This article shows how ‘normalized masculinity’ and its effects
are operative but invisible in public discussions of targeted violence against
girls. In school shootings, dating violence and sexual harassment, boys assaulted
girls who rejected them or otherwise caused the boys gender distress. Against this
backdrop, the analysis situates recent school shootings, dating violence and sexual
harassment on a continuum of unrecognized violence against young girls. Through a
media analysis of 13 United States school shootings that took place between 1996 and
2002, it shows how gender played a significant influencing role. It then puts
forward a framework for efforts to prevent violence rooted in damaging masculinity ideologies.
Adler, P.A.
,
S.J. Kless
and
P. Adler
(1992)
‘Socialization to Gender Roles: Popularity among Elementary
School Boys and Girls’
, Sociology of Education65(July):
169-187
.
2.
American Association of University Women (AAUW)
(1993) Hostile Hallways: The AAUW Survey on Sexual Harassment
in America’s Schools.
Washington, DC: AAUW
.
3.
Angel, M.
(1999)
‘Symposium: Abusive Boys Kill Girls Just Like Abusive Men Kill
Women: Explaining the Obvious’
, Temple Political and Civil Rights Law ReviewSpring:
283
.
4.
Arrindell, W.A.
,
A.M. Kolk
,
M.J. Pickergill
and
W.J. Hageman
(1993)
‘Biological Sex, Sex Role Orientation, Masculine Sex Role Stress,
Dissimulation and Self-reported Fears’
, Advances in Behaviour Research and Therapy15:
103-146
.
5.
Artz, S.
(1998) Sex, Power, and the Violent School Girl.
New York: Teachers College Press
.
6.
Artz, S.
and
T. Riecken
(1997)
‘What, So What, Then What? The Gender Gap in School-Based
Violence and Its Implications for Child and Youth Care Practice’
, CYC Forum26(4):
291-303
.
7.
Artz, S.
,
T. Riecken
,
B. MacIntyre
,
E. Lam
and
M. Maczewski
(2000)
‘Theorizing Gender Differences in Receptivity to Violence
Prevention Programs in Schools’
, BC Counselor22(1):
7-36
.
8.
Associated Press
(1999) Profile of Georgia School Gunman. Online via
Proquest, 21 May.
9.
Auster, C.
and
J. Leone
(2001)
‘Late Adolescents’ Perspectives on Marital Rape: The
Impact of Gender and Fraternity/Sorority Membership’
, Adolescence36(141):
141-152
.
10.
Baker, A.
(2002)
‘Police Arrest School Suspect and Detail Security Breach’
, New York Times (Late Edition—Final)19 January:
B1
.
11.
Barash, D.P.
(2002)
‘Evolution, Males, and Violence’
, The Chronicle of Higher Education: The Chronicle Review
(Section 2) 24 May:
B7-B9
.
12.
Barboza, D.
(2000)
‘A Life of Guns, Drugs, and Now, Killing, All at 6’
, New York Times (Late Edition—Final) 2 March:
A1
.
13.
BBC News (2000) ‘Schoolgirl, Six, Shot Dead by
Classmates’, BBC News. Online, 1 March.
14.
Belluck, P.
and
J. Wilgoren
(1999)
‘Caring Parents, No Answers in Columbine Killers’ Pasts’
, New York Times 29 June:
A1
.
15.
Benedict, J.
(1997) Public Heroes, Private Felons: Athletes and Crimes
against Women.
Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press
.
16.
Bernstein, N.
(1996)
‘Behind Some Fraternities’ Walls, Brothers in Crime’
, New York Times 6 May:
A1
.
17.
Blank, J.
(1998)
‘The Kid No One Noticed, Guns Would Get His Classmates’ Attention’
, US News and World Report. Online, 12 October.
18.
Boeringer, S.B.
(1996)
‘Influences of Fraternity Membership, Athletics, and Male Living
Arrangements on Sexual Aggression’
, Violence Against Women2:
134-147
.
19.
Bookwala, J.
,
I.H. Frieze
,
C. Smith
and
K. Ryan
(1992)
‘Predictors of Dating Violence: A Multivariate Analysis’
, Violence and Victims7(4):
297-311
.
20.
Bowman, R.L.
and
H.M. Morgan
(1998)
‘A Comparison of Rates of Verbal and Physical Abuse on Campus by
Gender and Sexual Orientation’
, College Student Journal32(1):
43-52
.
21.
Bragg, R.
(1998)
‘Five Are Killed at School: Boys 11 and 13 Are Held’
, New York Times. Online via Proquest, 25 May.
22.
Brooks, D.
(2004)
‘The Columbine Killers’
, New York Times (Editorial Desk) 24 April:
A17
.
