In Sexualities 3(2), Tamsin Wilton argues MTF transsexualism represents a `shallow' reading of the body resulting from an uncritical endorsement of Cartesian dualism. This article reviews the bases of Wilton's critique, to reveal tensions within feminist and queer theory. My aim is to argue that: (a) Wilton reproduces the very psycho-medical discourses that her article purports to critique; and (b) rather than critique the bases of determining `reality' and `experience', Wilton reifies this Cartesian dualism. The article concludes by inviting continued dialogue between and within transsex, lesbian and feminist communities.
Atkins, D.
, ed. (1998) Looking Queer. New York: Harrington Park Press.
2.
Barker, V.
(1997) `Definition and the Question of “Woman”', Hypatia12(2): 185-215.
3.
Baumbach, J.
and Turner, L. (1992) `Female Gender Disorder: A New Model and Clinical Applications', in W. Bockting and E. Coleman (eds) Gender Dysphoria. Interdisciplinary Approaches to Clinical Management. New York: The Haworth Press.
4.
Billings, D.
and Urban, T. (1982) `The Socio-Medical Construction of Transsexualism: An Interpretation and Critique', Social Problems29: 266-282.
5.
Bockting, W.
and Coleman, E. (1992) `A Comprehensive Approach to the Treatment of Gender Dysphoria', in W. Bockting and E. Coleman (eds) Gender Dysphoria. Interdisciplinary Approaches to Clinical Management. New York: The Haworth Press.
6.
Bolin, A.
(1996) `Transcending and Transgendering: Male-to-Female Transsexuals, Dichotomy and Diversity', in G. Herdt (ed.) Third Sex, Third Gender. New York: Zone Books.
7.
Bornstein, K.
(1994) Gender Outlaw. New York: Routledge.
8.
Bullough, V.
(1975) `Transsexualism in History', Archives of Sexual Behavior4: 561-571.
9.
Butler, J.
(1990) Gender Trouble. New York: Routledge.
10.
Calhoun, C.
(1998) `Taking Seriously Dual Systems and Sex', Hypatia13(1): 224-231.
11.
Califia, P.
(1997) Sex Changes. San Francisco, CA: Cleis Press.
12.
Card, C.
(1998) `Radicalesbianfeminist Theory', Hypatia13(1): 206-213.
13.
Cromwell, J.
(1999) Transmen and FTMs. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.
14.
Cuomo, C.
(1998) `Thoughts on Lesbian Differences', Hypatia13(1): 198-205.
15.
Delphy, C.
(1984) Close to Home. London: Hutchinson.
16.
Delphy, C.
(1994) `Changing Women in a Changing Europe. Is “Difference” the Future for Feminism?', Women's Studies International Forum17: 187-201.
17.
Denny, D.
, ed. (1998) Current Concepts in Transgender Identity. New York: Garland Publishers.
18.
Ekins, R.
(1997) Male Femaling. New York: Routledge.
19.
Ekins, R.
and King, D., eds (1996) Blending Genders. New York: Routledge.
20.
Ekins, R.
and King, D. (1997) `Blending Genders: Contributions to the Emerging Field of Transgender Studies', The International Journal of Transgendering. url: http://www.symposion.com/ijt/ijtc0101.htm.
21.
Ekins, R.
and King, D. (1998) `Blending Genders: Contributions to the Emerging Field of Transgender Studies', in D. Denny, ed. Current Concepts in Transgender Identity. New York: Garland Publishing.
22.
Ekins, R.
and King, D. (1999) `Towards a Sociology of Transgendered Bodies', The Sociological Review47: 580-602.
23.
Elliot, P.
and Roen, K. (1998) `Transgenderism and the Question of Embodiment: Promising Queer Politics?', GLQ4(2): 231-262.
24.
Ellis, H.
(1936) Studies in the Psychology of Sex. Philadelphia, PA: Davis.
25.
Esterberg, K.
