The purpose of this literature review is to consider key themes from empirical research relating to the knowledge and compliance of universal precautions amongst healthcare practitioners. Utilising international studies, strategies to improve universal precautions are analysed. The review identifies areas of limited knowledge, synthesises existing research and suggests aspects of universal precautions that need to be studied further.
A literature search of studies listed in the Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL) database was conducted from 1990–2003, using a number of key words. Review, analysis and synthesis of selected studies were performed.
The findings of this review showed that universal precautions are considered an effective means of protecting patients and staff and controlling infection. The consensus from this body of evidence is that, globally, knowledge of universal precautions is inadequate and compliance low. Studies from many countries have shown that specific intervention strategies, such as education, are influential in improving knowledge and compliance.
This review concludes that it is imperative that future research examines how the attitudes and beliefs of practitioners can be influenced and changed to reenforce adherence to universal precautions within the clinical practice setting. There remains a lack of evidence on the long-term benefits of practice interventions to improve compliance, and what specific barriers are influential in affecting how healthcare practitioners adopt universal precautions more effectively in their practice.
Arenas, J.M.D. , Sanchez-paya, J. , Gonzales, C. , Rivera, F. , Antolin, A. , Arenas, J.D. (1999) Audit on the degree of application of universal precautions in a haemodyalisis unit . Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation14:4, 1001–1003 .
2.
Barrett, S.P. (2002) Infection control in Britain . Journal of Infection Control50: 106–109 .
3.
Beekmann, S.E , Vaughn, T.E. , McCoy, K.D. , Ferguson, K.J. , Torner, J.C. , Woolson, R.F. , Doebbeling, B.N. (2001) Hospital blood-borne pathogens programs: program characteristics and blood and body fluid exposure rates . Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology22: 2, 73–82 .
4.
Bischoff, W.E. , Reynolds, T.M. , Sessler, C.N. , Edmond, M.B. , Wenzel, R.P. (2000) Handwashing compliance by health care workers: the impact of introducing an accessible, alcohol-based hand antiseptic . Archives of Internal Medicine160: 1017–1021 .
5.
Blake, S.M. , Windsor, R.A. , Lohrmann, D.K. , Gay, N. , Ledsky, R. , Richman, A. , Jones, S.B. , Banspach, S.W. (1999) Factors associated with occupational exposure and complication with universal precaution in an urban school district . Health Education and Behaviour26: 5, 734–750 .
6.
Bott, J. (1999) HIV risk reduction and the use of universal precautions . British Journal of Midwifery7:11, 671–675 .
7.
Brooks, A.J. , Phipson, M. , Potgieter, A. , Koertzen, H. , Boffard, K.D. (1999) Education of the trauma team: video evaluation of the compliance with universal barrier precautions in resuscitation . European Journal of Surgery165:12, 1125–1128 .
8.
Centres for Disease Control (1987) Recommendations for the prevention of HIV transmission in healthcare settings . Morbidity and Mortality Report36: 1s–18s .
9.
Centres for Disease Control (1996) Recommendations for isolation precautions in hospitals. (Part II). Hospital Infection Control Practices Advisory Committee , American Journal of Infection Control24: 32–52 .
10.
Chan, R. , Molassiotis, A. , Chan, E. , Chan, V. , Ho, B. , Lai, P. , Shit, F. , Yiu, I. (2002) Nurses' knowledge of and compliance with universal precautions in an acute care hospital . International Journal of Nursing Studies39: 157–163 .
11.
Curran, E. (2001) Reducing the risk of health care acquired infection . Nursing Standard16:1, 45–52 .
12.
Danchaivijitr, S. , Tangtrakool, T. , Chokloikaew, S. , Thamlikitkul, V. (1997) Universal precautions: cost for protective equipment . American Journal of Infection Control25:1, 44–50 .
13.
DeJoy, D.M. , Searcy, C.A. , Murphy, L.R. , Gershon, R.R. (2000) Behavioural– diagnostic analysis of compliance with universal precautions among nurses . Journal of Occupational Health Psychology5:1, 127–141 .
14.
Department of Health (1998) Guidance for Clinical Healthcare Workers: Protection Against Infection with Bloodborne Viruses. Recommendations of the Expert Advisory Group on Aids and the Advisory Group on Hepatitis. LondonDepartment of Health .
