In his belated riposte to my critique of the `critical consensus' (P.A.J. Waddington, 1991), David Waddington (1998) seeks to defend the conceptual adequacy and methodological integrity of that position, and especially his own `flashpoints' model (D. Waddington et al., 1987, 1989). In this reply, I demonstrate that not only is his defence unconvincing, but my original critique can be further developed. Conceptually, the notion of `precipitating incidents' is inevitably applied ex post facto, but also compresses complex patterns of interaction into a single, arbitrary incident and, furthermore, relies upon an impoverished notion of the crowd. Methodologically, lack of equivocation and hesitancy are no substitute for careful and systematic recording of what occurs. The `critical consensus' remains not only value-ladened, but advocacy. Moreover, it illustrates a characteristic feature of social movements/moral entrepreneurs: the attempt to `frame' events so as to cast claimants as `victims'. Indeed, there seem to be good grounds for regarding the `critical consensus' as simply part of a wider social movement that received political impetus from the riots of the early 1980s.
Armstrong, G.
(1998) Football Hooligans: Knowing the Score. Oxford: Berg.
2.
Becker, H.S.
(1967) `Whose Side Are We On?', Social Problems14: 239-247.
3.
Berk, R.A.
(1972) `The Controversy Surrounding Analyses of Collective Violence: Some Methodological Notes', in J.F. Short and M.E. Wolfgang (eds) Collective Violence, pp. 112-118. Chicago, IL. Aldine-Atherton.
4.
Berk, R.
and H. Aldrich (1972) `Patterns of Vandalism During Civil Disorder As an Indicator of Selection of Targets', American Sociological Review37: 533-547.
5.
Blain, M.
(1989) `Power and Practice in Peace Movement Discourse, in Conflicts and Change', in L. Kriesberg (ed.) Research in Social Movements, vol. 11, pp. 197-218. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
6.
Blumer, H.
(1971) `Social Problems As Collective Behaviour', Social Problems18(winter): 298-306.
7.
Butler, T.
(1985) `Objectives and Accountability', Policing1(3, summer): 174-186.
8.
Butler, T.
(1986) `Purposes and Process', Policing2(2, summer): 160-166.
9.
Cameron, L.
(1969) Report of the Commission on Disturbances in Northern Ireland. Belfast: Government of Northern Ireland.
10.
Cashmore, E.
and E. McLaughlin (1991) `Out of Order?', in E. Cashmore and E. McLaughlin (eds) Out of Order, pp. 10-41. London: Routledge.
11.
Cohen, S.
(1972) Folk Devils and Moral Panics. Oxford: Martin Robertson.
12.
Currie, E.
and J.H. Skolnick (1972) `A Critical Note on Conceptions of Collective Behaviour', in J.F. Short and M.E. Wolfgang (eds) Collective Violence, pp. 61-71. Chicago, IL: Aldine-Atherton.
13.
della Porta, D.
and M. Diani (1999) Social Movements: An Introduction. Oxford: Blackwell.
14.
della Porta, D.
and H. Reiter (eds) (1998) Policing Protest: The Control of Mass Demonstrations in Western Democracies. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
15.
Demuth, C.
(1978) `Sus': A Report on the Vagrancy Act 1824. London: Runnymede Trust.
16.
Dixon, D.
(1997) Law in Policing: Legal Regulation and Police Practices. Clarendon Studies in Criminology. Oxford: Clarendon.
17.
Dynes, R.
and E.L. Quarantelli (1968) `What Looting in Civil Disturbances Really Means', Transaction (May): 9-14.
18.
Eyerman, R.
and A. Jamison (1991) Social Movements. Oxford: Polity Press.
19.
Fogelson, R.M.
(1970) `Violence and Grievances: Reflections of the 1960s Riots', Journal of Social Issues26: 141-163.
20.
Fogelson, R.M.
(1971) Violence As Protest. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
21.
Gamson, W.A.
(1975) The Strategy of Social Protest. Homewood, IL: Dorsey.
22.
Gifford, Lord
(1986) Report of the Independent Inquiry into Disturbances of October 1985 at the Broadwater Farm Estate, Tottenham. London: The Broadwater Farm Inquiry.
23.
Gilroy, P.
(1982) `Police and Thieves', in Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies (ed.) The Empire Fights Back: Race and Racism in 70s Britain, pp. 143-182. London: Hutchinson.
24.
Goldsmith, A.J.
