Food is related to health, both directly and symbolically, in complex ways. Also, social practices around food are highly gendered, and, in the context of family life, fall largely to mothers. This study examines mothers’ talk about nutritional health, and food, health and dietary practices in the context of everyday life, using a discursive analysis of the talk from focus group discussions. Findings show that discourses surrounding nutritional health offer women a variety of conflictual subjectivities. If they do not engage in ‘correct’ dietary practices, women are positioned as immoral, both as individuals and as mothers. Further, their ability to determine which foods are ‘healthy’ or ‘unhealthy’ is undermined through a distrust of ‘facts’ and scientific evidence, and they are rendered susceptible to exploitation through claims made for food as health promoting. Together, these areas of conflict perpetuate subjectivities of anxiety around dietary practices.The women seek to re-position themselves and overcome these contradictions by offering a variety of legitimations for their dietary practices. In doing so, they resist nutritional health messages and reveal how such messages can have unintended effects.
Anderson N. ( 2005) Everyone Eats: Understanding Food and Culture. New York: New York University Press.
2.
Aphramor L. ( 2005) Is a Weight-Centred Health Framework Salutogenic? Some Thoughts on Unhinging Certain Dietary Ideologies. Social Theory & Health3(4): 315-340.
3.
Ashley B., Hollows J., Jones S., and Taylor B. ( 2004) Food and Cultural Studies. London: Routledge.
4.
Beardsworth A., Bryman A., Keil T., Goode J., Haslam C., and Lancashire E. ( 2002) Women, Men and Food: The Significance of Gender for Nutritional Attitudes and Choices. British Food Journal104(7): 470-491.
5.
Beck U. ( 1995) Ecological Politics and the Age of Risk. Cambridge: Polity.
6.
Benford R., Gough B. ( 2006) Defining and Defending ‘Unhealthy’ Practices: A Discourse Analysis of Chocolate ‘Addicts’’ Accounts. Journal of Health Psychology11(3): 427-440.
7.
Bray A. ( 1996) The Anorexic Body: Reading Disorders. Cultural Studies10(3): 413-429.
8.
Bugge B., Almas R. ( 2006) Domestic Dinner: Representations and Practices of a Proper Meal among Young Suburban Mothers. Journal of Consumer Culture6(2): 203-228.
9.
Campos P. ( 2004) The Obesity Myth: Why America’s Obsession with Weight Is Hazardous to Your Health. New York: Gotham Books.
10.
Campos P., Saguy A., Ernsberger P., Oliver E., and Gaesser G. ( 2006) The Epidemiology of Overweight and Obesity: Public Health Crisis or Moral Panic? International Journal of Epidemiology35(1): 55-60.
11.
Carrigan M., Szmigin I., and Leek S. ( 2006) Managing Routine Food Choices in UK Families: The Role of Convenience Consumption. Appetite47(3): 372-383.
12.
Chamberlain K., Hodgetts D. ( 2008) Social Psychology and Media: Critical Considerations. Social and Personality Psychology Compass2(3): 1-17.
13.
Charles N., Kerr M. ( 1988) Women, Food and Families. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
14.
Coveney J. ( 1999) The Science and Spirituality of Nutrition. Critical Public Health9(1): 23-37.
15.
Coveney J. ( 2005) A Qualitative Study Exploring Socio-Economic Differences in Parental Lay Knowledge of Food and Health: Implications for Public Health Nutrition. Public Health Nutrition8(3): 290-297.
16.
Coveney J. ( 2006) Food, Morals and Meaning: The Pleasure and Anxiety of Eating. London: Routledge.
17.
Crossley M. ( 2002) The Perils of Health Promotion and the ‘Barebacking’ Backlash. health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health , Illness and Medicine6(1): 47-68.
18.
Crossley M. ( 2003) ‘Would You Consider Yourself a Healthy Person?’: Using Focus Groups to Explore Health as a Moral Phenomenon. Journal of Health Psychology8(5): 501-504.
