Comparative optimism – feeling at less personal risk for negative outcomes than one’s peers – has been linked to reduced prevention efforts. This study examined a novel debiasing technique aimed at simultaneously reducing both indirectly and directly measured comparative optimism. Before providing direct comparative estimates, participants provided absolute self and peer estimates in a joint format (same computer screen) or a separate format (different computer screens). Relative to the separate format condition, participants in the joint format condition showed (1) lower comparative optimism in absolute/indirect measures, (2) lower direct comparative optimism, and (3) heightened worry. Implications for risk perception screening are discussed.
AucoteHMGoldRS (2005) Non-equivalence of direct and indirect measures of unrealistic optimism. Psychology, Health & Medicine10: 194–201.
2.
AucoteHMGoldRS (2008) Changing perception of average person’s risk does not suffice to change perception of comparative risk. Psychology, Health & Medicine13: 461–470.
3.
BrewerNTWeinsteinNDCuiteCLHerringonJ (2004) Risk perceptions and their relation to risk behavior. Annals of Behavioral Medicine27: 125–130.
4.
BrownSLImberA (2003) The effect of reducing opportunities for downward comparison on comparative optimism. Journal of Applied Social Psychology33: 1058–1068.
5.
BurgerJMPalmerML (1992) Changes in the generalization of unrealistic optimism following experiences with stressful events: Reactions to the 1989 California earthquake. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin18: 39–43.
6.
ChambersJWindschitlPD (2004) Biases in social comparative judgments: The role of nonmotivated factors in above-average and comparative-optimism effects. Psychological Bulletin130: 813–838.
7.
ChambersJWindschitlPDSulsJ (2003) Egocentrism, event frequency, and comparative optimism: When what happens frequently is ‘more likely to happen to me’. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin29: 1343–1356.
8.
ChapmanGBCoupsEJ (2006) Emotions and preventative health behavior: Worry, regret and influenza vaccination. Health Psychology25: 82–90.
9.
CoveyJADaviesA (2004) Are people unrealistically optimistic? It depends how you ask them. British Journal of Health Psychology9: 39–49.
10.
FrenchDHeveyD (2008) What do people think about when answering questionnaires to assess unrealistic optimism about skin cancer? A think aloud study. Psychology, Health, & Medicine13: 63–74.
GladisMMMichelaJLWalterHJVaughanRD (1992) High school students’ perceptions of AIDS risk: Realistic appraisal or motivated denial?Health Psychology11: 307–316.
13.
HarrisPMiddletonWJoinerR (2000) The typical student as an in-group member: Eliminating optimistic bias by reducing social distance. European Journal of Social Psychology30: 235–253.
14.
HayesAF (2009) Beyond Baron and Kenny: Statistical mediation analysis in the new millennium. Communication Monographs76: 408–420.
15.
Helweg-LarsenMShepperdJA (2001) Do moderators of the optimistic bias affect personal or target risk estimates: A review of the literatures. Personality and Social Psychology Review5: 74–95.
16.
HeveyDFrenchDPMarteauTMSuttonS (2009) Assessing unrealistic optimism: Impact of different approaches to measuring susceptibility to diabetes. Journal of Health Psychology14: 372–377.
17.
JanzNKBeckerMH (1984) The health belief model: A decade later. Health Education Quarterly11: 1–47.
18.
KleinWMP (2002) Comparative risk estimates relative to the average peer predict behavioral intentions and concern about absolute risk. Risk, Decision, & Policy7: 193–202.
19.
KleinWMPZajacL (2009) Imagining a rosy future: The psychology of optimism. In: MarkmanKKleinWMPSuhrJ (eds) Handbook of Imagination and Mental Simulation. New York: Psychology Press, pp. 313–330.
20.
KrugerJBurrusJ (2004) Egocentrism and focalism in unrealistic optimism (and pessimism). Journal of Experimental Social Psychology40: 220–232.
21.