(ed.) (1991) Complaints Against the Police. Oxford: Clarendon.
25.
Gurney, J.N.
and K.J. Tierney (1982) `Relative Deprivation and Social Movements: A Critical Look at Twenty Years of Theory and Research', Sociological Quarterly23(winter): 33-47.
26.
Hall, S.
, C. Critcher, T. Jefferson, J. Clarke and B. Roberts (1978) Policing the Crisis. London: Macmillan.
27.
Hunt, S.A.
, R.D. Benford and D.A. Snow (1994) `Identity Fields, Framing Processes and the Social Construction of Movement Identities', in E. Larana, J. Gusfield and H. Johnston (eds) New Social Movements: From Ideology to Identity, pp. 185-208. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
28.
Jenkins, J.C.
(1983) `Resource Mobilization Theory and the Study of Social Movements', Annual Review of Sociology9: 527-553.
29.
Jenkins, J.C.
(1985) The Politics of Insurgency. New York: Columbia University Press.
30.
Keith, M.
(1991) `Policing a Perplexed Society? No-Go Areas and the Mystification of Police-Black Conflict', in E. Cashmore and E. McLaughlin (eds) Out of Order?, pp. 189-214. London: Routledge.
31.
Keith, M.
(1993) Race, Riots and Policing: Lore and Disorder in a Multi-Racist Society. London: UCL Press.
32.
Kemp, C.
and R. Morgan (1989) `David and Goliath—Using Private Citizens to Monitor a Public Service: Lay Visitors to Police Stations'. Paper presented to the British Criminology Conference, Bristol Polytechnic, July.
33.
Kerner, O.
(1968) The Report of the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
34.
Le Bon, G.
(1895) The Crowd. Revised English translation 1995. New Brunswick, NJ: Viking.
35.
McAdam, D.
(1982) Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
36.
McCarthy, J.D.
and M.N. Zald (1977) `Resource Mobilization and Social Movements: A Partial Theory', American Journal of Sociology82: 1212-1241.
37.
McCone, J.A.
(1965) Violence in the City—An End Or a Beginning? Report by the Governor's Commission on the Los Angeles Riots. Los Angeles, CA: Governor's Commission on the Los Angeles Riots.
38.
McLaughlin, E.
(1994) Community, Policing and Accountability. Aldershot, Hants: Avebury.
39.
McPhail, C.
(1971) `Civil Disorder Participation', American Sociological Review36: 1058-1072.
40.
McPhail, C.
(1991) The Myth of the Madding Crowd. Hawthorne, NY: Aldine de Gruyter.
41.
McPhail, C.
(1994) `The Dark Side of Purpose: Individual and Collective Violence in Temporary Gatherings', Sociological Quarterly35: 1-32.
42.
McPhail, C.
and D. Schweingruber (1997) `Unpacking Protest Events: A Description Bias Analysis of Media Records With Systematic Direct Observations of Collective Action: The 1995 March for Life in Washington, DC', in D. Rucht, R. Koopmans and F. Neidhardt (eds) Acts of Dissent: New Developments in the Study of Protest, pp. 164-195. Berlin: Sigma.
43.
Marx, G.T.
(1974) `Thoughts on a Neglected Category of Social Movement Participant: The Agent Provocateur and the Informant', American Journal of Sociology80(2): 402-442.
44.
Mason, D.T.
(1984) `Individual Participation in Collective Racial Violence: A Rational Choice Synthesis', American Political Science Review78: 1040-1056.
45.
Melucci, A.
(1989) Nomads of the Present: Social Movements and Individual Needs in Contemporary Society. London: Hutchinson Radius.
46.
Metcalfe, J.
(1991) `Public Order Debriefing: Trafalgar Square Riot', unpublished. London: Metropolitan Police.
47.
Morgan, R.
(1987) `The Local Determinants of Policing Policy', in P. Willmott (ed.) Policing and the Community, pp. 29-53. London: Policy Studies Institute.
48.
Morgan, R.
(1989) `Police Accountability: Current Developments and Future Prospects', in M. Weatheritt (ed.) Police Research: Some Future Prospects, pp. 169-184. Aldershot: Avebury.
49.
Morgan, R.
and C. Maggs (1985) `Setting the PACE: Police Community Consultation Arrangements in England and Wales', Bath Social Policy Papers, No. 4. Bath: Centre for the Analysis of Social Policy, School of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Bath.
50.