19.
Department of Health and Ageing (2003) Healthy Weight 2008, Australia’s Future. Canberra : Commonwealth of Australia.
20.
Dixon J., Banwell C. ( 2004) Heading the Table: Parenting and the Junior Consumer. British Food Journal106(3): 181-190.
21.
Duruz J. ( 2005) Eating at the Borders: Culinary Journeys. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space23(1): 51-69.
22.
Elley W., Irving J. ( 1985) The Elley-Irving Socioeconomic Index 1981 Census Revision . New Zealand Journal of Educational Studies20: 115-128.
23.
Evans J., Rich E., and Holroyd R. ( 2004) Disordered Eating and Disordered Schooling: What Schools Do to Middle Class Girls. British Journal of Sociology of Education25(2): 123-143.
24.
Fieldhouse P. ( 1995) Food and nutrition: Customs and culture. London: Chapman and Hall.
25.
Fischler C. ( 1988) Food, Self and Identity. Social Science Information27(2): 275-292.
26.
Gard M., Wright J. ( 2005) The Obesity Epidemic: Science, Morality and Ideology. Oxfordshire: Routledge.
27.
Gough B., Conner M. ( 2006) Barriers to Healthy Eating amongst Men: A Qualitative Analysis. Social Science and Medicine62(2): 387-395.
28.
Groez L., Levine M., and Murnen S. ( 2002) The Effect of Experimental Presentation of Thin Media Images on Body Satisfaction: A Meta-Analytic Review. International Journal of Eating Disorders31(1): 1-16.
29.
Grogan S. ( 2006) Body Image and Health: Contemporary Perspectives. Journal of Health Psychology11(4): 523-530.
30.
Johnston O., Reilly J., and Kremer J. ( 2004) Women’s Experience of Appearance Concern and Body Control across the Lifespan: Challenging Accepted Wisdom. Journal of Health Psychology9(3): 397-410.
31.
Jutel A. ( 2005) Weighing Health: The Moral Burden of Obesity. Social Semiotics15(2): 113-125.
32.
Jutel A. ( 2006) The Emergence of Overweight as a Disease Entity: Measuring Up Normality. Social Science & Medicine63(9): 2268-2276.
33.
Kiefer I., Rathmanner T., and Kunze M. ( 2005) Eating and Dieting Differences in Men and Women. Journal of Men’s Health and Gender2(2): 194-201.
34.
Labra MP ( 2005) Burn Fat, Build Muscle: A Content Analysis of Men’s Health and Men’s Fitness. International Journal of Men’s Health4(2): 187-200.
35.
Lelwica M. ( 2006) Redefining Womanhood (?): Gender, Power, and the ‘Religion of Thinness’. Anthropology of Food5: http://aof.revues.org/document571.html (accessed 12 March 2008).
36.
Levine M., Piran N. ( 2004) The Role of Body Image in the Prevention of Eating Disorders . Body Image: An International Journal of Research1(1): 57-70.
37.
Litosseliti L. ( 2003) Using Focus Groups in Research. London : Continuum.
38.
Locher J., Yoels W., Maurer D., and Van Ells J. ( 2005) Comfort Foods: An Exploratory Journey into the Social and Emotional Significance of Food. Food & Foodways13(4): 273-298.
39.
Lupton D. ( 1996) Food, the Body and the Self. London : SAGE.
40.
Lupton D. ( 2005) Lay Discourses and Beliefs Related to Food Risks: An Australian Perspective. Sociology of Health and Illness27(4): 387-395.
41.
Madden H., Chamberlain K. ( 2004) Nutritional Health Messages in Women’s Magazines: A Conflicted Space for Women Readers. Journal of Health Psychology9(4): 583-597.
42.
Mennell S., Murcott A., and Van Otterloo A. ( 1992) The Sociology of Food: Eating, Diet and Culture. London: SAGE.
43.
