This study investigated the effect of a smoking health message on smokers’ comparative optimism. Two groups watched an anti-smoking scenario, with one group imagining being part of the scenario. Participants, including controls, completed comparative optimism ratings for four smoking-related illnesses. The intervention had negative consequences with both intervention groups reporting significantly higher comparative optimism versus the control group for all four smoking-related illnesses. It is concluded that media health messages can be powerful tools in changing comparative optimism but are influenced by peoples’ prior perceptions. Health messages need to be systematically assessed to understand prior beliefs of the target audience.
AyersBMyersLB (2012) Do Media Messages Change People’s Risk Perceptions for Binge Drinking?Alcohol and Alcoholism47: 52–56.
2.
BerryD (2004) Risk, Communication and Health Psychology. Buckingham: Open University Press.
3.
BishAYardleyLNicollA. (2011) Factors associated with uptake of vaccination against pandemic influenza: A systematic review. Vaccine29: 6472–6484.
4.
BlissmerBProchaskaJOVelicerW. (2010) Common factors predicting long-term changes in multiple health behaviors. Journal of Health Psychology15: 205–214.
5.
BrownSSmithE (2007) The inhibitory effect of a distressing anti-smoking message on risk perceptions in smokers. Psychology & Health22: 255–268.
6.
ChangDHwa-HyunKHo-SunL. (2012) Pre-existing beliefs and expectations influence judgments of novel health information. Journal of Health Psychology17: 753–763.
7.
DollRHillAB (1950) Smoking and carcinoma of the lung; preliminary report. British Medical Journal2: 739–748.
8.
DollRPetoRWheatleyK. (1994) Mortality in relation to smoking: 40 years’ observations on male British doctors. British Medical Journal309: 901–911.
9.
EiserJRArnoldBWA (1999) Out in the midday sun: Risk behaviour and optimistic beliefs among residents and visitors on Tenerife. Psychology & Health14: 529–544.
10.
GlockSMullerBRitterS (2012) Warning labels formulated as questions positively influence smoking-related risk perception. Journal of Health Psychology. Epub ahead of print March 2012. DOI: 10.1177/1359105312439734.
JanzNKBeckerMH (1984) The health belief model: A decade later. Health Education Quarterly11: 1–47.
13.
LeshnerGBollsPThomasE (2009) Scare’ em or disgust ’em: The effects of graphic health promotion messages. Health Communication24: 447–458.
14.
McDonaldDO’BrienJFarrE. (2010) Pilot study of inducing smoking cessation attempts by activating a sense of looming vulnerability. Addictive Behaviors35: 599–606.
15.
McKennaFPMyersLB (1995) Changing risk perceptions: The role of the mass media. In: GraysonGB (ed.) Behavioural Research in Road Safety V. Crowthorne: Transport Research Laboratory, pp. 23–34.
16.
McKennaFPMyersLB (1997) Can accountability reduce or reverse existing illusory self assessments?British Journal of Psychology88: 39–51.
17.
MyersLB (1999) Is optimistic bias for skin cancer realistic?Proceedings of the British Psychological Society7: 25.
18.
MyersLBFrostS (2002) Smoking and smoking cessation: Modifying perceptions of risk? In: RutterDQuineL (eds) Changing Health Behaviour: Research and Practice with Social Cognition Models. Buckingham: Open University Press, pp. 49–65.
19.
MyersLBReynoldsR (2000) How optimistic are repressors? The relationship between repressive coping, controllability, self-esteem and comparative optimism for health-related events. Psychology & Health15: 667–688.
20.
NestlerSEgloffB (2010) When scary messages backfire: Influence of dispositional cognitive avoidance on the effectiveness of threat communications. Journal of Research in Personality44: 137–141.
21.
ParkKChangSJKimHC. (2009) Big gap between risk perception for breast cancer and risk factors: Nationwide survey in Korea. Patient Education and Counseling76: 113–119.
22.
PerrissolSSmedingALaumondF. (2011) Effect of a road safety training program on drivers’ comparative optimism. Accident; Analysis and Prevention43: 478–482.
23.
RobbKACampbellJEvansP. (2008) Impact of risk information on perceived colorectal cancer risk: A randomized trial. Journal of Health Psychology13: 744–756.
24.
RogersRW (1975) A protection motivation theory of fear appeals and attitude change. Journal of Psychology91: 93–114.
25.
RuvoloAPMarkusHR (1992) Possible selves and performance – The power of self-relevant imagery. Social Cognition10: 95–124.
26.
SegerstromSCMcCarthyWJCaskeyNH. (1993) Optimistic bias among cigarette smokers. Journal of Applied Social Psychology23: 1606–1618.
27.
ShahabLWestR (2010) Public support in England for a total ban on the sale of tobacco products. Tobacco Control19: 143–147.
28.
Van der PligtJ (1998) Perceived risk and vulnerability as predictors of precautionary behavior. British Journal of Health Psychology3: 1–14.
29.
VasquezNABuehlerR (2007) Seeing future success: Does imagery perspective influence achievement motivation?Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin33: 1392–1405.
30.
WeinsteinND (1982) Unrealistic optimism about susceptibility to health problems. Journal of Behavioral Medicine5: 451–459.
31.
WeinsteinND (1987) Unrealistic optimism about susceptibility to health problems: Conclusions from a community-wide sample. Journal of Behavioral Medicine10: 481–500.
32.
WeinsteinND (1998) The precaution adoption process. Health Psychology7: 355–386.
33.
WeinsteinNDKleinWM (1995) Resistance of personal risk perceptions to debiasing interventions. Health Psychology14: 132–140.
34.
WelkenhuysenMEverskieboomsGDydewalleG (1997) Unrealistic optimism about specific genetic risks and perceived preventability. Psychologica Belgica37: 169–181.
35.
WitteK (1998) Fear as motivator, fear as inhibitor: Using the extended parallel process model to explain fear appeal successes and failures. In: AndersenPAGuerreroLK (eds) Handbook of Communication and Emotion: Research, Theory, Applications and Contexts. San Diego, CA: Academic Press, pp. 423–449.
