The increasing prevalence of mental disorders together with the uncertain validity of psychopathological diagnostics challenges psychiatry as the primary home of studying, diagnosing and treating mental health problems and developing mental healthcare. This marks an emerging paradigmatical shift towards ‘alternative’ mental health perspectives. With the ambition of attending authoritatively in definitory practices, contemporary scholars of psychology, sociology, anthropology and philosophy call for an interdisciplinary approach to mental health, with a predominant focus on the subject. We argue that a paradigmatical shift of mental health requires structural–historical considerations of the foundations upon which subjectivity has been and still is manifested through psychiatry. On this basis, we critically investigate fluctuating psychiatric discourses on subjectivity, normality and pathology. We conducted a genealogical analysis of 13 psychiatric sources (1938–2017) focusing on ‘Psychopathy’ as a fluctuating diagnosis. We elucidate how subject concepts in psychiatry develop in parallel to subject concepts in society and culture, exemplified through convincing similarities between psychopathic symptoms and neoliberal ideals. Considerations like these, offer scholars valuable bases for mental health research and debate, and also valuable insights to healthcare professionals.
Andkjær OlsenOKøppeS (1988) Freud’s Theory of Psychoanalysis. New York: New York University Press.
2.
ArrigoBAShipleyS (2001) The confusion over psychopathy (I): Historical considerations. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology45(3): 325–344.
3.
BakJAggernaesH (2012) Coercion within Danish psychiatry compared with 10 other European countries. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry66(5): 297–302.
4.
BaumeisterAHawkinsMF (2005) Continuity and discontinuity in the historical development of modern psychopharmacology. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences14(3): 199–209.
5.
BeyerholmO (1937) Psykiatriens Historie [The history of psychiatry]. Copenhagen: Munksgaard.
6.
BjerrumM (2008) Fra stat til amt [From the State to the County]. In: Vaczy-KraghJ (ed.) Psykiatriens historie i Danmark [The History of Psychiatry in Denmark]. 1st ed. Copenhagen: Hans Reitzels Forlag.
BourdieuP (1998) Practical Reason: On the Theory of Action. Stanford University Press.
9.
BrinkmannS (2005) Human kinds and looping effects in psychology: Foucauldian and Hermeneutic perspectives. Theory & Psychology15(6): 769–791.
10.
BrinkmannS (2015) Diagnoser som epistemiske objekter [Diagnosis as epistemic objects]. In: BrinkmannSPetersenA (eds) Diagnoser– perspektiver, kritikog diskussion [Diagnosis–Perspectives, critique and discussion]. 1st ed. Aarhus: Forlaget Klim, pp. 37–58.
11.
CanguilhemG (1991) The Normal and the Pathological. 1st ed. New York: Zone Books.
12.
ChristensenG (2016) Genealogy and educational research. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education29(6): 763–776.
13.
Dansk Psykiatrisk Selskabs Diagnoseudvalg (1952) Diagnoseliste med kommentarer [List of diagnose with comments]. Nordisk Psykiatrisk Medlemsblad6(4): 277–295.
14.
Egaa KristensenB (2007) Historisk metode [Method of history]. 1st ed. Copenhagen: Hans Reitzels Forlag.
15.
FoucaultM (1982) The subject and power. Critical Inquiry8(4): 777–795.
16.
FoucaultM (1984) The Foucault Reader (ed. P.Rabino). London: Penguin Books.
17.
HarveyD (2007) Neoliberalism as Creative Destruction. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science610(1): 21–44.
18.
HeedeD (2002) Det tomme menneske [The empty Human]. 2nd ed. Copenhagen: Museum Tuscalanums Forlag, University of Copenhagen.
19.
HemmingsenRParnasJSørensenT., et al (1994) Klinisk Psykiatri [Clinical psychiatry]. 1st ed. Copenhagen: Munksgaard.
20.
HergenhahnBR (2005) An introduction to the History of Psychology. 5th ed. USA: Thomsen Wadsworth.
21.
HerpertzSCSassH (2000) Emotional Deficiency and Psychopathy. Behavioral Sciences and the Law18(5): 567–580.
22.
HolenM (2011) Medinddragelse og lighed – en god idé?: en analyse af patienttilbliveler i det moderne hispital [User involvement and equality–A good idea?: An analysis of patients beings in the modern hospital]. Roskilde: Roskilde University.
23.
HorleyJ (2014) The emergence and development of psychopathy. History of the Human Sciences27(5): 91–110.
24.
KendlerKS (2008) Introduction: Why does psychiatry need philosophy? In: KendlerKSParnasJ (eds) Philosophical Issues in Psychiatry. 1st ed. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press, pp. 1–18.
25.
Klaebo ReitanSHelvikA-SIversenV (2018) Use of mechanical and pharmacological restraint over an eight-year period and its relation to clinical factors. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry72: 24–30.
