Assessment of the scientific rigour of randomized controlled trials on the effectiveness of cognitive behavioural therapy and graded exercise therapy for patients with myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome: A systematic review
Restricted accessReview articleFirst published online February, 2020
Assessment of the scientific rigour of randomized controlled trials on the effectiveness of cognitive behavioural therapy and graded exercise therapy for patients with myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome: A systematic review
Cognitive behavioural therapy and graded exercise therapy have been promoted as effective treatments for patients with myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome. However, criticism on the scientific rigour of these studies has been raised. This review assessed the methodological quality of studies on the effectiveness of cognitive behavioural therapy and graded exercise therapy. The methodological quality of the 18 included studies was found to be relatively low, as bias was prominently found, affecting the main outcome measures of the studies (fatigue, physical functioning and functional impairment/status). Future research should focus on including more objective outcome measures in a well-defined patient population.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2018) Myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome. Available at: https://www.cdc.gov/me-cfs/index.html (accessed 21 February 2018).
2.
ChalderTGoldsmithKAWhitePD, et al. (2015) Rehabilitative therapies for chronic fatigue syndrome: A secondary mediation analysis of the PACE trial. The Lancet Psychiatry2(2): 141–152.
3.
ChristleyYDuffyTMartinCR (2012) A review of the definitional criteria for chronic fatigue syndrome. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice18: 25–31.
4.
DealeAChalderTWesselyS (1998) Illness beliefs and treatment outcome in chronic fatigue syndrome. Journal of Psychosomatic Research45(1): 77–83.
5.
DealeAChalderTMarksI, et al. (1997) Cognitive behaviour therapy for chronic fatigue syndrome: A randomized controlled trial. The American Journal of Psychiatry154: 408–414.
6.
DealeAHusainKChalderT, et al. (2001) Long-term outcome of cognitive behaviour therapy versus relaxation therapy for chronic fatigue syndrome: A 5-year follow-up study. The American Journal of Psychiatry158: 2038–2042.
7.
DowsettEGRamsayAMMcCarteneyRA, et al. (1990) Myalgic encephalomyelitis a persistent enteroviral infection?Postgraduate Medical Journal66: 526–530.
8.
DugganCParryGMcMurranM, et al. (2014) The recording of adverse events from psychological treatments in clinical trials: Evidence from a review of NIHR-funded trials. Trials15: 335.
9.
FukudaKStrausSHickieI, et al. (1994) Chronic fatigue syndrome: A comprehensive approach to its definition and study. Annals of Internal Medicine121: 953–959.
10.
FulcherYFWhitePD (1997) Randomised controlled trial of graded exercise in patients with the chronic fatigue syndrome. British Medical Journal314: 1647–1652.
11.
GeraghtyK (2017) ‘PACE-Gate’: When clinical trial evidence meets open data access. Journal of Health Psychology22(9): 1106–1112.
12.
HigginsJPT (2011) The cochrane collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ343: d5928.
13.
Institute of Medicine (2015) Beyond Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: Redefining an Illness. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
14.
JasonLATorres-HardingSFriedbergF, et al. (2007) Non-pharmacologic interventions for CFS: A randomized trial. Journal of Clinical Psychology in Medical Settings14: 275–296.
15.
JonssonUAlaieIParlingT, et al. (2014) Reporting of harms in randomized controlled trials of psychological interventions for mental and behavioral disorders: A review of current practice. Contemporary Clinical Trials38(1): 1–8.
16.
KindlonT (2011) Reporting of harms associated with graded exercise therapy and cognitive behavioural therapy in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome. Bulleting of the IACFS/ME19(2): 59–111.
17.
LarunLBrunbergKGOdgaard-JensenJ, et al. (2017) Exercise therapy for chronic fatigue syndrome. Cochrane Library4: CD003200.
18.
LopezCAntoniMPenedoF, et al. (2011) A pilot study of cognitive behavioral stress management effects on stress, quality of life, and symptoms in persons with chronic fatigue syndrome. Journal of Psychosomatic Research70: 328–334.
19.
McCronePSharpeMChalderT, et al. (2012) Adaptive pacing, cognitive behaviour therapy, graded exercise, and specialist medical care for chronic fatigue syndrome: A cost-effectiveness analysis. PLoS ONE7(8): e40808.
20.
Moss-MorrisRSharonCTobinR, et al. (2005) A randomized controlled graded exercise trial for chronic fatigue syndrome: Outcomes and mechanisms of change. Journal of Health Psychology10(2): 245–259.
NunezMFernandes-SolaJNunezE, et al. (2011) Health-related quality of life in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome: Group cognitive behavioural therapy and graded exercise versus usual treatment. A randomised controlled trial with 1 year of follow-up. Clinical Rheumatology30: 381–389.