23.
Brownmiller, S.
(1975) Against Our Will: Men, Women and Rape.
New York: Simon & Schuster
.
24.
Butler, J.
(1990) Gender Trouble.
New York: Routledge
.
25.
Callahan, C.J.
(2000)
‘Schools That Have Not Protected and Worked with Gay and Lesbian
Students Have Been Sanctioned by the Courts’
, Education121(2):
313-326
.
26.
Campbell, A.
(1993) Men, Women, Aggression.
New York: Basic Books
.
27.
Carlson, C.N.
(2003)
‘Focus Section: Violence against Women: Invisible Victims:
Holding the Educational System Liable for Teen Dating Violence at School’
, Harvard Women’s Law Journal26:
351
.
28.
580CFRA News Talk Radio (1998) ‘Accused Teen Sniper’s
Girl Dumped Him Because He Was “Trouble”’, 580CFRA
News Talk Radio 29 March.
29.
Chancer, L.
(1998) Reconcilable Differences.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
30.
Chancer, L.
(2004)
Revisiting Domestic Violence in Theory and Practice
. Deviant Behavior.
31.
Cloud, J.
(1998)
‘Of Arms and the Boy: All Kids Battle Demons. Why Did These Five Lose?’
, Time.com. Online, 6 July.
32.
Cloud, J.
(1999)
‘Just a Routine School Shooting’
, Time. Online, 23 May.
33.
Connell, R.W.
(1995) Masculinities.
Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press
.
34.
Crosset, T.W.
,
J. Ptacek
,
M.A. McDonald
and
J. R. Benedict
(1996)
‘Male Student Athletes and Violence against Women’
, Violence Against Women2:
163-179
.
35.
Cullen, D.
(2004)
‘The Depressive and the Psychopath: At Last We Know Why the
Columbine Killers Did It’
, Slate. Online, 20 April. Available at
http://www.slate.msn.com (accessed 10 July 2004).
36.
Daly, M.
and
M. Wilson
(1980)
‘Discriminative Parental Solicitude: A Biological Perspective’
, Journal of Marriage and Family42:
277-288
.
37.
Davis, T.
(2000)
‘Programming for Men to Reduce Sexual Violence’
, New Directions for Student Services90:
79-89
.
38.
Dobash, E.
and
R. Dobash
(eds) (1998) Rethinking Violence against Women.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications
.
39.
Efthim, P.
,
M.E. Kenny
and
J.R. Mahalik
(2001)
‘Gender Role Stress in Relation to Shame, Guilt, and Externalization’
, Journal of Counseling and Development79(4):
430-438
.
40.
Egan, T.
(1998)
‘Oregon Freshman Goes to Court as Number of Deaths Rises to 4’
, New York Times 23 May:
A21
.
41.
Eisler, R.M.
,
J.R. Skidmore
and
C.H. Ward
(1988)
‘Masculine Gender Role Stress: Predictor of Anger, Anxiety, and
Health Risk Behaviors’
, Journal of Personality Assessment52:
133-141
.
42.
Fainaru, Steve
(1998)
‘Cry for Help Went Unheeded’
, Boston Globe 8 November:
A1
.
43.
Faludi, S.
(2000) Stiffed: The Betrayal of the American man.
New York: Harper Perennial
.
44.
Firestone, D.
(1999).
‘Guns and Schools: An Affinity for Weapons, But No Signs of Anger’
, New York Times. Online, 21 May.
45.
Frinter, M.P.
and
L. Rubinson
(1993)
‘Acquaintance Rape: The Influence of Alcohol, Fraternity
Membership, and Sports Team Membership’
, Journal of Sex Education and Therapy19:
272-284
.
46.
Gaines, D.
(1998) Teenage Wasteland.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
47.
Gelles, R.J.
(1998) ‘Family Violence’, in
M. Tonry
(ed.) The Handbook of Crime and Punishment, pp.
178-206.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
48.
Glassner, B.
(1999a) The Culture of Fear.
New York: Basic Books
.
49.
Glassner, B.
(1999b)
‘School Violence: The Fears, the Facts’
, New York Times 13 August:
A27
.
50.
Greenfield, N.
(1999)
‘Killings Spark Discipline Drive’
, The Times Educational Supplement 28 May (4326):
22
.
51.
Hall, S.
(1999)
‘The Bully in the Mirror’
, New York Times Magazine 22 August.
52.
Hartocollis, A.
(2002)
‘Levy Discloses Flaw in Security in Wake of Shootings in School’
, New York Times (Late Edition—Final) 24 January:
B2
.
Hills, S.
