This article presents a critique of HIV prevention research and practice with gay men
in light of reports that HIV seroprevalence appears to be increasing in this
population. Central to this critique is the possibility that people may have a need
for transcendence, which some gay men might seek to satisfy through sexual
experience. Theories underpinning HIV prevention generally do not account for such
nonrational aspects of sexuality, and they fail to acknowledge the impact of
differential values on people’s health behaviours.
Appleby, G. A.
and
Anastas, J. W.
(1998) Not Just a Passing Phase: Social Work with Gay,
Lesbian, and Bisexual People.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
2.
Areinas, R.
(1993 [1992]) Before Night Falls, trans. D. M. Koch.
New York: Penguin Putnam
.
3.
Bataille, G.
(1986 [1957]) Erotism: Death and Sensuality, trans. M.
Dalwood.
San Francisco: City Lights Books
.
4.
Baumeister, R. F.
(1991) Escaping the Self: Alcoholism, Spirituality,
Masochism, and Other Flights from the Burden of Selfhood.
New York: Basic Books
.
5.
Becker, M. H.
and
Joseph, J. G.
(1988)
‘AIDS and Behavioral Change to Reduce Risk: A Review’
, American Journal of Public Health78:
394-410
.
6.
Blumenstein, P.
and
Schwartz, P.
(1983) American Couples: Money, Work, and Sex.
New York: Pocket Books
.
7.
Bochow, M.
(2000) ‘The Response of Gay German Men to HIV:
The National Gay Press Surveys 1987-96’, in
R. Rosenbrock
and
M. T. Wright
(eds) Partnership and Pragmatism: Germany’s Response to AIDS
Prevention and Care, pp. 129-142.
New York: Routledge
.
8.
Boulton, M.
,
McLean, J.
,
Fitzpatrick, R.
and
Hart, G.
(1995)
‘Gay Men’s Accounts of Unsafe Sex’
, AIDS Care7:
619-630
.
9.
Brehm, J.
and
Brehm, S.
(1981) Psychological Reactance.
New York: Wiley
.
10.
Bronski, M.
(1998) The Pleasure Principle: Sex, Backlash, and the
Struggle for Gay Freedom.
New York: St Martin’s Press
.
11.
Browning, F.
(1993) The Culture of Desire: Paradox and Perversity in Gay
Lives Today.
New York: Vintage Books
.
12.
Buchanan, D. R.
(2000) An Ethic for Health Promotion: Rethinking the Sources
of Human Well-Being.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
13.
Cantwell, M. A.
(1996) Homosexuality: The Secret a Child Dare Not Tell.
San Rafael, CA: Rafael Press
.
14.
Catania, J. A.
,
Osmond, D.
,
Stall, R. D.
,
Pollack, L.
,
Paul, J. P.
,
Blower, S.
,
Binson, D.
,
Canchola, J. A.
,
Mills, T. C.
,
Fisher, L.
,
Choi, K. H.
,
Porco, T.
,
Turner, C.
,
Blair, J.
,
Henne, J.
,
Bye, L. L.
and
Coates, T. J.
(2001)
‘The Continuing HIV Epidemic among Men who have Sex with Men’
, American Journal of Public Health91:
907-914
.
15.
Chauncey, G.
(1994) Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of
the Gay Male World, 1890-1940.
New York: Basic Books
.
16.
Coates, T. J.
,
Katz, M.
,
Goldstein, E.
,
McFarland, W.
,
Morin, S.
,
Schwarz, S.
,
Sheehy, J.
,
Shriver, M.
and
Tierney, S.
(2000) The San Francisco Department of Public Health and AIDS
Research Institute/UCSF Response to the Updated Estimates of HIV Infection in
San Francisco.
San Francisco: Department of Public Health and
AIDS Research Institute/University of California, San Francisco
.
17.
Crocker, J.
and
Major, B.
(1989)
‘Social Stigma and Self-Esteem: The Self-Protective Properties of Stigma’
, Psychological Review96:
608-630
.
18.
Crossley, M. L.
