research scrutiny. In this article, based on interviews with Australian gay men, the various meanings of biological relatedness to children are explored from the men’s perspective. Of particular interest is the difference between a ‘donor’ and a ‘father’ for the men, and the extent of their complicity with patriarchal discourses about fatherhood. I argue that, on one level, it is important to distinguish between patriarchal concepts of relatedness that connote entitlement to authority, proprietoriality or legal rights over children, and the various other dimensions of affinity men revealed, including that predicated on biological relatedness. Men’s stories often indicated a strong sense of connection to children in the absence of a sense of parental entitlement. I also explore some slippage between ‘proprietorial’ and ‘connected’ concepts of relatedness which potentially have negative as well as positive implications for relationships with children growing up in lesbian-parented families and their mothers.
AgigianA (2004) Baby Steps: How Lesbian Alternative Insemination is Changing the World. Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press.
2.
ArnupK (1994) ‘Finding fathers’: Artificial insemination, lesbians and the law. Canadian Journal of Women and the Law7(1): 97–115.
3.
ArnupKBoydS(1995) Familial disputes? Sperm donors, lesbian mothers and legal parenthood. In: HermanDStychinC (eds). Legal Inversions: Lesbians, Gay Men and the Politics of Law. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press. 77–101.
4.
BorthwickPBlochB (1993) Mothers and Others: An Exploration of Lesbian Parenting in Australia. Sydney: Jam Jar Publishing.
5.
CarstenJ (2004) After Kinship. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
6.
DanielsK(1998) The semen providers. In: DanielsKHaimesE (eds). Donor Insemination: International Social Science Perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 76–104.
7.
DempseyD (2004) Donor, father or parent? Conceiving paternity in the Australian family court. International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family18(1): 76–102.
8.
DempseyD(2005) Lesbians’ right to choose, children’s right to know. In: JonesHGKirkmanM (eds). Sperm Wars. Sydney: ABC books. 185–195.
9.
DempseyD (2006) Beyond choice: Family and kinship in the Australian lesbian and gay ‘baby boom’. Unpublished doctoral thesis, La Trobe University, Melbourne.
10.
DonovanC (2000) Who needs a father? Negotiating biological fatherhood in British lesbian families using self-insemination. Sexualities3(2): 149–164.
11.
DowsettGW (1996) Practicing Desire: Homosexual Sex in the Era of AIDS. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
12.
DumitJDavis-FloydR(1998) Introduction: Cyborg babies, children of the third millennium. In: Davis-FloydRDumitJ (eds). Cyborg Babies: From Techno-Sex to Techno-Tots. New York and London: Routledge. 1–20.
13.
EdwardsJStrathernM(2000) Including our own. In: CarstenJ (ed.) Cultures of Relatedness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 149–166.
14.
Franklin S (1997) Embodied Progress: A Cultural Account of Assisted Conception. London and New York: Routledge.
15.
HaimesEWeinerK (2000) ‘Everybody's got a dad …' Issues for lesbian families in the management of donor insemination. Sociology of Health and Illness22(4): 477–499.
16.
Hayden, C (1995) Gender, genetics and generation: Reformulating biology in lesbian kinship. Current Anthropology 10(1): 41–63.
17.
Kelly, F (2002) Redefining parenthood: Gay and lesbian families in the Family Court – the case of Re. Patrick. Australian Journal of Family Law 16:204–226.
18.
KellyF(2005) In search of a father: Sperm donors, lesbian-headed families, and the Re. Patrick case. In: JonesHGKirkmanM (eds). Sperm Wars. Sydney: ABC Books. 252–263.
19.
KnepferG (1984) Sex in Australia. Milson's Point, Sydney: J & G Publishing.
20.
LayneLL(1999) The child as gift. In: LayneLL (ed.) Transformative Motherhood: On Giving and Getting in Consumer Culture. New York: New York University Press. 1–28.
21.
MartinA (1993) The Lesbian and Gay Parenting Handbook: Creating and Raising Our Families. New York: Harper Collins.
22.
MasonJ (2008) Tangible affinities and the real life fascination of kinship. Sociology42(1): 29–45.
23.
McNairRDempseyDWiseS (2002) Lesbian parenthood: Issues, strengths and challenges. Family Matters63(spring/summer): 40–49.
24.
MillbankJ (2008) Unlikely fissures and uneasy resonances: Lesbian co-mothers, surrogate parenthood and fathers’ rights. Feminist Legal Studies16(2): 141–167.
25.
NovaesS (1989) Giving, receiving, repaying: Gamete donors and donor policies in reproductive medicine. International journal of Technology Assessment in Healthcare5(4): 639–657.
26.
PlummerK (2001) Documents of Life 2: An Invitation to Critical Humanism. London: SAGE.
27.
Rhoades H (2006) Yearning for law: Fathers' groups and family law reform in Australia. In Sheldon S and Collier R (eds) Fathers' Rights Activism and Law Reform in Comparative Perspective. Hart: Oxford: 125–146.
28.
RiggsDW (2008a) Lesbian mothers, gay sperm donors and community: Ensuring the well-being of children and families. Health Sociology Review17(3): 226–234.
29.
RiggsDW (2008b) Using Multinomial logistic regression analysis to develop a model of Australian gay and heterosexual sperm donors’ motivations and beliefs. International Journal of Emerging Technologies and Society6(2): 106–123.
30.
RipperM (2008) Australian sperm donors: Public image and private motives of gay, bisexual and heterosexual donors. Health Sociology Review17(3): 313–325.
31.
Ryan-FloodR (2005) Contested heteronormativities: Discourses of fatherhood among lesbian parents in Sweden and Ireland. Sexualities18(2): 189–204.
32.
ShortL (2007) Lesbian mothers living well in the context of heterosexism and discrimination: Resources, strategies and legislative change. Feminism & Psychology17(1): 57–74.
33.
SmartCNealeB(1999) ‘I hadn't really thought about it’: New identities, New Fatherhoods. In: SeymourJBagguleyP (eds). Relating Intimacies: Power and Resistance. Houndmills: Macmillan. 118–141.
34.
Stacey J (1996) In the name of the family: rethinking family values in the post-modern age. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
35.
StrathernM (1992) Reproducing the Future. New York: Routledge.
36.
ToberDM (2001) Semen as gift, semen as goods: Reproductive workers and the market in altruism. Body & Society7(2–3): 137–160.
37.
VanfraussenKPonjaert-KristoffersenIBrewaeysA (2001) An attempt to reconstruct children's donor concept: A comparison between children's and lesbian parents' attitudes towards donor anonymity. Human Reproduction16(9): 2019–2025.
38.
Van ReykP(1995) Donor dads: The sperm givers' view. In: WakelingLBradstockM (eds). Beyond Blood: Writings on the Lesbian and Gay Family. Sydney: Black Wattle Press. 82–85.
39.
WakelingLBradstockM (1995) Introduction. Beyond Blood: Writings on the Lesbian and Gay Family. Sydney: Black Wattle Press. 1–4.
40.
WeeksJHeaphyBDonovanC (2001) Same Sex Intimacies; Families of Choice and Other Life Experiments. London: Routledge.
41.
WestonK (1991) Families We Choose: Lesbians, Gays, Kinship. New York: Columbia University Press.
