Medical adult male circumcision has been shown to offer men significant protection against HIV infection during peno-vaginal sex. This has resulted in calls for a national roll-out of medical adult male circumcision in South Africa, a rights-based constitutional democracy. This article explores the ways that the potential tensions between this call to circumcise as a practice of good health citizenship and the guaranteed right to bodily integrity are negotiated in interviews with 30 urban-based men in Johannesburg. The results suggest that despite its demonstrable biological efficacy, these tensions may paralyse decision- and policy-makers in grappling with the potential scaling up of medical adult male circumcision for HIV prevention in South Africa.
AliAKockEMoltenoCet al. (2015) Ethnicity and self-reported experiences of stigma in adults with intellectual disability in Cape Town, South Africa. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research59(6): 530–540.
2.
AloufB (2005) What your doctormaynot tell you about circumcision: Untold facts on America’s most widely performed – and most unnecessary – surgery. Journal of the National Medical Association97(6): 850–852.
3.
AuvertBTaljaardDRechDet al. (2013) Association of the ANRS-12126 male circumcision project with HIV levels among men in a South African township: Evaluation of effectiveness using cross-sectional surveys. PLoS Medicine10(9): e1001509.
4.
BaileyRCEgesahORosenbergS (2008) Male circumcision for HIV prevention: A prospective study of complications in clinical and traditional settings in Bungoma, Kenya. Bulletin of the World Health Organization86(9): 669–677.
5.
BambraCFoxDScott-SamuelA (2005) Towards a politics of health. Health Promotion International20(2): 187–193.
6.
BayerRColgroveJ (2002) Public health vs. civil liberties. Science297(5588): 1811.
7.
BhattacharjeePK (2008) Male circumcision: An overview. African Journal of Paediatric Surgery5(1): 32–36.
8.
BollingerRCTripathySPQuinnTC (1995) The human immunodeficiency virus epidemic in India: Current magnitude and future projections. Medicine74(2): 97–106.
ClarkPAEisenmanJSzapoS (2011) Surgical Vaccine: Should male circumcision be mandatory in Sub-Saharan Africa?International Journal of Ethics7(3/4): 211–231.
11.
CoovadiaHJewkesRBarronPet al. (2009) The health and health system of South Africa: Historical roots of current public health challenges. The Lancet374(9692): 817–834.
12.
DarbyR (2003) The masturbation taboo and the rise of routine male circumcision: A review of the historiography. Journal of Social History36(3): 737–757.
13.
Department of Health (2013) National Strategic Plan for HIV and AIDS/Comprehensive HIV and AIDS Treatment Plan Statistics Memorandum. Pretoria, South Africa: Department of Health.
14.
De VincenziIMertensT (1994) Male circumcision: A role in HIV prevention?AIDS8(2): 153–160.
El-HoutYKhauliRB (2007) The case for routine circumcision. The Journal of Men’s Health & Gender4(3): 300–305.
17.
EsparzaJ (2013) A brief history of the global effort to develop a preventive HIV vaccine. Vaccine31(35): 3502–3518.
18.
FriedenTRDas-DouglasMKellermanSEet al. (2005) Applying public health principles to the HIV epidemic. The New England Journal of Medicine353(22): 2397–2402.
19.
GostinLO (1989) The politics of AIDS: Compulsory state powers, public health, and civil liberties. The Ohio State Law Journal49(1017): 1041–1043.
20.
GostinLO (2001) Public health, ethics, and human rights: A tribute to the late Jonathan Mann. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics29(2): 121–130.
21.
GostinLO (2003) Public health ethics: Tradition, profession, and values. Acta Bioethica9(2): 177–188.
22.
GwandureC (2011) The ethical concerns of using medical male circumcision in HIV prevention in Sub-Saharan Africa. South African Journal of Bioethics and Law4(2): 89–94.
23.
HalperinDTBaileyRC (1999) Male circumcision and HIV infection: 10 years and counting. The Lancet354(9192): 1813–1815.
24.
HansenHGroceNE (2001) From quarantine to condoms: Shifting policies and problems of HIV control in Cuba. Medical Anthropology19(3): 259–292.
25.
Hansson SchermanMLöwhagenO (2004) Drug compliance and identity: Reasons for non-compliance: Experiences of medication from persons with asthma/allergy. Patient Education & Counseling54(1): 3–9.
26.
HemmingsSMJLochnerCvan der MerweLet al. (2013) BDNF Val66Met modifies the risk of childhood trauma on obsessive-compulsive disorder. Journal of Psychiatric Research47(12): 1857–1863.
27.
Howard-PayneL (2016) Glaser or Strauss? Considerations for selecting a grounded theory study. South African Journal of Psychology46(1): 50–62.
28.