(2002)
‘The Perils of Health Promotion and the
‘Barebacking’ Backlash’
, Health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of
Health, Illness and Medicine6:
47-68
.
19.
Cushman, P.
(1995) Constructing the Self, Constructing America: A
Cultural History of Psychotherapy.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley
.
20.
Davis, M.
(2002)
‘HIV Prevention Rationalities and Serostatus in the Risk
Narratives of Gay Men’
, Sexualities5:
281-299
.
21.
Díaz, R. M.
,
Ayala, G.
and
Bein, E.
(2002)
‘Sexual Risk as an Outcome of Social Oppression: Data from a
Probability Sample of Latino Gay Men in Three US Cities’
, Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology10:
255-267
.
22.
Doré, R.
and
Prévost, M. L.
(eds) (1990) Selected Letters of Romain Rolland.
Delhi: Indira Gandhi National Centre for the Arts
.
23.
Elford, J.
and
Hart, G.
(2003)
‘If HIV Prevention Works, Why are Rates of High-Risk Sexual
Behavior Increasing among MSM?’
, AIDS Education and Prevention15:
294-308
.
24.
Etgeton, S.
(2000) ‘Structural Prevention: The Basis for a
Critical Approach to Health Promotion’, in
R. Rosenbrock
and
M. T. Wright
(eds) Partnership and Pragmatism: Germany’s Response to AIDS
Prevention and Care, pp. 73-81.
New York: Routledge
.
25.
Euripides
(1960) The Bacchae, trans. and ed.
E. R. Dodds
(2nd edn).
New York: Oxford University Press
.
26.
Fox, K. K.
,
del Rio, C.
,
Holmes, K. K.
,
Hook, E. W.
,
Judson, F. N.
,
Knapp, J. S.
,
Procop, G. W.
,
Wang, S. A.
,
Whittington, W. L.
and
Levine, W. C.
(2001)
‘Gonorrhea in the HIV Era: A Reversal in Trends among Men who
have Sex with Men’
, American Journal of Public Health91:
959-964
.
27.
Frankis, J.
and
Flowers, P.
(2005)
‘Men who Have Sex with Men (MSM) in Public Sex Environments
(PSEs): A Systematic Review of Quantitative Literature’
, AIDS Care17:
273-288
.
28.
Freud, S.
(1961 [1930]) Civilization and its Discontents, trans.
and ed.
J. Strachey
.
New York: Norton
.
29.
Gammeltoft, T.
(2002)
‘Seeking Trust and Transcendence: Sexual Risk-Taking among
Vietnamese Youth’
, Social Science and Medicine55:
483-496
.
30.
Granvold, D. G.
and
Martin, J. I.
(1999) ‘Family Therapy with Gay and Lesbian
Clients’, in
C. Franklin
and
C. Jordan
(eds) Family Practice: Brief Systems Methods for Social Work, pp.
299-320.
Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole
.
31.
Grof, S.
(1988) The Adventure of Self-Discovery.
Albany, NY: State University of New York Press
.
32.
Halkitis, P. N.
and
Parsons, J. T.
(2003)
‘Intentional Unsafe Sex (Barebacking) among HIV-Positive Gay Men
who Seek Sexual Partners on the Internet’
, AIDS Care15:
367-378
.
33.
Halkitis, P. N.
,
Parsons, J. T.
and
Wilton, L.
(2003)
‘Barebacking among Gay and Bisexual Men in New York City:
Explanations for the Emergence of Intentional Unsafe Behavior’
, Archives of Sexual Behavior32:
351-357
.
34.
Henriksson, B.
(1995) ‘Risk Factor Love: The Symbolic Meaning
of Sexuality and HIV Prevention’, in
D. Friedrich
and
W. Heckmann
(eds) AIDS in Europe: The Behavioural Aspect, vol. 2, pp.
115-131.
Berlin: Edition Sigma
.
35.
Herdt, G.
and
Boxer, A.
(1993) Children of Horizons: How Gay and Lesbian Teens are
Leading a New Way out of the Closet.
Boston: Beacon Press
.
36.
Holleran, A.