26.
KøppeS (2014a) Evolutionspsykologi [Evolution psychology]. In: KøppeSDammeyerJ (eds) Personlighedspsykologi [Personality psychology]. 1st ed. Hans Reitzels Forlag: Copenhagen, pp. 351–369.
27.
KøppeS (2014b) Personlighed, subjektivitet og historicitet [Personality, subjectivity and historicity]. In: KøppeSDammeyerJ (eds) Personlighedspsykologi [Personality psychology]. 1st ed. Hans Reitzels Forlag: Copenhagen, pp. 219–255.
28.
Kragh-SørensenPParnasJMorsO (2010) Psykiatriens teoretiske fundament: Sygdomsbregreb, klassifikation og diagnostik [The theoretical foundation of psychiatry: Concept of disease, classification and diagnostics]. In: MorsOKragh-SørensenPParnasJ (eds) Klinisk Psychiatri [Clinical psychiatry]. 3rd ed. Copenhagen: Munksgaard, pp. 1–28.
MellemgaardS (1998) Kroppens Natur. Sundhedsoplysning og naturidealer i 250 år [The nature of the body. Health information and ideals of nature in 250 years]. 3rd ed. Copenhagen: Museum Tuscalanums Forlag, University of Copenhagen.
RimkeHHuntA (2002) From sinners to degenerates: The medicalization of morality in the 19th century. History of the Human Sciences15(1): 59–88.
33.
RingerA (2013) Listening to Patients A Study of Illness Discourses, Patient Identities, and User Involvement in Contemporary Psychiatric Practice. Roskilde: Roskilde University.
34.
RoseN (1998) Inventing Our Selves: Psychology, Power, and Personhood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
RoseN (2006) Disorders without borders? The expanding scope of psychiatric practice. BioSocieties1(4): 465–485.
RothmanDJ (2002) Conscience and Convenience: The Asylum and Its Alternatives in Progressive America, New Lines in Criminology. Piscataway, NJ: Aldine Transaction.
38.
SimonsenEMøhlB (2010) Grundbog i Psykiatri [Psychiatric textbook]. 1st ed. Copenhagen: Hans Reitzels Forlag.
Sonne-RagansV (2013) Anvendt Videnskabsteori [Applied theory of science]. 1st ed. Frederiksberg: Hans Reitzels Forlag.
41.
StickleyT (2006) Should service user involvement be consigned to history? A critical perspective. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing13: 570–577.
SzaszTS (1961) The uses of naming and the origin of the myth of mental illness. American Psychologist16: 59–65.
45.
The Danish Ministry of Health (1989) Lov om frihedsberøvelse og anden tvang i psykiatrien [Act on loss of liberty and other coercion in psychiatry]. Copenhagen: The Danish Ministry of Health.
46.
The Danish Ministry of Health (2015) Bekendtgørelse af lov om anvendelse af tvang i psykiatrien [Notice of Act on use of coercion in psychiatry]. Copenhagen: The Danish Ministry of Health.
47.
The Danish Ministry of Justice (1938) Lov om sindssyge Personers Hospitalshold [Act on hospitalization of mad people]. Copenhagen: The Danish Ministry of Justice.
48.
The Danish Ministry of Justice (1954) Lov om ændringer i lov nr. 118 af 13. april 1938 om sindssyge personers hospitalsophold [Act on changes of Act 118 on hospitalization of mad people]. Copenhagen: The Danish Ministry of Justice.
49.
TürkenSNafstadHEBlakarRM, et al. (2016) Making sense of neoliberal subjectivity: A discourse analysis of media language on self-development. Globalizations13(1): 32–46.
50.
TyrerPReedGMCrawfordMJ (2015) Classification, assessment, prevalence, and effect of personality disorder. The Lancet385(9969): 717–726.
51.
VolkertJGablonskiT-CRabungS (2018) Prevalence of personality disorders in the general adult population in Western countries: Systematic review and meta-analysis. The British Journal of Psychiatry231: 709–715.
52.
WerlinderH (1978) Psychopathy: A History of the Concepts. London: Coronet Books.
53.
WhiteheadPCrawshawP (2013) Shaking the foundations: On the moral economy of criminal justice. The British Journal of Criminology53(4): 588–604.
54.
WHO (1974) Glossary of Mental Disorders and Guide to Their Classification for Use in Conjunction With the International Classification of Diseases. 8th revised ed. Geneva: WHO.
55.
WHO (1994) Psykiske lidelser og adfærdsmæssige forstyrrelser. Klassifikation og Diagnostiske kriterier [Mental illness and behavioral disorders. Classification and diagnostic criteria]. 1st ed. Copenhagen: Munksgaard.
56.
WHO (2017) 06 mental or behavioural disorders, ICD-11 beta draft (Mortality and morbidity statistics). Available at: https://icd.who.int/browse11/l-m/en
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