15.
Diekema, D.J. , Schuldt, S.S. , Albanese, M.A. , Doebbeling, B.N. (1995) Universal precautions training in preclinical students: impact on knowledge, attitudes, and compliance . Preventative Medicine24:6, 580–585 .
16.
DiGiacomo, C.J. , Hoff, W.S. , Rotondo, M.F. , Martin, K. , Kauder, D.R. , Anderson, H.L. , Phillips, G.R. , Schwab, C.W. (1997) Barrier precautions in trauma resuscitation: real time analysis utilising videotape review . American Journal of Emergency Medicine15:1, 34–39 .
17.
Dyke, M. (2002) Hepatitis C in peri-operative practice . British Journal of Perioperative Practice12:1, 18–23 .
18.
Evanoff, B. , Kim, L. , Mutha, S. , Jeffe, D. , Haase, C. , Andreck, D. , Fraser, V. (1999) Compliance with universal precautions among emergency department personnel caring for trauma patients . Annals of Emergency Medicine33:2, 160–165 .
19.
Gershon, R.R.M. , Karkashian, C. , Felknor, S. (1994) Universal precautions: an update . Heart and Lung23:4, 352–358 .
20.
Gershon, R.R. , Karkasshian, C.D. , Vlahov, D. , Kummer, L. , Kasting, C. , Green-McKenzie, J. , Escamilla-Cejudo, J.A. , Kendig, N. , Swetz, A. , Martin, L. (1999) Compliance with universal precautions in correctional health care facilities . Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine41:3, 181–189 .
21.
Gershon, R.R.M. , Vlahov, D. , Felknor, S. , Velsey, D. , Johnson, P.C. , Delcios, G.L. , Murphy, L.R. (1995) Compliance with universal precautions among workers at three regional hospitals . American Journal of Infection Control23:4, 225–236 .
22.
Giramonti, K.M. , Johnson-Robbins, L.A. , Weatherwax, D.L. , Horgan, M.J. (2000) Re-evaluating practice changes: return to standard precautions after an outbreak of multi-drug resistant Klebsiella oxytoca . Journal of Nursing Care Quality14:2, 57–62 .
23.
Glenn, L.L. , Ramsey, P.W. (1995) Universal Precautions compliance and exposure frequency to patient body fluids in nurses employed by urban and rural health care agencies . The Journal of Rural Health11:3, 158–168 .
24.
Gould, D. (1995) Infection control: a survey to determine knowledge of nurses in a clinical setting . Nursing Standard9:36, 35–38 .
25.
Green-McKenzie, J. (2001) Infection control practices among correctional healthcare workers, effects of management attitudes and availability of protective equipment and engineering controls . Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology22:9, 555–559 .
26.
Harris, A.D. , Samore, M.H. , Nafziger, R. , Dirosario, K. , Roghmann, M.C. , Carmeli, Y. , (2000). A survey on handwashing practices and opinions of healthcare workers . Journal of Hospital Infection45: 318–321 .
Henderson, D.K. (2001) Raising the bar: the need for standardising the use of standard precautions as a primary intervention to prevent occupational exposures to bloodborne pathogens . Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology22:2, 70–72 .
29.
Huang, J. , Jiang, D. , Wang, X. , Liu, Y. , Fennie, K. , Burggess, J. , Williams, A.B. (2002) Changing knowledge, behaviour and practice related to universal precautions among hospital nurses in China . Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing33:5, 217–224 .
30.
Jacobson, W. , Cadwallader, H. (1999) Implementing standard precautions in the operating theatre: the role of the infection control liaison nurse . Australian Infection Control4:1, 7–11 .
31.
Jeffe, D.B. , Mutha, S. , Lynn, K. , Evanoff, B.A. , L‘Ecuyer, P.B. , Fraser, V.J. (1998) Does clinical experience affect medical students’ knowledge, attitudes and compliance with universal precautions?Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology19:10, 767–771 .
32.
Kim, L.E. , Evanoff, B.E. , Parkes, R.L. , Jeffe, D.B. , Mutha, S. , Haase, C. , Fraser, V.J. (1999) Compliance with universal precautions among emergency department personnel: implications for prevention programs . American Journal of Infection Control27:5, 453–455 .