(1978) Dancer from the Dance.
New York: William Morrow & Co
.
37.
Johnson, T.
(2000) Gay Spirituality: The Role of Gay Identity in the
Transformation of Human Consciousness.
Los Angeles: Alyson Books
.
38.
Kippax, S.
and
Race, K.
(2003)
‘Sustaining Safe Practice: Twenty Years on’
, Social Science and Medicine57:
1-12
.
39.
Klausner, J. D.
,
Kim, A.
and
Kent, C.
(2002)
‘Are HIV Drug Advertisements Contributing to Increases in Risk
Behavior among Men in San Francisco, 2001?’AIDS16:
2, 349-350
.
40.
Koblin, B. A.
,
Torian, L. V.
,
Guilin, V.
,
Ren, L.
,
MacKellar, D. A.
and
Valleroy, L. A.
(2000)
‘High Prevalence of HIV Infection among Young Men who have Sex
with Men in New York City’
, AIDS14:
1, 793-800
.
41.
LaSala, M. C.
(2001)
‘Monogamous or not: Understanding and Counseling Gay Male Couples’
, Families in Society82:
605-611
.
42.
LaSala, M. C.
(2004)
‘Extradyadic Sex in Gay Male Couples: Comparing Monogamous and
Nonmonogamous Relationships’
, Families in Society85(3):
405-412
.
43.
Laumann, E. O.
,
Gagnon, J. H.
,
Michael, R. T.
and
Michaels, S.
(1994) The Social Organization of Sexuality: Sexual Practices
in the United States.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
44.
Longman, R. Jr
(2003) Baptism in Water, Word, and the Holy Spirit, on
www.spirithome.com/baptcomm.html (accessed 1 October 2003).
45.
Mallon, G. P.
(1998) We Don’t Exactly Get the Welcome Wagon: The
Experiences of Gay and Lesbian Adolescents in North America’s Child
Welfare System.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
46.
Mann, A. T.
and
Lyle, J.
(1995) Sacred Sexuality.
New York: Barnes & Noble Books
.
47.
Martin, J. I.
and
Knox, J.
(1997)
‘Self-Esteem Instability and its Implications for HIV Prevention
among Gay Men’
, Health and Social Work22:
264-273
.
48.
Martin, J. I.
,
Pryce, J. G.
and
Leeper, J.
(2005)
‘Avoidance Coping and HIV Risk Behavior among Gay Men’
, Health and Social Work30:
193-201
.
49.
Maslow, A. H.
(1964) Religions, Values, and Peak-Experiences.
New York: Viking Press
.
50.
Mastoon, A.
(1997) The Shared Heart: Portraits and Stories Celebrating
Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Young People.
New York: William Morrow & Co
.
51.
May, R.
(1969) Love and Will.
New York: W.W. Norton
.
52.
Mays, V. M.
,
Cochran, S. D.
and
Zamudio, A.
(2004)
‘HIV Prevention Research: Are We Meeting the Needs of African
American Men who Have Sex with Men?’Journal of Black Psychology30:
78-105
.
53.
McKechnie, J. L.
(ed.) (1983) Webster’s New Twentieth Century
Dictionary (2nd edn).
New York: Simon & Schuster
.
54.
McKirnan, D. J.
,
Ostrow, D. G.
and
Hope, B.
(1996)
‘Sex, Drugs and Escape: A Psychological Model of HIV-Risk Sexual Behaviors’
, AIDS Care8:
655-669
.
55.
Meyer, I. H.
(2003)
‘Prejudice, Social Stress, and Mental Health in Lesbian, Gay, and
Bisexual Populations: Conceptual Issues and Research Evidence’
, Psychological Bulletin129:
674-697
.
56.
Mollenkott, V. R.
(1992) Sensuous Spirituality: Out from Fundamentalism.
New York: Crossroad
.
57.
National Association of Social Workers
(2003) ‘Policy on HIV and AIDS’, in
Social Work Speaks (6th edn), National Association of
Social Workers Policy Statements 2003-2006, pp.
176-183.
Washington, DC: National Association of Social Workers
.
