Restorative justice interventions, which focus upon repairing the harm caused by an offence, are consistent with the approach advocated by reintegrative shaming theory. However, some have argued that remorse and empathy play a more important role in restoration, and that a focus upon disapproval and the emotion of shame may be misguided. This article analyses theoretical distinctions between shame and guilt before discussing their role in restorative interventions. It is argued that emotions like empathy, remorse and guilt will spill over into feelings of shame, and that it is the resolution of these emotions that is critical for successful justice interventions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abrams, D., M. Wetherell, S. Cochrane, M.A. Hogg and J.C. Turner (1990) ‘Knowing What to Think by Knowing Who You Are: Self-Categorization and the Nature of Norm Formation, Conformity and Group Polarization’ , British Journal of Social Psychology29(2): 97–119 .
2.
Ahmed, E. (2001) ‘Part III. Shame Management: Regulating Bullying’, in E. Ahmed, N. Harris, J. Braithwaite and V. Braithwaite (eds) Shame Management through Reintegration, pp. 209–311. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press .
3.
Ahmed, E., N. Harris, J. Braithwaite and V. Braithwaite (2001) Shame Management through Reintegration. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press .
4.
Barton, C. (2000) ‘Empowerment and Retribution in Criminal Justice’, in H. Strang and J. Braithwaite (eds) Restorative Justice: Philosophy to Practice, pp. 55–76. Aldershot: Ashgate .
5.
Benedict, R. (1946) The Chrysanthemum and the Sword: Patterns of Japanese Culture. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin .
6.
Bottoms, A.E. (2003) ‘Some Sociological Reflections on Restorative Justice’, in A. von Hirsch, J.V. Roberts, A.E. Bottoms, K. Roach and M. Schiff (eds) Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice. Competing or Reconcilable Paradigms?, pp. 79–113. Oxford: Hart .
7.
Boutellier, H. (2000) Crime and Morality. The Significance of Criminal Justice in Post-Modern Culture. Dordrecht & Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers .
8.
Braithwaite, J. (1989) Crime, Shame and Reintegration. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press .
9.
Braithwaite, J. (2002) Restorative Justice and Responsive Regulation. New York: Oxford University Press .
10.
Braithwaite, J. and V. Braithwaite (2001) ‘Part I. Shame, Shame Management and Regulation’, in E. Ahmed, N. Harris, J. Braithwaite and V. Braithwaite (eds) Shame Management through Reintegration, pp. 1–69. Melbourne: University of Cambridge Press .
11.
Braithwaite, J. and S. Mugford (1994) ‘Conditions of Successful Reintegration Ceremonies: Dealing with Juvenile Offenders’ , British Journal of Criminology34(2): 139–171 .
12.
Crozier, W.R. (1990) ‘Social Psychological Perspectives on Shyness, Embarrassment and Shame’, in W.R. Crozier (ed.) Shyness and Embarrassment: Perspectives from Social Psychology, pp. 19–58. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
13.
Cullen, F.T. (1994) ‘Social Support as an Organizing Concept for Criminology: Presidential Address to the Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences’ , Justice Quarterly11(4): 527–559 .
14.
Daly, K. (2000) ‘Revisiting the Relationship between Retributive and Restorative Justice’, in H. Strang and J. Braithwaite (eds) Restorative Justice: Philosophy to Practice, pp. 33–54. Aldershot: Ashgate .
15.
Daly, K. (2003) ‘Mind the Gap: Restorative Justice in Theory and Practice’, in A. von Hirsch, J.V. Roberts, A.E. Bottoms, K. Roach and M. Schiff (eds) Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice. Competing or Reconcilable Paradigms?, pp. 61–78. Oxford: Hart .
16.
De Haan, W. and I. Loader (2002) ‘On the Emotions of Crime, Punishment and Social Control’ , Theoretical Criminology6(3): 243–254 .
17.
Duff, A. (2002) ‘Restorative Punishment and Punitive Restoration’, in L. Walgrave (ed.) Restorative Justice and the Law, pp. 82–100. Cullompton, UK: Willan Publishing .
18.
Edelmann, R.J. (1987) The Psychology of Embarrassment. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons .
19.
Gibbons, F.X. (1990) ‘The Impact of focus of Attention and Affect on Social Behaviour’, in W.R. Crozier (ed.) Shyness and Embarrassment: Perspectives from Social Psychology, pp. 119–143. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
20.
Grasmick, H.G. and R.J. Bursik (1990) ‘Conscience, Significant Others, and Rational Choice: Extending the Deterrence Model’ , Law and Society Review24(3): 837–861 .
