Understanding contradictory styles of policing

Abstract

Policing scholars have shown that logics of police governance that appear mutually exclusive can coexist in the same space and time. Within police institutions, we can find more military-like mindsets alongside democratic rationalities. We here present a novel theoretical perspective for understanding such coexistence. Instead of attempting to identify police rationalities by reference to organizational/structural factors such as subcultures, training, or firearms and other equipment, we show that contradictory logics of policing can coexist within the same force by differentiating policing's targets by space, temporality, and identity. To do so, we use the idea of “chronotope” to identify and understand how police officers decide between conflicting rationalities of policing.

Keywords

Contradictory rationalities crime governance militarization police security

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adarve Calle

(2012) La Ley de los Caballos de 1888: entre la búsqueda del “orden” y la construcción de un enemigo. Nuevo Foro Penal 7(78): 146–168.

Antillano

(2010) ¿Qué conocemos de la violencia policial en Venezuela? Espacio Abierto 19(2): 331–345.

Antillano

(2016) La reforma policial en Venezuela. Civitas Revista de Ciências Sociais 16(4): 618–635.

Ariza

(2021) Cali, nuestra nueva vorágine. Revista 070, 11 May. Available at: https://cerosetenta.uniandes.edu.co/cali-nuestra-nueva-voragine/

Brodeur

(1983) High policing and low policing: remarks about the policing of political activities. Social Problems 30(5): 507–520.

Brodeur

(2007) High policing and low policing in post-9/11 times. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 1(1): 25–37.

Cajas Sarría

(2018) La justicia constitucional contra los bolcheviques: la Corte Suprema de Justicia conservadora y la represión al movimiento obrero, 1926–1930. Estudios Jurídicos de la Universidad Icesi 19: 505–532.

Caldeira TS (2000) City of Walls: Crime, Segregation, and Citizenship in Sao Paulo. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Centro de Memoria Histórica (2016) Grupos armados posdesmovilizacion (2006–2015). Trayectorias, rupturas y continuidades. Bogotá: Centro Nacional de Memoria Histórica.

10.

Crawford

(2005) Governing through anti-social behaviour: regulatory challenges to criminal justice. British Journal of Criminology 49: 810–831.

11.

Cyr

Ricciardelli

Spencer

(2020) Militarization of police: a comparison of police paramilitary units in Canadian and the United States. Police & Science Management 22(2): 137–147.

12.

Dammert

(2005) Prevención comunitaria del delito en América Latina: desafíos y oportunidades. Desafíos 13: 124–156.

13.

Dammert

(2020) Reforma policial. Agenda (aún) pendiente en América Latina. (Documento de trabajo Julio 2020.) El Diálogo. Liderazgo para las Américas.

14.

Dammert

Malone

FMT

(2020) From community policing to political police in Nicaragua. Revista Europea de Estudios Latinoamericanos y Del Caribe 110: 79–99.

15.

DeMichele

Kraska

(2001) Community policing in battle garb: a paradoxical or coherent strategy? In: Kraska

(ed.) Militarizing the American Criminal Justice System: The Changing Role of the Armed Forces and the Police. Boston: Northeastern University Press, pp. 82–101.

16.

Eslava

(2015) Local Space, Global Life: The Everyday Operation of International Law and Development. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

17.

Fassin

(2016) La fuerza del orden. Una etnografía del accionar policial en las periferias urbanas. Buenos Aires: Siglo XXI Editores.

18.

Frühling

(2007) The impact of international models of policing in Latin America: the case of community policing. Police Practice and Research 8(2): 125–144.

19.

Frühling

HFH

(2003) Policía Comunitaria y Reforma Policial en América Latina ¿Cúal es el impacto? Santiago de Chile: Universidad de Chile-Instituto de Asuntos Públicos.

20.

Goldsmith

(2002) Policing weak states: citizen safety and state responsibility. Policing & Society 13(1): 3–21.

21.

González

(2021) Authoritarian Police in democracy. Contested Security in Latin America. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.

22.

Granada

Restrepo

Tobon García

(2009) Neoparamilitarismo en Colombia: una herramienta conceptual para la interpretación de dinámicas recientes del conflicto armado colombiano. In: Restrepo

Aponte

(eds) Guerra y violencias en Colombia: Herramientas e interpretaciones. Bogotá: Pontificia Universidad Javeriana, pp. 467–499.

23.

Herzog

(2001) Militarization and demilitarization processes in the Israeli and American police forces: organizational and social aspects. Policing and Society 11(2): 181–208.

24.

Hill

Berger

(2009) A paramilitary policing juggernaut. Social Justice 1(115): 25–40.

25.

ILEX, Raza & Igualdad and CODHES (2021) Informe de afectaciones a personas afrodescendientes en el marco del paro nacional en Colombia. (Actualización de 06 de junio–julio 08/2021). Bogotá: ILEX Acción Jurídica.

26.

INDEPAZ and Temblores ONG (2021) Cifras de la violencia en el marco del paro nacional 2021. Bogotá: INDEPAZ-Temblores ONG.

27.

Iossa

Selberg

(2022) Socio-legal aspects of labour market segmentation in the agri-food sector in Sweden: spatio-temporal dimensions. European Journal of Migration and Law 24(2): 241–264.