(1984) ‘Crime and Deviance on College Campus:
The Privilege of Class’, in
M.D. Schwartz
and
D.O. Friedrichs
(eds) Humanistic Perspectives on Crime and Justice, pp.
60-69.
Hebron, CT: Practitioner Press.
55.
Holtzworth-Munroe, A.
,
G.L. Stuart
and
G. Hutchinson
(1997)
‘Violent versus Nonviolent Husbands: Differences in Attachment
Patterns, Dependency, and Jealousy’
, Journal of Family Psychology < BI > </BI
> 11(3):
314-331
.
56.
Hong, L.
(2000)
‘Toward a Transformed Approach to Prevention: Breaking the Link
between Masculinity and Violence’
, Journal of American College Health48(6):
269-279
.
57.
Howard, D.E.
and
M. Wang
(2003)
‘Risk Profiles of Adolescent Girls Who Were Victims of Dating Violence’
, Adolescence38(Spring):
1-14
.
58.
Huss, M.T.
and
J. Langhinrichsen-Rohling
(2000)
‘Identification of the Psychopathic Batterer: The Clinical,
Legal, and Policy Implications’
, Aggression and Violent Behavior5:
403-422
.
59.
Hutt, M.J.
,
H.L. Iverson
,
H. Bass
and
W.F. Gayton
(1997)
‘Further Validation of the Vengeance Scale’
, Psychological Reports80:
744-746
.
60.
Johnson, C.C.
and
K.A. Johnson
(2000)
‘High-Risk Behavior among Gay Adolescents: Implications for
Treatment and Support’
, Adolescence35(140):
619-637
.
61.
Kimmel, M.
(1990) Men Confront Pornography.
New York: Penguin
.
62.
Kimmel, M.S.
(1996) Manhood in America: A Cultural History.
New York: The Free Press
.
63.
Kimmel, M.
and
M. Mahler
(2003)
‘Adolescent Masculinity, Homophobia, and Violence: Random School
Shootings, 1982-2000’
, American Behavioral Scientist:
1439
.
64.
Kindlon, D.
and
M. Thompson
(1999) Raising Cain: Protecting the Emotional Life of
Boys.
New York: Free Press
.
65.
Klein, J.
(2003) ‘Mass Violence in
Schools’, in
S.L.A. Straussner
and
N.K. Phillips
(eds) Mass Violence and Social Work Practice, pp.
71-86.
Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon
.
66.
Klein, J.
and
L. Chancer
(2000) ‘Masculinity Matters: The Role of Gender
in High-Profile School Violence Cases’, in
S. Spina
(ed.) Smoke and Mirrors: The Hidden Context of Violence in Schools and
Society, pp. 129-162.
New York: Rowman & Littlefield
.
67.
Klein, J.
and
L. Chancer
(2006, forthcoming) ‘Normalized Masculinity: The
Ontology of Violence in Everyday Life’, in
B.A. Arrigo
(ed.) Philosophical Foundations.
Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press
.
68.
Lefkowitz, Bernard
(1997) Our Guys.
New York: Vintage Books
.
69.
Lobel, K.
(ed.) (1986) Naming the Violence: Speaking Out about Lesbian
Battering.
Seattle, WA: The Seal Press
.
70.
MacKinnon, C.A.
(1987) Feminism Unmodified: Discourse on Life and Law.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
71.
Messerschmidt, J.
(2000) Nine Lives: Adolescent Masculinities, the Body, and
Violence.
New York: Westview Press
.
72.
National Research Council and Institute of Medicine (2003) Deadly
Lessons: Understanding Lethal School Violence. Case Studies of School
Violence Committee, Mark H. Moore, Carol V. Petrie, Anthony A. Braga and Brenda L.
McLaughlin, editors. Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education.
Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
73.
Naughton, K.
and
T. Evan
(2000)
‘Did Kayla Have to Die?’
, Newsweek 13 March.
74.
Newman, K.S.
,
C. Fox
,
D. Harding
,
J. Mehta
and
W. Roth
(2004) Rampage: The Social Roots of School Shootings.
New York: Basic Books
.
75.
New York Times (1998)
‘News Summary’
, New York Times 29 March:
A2
.
76.
Olinger, D.
and
M. Robinson
(1999)
‘School Attack Probe Widens, Focus Falls on 3 Associates of Killers’
, Denver Post 12 May:
B01
.
77.
Orenstein, C.
(2002) Little Red Riding Hood Uncloaked.
New York: Basic Books
.
78.
O’Toole, M.
(2000) The School Shooter: A Threat Assessment
Perspective.
Quantico, VA: National Center for the Analysis
of Violent Crime, FBI Academy
.
79.
PBS Video (1999) Frontline: The Killer at Thurston High.