21.
Harr¥e, R. (1990) ‘Embarrassment: A Conceptual Analysis’, in W.R. Crozier (ed.) Shyness and Embarrassment: Perspectives from Social Psychology, pp. 181–204. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
22.
Harris, N. (2001) ‘Part II. Shaming and Shame: Regulating Drink Driving’, in E. Ahmed, N. Harris, J. Braithwaite and V. Braithwaite (eds) Shame Management through Reintegration, pp. 71–207. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press .
23.
Harris, N. (2003) ‘Reassessing the Dimensionality of the Moral Emotions’ , British Journal of Psychology94(4): 457–473 .
24.
Hogg, M.A. and J.C. Turner (1987) ‘Social Identity and Conformity: A Theory of Referent Information Influence’, in W. Doise and S. Moscovici (eds) Current Issues in European Social Psychology, vol. 2, pp. 139–182. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press .
25.
Hoyle, C., R. Young and R. Hill (2002) Proceed with Caution: An Evaluation of the Thames Valley Police Initiative in Restorative Cautioning. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation .
26.
Karstedt, S. (2002) ‘Emotions and Criminal Justice’ , Theoretical Criminology6(3): 299–317 .
27.
Lewis, H.B. (1971) Shame and Guilt in Neurosis. New York: International Universities Press .
28.
Lindsay-Hartz, J. (1984) ‘Contrasting Experiences of Shame and Guilt’ , American Behavioral Scientist27(6): 689–704 .
29.
Mackie, D.M. (1986) ‘Social Identification Effects in Group Polarization’ , Journal of Personality and Social Psychology50(4): 720–728 .
30.
Maruna, S. (2001) Making Good: How Ex-Convicts Reform and Rebuild Their Lives. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association .
31.
Maxwell, G. and A. Morris (1993) Family, Victims and Culture: Youth Justice in New Zealand. Wellington: Social Policy Agency and Institute of Criminology, Victoria University of Wellington .
32.
Maxwell, G. and A. Morris (1999) Reducing Reoffending. Wellington: Institute of Criminology, Victoria University .
33.
Maxwell, G. and A. Morris (2002) ‘The Role of Shame, Guilt, and Remorse in Restorative Justice Processes for Young People’, in E. Weitekamp and H.-J. Kerner (eds) Restorative Justice: Theoretical Foundations, pp. 267–284. Cullompton, UK: Willan Publishing .
34.
Mead, G.H. (1934) Mind, Self and Society(1st edn). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
35.
Mead, M. (1937) Cooperation and Competition among Primitive Peoples. New York: McGraw-Hill .
Moore, D. and L. Forsythe (1995) A New Approach to Juvenile Justice: An Evaluation of Family Conferencing in Wagga Wagga. Wagga Wagga: Juvenile Justice, the Centre for Rural Research .
38.
Morris, A. (2002) ‘Shame, Guilt and Remorse: Experiences from Family Group Conferences in New Zealand’, in I. Weijers and A. Duff (eds) Punishing Juveniles: Principles and Critique, pp. 157–178. Oxford: Hart Publishing .
39.
Morris, A. and G. Maxwell (1993) ‘Juvenile Justice in New Zealand: A New Paradigm’ , Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology26: 72–90 .
40.
Moscovici, S. (1976) Social Influence and Social Change. London: Academic Press .
41.
Nathanson, D.L. (1992) Shame and Pride: Affect, Sex and the Birth of the Self. New York: W.W. Norton & Company .
42.
Nathanson, D.L. (1997) ‘Affect Theory and the Compass of Shame’, in M.R. Lansky (ed.) The Widening Scope of Shame, pp. 339–354. Hillsdale, NJ: The Analytic Press .
43.
Niedenthal, P.M., J.P. Tangney and I. Gavanski (1994) ‘“If Only I Weren’t” versus “If Only I Hadn’t”: Distinguishing Shame and Guilt in Counterfactual Thinking’ , Journal of Personality and Social Psychology67(4): 585–595 .
44.
Retzinger, S.M. and T.J. Scheff (1996) ‘Strategy for Community Conferences: Emotions and Social Bonds’, in B. Galaway and J. Hudson (eds) Restorative Justice: International Perspectives, pp. 315–336. Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press .
45.
Rorty, R. (1989) Contingency, Irony and Solidarity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
46.
Sabini, J. and M. Silver (1997) ‘In Defense of Shame: Shame in the Context of Guilt and Embarrassment’ , Journal for the Theory of Social Behavior27(1): 1–15 .
47.