58.
Nava, M.
(1995) ‘Coming Out and Born
Again’, in
B. Bouldrey
(ed.) Wrestling with the Angel: Faith and Religion in the Lives of Gay
Men, pp. 175-182.
New York: Riverhead Books
.
59.
Nelson, J. B.
(1983) Between Two Gardens: Reflections on Sexuality and
Religious Experience.
New York: Pilgrim Press
.
60.
Nelson, J. B.
(1994) ‘Embracing
masculinity’, in
J. B. Nelson
and
S. P. Longfellow
(eds) Sexuality and the Sacred: Sources for Theological
Reflection, pp. 195-215.
Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press
.
61.
Nicolosi, J.
(2002) Why Reveal the Dark Side of the Gay Movement?National Association for Research and Therapy of Homosexuality
, on www.narth.com/docs/whyreveal.html (accessed 1 December 2003).
62.
Nimmons, D.
(2002) The Soul beneath the Skin: The Unseen Hearts and
Habits of Gay Men.
New York: St Martin’s Press
.
63.
Noss, D. S.
(1999) A History of the World’s Religions,
10th edn.Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall
.
64.
Odets, W.
(1995) In the Shadow of the Epidemic: Being HIV-Negative in
the Age of AIDS.
Durham, NC: Duke University Press
.
65.
Parker, R. G.
(1995) ‘The Social and Cultural Construction of
Sexual Risk, or How to Have (Sex) Research in an Epidemic’,
in
H. ten Brummelhuis
and
G. Herdt
(eds) Culture and Sexual Risk: Anthropological Perspectives on
AIDS, pp. 257-269.
New York: Gordon and Breach
.
66.
Pentecostal World Fellowship
(n.d.) About the Pentecostal World Fellowship, on
www.pentecostalworldconf.org/01_about/about.html%23believe (accessed 1
October 2003).
67.
Pickstone, C.
(1996) The Divinity of Sex: The Search for Ecstasy in a
Secular Age.
New York: St Martin’s Press
.
68.
Plato
(1994) Symposium, trans. R. Waterfield. New York:
Oxford University Press.
69.
Prieur, A.
(1990)
‘Norwegian Gay Men: Reasons for Continued Practice of Unsafe Sex’
, AIDS Education and Prevention2:
109-115
.
70.
Race, K. D.
(2003)
‘Revaluation of Risk among Gay Men’
, AIDS Education and Prevention15:
369-381
.
71.
Reynolds, R.
and
Sullivan, G.
(2003) ‘Sex and Truth in Gay Men’s
Narratives’, in
R. Reynolds
and
G. Sullivan
(eds) Gay Men’s Sexual Stories: Getting It! pp.
143-152.
New York: Harrington Park Press
.
72.
Ridge, D. T.
(2004)
‘“It Was an Incredible Thrill”: The Social
Meanings and Dynamics of Younger Gay Men’s Experiences of
Barebacking in Melbourne’
, Sexualities7:
259-279
.
73.
Rofes, E.
(1996) Reviving the Tribe: Regenerating Gay Men’s
Sexuality and Culture in the Ongoing Epidemic.
New York: Haworth Press
.
74.
Rofes, E.
(1998a)
‘Context is Everything: Thoughts on Effective HIV Prevention and
Gay Men in the United States’
, Journal of Psychology and Human Sexuality10(3-4):
133-142
.
75.
Rofes, E.
(1998b) Dry Bones Breathe: Gay Men Creating Post-AIDS
Identities and Cultures.
New York: Harrington Park Press
.
76.
Roy, L.
(2001) Transcendent Experiences: Phenomenology and
Critique.
Toronto: University of Toronto Press
.
77.
Russell, B.
(1967) The Autobiography of Bertrand Russell,
1872-1914.
London: George Allen & Unwin
.
78.
Seligman, A. B.
(2000) Modernity’s Wager: Authority, the Self, and
Transcendence.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
79.
Scheper-Hughes, N.
(1994)
‘An Essay: AIDS and the Social Body’
, Social Science and Medicine39:
991-1003
.