33.
Kim, L.E. , Evanoff, B.E. , Jeffe, D.B. , Mutha, S. , Haase, C. , Freeman, B. , Fraser, V.J. (2001) Improved compliance with universal precautions in the operating room following an educational intervention . Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology22:8, 522–524 .
34.
Knight, V.M. , Bodsworth, N.J. (1998) Perceptions and practice of universal blood and body fluid precautions by registered nurses at a major Sydney teaching hospital . Journal of Advanced Nursing27: 746–751 .
35.
Kretzer, E.K. , Larson, E.L. (1998) Behavioral interventions to improve infection control practices . American Journal of Infection Control26: 245–253 .
36.
Larson, E.L. , Bryan, J.L. , Adler, L.M. , Blane, C. (1997) A multifaceted approach to changing handwashing behavior . American Journal of Infection Control25: 3–10 .
37.
Larson, E. , McGeer, A. , Quraishi, A. , Krenzischek, D. , Parsons, B.J. , Holdford, J. et. al. (1991) Effect of an automated sink on handwashing practices and attitudes in high-risk units . Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology12: 422–428 .
38.
Leliopoulou, C. , Waterman, H. , Chakrabarty, S. (1999) Nurses' failure to appreciate the risks of infection due to needlestick accidents: a hospital based survey . Journal of Hospital Infection42: 53–59 .
39.
Levin, P.F. (1995) Improving compliance with universal precautions. Efffectiveness of interventions . American Association of Occupational Health Nurses Journal43:7, 362–370 .
40.
Lunding, S. , Nielsen, T.L. , Nielsen, J.O. (1998) Poor compliance with universal precautions among Danish physicians . Ugeskrift for Laeger160:12, 1789–1793 .
41.
McCoy, K.D. , Beekmann, S.E. , Ferguson, K.J. , Vaughn, T.E. , Toner, J.C. , Woolson, R.F. , Doebbeling, B.N. (2001) Monitoring adherence to standard precautions . American Journal of Infection Control29:1, 24–31 .
42.
McCulloch, J. (1999) Risk management and infection control . Nursing Standard13:24, 44–46 .
43.
Madan, A.K. , Raafat, A. , Hunt, J.P. , Rentz, D. , Wahle, M.J. , Flint, L.M. (2002) Barrier precautions in trauma: is knowledge enough?Journal of Trauma52:3, 540–543 .
44.
Madan, A.K. , Rentz, D.E. , Wahle, M.J. , Flint, L.M. (2001) Noncompliance of health care workers with universal precautions during trauma resuscitations . Southern Medical Journal94:3, 277–280 .
45.
Michalsen, A. , Delclos, G.L.Felknor, S.A. (1997) Compliance with universal precautions among physicians . J. Occup. Environ. Med.39:2, 130–137 .
46.
Moore, S. , Goodwin, H. , Grossberg, R. , Tltzis, P. (1998) Compliance with universal precautions among paediatric residents . Arch. Pediatr. Adolesc. Med.152:6, 554–557 .
47.
Mukti, A.G. , Treloar, C. , Suprawimbarti, A.A.H. , D‘Este, K. , Higginbotham, N. , Heller, R. (2000) A universal precautions education intervention for health workers in Sarjito and PKU hospital Indonesia . Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical. Medicine and Public Health31:20, 405–411 .
48.
Naikoba, S. , Hayward, A. (2001) The effectiveness of interventions aimed at increasing handwashing in health care workers—a systematic review . Journal of Hospital Infection47:3, 173–180 .
49.
Nelsing, S. , Neilsen, T.H. , Nielsen, J.O. (1997) Non-compliance with universal precautions and the associated risk of muco-cutaneous blood exposure among Danish physicians . Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology18:10, 692–698 .
50.
O‘Boyle, C.A. , Hemly, S.J. , Larson, E. (2001) Understanding adherence to hand hygiene recommendations: the theory of planned behaviour . American Journal of Infection Control29:6, 352–360 .
51.
O‘Rourke, N. , Bennett, M. , Porter, J. , Gallagher, D.J. , Shorten, G. (2000) Universal precautions do Irish anaesthetists comply?Irish Journal of Medical Science169:3, 211–214 .