23.
O’DowdHGladwellPRogersCA, et al. (2006) Cognitive behavioural therapy in chronic fatigue syndrome: A randomised controlled trial of an outpatient group programme. Health Technology Assessment10(37): 1–121.
24.
PetrieKJWeinmanJ (2017) The PACE trial: It’s time to broaden perceptions and move on. Journal of Health Psychology22(9): 1198–1200.
25.
PrinsJBBleijenbergGBazelmansE, et al. (2001) Cognitive behaviour therapy for chronic fatigue syndrome: A multicentre randomised controlled trial. The Lancet357: 841–847.
26.
SharpeMArchardLBanatvalaJ, et al. (1991) Chronic fatigue syndrome: Guidelines for research. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine84: 118–121.
27.
SharpeMGoldsmithKAJohnsonAL, et al. (2015) Rehabilitative treatments for chronic fatigue syndrome: Long-term follow-up from the PACE trial. The Lancet Psychiatry2: 1067–1074.
28.
SharpeMHawtonKSimkinS, et al. (1996) Cognitive behaviour therapy for the chronic fatigue syndrome: A randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal312: 22–26.
29.
SmithMEHaneyEMcDonaghM, et al. (2015) Treatment of myalgic encephalomyellitus/chronic fatigue syndrome: A systematic review for a national institutes of health pathways to prevention workshop. Annals of Internal Medicine162(12): 841–850.
TullerD (2017) Once again, the PACE authors respond to concerns with empty answers. Journal of Health Psychology22(9): 1118–1122.
32.
TummersMKnoopHBleijenbergG (2010) Effectiveness of stepped care for chronic fatigue syndrome: A randomized noninferiority trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology78(5): 724–731.
33.
TwiskFNMCorsiusLAMM (2017) An analysis of Dutch hallmark studies confirms the outcome of the PACE trial: Cognitive behaviour therapy with a graded activity protocol is not effective for chronic fatigue syndrome and myalgic encephalomyelitis. General Medicine Open1: 1–13.
34.
VaughanBGoldsteinMHAlikakosM, et al. (2014) Frequency of reporting of adverse events in randomized controlled trials of psychotherapy vs. psychopharmacotherapy. Comprehensive Psychiatry55(4): 849–855.
35.
VinkM (2017) Assessment of individual PACE trial data: In myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome, cognitive behavioral and graded exercise therapy are ineffective, do not lead to actual recovery and negative outcomes may be higher than reported. Journal of Neurology and Neurobiology3(1): 10.16966/2379-7150.136.
36.
VinkMVink-NieseA (2018) Graded exercise therapy for myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome is not effective and unsafe: Re-analysis of a cochrane review. Health Psychology Open5(2): 2055102918805187.
37.
Vos-VromansDCSmeetsRJHuijnenIP, et al. (2016) Multidisciplinary rehabilitation treatment versus cognitive behavioural therapy for patients with chronic fatigue syndrome: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Internal Medicine279: 268–282.
38.
WallmanKEMortonARGoodmanC, et al. (2004) Randomised controlled trial of graded exercise in chronic fatigue syndrome. The Medical Journal of Australia180: 444–448.
39.
WhitePDGoldsmithKAJohnsonAL, et al. (2011) Comparison of adaptive pacing therapy, cognitive behaviour therapy, graded exercise therapy, and specialist medical care for chronic fatigue syndrome (PACE): A randomised trial. The Lancet377: 823–836.
40.
WhitePDGoldsmithKAJohnsonAL, et al. (2013) Recovery from chronic fatigue syndrome after treatments given in the PACE trial. Psychological Medicine43: 2227–2235.
41.
WiborgJFKnoopHStulemeijerM, et al. (2010) How does cognitive behaviour therapy reduce fatigue in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome? The role of physical activity. Psychological Medicine40(8): 1281–1287.
42.
WiborgJFVan BusselJVan DijkA, et al. (2015) Randomised controlled trial of cognitive behaviour therapy delivered in groups of patients with chronic fatigue syndrome. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics84: 368–376.
43.
WilshireCEKindlonTCourtneyR, et al. (2018) Rethinking the treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome – a reanalysis and evaluation of findings from a recent major trial of graded exercise and CBT. BMC Psychology6: 6.
44.
WilshireCEKindlonTMattheesA, et al. (2017) Can patients with chronic fatigue syndrome really recover after graded exercise or cognitive behavioural therapy? A critical commentary and preliminary re-analysis of the PACE trial. Fatigue: Biomedicine, Health & Behavior5(1): 43–56.
