Anthropologically informed plaster face casts were created and collected in the 19th and 20th centuries as part of an effort to develop human typologies, and to acquire data on what were perceived to be the morphological attributes of race. Their subsequent affective, politically sensitive, promiscuously mobile, and precarious qualities have resulted in them occupying highly charged territories within collections, as well as between museums and descendant communities. They are objects with inherent ambiguities due to how they exist at the intersections of art and science, merging individual, cultural, political, and colonialized bodies. Casts also provide tangible traces of unwanted physical intimacy resulting from how colonized peoples often had no choice in being cast or handled by strangers. In recent years, however, they have also been used by descendent communities as memorials of family members. This article explores this potent intersection of ambiguity and intimacy that these casts occupy, arguing for ethical protocol for their treatment that acknowledges their history, colonial contexts, and the processes behind their creation, as well as their current re-socialization through renewed relationships with descendant communities.
BairdSF (1878) Catalogue of casts taken by Clark Mills, Esq., of the heads of sixty-four Indian prisoners of various western tribes, and held at Fort Marion, Saint Augustine, Fla., in charge of capt. In: PrattRH (ed) Proceedings of the United States National Museum (v. 1 1878). Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 201.
2.
BartheC (2004) Models and Norms: The relationship between ethnographic photographs and sculptures. In Laure de Margerie and Eduard Papet, eds. Facing the Other: Charles Cordier, Ethnographic Sculptor. New York: Harry N. Abrams, Inc. Publishers, 93–127.
3.
BlackleyR (2004) Beauty and the beast: Plaster casts in a colonial museum. In: SmithAWeversL (eds) On Display: New Essays in Cultural Studies. Wellington: Victoria University Press, 41–64.
4.
BloomME (2003) Waxworks: A Cultural Obsession. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
5.
BronfenE (1992) Over Her Dead Body: Death, Femininity and the Aesthetic. Manchester: University Press.
6.
BrowereJHIFoxDR (1940) Life Masks of Noted Americans of 1825: Exhibition, February 12 to February 24, 1940 under the Sponsorship of the New York State Historical Association, Cooperstown, New York. New York: M. Knoedler and Company.
7.
De VilleJ (1828) Outlines of Phrenology: As an Accompaniment to the Phrenological BustLondon: J. De Ville.
8.
DriverF (2018) Face to face with Nain Singh: The Schlagintweit collections and their uses. In: MacGregorA (ed) Naturalists in the Field: Collecting, Recording and Preserving the Natural World from the Fifteenth to the Twenty-First Century. Boston: Brill, 441–469.
9.
EwenEEwenS (2006) Typecasting: On the Arts & Sciences of Human Inequality: A History of Dominant Ideas. New York: Seven Stories Press.
10.
Fear-SegalJ (2013) Plaster-cast Indians at the national museum. In: Fear-SegalJTillettR (eds) Indigenous Bodies: Reviewing, Relocating, Reclaiming. Albany: State University of New York Press, 33–52.
11.
FeldmanJ (2006) Contact points: Museums and the lost body problem. In: EdwardsEGosdenCPhillipsRB (eds) Sensible Objects: Colonialism, Museums and Material Culture. New York: Berg, 245–268.
12.
FuscoC (1994) The other history of intercultural performance. TDR (1988–)38(1): 143–167.
13.
GlancyD (2014) Fort Marion Prisoners and the Trauma of Native Education. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
14.
HallamEHockeyJ (2001) Death, Memory and Material Culture. Oxford: Berg.
15.
HenningsenAF (2018) Ethnographic mannequins: Copying as artefactualisation of human difference. In: BrennaBChristensenHDHamramO (eds) Museums as Cultures of Copies; The Crafting of Artefacts of Authenticity. New York: Routledge, 149–162.
16.
HoffmannA (2015) Of storying and storing: ‘Reading’ Lichtenecker’s voice recordings. In: SilvesterJ (ed) Re-Viewing Resistance in Namibian History. Windhoek: University of Namibia Press, 89–104.
17.
HowesH (2011) ‘It is not so!’ Otto Finsch, expectations and encounters in the pacific 1865–85. Historical Records of Australian Science22(1): 32–52.
18.
HrdličkaA (1904) Directions for Collecting Information and Specimens for Physical Anthropology. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
19.
HuttonL (1894) Portraits in Plaster, from the Collection of Laurence Hutton. New York: Harper & Brothers.
20.
IsaacG (2011) Whose idea was this? Museums, replicas and the reproduction of knowledge. Current Anthropology52(4): 585–595.
21.
IsaacG (forthcoming) Body politics and museums: Understanding face casts of Native Americans as sensitive objects. In: EhrenreichR (ed) Material Culture of Difficult Histories. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
22.
IsaacG (2022) Digital/object/beings and 3d replication object in the intercultural museum context: Have you socialized your clones? In: MorphyHMackenzieR (eds) Value Creations. Routledge Press.
23.
IsaacGClarkKAdamsK, et al. (2019) Anthropology, museums and the body: Lessons from an experimental teaching environment. Museum and Society17(3): 472–493.
LonetreeA (2012) Decolonizing Museums: Representing Native America in National and Tribal Museums. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press.
26.
MartinM (2006) The miscast exhibition at the South African national gallery. In: LobmanJGoodnowK (eds) Human Remains & Museum Practice. London: Museum of London, 25–32.
27.
MclarenA (1981) A Prehistory of the Social Sciences: Phrenology in France. Comparative Studies in Society and History23(1): 3–22.
28.
MeschuttD (1989) “A perfect likeness”: John H. I. Browere's life mask of Thomas Jefferson. American Art Journal21(4): 5–25.
New York Times (1857-1922), July 28, 1877. “A Sculptor Among the Indians: Sixty-Four casts of Chiefs Confined at St. Augustine—The Process of Taking Them.” From the Savannah News. ProQuest Historical Newspapers: The New York Times with Index, p. 8.
31.
PointonM (2014) Casts, imprints, and the deathliness of things: Artifacts at the edge. The Art Bulletin96(4): 170–195.
32.
PouletAL (2003) Jean-Antoine Houdon: Sculptor of the Enlightenment. Washington, DC: University of Chicago Press.
33.
QureshiS (2011) Peoples on Parade: Exhibitions, Empire, and Anthropology in Nineteenth-Century Britain. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
34.
QureshiS (2018) Peopling natural history. In: CurryHAJardineNSecordJA et al. (eds) Worlds of Natural History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 363–377.
35.
RedmanS (2016) Bone Rooms: From Scientific Racism to Human Prehistory in Museums. Harvard University Press.
36.
RosiekJLSnyderJPrattS (2019) The New Materialisms and Indigenous Theories of Non-Human Agency: Making the Case for Respectful Anti-colonial Engagement. Qualitative Inquiry, 26(3–4): 331–346.