52.
Pittet, D. (2000) Improving compliance with hand hygiene in hospitals . Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology21: 381–386 .
53.
Pittet, D. , Hugonnet, S. , Harbarth, S. , Mourouga, P. , Sauvan, V. , Touveneau, S. et al. (2000) Effectiveness of a hospital-wide programme to improve compliance with hand hygiene . Lancet356: 1307–1312 .
54.
Pittet, D. (2001) Improving adherence to hand hygiene practice: a multidisciplinary approach . Emerging Infectious Disease7:2, 234–240 .
55.
Rabaud, C. , Zanea, A. , Mur, J.M. , Blech, M.F. , Dazy, D. , May, T. (2000) Occupational exposure to blood: search for a relation between personality and behaviour . Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology21: 564–574 .
56.
Richman, G. , Dorsey, A. , Stayer, S. , Schwartz, R. (2000) Compliance with standard precautions among paediatric anaesthetic providers . Internet Journal of Advanced Nursing Practice4:1, 10-10 .
57.
Roberts, C. (2000) Universal Precautions: improving the knowledge of trained nurses . British Journal of Nursing9:1, 43–47 .
58.
Roup, B.J. (1997) Factors associated with compliance of critical care nurses with universal precaution: a pilot study . American Journal of Critical Care6:3, 218–224 .
59.
Sharbaugh, R.J. (1999) The risk of occupational exposure and infection with infectious disease . Nursing Clinics of North America34:2, 493–506 .
60.
Steele, A. , Melby, V. (1995) Nurses' knowledge and beliefs about AIDS: comparing nurses in community and hospital settings . Journal of Advanced Nursing22: 979–887 .
61.
Tait, A.R. , Voepel-Lewis, T. , Tuttle, D.B. , Malviya, S. (2000) Compliance with standard guidelines for the occupational transmission of bloodborne and airborne pathogens: a survey of post anaesthesia nursing practice . Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing31:1, 38–44 .
62.
Talan, D. , Barraff, L. (1990) Effects of education on the use of universal precautions in a university hospital emergency department . Annals of Emergency Medicine19: 1322–1326 .
63.
Taylor, M. (1993) Universal precautions in the operating department . British Journal of Theatre Nursing1: 4–7 .
64.
Waddell, C. (1997) Perception of HIV risk and reported compliance with universal precautions: a comparison of Australian dental hygienists and dentists . Journal of Dental Hygiene7:10, 17–21 .
65.
Wang, H. , Fennie, K. , He, G. , Burgess, J. , Williams, A.B. (2003) A training programme for the prevention of occupational exposure to bloodborne pathogens: impact on knowledge, behaviour and incidence of needlestick injuries among student nurses in Changsha, People's Republic of China . Journal of Advanced Nursing41:2, 187–194 .
66.
Wicker, P. (1991) Universal precautions: infection control in a high risk environment . British Journal of Theatre Nursing1:9, 16–18 .
67.
Williams, C.O. , Campbell, S. , Henry, K.Collier, O. (1994) Variables influencing worker compliance with universal precautions in the emergency department . American Journal of Infection Control22: 138–148 .
68.
Willy, M.E. , Dhillon, G. , Loewen, N.L. , Wesley, R.A. , Henderson, D.K. (1990) Adverse exposures and universal precaution practices among a group of highly exposed health professionals . Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology11: 351–356 .
69.
Wilson, J. , Breedon, P. (1990) Universal Precautions . Nursing Times86:37, 67–70 .
70.
Wong, E.S. , Stotka, J.L. , Chinchilli, V.M. , Williams, D.S. , Stuart, C.G. , Markoitzm S.M. (1991) Are universal precautions effective in reducing the number of occupational exposures among healthcare workers . Journal of the American Medical Association265: 1123–1128 .
71.
Wright, B.J. , Turner, J.G. , Daffin, P. (1997) Effectiveness of computer assisted instruction in increasing the rate of universal precautions–related behaviours . American Journal of Infection Control25:5, 426–429 .
72.
Young, E.W. , Forti, E.M. , Preston, D.B. (1996) Rural nurses use of universal precautions in relation to perceived knowledge of patients' HIV status . International Journal of Nursing Studies33:3, 249–258 .