Videotape—Public Television Videocassette Service. 1993-1999 WGBH
Educational Foundation.
80.
Peterman, L.M.
and
C.G. Dixon
(2003)
‘Domestic Violence between Same-Sex Partners: Implications for Counseling’
, Journal of Counseling and Development81(1):
40-47
.
81.
Pleck, J.
(1981) The Myth of Masculinity.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
82.
Pollack, W.
(1998) Real Boys: Rescuing Our Sons from the Myths of
Boyhood.
New York: Random House
.
83.
Popyk, Lisa
(1998a)
‘I Knew It Wouldn’t Be Right’
, Cincinnati Post. Online, 9 November.
84.
Popyk, Lisa
(1998b)
‘Violence Is Seductive to New Breed of Killers’
, Cincinnati Post. Online, 9 November.
85.
Quesada, E.
(1998)
‘Note: Innocent Kiss or Potential Legal Nightmare: Peer Sexual
Harassment and the Standard for School Liability Under Title IX’
, Cornell Law Review83(May):
1014
.
86.
Ranney, F.
(2000)
‘Beyond Foucault: Toward a User-Centered Approach to Sexual
Harassment Policy’
, Technical Communication Quarterly9(1):
9-28
.
87.
Reese, S.
(1997)
‘The Law and Gay-Bashing in Schools’
, Educational Digest62(9) (online).
88.
Rennison, C.M.
(2001) ‘Violence Rates among Intimate Partners
Differ Greatly According to Age’, Bureau of Justice Statistics
Press Release. Online, 28 October. Available at www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/press/ipva99pr.htm
89.
Russell, D.E.H.
(1975) The Politics of Rape.
New York: Stein & Day
.
90.
Schiraldi, V.
(1998)
‘Media Misleading on School Shootings’
, The Progressive 26 May.
91.
Schwartz, M.D.
and
W.S. DeKeseredy
(1997) Sexual Assault on the College Campus: The Role of Male
Peer Support.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications
.
92.
Scully, Elinor
(2001)
‘Boys, Sex, and the Social Landscape: Normality of Harassment and Homophobia’
, Independent School60(2):
36-46
.
93.
Segal, L.
(1990) Slow Motion: Changing Masculinities, Changing
Men.
New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press
.
94.
Smuts, B.
(1992)
‘Male Aggression against Women: An Evolutionary Perspective’
, Human Nature3:
1-44
.
95.
Sommers, J.
(2000)
‘Vengeance Scores among College Students: Examining the Role of
Jealousy and Forgiveness’
, Education121(1):
114-119
.
96.
Stamp, G.H.
and
C. Sabourin
(1995)
‘Accounting for Violence: An Analysis of Male Spousal Abuse Narratives’
, Journal of Applied Communication Research23:
284-307
.
97.
Stein, N.
(1999) Classrooms and Courtrooms: Facing Sexual Harassment in
K- 12 Schools.
New York: Teachers College Press
.
98.
Sunday, S.R.
and
E. Toback
(1985) Violence against Women: A Critique of the Sociobiology
of Rape.
New York: Gordian Press
.
99.
Sweetman, C.
(ed.) (1998) Violence against Women.
Oxford, UK: Oxfam Press
.
100.
Tonso, K.L.
(2002)
‘Reflecting on Columbine High: Ideologies of Privilege in
“Standardized” Schools’
, Educational Studies33(4):
389-403
.
Townsend, M.
and
G. Hinsliff
(2003)
‘Victims of Bullying Strike Back’
, Observer 22 June.
103.
University of Victoria
(1999)
‘Recognitions of Gender Differences Key to Violence Prevention’
, The Ring. Online, 1 June.
104.
US Department of Justice
,
Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention
(1994) Comprehensive Strategy for Serious, Violent, and
Chronic Offenders.
Washington, DC: US Department of Justice
.
105.
US Department of Justice
(1999) National Crime Victimization Survey (NVAA).
Chapter 8. Online. Available at http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/ovc/assist/nvaa99/chap8.htm
106.
Velte, K.
(1998)
‘The Whys? of the Jonesboro Shootings: Gender Bias, the
Overlooked Answer’
, American JuristMay:
1
.
107.
Walklate, S.
(1995) Gender and Crime.
Hemel Hempstead, UK: Harvester Wheat-Sheaf
.
108.
West, R.
(1997) Caring for Justice.
New York: New York University Press
.
109.
Willert, H.J.
(2002)
‘Do Sweat the Small Stuff: Stemming School Violence’
, American Secondary Education30(2):
2-13
.
110.
Yellin, Emily
(1998)
‘Out of Violence, a Survivor and a Scholar’
, New York Times 2 June:
A18
.