Quarantelli, E.L.
and R. Dynes (1968) `Looting in Civil Disorder: An Index of Social Change', in L.H. Masotti and D.R. Bowen (eds) Civil Violence in the Urban Community, pp. 131-141. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
51.
Reicher, S.D.
(1984) `The St Paul's Riot: An Explanation of the Limits of Crowd Action in Terms of a Social Identity Model', European Journal of Social Psychology14: 1-21.
52.
Richards, M.D.
(1986) Public Disorder in Tottenham, 6th October 1985. London: Metropolitan Police.
53.
Rock, P.
(1981) `Rioting', London Review of Books (17 September): 3-4.
54.
Scarman, Lord
(1981) The Brixton Disorders 10-12 April 1981: Report of an Inquiry by the Rt. Hon. The Lord Scarman, OBE. Cmnd 8427 London: HMSO.
55.
Scott, A.
(1990) Ideology and the New Social Movements. London: Unwin Hyman.
56.
Skolnick, J.H.
(1969) The Politics of Protest: A Task Force Report to the National Commission on the Causes and Prevention of Violence. New York: Simon & Schuster.
57.
Smelser, N.J.
(1972) `Two Critics in Search of a Bias: A Response to Currie and Skolnick', in J.F. Short and M.E. Wolfgang (eds) Collective Violence, pp. 73-81. Chicago, IL: Aldine-Atherton.
58.
Snow, D.A.
and R.D. Benford (1988) `Ideology, Frame Resonance and Participant Mobilization', International Social Movement Research1: 197-217.
59.
Snow, D.A.
and R.D. Benford (1992) `Master Frames and Cycles of Protest', in A.D. Morris and C.M. Mueller (eds) Frontiers in Social Movement Theory, pp. 133-155. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
60.
Snow, D.A.
, E. Burke, S.K. Worden and R.D. Benford (1986) `Frame Alignment Processes, Micromobilization, and Movement Participation', American Sociological Review51: 464-481.
61.
Solomos, J.
(1988) Black Youth, Racism and the State: The Politics of Ideology and Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
62.
Solomos, J.
(1993) `Constructions of Black Criminality: Racialisation and Criminalisation in Perspective', in D. Cook and B. Hudson (eds) Racism and Criminology, pp. 118-135. London: Sage.
63.
Spilerman, S.
(1970) `The Causes of Racial Disturbances: A Comparison of Alternative Explanations', American Sociological Review35: 627-649.
64.
Spilerman, S.
(1971) `The Causes of Racial Disturbances: Tests of an Explanation', American Sociological Review36: 427-442.
65.
Spilerman, S.
(1976) `Structural Characteristics of Cities and the Severity of Racial Disorders', American Sociological Review41: 771-793.
66.
Taylor, S.
(1984) `The Scarman Report and Explanations of Riots', in J. Benyon (ed.) Scarman and After, pp. 20-35. London: Pergamon.
67.
Tilly, C.
(1981) `Introduction', in L. Tilly and C. Tilly (eds) Class Conflict and Collective Action, pp. 13-25. Beverly Hill, CA: Sage.
68.
Turner, R.H.
(1969) `The Public Perception of Protest', American Sociological Review32: 815-831.
69.
Waddington, D.
(1992) Contemporary Issues in Public Disorder. London: Routledge.
70.
Waddington, D.
(1998) `Waddington Versus Waddington: Public Order Theory on Trial', Theoretical Criminology2(3): 373-394.
71.
Waddington, D.
, K. Jones and C. Critcher (1987) `Flashpoints of Public Disorder', in G. Gaskell and R. Benewick (eds) The Crowd in Contemporary Britain, pp. 155-199. London: Sage.
72.
Waddington, D.
, K. Jones and C. Critcher (1989) Flashpoints: Studies in Public Disorder. London: Routledge.
Walsh, E.J.
(1988) Democracy in the Shadows: Citizen Mobilization in the Wake of the Accident at Three Mile Island. Westport, CT: Greenwood.
81.
Widgery, R.H., Lord
(1972) The Report of the Tribunal Appointed to Inquire into the Events on Sunday 30th January. HoC: 220. Session 1971-2. London: House of Commons.
82.
Wright, J.D.
and P.H. Rossi (1986) Armed and Considered Dangerous: A Survey of Felons and their Firearms. London: Aldine.
83.
Wright, J.D.
, P.H. Rossi and K. Daly (1983) Under the Gun: Weapons, Crime, and Violence in America. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