Miller E., Halberstadt J. ( 2005) Media Consumption, Body Image and Thin Ideals in New Zealand Men and Women. New Zealand Journal of Psychology34(3): 189-195.
44.
Moisio R., Arnould E., and Price L. ( 2004) Between Mothers and Markets: Constructing Family Identity through Homemade Food. Journal of Consumer Culture4(3): 361-384.
45.
Monaghan L. ( 2005) Discussion Piece: A Critical Take on the Obesity Debate . Social Theory & Health3(4): 302-314.
46.
Monaghan L. ( 2007) Body Mass Index, Masculinities and Moral Worth: Men’s Critical Understandings of ‘Appropriate Weight-for-Height’. Sociology of Health and Illness29(4): 584-609.
47.
Monro F., Huon G. ( 2005) Media-Portrayed Idealized Images, Body Shame, and Appearance Anxiety. International Journal of Eating Disorders38(1): 85-90.
48.
Nordin S., Broman D., Garvill J., and Nyroos M. ( 2004) Gender Differences in Factors Affecting Rejection of Food in Healthy Young Swedish Adults. Appetite43(3): 295-301.
49.
Paquette M-C., Raine K. ( 2004) Sociocultural Context of Women’s Body Image. Social Science & Medicine59(5): 1047-1058.
50.
Parker I. ( 1992) Discourse Dynamics: Critical Analysis for Social and Individual Psychology. London: Routledge.
51.
Pettinger C., Holdsworth M., and Gerber M. ( 2006) Meal Patterns and Cooking Practices in Southern France and Central England. Public Health Nutrition9(8): 1020-1026.
52.
Pieterman R. ( 2007) The Social Construction of Fat: Care and Control in the Public Concern for Healthy Behaviour. Sociology Compass1(1): 309-321.
53.
Rich E., Evans J. ( 2005) ‘Fat Ethics’: The Obesity Discourse and Body Politics. Social Theory and Health3(4): 341-358.
54.
Ristovski-Slijepcevic S., Chapman G., and Beagan B. ( 2008) Engaging with Healthy Eating Discourse(s): Ways of Knowing about Food and Health in Three Ethnocultural Groups in Canada. Appetite50(1): 167-178.
55.
Saguy A., Riley K. ( 2005) Weighing Both Sides: Morality, Mortality, and Framing Contests over Obesity. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law30(5): 869-923.
56.
Silverstein B., Perdue L., Peterson B., and Kelly E. ( 1986) The Role of the Mass Media in Promoting a Thin Standard of Bodily Attractiveness for Women. Sex Roles14(9/10): 519-532.
57.
Smith ML ( 2006) The Archaeology of Food Preference. American Anthropologist108(3): 480-493.
58.
Sobal J. ( 2005) Men, Meat and Marriage: Models of Masculinity. Food and Foodways13(1/2): 135-158.
59.
Sparkes AC ( 1997) Reflections on the Socially Constructed Physical Self . In: Fox, K. (ed.) The Physical Self from Motivation to Wellbeing. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics Press, 83-110.
60.
Sypeck M., Gray J., and Ahrens A. ( 2004) No Longer Just a Pretty Face: Fashion Magazines’ Depictions of Ideal Female Beauty from 1959 to 1999. International Journal of Eating Disorders36(3): 342-347.
61.
Vartanian L., Herman C., and Polivy J. ( 2007) Consumption Stereotypes and Impression Management: How You Are What You Eat. Appetite48(3): 265-277.
62.
Wilkinson S. ( 1998) Focus Groups in Health Research: Exploring the Meanings of Health and Illness. Journal of Health Psychology3(3): 329-348.
63.
Williams SJ ( 1998) Health as Moral Performance: Ritual, Transgression and Taboo. health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Study of Health, Illness and Medicine2(4): 435-457.
64.
Willig C. ( 2001) Introducing Qualitative Research in Psychology. Buckingham: Open University Press.
