Executive functioning differences between adults with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and autistic spectrum disorder in initiation,planning and strategy formation
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online May, 2009
Executive functioning differences between adults with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and autistic spectrum disorder in initiation,planning and strategy formation
Executive functioning deficits characterize the neuropsychological profiles of the childhood neurodevelopmental disorders of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and autistic spectrum disorder (ASD). This study sought to determine whether similar impairments exist in adults with ADHD (N = 53) and ASD (N = 45) in comparison with a healthy control group (N = 31), whether the two disorders can be distinguished on the basis of their executive functioning features, and whether these impairments are related to symptom severity. Both clinical groups were found to exhibit executive functioning deficits. The ADHD group had difficulty withholding a response, with relative preservation of initiation and planning abilities. In contrast, the ASD group exhibited significant impairments in initiation, planning and strategy formation. The specific executive functioning deficits were related to severity of response inhibition impairments in ADHD and stereotyped, repetitive behaviours in ASD. These findings suggest the pattern of executive functioning deficits follows a consistent trajectory into adulthood.
Ambery, F.Z., Russell, A.J., Perry, K., Morris, R. & Murphy, D.G.M. (2006) `Neuropsychological Functioning in Adults with Asperger Syndrome', Autism10 (6): 551-64.
2.
Baddeley, A., Emslie, H. & Nimmo-Smith, I. (1994) Doors and People. Bury St Edmunds: Thames Valley Test Company.
3.
Barkley, R.A. (1997) `Behavioral Inhibition, Sustained Attention, and Executive Functions: Constructing a Unifying Theory of ADHD', Psychological Bulletin121; 65-94.
4.
Barkley, R.A. (1998) Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: A Handbook for Diagnosis and Treatment. New York: Guilford.
5.
Bennetto, L., Pennington, B.F. & Rogers, S.J. (1996) `Intact and Impaired Memory Functions in Autism' , Child Development67 (4): 1816-35.
6.
Billstedt, E., Gillberg, I.C. & Gillberg, C. (2005) `Autism after Adolescence: Population-Based 13-22-Year Follow-Up Study of 120 Individuals with Autism Diagnosed in Childhood', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders35: 351-60.
7.
Boonstra, A.M., Oosterlaan, J. & Buitelaar, J.K. (2005) `Executive Functioning in Adult ADHD: A Meta-Analytic Review', Psychological Medicine35: 1097-108.
8.
Bradshaw, J.L. & Sheppard, D.M. (2000) `The Neurodevelopmental Frontostriatal Disorders: Evolutionary Adaptiveness and Anomalous Lateralization' , Brain and Language73: 297-320.
9.
Brassett-Grundy, A. & Butler, N. (2004) `Prevalence and Adult Outcomes of Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder'. Bedford Group for Lifecourse and Statistical Studies, Institute of Education, University of London.
10.
Bush, G., Frazier, J.A., Rauch, S.L., Seidman, L.J., Whalen, P.J., Jenike, M.A., Rosen, B.R. & Biederman, J. (1999) `Anterior Cingulate Cortex Dysfunction in Attention-Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder Revealed by fMRI and the Counting Stroop', Biological Psychiatry45: 1542-52.
11.
Cairnes, E. & Cammock, T. (1978) `Development of a More Reliable Version of the Matching Familiar Figures Test', Developmental Psychology14: 555-60.
12.
Carper, R.A. & Courchesne, E. (2005) `Localized Enlargement of the Frontal Cortex in Early Autism', Biological Psychiatry57 (2): 126-33.
Corbett, B.A. & Constantine, LJ (2006) `Autism and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: Assessing Attention and Response Control with the Integrated Visual and Auditory Continuous Performance Test', Child Neuropsychology12: 335-48.
15.
Craik, F.I.M. & Bialystok, E. (2006) `Cognition through the Lifespan: Mechanisms of Change', Trends in Cognitive Sciences10: 131-8.
16.
Filipek, P.A., Semrud-Clikeman, M., Steingard, R.J., Renshaw, P.F., Kennedy, D.N. & Biederman, J. (1997) `Volumetric MRI Analysis Comparing Subjects Having Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder with Normal Controls', Neurology48: 589-601.
17.
Geurts, H.M., Verte, S., Oosterlaan, J., Roeyers, H. & Sergeant, J.A. (2004) `How Specific Are Executive Functioning Deficits in Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and Autism?' , Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry45 (4): 836-54.