(1996) `“A Certain Swagger When I Walk”: Performing Lesbian Identity', in S. Seidman (ed.) Queer Theory/Sociology, pp. 259-279. Cambridge: Blackwells.
26.
Farquhar, C.
and Wilton, T. (2000) `Assume the Lesbian Position', Sexualities3(2): 131-132.
27.
Feinberg, L.
(1996) Transgender Warriors. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.
28.
Ferguson, A.
(1998) `Cheshire Calhoun's Project of Separating Lesbian Theory from Feminist Theory', Hypatia13(1): 214-223.
29.
Frye, M.
(1983) The Politics of Reality. Trumansburg, NY: Crossing Press.
30.
Fuss, D.
(1989) Essentially Speaking. New York: Routledge.
31.
Garfinkel, H.
(1967) Studies in Ethnomethodology. Cambridge, MA: Polity Press.
32.
Ginzberg, R.
(1994) `Audre Lorde's (Nonessentialist) Lesbian Eros', in C. Card (ed.) Adventures in Lesbian Philosophy. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
33.
Goffman, E.
(1976) Gender Advertisements. London: Macmillan.
34.
Halberstam, J.
(1998) Female Masculinity. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
35.
Hale, J.
(1996) `Are Lesbians Women?', Hypatia11(2): 94-121.
36.
Hansen, D.
(1976) An Invitation to Critical Sociology. New York and London: The Free Press.
37.
Harry Benjamin's International Gender Dysphoria Association
(1998) The Standards of Care for Gender Identity Disorders. url: http://www.tc.umn.edu/colem001/hbigda/hstndrd.htm.
38.
Hausman, B.
(1995) Changing Sex. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
39.
Hird, M. J.
(2000) `Gender's Nature: Intersexuality, Transsexualism and the “Sex” / “Gender” Binary', Feminist Theory1(3): 347-364.
40.
Hird, M. J.
(2002) `For a Sociology of Transsexualism', Sociology36(3): 573-591.
41.
Hood-Williams, J.
(1996) `Goodbye to Sex and Gender', The Sociological Review44(1): 1-16.
42.
Jackson, S.
(1999) Heterosexuality in Question. London: Sage Publications.
43.
Jeffreys, S.
(1990) Anticlimax. London: The Women's Press.
44.
King, D.
(1981) `Gender Confusions: Psychological and Psychiatric Conceptions of Transvestism and Transsexualism', in P. Plummer (ed.) The Making of the Modern Homosexual. London: Hutchinson.
45.
King, D.
(1993) The Transvestite and the Transsexual. Aldershot: Avebury.
46.
Krafft-Ebing, R. von
(1965[1894]). Psychopathia Sexualis. London: Panther.
47.
Kristeva, J.
(1981) `Woman Can Never be Defined', in E. Marks and I. DeCourtivron (eds) New French Feminisms. London: Harvester.
48.
Laqueur, T.
(1990) Making Sex. London: Harvard University Press.
49.
Layton, L.
(1998) Who's That Girl? Who's That Boy? Clinical Practice Meets Postmodern Gender Theory. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson Inc.
50.
Levine, S.
(1980) `Psychiatric Diagnosis of Patients Requesting Sex Reassignment Surgery', Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy6(3): 164-173.
51.
Levine, S.
and Lothstein, L. (1981) `Transsexualism or the Gender Dysphoria Syndromes', Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy7(2): 85-113.
52.
Lewins, F.
(1995) Transsexualism in Society. Melbourne: Macmillan.
53.
Lothstein, L.
(1977) `Psychotherapy with Patients with Gender Dysphoria Syndromes', Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic41(6): 563-583.
54.
Lothstein, L.
and Levine, S. (1981) `Expressive Psychotherapy with Gender Dysphoric Patients', Archives of General Psychiatry38: 924-929.
55.
MacKenzie, G.
(1994) Transgender Nation. Bowling Green, OH: State University Popular Press.
