You Never Stop Being a Doctor: The Stories of Russian Immigrant Physicians Who Converted to Physiotherapy

Abstract

This article is based on 28 in-depth interviews with Russian immigrant physicians (11 men and 17 women, age range 30–53) who decided not to seek Israeli medical license and converted to physiotherapy. This research was theoretically informed by the literature on physicians’ professional commitment. It explored the case of conversion from a perceived higher to lower status health care occupation and the ensuing changes in former doctors’ professional self-image, relations with the patients and colleagues, and adjustment to the new work role. Informants were recruited among the graduates of the retraining courses sponsored in the mid-1990s by the Israeli Ministry of Health in order to provide jobs for immigrant doctors and to fill in existing vacancies in physiotherapy. The stories of former MDs–novice physiotherapists indicate that most are well adjusted to their new role, maintain positive professional self-image, and are satisfied with the terms of their employment. At the same time, most informants admitted that their mode of thinking and relation to patients remained those of physicians rather than paramedics. Some informants gave medical advice to the patients (especially to their co-ethnics) when asked and discussed treatment options with physicians whenever the work context allowed. Ostensibly good readjustment of this group may reflect the interplay of their actual success in the new role, reluctance to disclose problems in the interview, and self-selection of this group (i.e. doctors who were ready to trade their higher status for pragmatic work benefits). We conclude that complete occupational make-over of immigrant physicians is hardly possible; their professional socialization leaves deep imprint on the mindset and conduct, regardless of subsequent career change.

Keywords

conversion to physiotherapy immigrant physicians Israel professional statuses role accommodation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Basok, T. (1997). The admission and licensing of immigrant physicians in Canada. In J.T. Shuval & J.H. Bernstein (Eds.), Immigrant physicians. Former Soviet doctors in Israel, Canada and the United States, pp. 61–80.Westport, CT: Praeger.

Bernstein, J.H. and Shuval, J.T. (1994). Emigrant physicians evaluate the health care system of the former Soviet Union. Medical Care, 32(2), 141–149.

Blau, G. and Lunz, M. (1998). Testing the incremental effect of professional commitment on intent to leave one’s profession beyond the effects of external, personal, and work-related variables. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 52(2), 260–269.

Carmel, S. (1997). The professional self-esteem of physicians. Scale, structure, properties, and the relationship to work outcomes and life satisfaction. Psychological Reports, 80, 591–602.

Costello, C.G.Y. (2000). Professional identity crisis: Professional socialization and identity dissonance. Ph.D. Thesis. University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.

Crabtree, B.F. and Miller, W.L. (1992). A template approach to text analysis. Developing and using codebooks. In B.F. Crabtree and W.L. Miller (Eds.), Doing qualitative research, pp. 93–109. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

Crompton, R. , Le Feuvre, N. , and Birkelund, G.E. (1999). The restructuring of gender relations within the medical profession. In R.Crompton (Ed.), The restructuring of gender relations and employment, pp. 179–199. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Feder-Bubis, P. (1997). Patterns of professional commitment in the stories of immigrant physicians from the former Soviet Union in Israel. In J.T. Shuval and J.H. Bernstein (Eds.), Immigrant physicians. Former Soviet doctors in Israel, Canada and the United States, pp. 61–80. Westport, CT: Praeger.

Field, M.G. (1990). Noble purpose, grand design, failing execution, mixed results: Soviet socialized medicine after seventy years. American Journal of Public Health, 30, 144–152.

10.

Hafferty, F.W. and Light, D.W. (1995). Professional dynamics and the changing nature of medical work. Journal of Health and Social Behavior (Extra Issue), 132–153.

11.

Heiligers, J.M. and Hingstman, L. (2000). Career preferences and the work-family balance in medicine: Gender differences among medical specialists. Social Science and Medicine, 50, 1235–1246.

12.

Hiremath, S.L. and Somashekhar, C. (1998). Professional commitment among Indian physicians. International Sociological Association paper 98S34609.