Sabini, J., B. Garvey and A.L. Hall (2001) ‘Shame and Embarrassment Revisited’ , Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin27(1): 104–117 .
48.
Scheff, T.J. and S.M. Retzinger (1991) Emotions and Violence: Shame and Rage in Destructive Conflicts. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books/D.C. Heath & Company .
49.
Sherman, L. (1993) ‘Defiance, Deterrence and Irrelevance: A Theory of the Criminal Sanction’ , Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency30(4): 445–473 .
50.
Sherman, L. (2003) ‘Reason for Emotion: Reinventing Justice with Theories, Innovations and Research—the American Society of Criminology 2002 Presidential Address’ , Criminology41(1): 1–37 .
51.
Strang, H. (2002) Repair or Revenge: Victims and Restorative Justice. Oxford: Clarendon Press .
52.
Sykes, G. and D. Matza (1957) ‘Techniques of Neutralization: A Theory of Delinquency’ , American Sociological Review22(6): 664–673 .
53.
Tajfel, H. (1972) ‘La Categorisation Sociale’, in S. Moscovichi (ed.) Introduction a la Psychologie Sociale, pp. 272–302. Paris: Larousse.
54.
Tajfel, H. and J.C. Turner (1979) ‘An Integrative Theory of Intergroup Conflict’, in W.G. Austin and S. Worchel (eds) The Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations, pp. 33–48. Monterey: Brooks/Cole .
55.
Tangney, J.P. (1991) ‘Moral Affect: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly’ , Journal of Personality and Social Psychology61(4): 598–607 .
56.
Tangney, J.P., R.S. Miller, L. Flicker and D.H. Barlow (1996) ‘Are Shame, Guilt, and Embarrassment Distinct Emotions?’ , Journal of Personality and Social Psychology70(6): 1256–1269 .
57.
Tangney, J.P., P. Wagner, C. Fletcher and R. Gramzow (1992) ‘Shamed into Anger? The Relation of Shame and Guilt to Anger and Self-Reported Aggression’ , Journal of Personality and Social Psychology62(4): 669–675 .
58.
Taylor, G. (2002) ‘Guilt, Shame and Shaming’, in I. Weijers and A. Duff (eds) Punishing Juveniles: Principle and Critique, pp. 179–192. Oxford: Hart Publishing .
59.
Turner, J.C. (1991) Social Influence. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole Publishing Co.
60.
Turner, J.C. and R.S. Onorato (1999) ‘Social Identity, Personality, and the Self-Concept: A Self-Categorizing Perspective’, in T.R. Tyler (ed.) The Psychology of the Social Self: Applied Social Research, pp. 11–46. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates .
61.
Vanfraechem, I. (2003) Hergo in Vlaanderen. Een Onderzoeksrapport (FGC inFlanders. A Report of Research). Leuven: K.U. Leuven, Onderzoeksgroep Jeugdcriminologie.
62.
Van Stokkom, B. (2002) ‘Moral Emotions in Restorative Justice Conferences: Managing Shame, Designing Empathy’ , Theoretical Criminology6(3): 339–360 .
63.
Walgrave, L. (2003) ‘Imposing Restoration Instead of Inflicting Pain’, in A. von Hirsch, J.V. Roberts, A.E. Bottoms, K. Roach and M. Schiff (eds) Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice: Competing or Reconcilable Paradigms?, pp. 61–78. Oxford: Hart .
64.
Walgrave, L. and I. Aertsen (1996) ‘Reintegrative Shaming and Restorative Justice: Interchangeable, Complementary or Different?’ , European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research4(4): 6785-6785 .
65.
Wallbott, H.G. and K.R. Scherer (1995) ‘Cultural Determinants in Experiencing Shame and Guilt’, in J.P. Tangney and K.W. Fischer (eds) Self Conscious Emotions: The Psychology of Shame, Guilt, Embarrassment, and Pride, pp. 465–487. New York: Guilford Press .
66.
Weber, M. (1949) Methodology of Social Sciences. New York: Free Press .
67.
Weiner, B. (1986) An Attributional Theory of Motivation and Emotion. New York: Springer-Verlag .
68.
Wicker, F.W., G.C. Payne and R.D. Morgan (1983) ‘Participant Descriptions of Guilt and Shame’ , Motivation and Emotion7(1): 25–39 .
69.
Williams, B. (1993) Shame and Necessity. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press .
70.
Zehr, H. (2002) ‘Journey to Belonging’, in E.G.M. Weitekamp and H.-J. Kerner (eds) Restorative Justice: Theoretical Foundations, pp. 21–31. Cullompton, UK: Willan Publishing .