56.
Mead, G. H.
(1934) Mind, Self and Society. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
57.
Millott, C.
(1983) Horsexe. New York: Autono Media.
58.
Money, J.
(1991) `Serendipities on the Sexological Pathway to Research in Gender Identity and Sex Reassignment', Journal of Psychology and Human Sexuality4(1): 101-113.
59.
More, K.
and Whittle, S. (1999) Reclaiming Genders. Cassette College Audio.
60.
Morris, Esther Marguerite
(2000) An Additional Monologue. http://homestead.juno.com/mrkh1/files/AdditionalMonologue.htm.
61.
Morris, J.
(1974) Conundrum. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
62.
Namaste, K.
(1996) ` “Tragic Misreadings”: Queer Theory's Erasure of Transgender Subjectivity', in B. Beemyn and M. Eliason (eds) Queer Studies, pp. 183-203. New York: New York University Press.
63.
Oppenheimer, A.
(1991) `The Wish for a Sex Change: A Challenge to Psycho-analysis?', International Journal of Psycho-analysis72: 221-231.
64.
Oxford English Dictionary (1989) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
65.
Pauly, I.
(1992) `Terminology and Classification of Gender Identity Disorders', in W. Bockting, and E. Coleman (eds) Gender Dysphoria. Interdisciplinary Approaches to Clinical Management. New York: The Haworth Press.
66.
Prosser, J.
(1998) Second Skins. New York: Columbia University Press.
67.
Raymond, J.
(1979) The Transsexual Empire. New York: Teachers College Press.
68.
Rich, A.
(1980) `Compulsory Heterosexuality and Lesbian Experience', Signs5(4): 631-660.
69.
Stoller, R.
(1968). Sex and Gender: Vol.I: The Development of Masculinity and Femininity. London: Maresfield Reprints.
70.
Stoller, R.
(1969) `Parental Influences in Male Transsexualism', in R. Green and J. Money (eds) Transsexualism and Sex Reassignment. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press.
71.
Stoller, R.
(1975) Sex and Gender. Vol.II. New York: Science House.
72.
Stoltenberg, J.
(1989) Refusing to Be a Man. Portland, OR: Breitenbursh.
73.
Stone, S.
(1991) `The Empire Strikes Back', in J. Epstein and K. Straub (eds) Bodyguards. London: Routledge.
74.
Stryker, S.
(1994) `My Words to Victor Frankenstein Above the Village of Chamounix', GLQ1(3): 237-254.
75.
Stryker, S.
(1995) `Transsexuality: The Postmodern Body and/as Technology', Exposure30(1/2): 38-50.
76.
Szasz, T.
(1990) Sex by Prescription. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.
77.
Whittle, S.
(1998) `The Trans-Cyberian Mail Way', Social & Legal Studies7: 389-408.
78.
Whittle, S.
(2000a) Transgender. London: Garnett Publishers.
79.
Whittle S.
(2000b) The Transgender Debate: The Crisis Surrounding Gender Identities. London: South Street Press.
80.
Whittle, S.
(2000c) `The Becoming Man: The Law's Ass Brays', in K. More and S. Whittle (eds) Reclaiming Genders. Cassette College Audio.
81.
Willmott, J.
(2000) `The Experiences of Women with Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome', Feminism and Psychology10(1): 107-116.
82.
Wilton, T.
(2000) `Out/performing Our Selves: Sex, Gender and Cartesian Dualism', Sexualities3(2): 237-254.
83.
Wittig, M.
(1981[1993]) `One is not born a woman', in H. Abelove, M. Barale and D. Halperin (eds) The Lesbian and Gay Studies Reader. New York: Routledge.
84.
Zita, J.
(1998) Body Talk. New York: Columbia University Press.
85.
Zucker, K.
and Bradley, S. (1995) Gender Identity Disorder and Psychosexual Problems in Children and Adolescents. New York and London: The Guildford Press.