18.
Goldberg, M.C., Mostofsky, S.H., Cutting, L.E., Mahone, E.M., Astor, B.C., Denckla, M.B. & Landa, R.J. (2005) `Subtle Executive Impairment in Children with Autism and Children with ADHD', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders35 (3): 279-93.
19.
Goldstein, S. & Schwebach, A.J. (2004) `The Comorbidity of Pervasive Developmental Disorder and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: Results of a Retrospective Chart Review', Journal of Autism and DevelopmentalDisorders34: 329-39.
20.
Greenhill, L.L., Pliszca, S. & Dulcan, M.K. (2002) `Practice Parameter for the Use of Stimulant Medications in the Treatment of Children, Adolescents, and Adults', Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry41 (2 suppl.): 26S-49S.
21.
Grodzinsky, G.M. & Diamond, R. (1992) `Frontal Lobe Functioning in Boys with Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder', Developmental Neuropsychology8 (4): 427-45.
22.
Happé, F., Booth, R., Charlton, R. & Hughes, C. (2006) `Executive Function Deficits in Autism Spectrum Disorders and Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder: Examining Profiles across Domains and Ages', Brain and Cognition61: 25-39.
23.
Harris, E.L., Schuerholz, L.J., Singer, H.S., Reader, M.J., Brown, J.E., Cox, C., Mohr, J., Chase, C.A. & Denckla, M.B. (1995) `Executive Function in Children with Tourette Syndrome and/or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder', Journal of International Neuropsychological Society1 (6): 511-16.
24.
Heilman, K.M., Voeller, K.K.S. & Nadeau, S.E. (1991) `A Possible Pathophysiological Substrate of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder', Journal of Child Neurology6: 74-9.
25.
Hervey, A.S., Epstein, J.N. & Curry, J.F. (2004) `Neuropsychology of Adults with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder: A Meta-Analytic Review', Neuropsychology18 (3): 485-503.
26.
Hill, D.E., Yeo, R.A., Campbell, R.A., Hart, B., Vigil, J. & Brooks, W. (2003) `MRI Correlates of ADHD in Children', Neuropsychology17: 496-506.
27.
Hill, E. (2004) `Executive Dysfunction in Autism', Trends in Cognitive Sciences8 (1): 26-31.
28.
Houghton, S., Douglas, G., West, J., Whiting, K., Wall, M., Lansford, S., Powell, L. & Carroll, A. (1999) `Differential Patterns of Executive Function in Children with Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder According to Gender and Subtype', Journal of Child Neurology14: 801-5.
29.
Howlin, P. (2003) `Outcome in High-Functioning Adults with Autism with and without Early Language Delays: Implications for the Differentiation between Autism and Asperger Syndrome', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders33 (1): 3-13.
30.
Johnson, K.A., Robertson, I.H., Kelly, S.P., Silk, T.J., Barry, E., Daibhis, A., Watchorn, A., Keavey, M., Fitzgerald, M., Gallagher, L., Gill, M. & Bellgrove, M.A. (2007) `Dissociation of Performance of Children with ADHD and High-Functioning Autism on a Task of Sustained Attention' , Neuropsychologia45: 2234-45.
31.
Just, M.A., Cherkassky, V.L., Keller, T.A. & Minshew, N.J. (2004) `Cortical Activation and Synchronization during Sentence Comprehension in High-Functioning Autism: Evidence of Underconnectivity' , Brain127: 1811-21.
32.
Kemper, T.L. & Bauman, M.L. (1998) `Neuropathology of Infantile Autism', Journal of Neuropathology and Experimental Neurology57: 645-52.
33.
Klin, A., Sparrow, S.S., Marans, W.D., Carter, A. & Volkmar, F.R. (2000) `Assessment Issues in Children and Adolescents with Asperger Syndrome', in A. Klin, F.R. Volkmar & S.S. Sparrow (eds) Asperger Syndrome, pp. 309-39. New York: Guilford.
34.
Klorman, R., Hazel-Fernandez, L.A., Shaywitz, S.L., Fletcher, J.M., Marchione, K.E., Holahan, J.M., Stuebing, K.K., Brumaghim, J.T. & Shaywitz, B.A. (1999) `Executive Functioning Deficits in Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder Are Independent of Oppositional Defiant or Reading Disorder', Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry38: 1148-55.
35.