LipkusIMCrawfordYFennK. (1999) Testing different formats for communicating colorectal cancer risk. Journal of Health Communication4: 311–324.
22.
LipkusIMKuchibhatlaMMcBrideCM. (2000b) Relationship among breast cancer perceived absolute risk, comparative risk, and worries. Cancer Epidemiology Biomarkers and Prevention9: 973–975.
23.
LipkusIMLynaPRRimerBK (2000a) Colorectal cancer risk perceptions and screening intentions in a minority population. Journal of National Medical Association92: 492–500.
24.
McCaulKDO’DonnellSM (1998) Naïve beliefs about breast cancer risk. Women’s Health4: 93–101.
25.
McKennaFPMyersLB (1997) Illusory self-assessments – can they be reduced?British Journal of Psychology88: 39–51.
26.
MyersLBFrostS (2002) Smoking and smoking cessation: Modifying perceptions of risk. In: RutterDQuineL (eds) Changing Health Behaviour: Intervention and Research with Social Cognition Models. England: Open University Press.
27.
PreacherKJHayesAF (2008) Asymptotic and resampling strategies for assessing and comparing indirect effects in multiple mediator models. Behavior Research Methods40: 879–891.
28.
PricePCPentecostHCVothRM (2002) Perceived event frequency and the optimistic bias: Evidence for a two-process model of personal risk judgments. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology38: 242–252.
29.
RanbyKWAikenLSGerendMAErchullMJ (2010) Perceived susceptibility measures are not interchangeable: Absolute, direct comparative, and indirect comparative risk. Health Psychology29: 20–28.
30.
RobbKACampbellJEvansPMilesAWardleJ (2008) Impact of risk information on perceived colorectal cancer risk: A randomized trial. Journal of Health Psychology13: 744–756.
31.
RoseJP (2010) Are direct or indirect measures of comparative risk better predictors of concern and behavioural intentions?Psychology & Health25: 149–165.
32.
RoseJPEndoYWindschitlPDSulsJ (2008) Cultural differences in unrealistic optimism and pessimism: The role of egocentrism and direct vs. indirect comparison measures. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin34: 1236–1248.
33.
RoseJPSulsJWindschitlPD (2011) When and why people are comparatively optimistic about future health risk: The role of direct and indirect comparison measures. Psychology, Health, & Medicine169: 475–483.
34.
RothmanAJKleinWMWeinsteinND (1996) Absolute and relative biases in estimations of personal risk. Journal of Applied Social Psychology26: 1213–1236.
35.
SuttonS (2002) Influencing optimism in smokers by giving information about the average smoker. Risk Decision and Policy7: 165–174.
36.
SvensonO (1981) Are we all less risky and more skillful than our fellow drivers?Acta Psychologica47: 143–148.
37.
TaylorSBrownJ (1988) Illusion and well-being: A social psychological perspective on mental health. Psychological Bulletin103: 193–210.
38.
WeinsteinND (1980) Unrealistic optimism about future life events. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology39: 806–820.
39.
WeinsteinND (1983) Reducing unrealistic optimism about illness susceptibility. Health Psychology2: 11–20.
40.
WeinsteinND (1987) Unrealistic optimism about susceptibility to health problems: Conclusions from a community-wide sample. Journal of Behavioral Medicine10: 481–500.
41.
WeinsteinNDKleinWM (1995) Resistance of personal risk perceptions to debiasing interventions. Health Psychology14: 132–140.
42.
WeinsteinNDLachendroE (1982) Egocentrism as a source of unrealistic optimism. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin8: 199–200.
43.
WeinsteinNDNicolichM (1993) Correct and incorrect interpretations of correlations between risk perceptions and risk behaviors. Health Psychology12: 235–245.
44.
WindschitlPDRoseJPStalkfleetMSmithAS (2008) Are people excessive or judicious in their egocentrism? A modeling approach to understanding bias and accuracy in people’s optimism. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology95: 253–273.