Howard-PayneL (2015) The methodological implications of relying upon fieldworkers for qualitative health psychology research. Forum: Qualitative Social Research. Available at: http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0114-fqs150239
Kaiser Health News (2006) Routine male circumcision in Sub-Saharan Africa could prevent 6M new infections, 3M deaths over 20 years, report says. KHN Morning Briefing. Available at: www.khn.org/morning-breakout/dr00038425/ (accessed 2 January 2016).
31.
LangaM (2008) Using photo-narratives to explore the construction of young masculinities. Psychology in Society36: 6–23.
32.
LaurinKKayACProudfootDet al. (2013) Response to restrictive policies: Reconciling system justification and psychological reactance. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes122(2): 152–162.
33.
LuriePWolfeSM (2012) Unethical trials of interventions to reduce peri-natal transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus in developing countries. In: HollandS (ed.) Arguing about Bioethics. New York: Routledge, pp. 479–484.
34.
ManirankundaLLoosJDebackaerePet al. (2012) ‘It is not easy’: Challenges for provider-initiated HIV testing and counseling in Flanders, Belgium. AIDS Education and Prevention24(5): 456–468.
35.
MechanicD (2013) The social context of health and disease and choices among health interventions. In: BrandtAMRozinP (eds) Morality and Health. London: Routledge, pp. 79–100.
36.
MeyerB (2004) Christianity in Africa: From African independent to Pentecostal-charismatic churches. Annual Review of Anthropology33: 447–474.
37.
MogotlaneSMNtlangulelaJTOgunbanjoBG (2004) Mortality and morbidity among traditionally circumcised Xhosa boys in the Eastern Cape Province, South Africa. Curations27(2): 57–62.
38.
MorganKP (1998) Contested bodies, contested knowledges: Women, health, and the politics of medicalization applied to circumcision. In: SherwinS (ed.) The Politics of Women’s Health: Exploring Agency and Autonomy. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, pp. 83–121.
39.
NjohAJ (2009) Ideology and public health elements of human settlement policies in sub-Saharan Africa. Cities26(1): 9–18.
40.
PechèreJHughesDKardasPet al. (2007) Non-compliance with antibiotic therapy for acute community infections: A global survey. International Journal of Antimicrobial Agents29: 245–253.
41.
PierettiRVGoldsteinAMPieretti-VanmarckeR (2010) Late complications of newborn circumcision: A common and avoidable problem. Pediatric Surgery International26(5): 515–518.
42.
RadayF (2003) Culture, religion, and gender. International Journal of Constitutional Law1(4): 663–715.
43.
RenshawDC (2003) Body dysmorphia, the plastic surgeon, and the counselor. The Family Journal11(3): 264–267.
44.
RoseNNovasC (2004) Biological citizenship. In: OngACollierS (eds) Global Assemblages: Technology, Politics, and Ethics as Anthropological Problems. Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 439–463.
45.
SmithDKTaylorAKilmarxPHet al. (2010) Male circumcision in the United States for the prevention of HIV infection and other adverse health outcomes: Report from a CDC consultation. Public Health Reports125(1): 72–82.
46.
StevensonN (2002) Cosmopolitanism, multiculturalism and citizenship. Sociological Research Online7(1): 41–66.
47.
StraussALCorbinJM (1997) Grounded Theory in Practice. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
48.
SusserMCherryVP (1982) Health and health care under apartheid. Journal of Public Health Policy3(4): 455–475.
49.
SwartzL (2013) Multiculturalism and mental health in South Africa. In: PedersenP (ed.) Multiculturalism as a Fourth Force. New York: Routledge, pp. 93–110.
50.
ThomasEJBurstinHRO’NeilACet al. (1996) Patient noncompliance with medical advice after the emergency department visit. Annals of Emergency Medicine27(1): 49–55.
51.
Van HoweRS (1999) Circumcision and HIV infection: Review of the literature and meta-analysis. International Journal of STD & AIDS10(1): 8–16.
52.
Van HoweRSStormsMR (2011) How the circumcision solution in Africa will increase HIV infections. Journal of Public Health in Africa2(1): 11–15.
53.
VincentL (2008) Cutting tradition: The political regulation of traditional circumcision rites in South Africa’s liberal democratic order. Journal of Southern African Studies34(1): 77–91.
54.
VincentL (2009) Moral panic and the politics of populism. Representation45(2): 213–221.
55.
WeissHALarkeNHalperinDet al. (2010) Complications of circumcision in male neonates, infants and children: A systematic review. BMC Urology10(1): 2–15.
56.
WHO (2006) Demand for male circumcision rises in a bid to prevent HIV. Bulletin of the World Health Organisation84(7): 505–588.
57.
WilckenAKeilTDickB (2010) Traditional male circumcision in eastern and southern Africa: A systematic review of prevalence and complications. Bulletin of the World Health Organization88(12): 907–914.
58.
ZolaIK (1975) In the name of health and illness: On some socio-political consequences of medical influence. Social Science & Medicine9: 83–87.
59.
ZolaIK (1979) Pathways to the doctor – From person to patient. Social Science & Medicine9: 83–87.