Lockwood, K.A., Marcotte, A.C. & Stern, C. (2001) `Differentiation of Attention-Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder Subtypes: Application of a Neuropsychological Model of Attention' , Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology23 (3): 317-30.
36.
Lopez, B.R., Lincoln, A.J., Ozonoff, S. & Lai, Z. (2005) `Examining the Relationship between Executive Functions and Restricted, Repetitive Symptoms of Autistic Disorder', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders35 (4): 445-60.
37.
Lord, C., Rutter, M. & LeCouteur, A. (1994) `Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised: A Revised Version of a Diagnostic Interview for Caregivers of Individuals with Possible Pervasive Developmental Disorders', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders24 (5): 659-85.
38.
Lou, H.C., Henriksen, L., Bruhn, P., Borner, H. & Nielsen, J.B. (1989) `Striatal Dysfunction in Attention Deficit and Hyperkinetic Disorder', Archives of Neurology46 (1): 48-52.
39.
Luna, B., Minshew, N.H., Garver, K.E., Lazar, N.A., Thulborn, K.R. & Eddy, W.F. (2002) `Neocortical System Abnormalities in Autism: An fMRI Study of Spatial Working Memory', Neurology59: 834-40.
40.
McAlonan, G.M., Cheung, V., Cheung, C., Chua, S.E., Murphy, D.G., Suckling, J., Tai, K.S., Yip, L.K., Leung, P. & Ho, T.P. (2005) `Mapping the Brain in Autism: A Voxel-Based MRI Study of Volumetric Differences and Intercorrelations in Autism', Brain128: 268-76.
41.
Minshew, N.J., Muenz, L.R., Goldstein, G. & Payton, J.B. (1992) `Neuropsychological Functioning in Nonmentally Retarded Autistic Individuals', Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology14: 749-61.
42.
Minshew, N.J., Goldstein, G. & Siegel, D.J. (1995) `Speech and Language in High-Functioning Autistic Individuals', Neuropsychology9: 255-61.
43.
Mostofsky, S.H., Cooper, K.L., Kates, W.R., Denckla, M.B. & Kaufmann, W.E. (2002) `Smaller Prefrontal and Premotor Volumes in Boys with ADHD', Biological Psychiatry52: 785-94.
44.
Murphy, D.G.M., Critchley, H.D., Schmitz, N., McAlonan, G., Van Amelsvoort, T., Robertson, D., Daly, E., Rowe, A., Russell, A., Simmons, A., Murphy, K. & Howlin, P. (2002) `Asperger Syndrome: A 1H Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy Study of Brain', Archives of General Psychiatry59 (10): 885-91.
45.
Nyden, A., Gillberg, C., Hjelmquist, E. & Heiman, M. (1999) `Executive Function/ Attention Deficits in Boys with Asperger Syndrome, Attention Disorder and Reading/Writing Disorder', Autism3: 213-28.
46.
Oosterlaan, J. & Sergeant, J.A. (1998) `Response Inhibition and Response Re-Engagement in Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, Disruptive, Anxious and Normal Children', Behavioural Brain Research94: 33-43.
47.
Ozonoff, S. (1997) `Components of Executive Function in Autism and Other Disorders', in J. Russell (ed.) Autism as an Executive Disorder, pp. 179-211. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
48.
Ozonoff, S. & Jensen, J. (1999) `Specific Executive Function Profiles in Three Neurodevelopmental Disorders', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders29: 171-7.
49.
Ozonoff, S. & McEvoy, R.E. (1994) `A Longitudinal Study of Executive Function and Theory of Mind Development in Autism', Developmental Psychopathology6: 415-31.
Ridley, R.M. (1994) `The Psychology of Perserverative and Stereotyped Behaviour', Progress in Neurobiology, 44: 221-31.
52.
Rinehart, N.J., Bradshaw, J.L., Moss, S.A., Brereton, A.V. & Tonge, B.J. (2001) `A Deficit in Shifting Attention Present in High-Functioning Autism But Not Asperger's Disorder', Autism5 (1): 67-80.
53.
Rubia, K., Overmeyer, S., Taylor, E., Brammer, M., Williams, S.C.R., Simmons, A., Andrew, C. & Bullmore, E.T. (1999) `Hypofrontality in Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder during Higher Order Motor Control: A Study with fMRI', American Journal of Psychiatry156 (6): 891-6.
54.