80.
Sheon, N.
and
Plant, A.
(n.d.) ‘Protease Dis-Inhibitors? The Gay Bareback
Phenomenon’, on
http://www.managingdesire.org/sexpanic/ProteaseDisInhibitors.html
(accessed 27 May 2005).
81.
Snodgrass, M.
(2003) ‘Beating the Odds’, in
R. Reynolds
and
G. Sullivan
(eds) Gay Men’s Sexual Stories: Getting It! pp.
89-95.
New York: Harrington Park Press
.
82.
Stall, R.
(1994)
‘How to Lose the Fight against AIDS among Gay Men’
, British Medical Journal309:
685-686
.
83.
Stolte, I. G.
,
Dukers, N. H.
,
Geskus, R. B.
,
Coutinho, R. A.
and
de Wit, J. B.
(2004)
‘Homosexual Men Change to Risky Sex when Perceiving Less Threat
of HIV/AIDS since Availability of Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy: A
Longitudinal Study’
, AIDS18:
303-309
.
84.
Synan, V.
(2002) The Origins of the Pentecostal Movement. Holy Spirit
Research Center, Oral Roberts University on
www.oru.edu/university/library/holyspirit/pentorg1.html (accessed 1
October 2003).
85.
Taylor, C.
(1991) The Ethics of Authenticity.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
86.
Timmerman, J. H.
(1992) Sexuality and Spiritual Growth.
New York: Crossroad
.
87.
Torgovnick, M.
(1997) Primitive Passion: Men, Women, and the Quest for
Ecstasy.
New York: Alfred A. Knopf
.
88.
Traditional Values Coalition
(2003) Special Report: Federal AIDS Dollars Fund Homosexual Proms and
Fisting Seminars, on
www.traditionalvalues.org/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=854
(accessed 28 October 2003).
89.
Turner, D. C.
(1997) Risky Sex: Gay Men and HIV Prevention.
New York: Columbia University Press
.
90.
Vanable, P. A.
,
Ostrow, D. G.
,
McKirnan, D. J.
,
Taywaditep, K. J.
and
Hope, B. A.
(2000)
‘Impact of Combination Therapies on HIV Risk Perceptions and
Sexual Risk among HIV-Positive and HIV-Negative Gay and Bisexual Men’
, Health Psychology19:
134-145
.
91.
Wade, J.
(2000)
‘Mapping the Courses of Heavenly Bodies: The Varieties of
Transcendent Sexual Experience’
, Journal of Transpersonal Psychology32:
103-122
.
92.
Warner, M.
(1999) The Trouble with Normal: Sex, Politics, and the Ethics
of Queer Life.
New York: Free Press
.
93.
Warwick, I.
,
Douglas, N.
,
Aggleton, P.
and
Boyce, P.
(2003)
‘Young Gay Men and HIV/AIDS: Towards a Contextual Understanding
of Sexual Risk’
, Sex Education3:
215-229
.
94.
Wolitski, R. J.
,
Valdiserri, R. O.
,
Denning, P. H.
and
Levine, W. C.
(2001)
‘Are We Headed for a Resurgence of the HIV Epidemic among Men who
have Sex with Men?’American Journal of Public Health91:
883-888
.
95.
Wright, M. T.
(1998)
‘Beyond Risk Factors: Trends in European Safer Sex Research’
, Journal of Psychology and Human Sexuality10(3):
7-18
.
96.
Yep, G. A.
,
Lovaas, K. E.
and
Pagonis, A. V.
(2002)
‘The Case of “Riding Bareback”: Sexual
Practices and the Paradoxes of Identity in the Era of AIDS’
, Journal of Homosexuality42(4):
1-14
.
97.
Zitner, A.
(28 October 2003)
‘“Intimidation” against AIDS Studies Claimed’
, Los Angeles Times, on
www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-nih28oct28,1,6540123.story
(accessed 28 October 2003).
98.
Zweig, C. (1995) ‘The Holy Longing: A Psychological Study of the
Religious Impulse’, unpublished PhD thesis, Pacifica Graduate Institute.