13.

Hoelter, J.W. (1983). The effects of role evaluation and commitment on identity salience. Social Psychology Quarterly, 46, 140–158.

14.

Jones, A. , Ed. (1991). Professions and the state: Expertise and autonomy in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.

15.

Loyttyniemi, V. (2001). Doctors drifting: autonomy and career uncertainty in young physicians’ stories. Social Science and Medicine, 52(2), 227–237.

16.

McAulay, B.J. (2000). Work commitment in a turbulent career environment: Job insecurity’s effect on psychological attachment to organization and profession. Dissertation Abstracts International (Humanities and Social Sciences), 60(7), 2695-A–2695-A.

17.

Nirel, N. (1999). The employment of immigrant physicians from the former Soviet Union in 1998: Summary of funding from a follow-up study. Jerusalem: JDCBrookdale Institute of Gerontology and Human Development (Hebrew).

18.

Remennick, L. (1998). Identity quest among Russian Jews of the 1990s: Before and after emigration. In E. Krausz and G. Tulea (Eds.), Jewish survival: The identity problem at the close of the 20th century, pp. 241–258. New Brunswick: Transaction.

19.

Remennick, L. (1999). Women with a ‘Russian accent’ in Israel. On the gender aspects of immigration. The European Journal of Women’s Studies, 6(4), 441–461.

20.

Remennick, L. and Shtarkshall, R. (1997). Technology versus responsibility: immigrant physicians from the former Soviet Union reflect on Israeli health care. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 38 (September), 191–202.

21.

Robinson, V. and Carey, M. (2000). Peopling skilled international migration: Indian doctors in the UK. International Migration, 38(1), 89–105.

22.

Rosenthal, M. , Young, R.F. , and Schecter, K. (1997). Immigrant physicians in a saturated market. In J.T. Shuval and J.H. Bernstein (Eds.), Immigrant physicians. Former Soviet doctors in Israel, Canada, and the United States, pp. 119–132. Westport, CT/London: Praeger.

23.

Ryan, M. (1986). Morale among Soviet doctors. British Medical Journal, 292, 1451–1456.

24.

Schecter, K. (1992). Soviet socialized medicine and the right to health care in a changing Soviet Union. Human Rights Quarterly, 14, 206–224.

25.

Shin, E.-H. and Chang, K.S. (1988). Peripherization of immigrant professionals: Korean physicians in the United States. International Migration Review, 22(4), 609–626.

26.

Shuval, J.T. (1995). Elitism and professional control in a saturated market: immigrant physicians in Israel. Sociology of Health and Illness, 17(4), 550–565.

27.

Shuval, J.T. (1997). Migrant physicians in post-industrial societies. In J.T. Shuval and J.H. Bernstein . Immigrant physicians. Former Soviet doctors in Israel, Canada and the United States, pp. 3–18. Westport, CT: Praeger.

28.

Shuval, J.T. and Bernstein, J. (1996). The dynamics of professional commitment: immigrant physicians from the former Soviet Union in Israel. Social Science and Medicine, 42(7), 965–974.

29.

Thoits, P.A. (1983). Multiple identities and psychological well-being. American Sociological Review, 48(1), 174–199.

30.

Werner, S. (1987). The development of physiotherapy in Israel. Physiotherapy Practice, 3, 1–4.

31.

Whitfeld, A.T.W. , Allison, I. , Laing, A. , and Turner, P.A. (1996). Perceptions of the physiotherapy profession: A comparative study. Physiotherapy Theory and Practice, 12(1), 39–48.

32.

Zhuravleva, I.V. (1999). Post-socialist medicine from public to private: Changes in doctor-patient relations and physicians’ motivations for work. In I.V. Zhuravleva and E.D. Katalova (Eds.), Russian medical system at the crossroads. Moscow: Semashko Institute for Public Health and Social Hygiene (Russian).