Rubia, K., Smith, A., Brammer, M. & Taylor, E. (2003) `Right Inferior Prefrontal Cortex Mediates Response Inhibition While Mesial Prefrontal Cortex Is Responsible for Error Detection' , NeuroImage20: 351-8.
55.
Schachar, R., Mota, V.L., Logan, G.D., Tannock, R. & Klim, P. (2000) `Confirmation of an Inhibitory Control Deficit in Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder', Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology28: 227-35.
56.
Schmitz, N., Rubia, K., Daly, E., Smith, A., Williams, S. & Murphy, D.G.M. (2006) `Neural Correlates of Executive Function in Autistic Spectrum Disorders', Biological Psychiatry59: 7-16.
57.
Shallice, T. & Burgess, P.W. (1991) `Higher-Order Cognitive Impairments and Frontal Lobe Lesions in Man', in H.S. Levin, H.M. Eisenberg & A.L. Benton (eds) Frontal Lobe Function and Dysfunction, pp. 125-38. New York: Oxford University Press.
58.
Shaw, P., Lerch, J., Greenstein, D., Sharp, W., Clasen, L., Evans, A., Giedd, J., Castellanos, X. & Rapoport, J. (2006) `Longitudinal Mapping of Cortical Thickness and Clinical Outcome in Children and Adolescents with Attention-Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder', Archives of General Psychiatry63: 540-9.
59.
Sinzig, J., Morsch, D., Bruning, N., Schmidt, M.H. & Lehmkuhl, G. (2008) `Inhibition, Flexibility, Working Memory and Planning in Autism Spectrum Disorders with and without Comorbid ADHD Symptoms', Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Mental Health epub ahead of print.
60.
Sowell, E.R., Thompson, P.M., Holmes, C.J., Jernigan, T.L. & Toga, A.W. (1999) `In vivo Evidence for Post-Adolescent Brain Maturation in Frontal and Striatal Regions', Nature Neuroscience2: 859-61.
61.
Strauss, E., Sherman, E.M.S. & Spreen, O. (2006) A Compendium of Neuropsychological Tests: Administration, Norms, and Commentary. New York: Oxford University Press.
62.
Stuss, D.T. & Benson, D.F. (1983) `Frontal Lobe Lesions and Behavior', in Andrew Kertesz (ed.) Localization in Neuropsychology , pp. 429-54. New York: Academic.
63.
Tucha, O., Smely, C., Preier, M. & Lange, K.W. (2000) `Cognitive Deficits before Treatment among Patients with Brain Tumors', Neurosurgery47: 324-34.
64.
Turner, M. (1999) `Annotation. Repetitive Behaviour in Autism: A Review of Psychological Research', Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry40 (6): 839-49.
65.
Wechsler, D. (1997) Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-III. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation.
66.
Willcutt, E.G., Pennington, B.F. & DeFries, J.C. (2000) `Twin Study of the Etiology of Comorbidity between Reading Disability and Attentional Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder', American Journal of Medical Genetics (Neuropsychiatric Genetics)96: 293-301.
67.
Willcutt, E.G., Doyle, A.E., Nigg, J.T., Faraone, S.V. & Pennington, B.F. (2005) `Validity of the Executive Function Theory of ADHD: A Meta-Analytic Review', Biological Psychiatry57: 1336-46.
68.
Wilson, B.A., Alderman, N., Burgess, P.W., Emslie, H. & Evans, J.J. (1996) Behavioural Assessment of the Dysexecutive Syndrome (BADS). Bury St Edmunds: Thames Valley Test Company.
69.
Young, S., Channon, S. & Toone, B.K. (2000) `Neuropsychological Assessment of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder in Adulthood', Clinical Neuropsychological Assessment1 (4): 283-94.
70.
Young, S., Bramham, J., Tyson, C. & Morris, R. (2006) `Inhibitory Dysfunction on the Stroop in Adults Diagnosed with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder', Personality and Individual Differences41 (8): 1377-84.
71.
Young, S., Morris, R.G., Toone, B.K. & Tyson, C. (2007) `Planning Ability in Adults Diagnosed with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder: A Deficit in Planning Ability', Neuropsychology21 (5): 581-89.
72.
Zametkin, A.J., Nordahl, T.E., Gross, M., King, A.C., Semple, W.E., Rumsey, J., Hamburger, S. & Cohen, R.M. (1990) `Cerebral Glucose Metabolism in Adults with Hyperactivity of Childhood Onset', New England Journal of Medicine323 (20): 1361-6.