28.

Iturralde

(2008) Emergency penality and authoritarian liberalism. Theoretical Criminology 12(3): 377–397.

29.

Iturralde

(2010) Castigo, liberalismo autoritario y justicia penal de excepción. Bogotá: Siglo del Hombre-Universidad de los Andes.

30.

Koslicki

Willits

(2018) The iron fist in the velvet glove? Testing the militarization/community policing paradox. Police & Science Management 20(2): 143–154.

31.

Kostiwaran

(2015) Valverde’s chronotopes of law: reflections on an agenda for socio-legal stuides. Feminist Legal Studies 23: 353–359.

32.

Kraska

Kappeler

(1997) Militarizing American police: the rise and normalization or paramilitary units. Social Problems 44(1): 1–18.

33.

Otálora

and La Liga Contra el Silencio (2021) “Enciérrenlas y ahóguenlas”: abuso policial en Palmira durante el paro. Mutante ONG, 24 May. Available at: https://www.mutante.org/contenidos/encierrenlas-ahoguenlas-abuso-policial-palmira-paro/

34.

Lutterbeck

(2004) Between police and military: the new security agenda and the rise of gendarmeries. Cooperation and Conflict: Journal of the Nordic International Studies Association 39(1): 45–68.

35.

Müller

(2012) Addressing an ambivalent relationship: policing and the urban poor in Mexico City. Journal of Latin American Studies 44(2): 319–345.

36.

O’Donnell

Tenembaum

(2021) Ministro de Defensa de Colombia vincula vandalismo en las protestas con las FARC y el ELN. CNN, 7 May. Available at: https://cnnespanol.cnn.com/video/colombia-ministro-defensa-molano-aponte-protestas-farc-eln-conecta2/

37.

O’Malley

(1999) Volatile and contradictory punishment. Theoretical Criminology 3(2): 175–196.

38.

Pauschinger

(2020) Working at the edge: police, emotions and space in Rio de Janeiro. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 38(3): 510–527.

39.

Pérez Toro

Vanegas Yepes

Álvarez Martínez

(1997) Estado de derecho y sistema penal: La emergencia permanente de la reacción punitiva en Colombia. Medellín: Dike-Universidad de Antioquia.

40.

Porch

Ramussen

(2007) Demobilization of paramilitaries in Colombia: transformation or transition? Studies in Conflict & Terrorism 8(6): 520–540.

41.

Ruíz Vásquez

(2012) Community police in Colombia: an idle process. Policing & Society 22(1): 43–56.

42.

Samper

(1998) La miseria en Bogotá. Bogotá: Colseguros.

43.

Schultze-Kraft

(2012) La cuestión militar en Colombia: la fuerza pública y los retos de la construcción de paz. In: Rettberg

(ed.) Construcción de paz en Colombia. Bogotá: Universidad de los Andes, pp. 405–433.

44.

Shalhoub-Kevorkian

(2014) Criminality in spaces of death: the Palestinian case study. British Journal of Criminology 54: 38–52.

45.

Simckes

Hajat

Revere

, et al. (2019) A conceptualization of militarization in domestic policing. Police Quarterly 22(4): 511–538.

46.

Tamayo Arboleda

(2021) Del Estado al parque. El gobierno del crimen en las ciudades contemporáneas. Bogotá: Universidad de los Andes-Siglo del Hombre Editores.

47.

Tamayo Arboleda

Ariza

(2022) Building a secure city: urban governance, crime control and segregation in Bogotá. City. Analysis of Urban Change, Theory, Action 26(2–3): 243–260.

48.

Tamayo Arboleda

Orrego Fernández

(2021) La creación del delito y el delincuente en Colombia. Análisis socio-jurídico del decreto 707 de 1927. In: Hernández Jiménez

(ed.) Temas criminológicos latinoamericanos. Teoría, evidencia empírica y ejecución penal. Bogotá: Universidad Javeriana-Tirant lo Blanch, pp. 63–91.

49.

Temblores

ONG

(2022) Reporte sobre los hechos de violencia policial ocurridos durante el 2021. Bogotá: Temblores ONG.

50.

Torrado

(2021) Civiles armados disparan a grupos indígenas y el caos se apodera de Cali. El País, 9 May. Available at: https://elpais.com/internacional/2021-05-10/civiles-armados-disparan-a-grupos-indigenas-y-el-caos-se-apodera-de-cali.html

51.

Ungar

(2013) The rot within: security and corruption in Latin America. Social Research: An International Quarterly 80(4): 1187–1212.

52.

Valverde

(2006) Law and Order: Images, Meaning, Myths. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

53.

Valverde

(2015) Chronotopes of Law: Jurisdiction, Scale and Governance. New York: Routledge.

54.

Weiss T (2011) The blurring border between the police and the military: a debate without foundations. Cooperation and Conflict 46(3): 396–405.

55.

Westmarland

(2008) Policing culture. In: Newburn

(ed.) Handbook of Policing. Portland: Willan Publishing, pp. 253–280.

56.

Wienand

Tremaria

(2017) Paramilitarism in a post-demobilization context? Insights from the Department of Antioquia in Colombia. European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies 103: 25–50.