Does retaliation against a whistleblower qualify as discrimination or an infringement of freedom of expression? In France, whistleblowing legislation has built whistleblower protection on the model of discrimination. The transposition of the European Directive 2019/1937 of 23 October 2019 on the protection of persons who report breaches of EU law, reinforced by domestic case law, shifts the balance towards freedom of expression. Standing at the crossroads of discrimination and freedom of expression, the protection of whistleblowers is in urgent need of conceptual clarification, which this article seeks to provide. To this end, the article proposes to consider the status of whistleblower as a layered legal regime, in addition to an underlying legal status such as employee, civil servant, journalist or other. The articulation between discrimination and freedom of expression thereby gains a strategic dimension that is essential to it. This understanding helps to clarify how discrimination law and freedom of expression can benefit whistleblowers and thus strengthen rather than weaken their protection.
AdamP (2017) A propos de la protection générale des lanceurs d’alerte dans l’entreprise privée. Revue de jurisprudence sociale5: 355–361.
2.
AltE (2014) Lanceurs d’alerte: un droit en tension. La Semaine Juridique Edition Générale43: 1925–1932.
3.
ApazaCRChangY (eds), (2017) Whistleblowing in the World: Government Policy, Mass Media and the Law. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
4.
AshA (2016) Whistleblowing and Ethics in Health and Social Care. London, UK: Jessica Kingsley Publ.
5.
Blay-GrabarczykK (2018) Le statut de lanceur d’alerte dans les arrêts de la Cour européenne des droits de l’homme. Revue trimestrielle des droits de l’homme116: 855–871.
6.
DabosvilleB (2012) Contours de l’abus d’expression du salarié. Revue de droit du travail5: 275–281.
7.
DworkinTBrownAA (2013) The money or the media: lessons from contrasting developments in US and Australian whistleblowing laws. Seattle Journal for Social Justice11(2): 653–714.
8.
FabreAAdamP (2022) Liberté d'expression du salarié: de l'abus à l'atteinte. Revue de droit du travail9: 492–500.
9.
FasterlingB (2014) Whistleblower protection: a comparative law perspective. In: BrownAJLewisDMoberlyR, et al. (eds) International Handbook on Whistleblowing Research. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 331–348.
10.
FoegleJ-P (2015) De Washington à Paris, la « protection de carton » des agents secrets lanceurs d’alerte. La Revue des droits de l’homme, Actualités Droits-Libertés, Juin 2015 [online]. URL:http://revdh.revues.org/1369
11.
GobertJPunchM (2000) Whistleblowers, the public interest, and the public interest disclosure act 1998. The Modern Law Review63(1): 25–54.
12.
HandJ (2015) Outside the equality act: non-standard protection from discrimination in British law. International Journal of Discrimination and the Law15(4): 205–221.
13.
HardyKWilliamsG (2014) Terrorist, traitor, or whistleblower? offences and protections in Australia for disclosing national security information. UNSW Law Journal37(2): 784–819.
14.
JunodV (2022) Whistleblowing: des frontiers mouvantes. Revue trimestrielle des droits de l’homme129: 113–122.
15.
KeatingRKeatingR (2013) Whistling in the wind: the protected disclosure bill. King’s Inns Student L. Rev3: 97–116.
16.
KieransL (2015) Whistle while you work: protected disclosures act 2014. Irish Business Law Review2(2): 31–60.
17.
LeclercO (2007) La protection du salarié lanceur d’alerte. In: DockèsE (ed) Au cœur des combats juridiques. Pensées et témoignages de juristes engagés. Paris, France: Dalloz, pp. 287–298.
18.
LeclercO (2017) Protéger les lanceurs d’alerte. La démocratie technique à l’épreuve de la loi. Paris, France: LGDJ.
19.
LeclercO (2022a) L’enquête consécutive à une alerte. Droit Ouvrier883: 110–122.
20.
LeclercO (2022b) Ce que l’alerte fait aux frontières de l’entreprise. Revue de droit du travail5: 281–285.
21.
LewisD (1998) The public interest disclosure act 1998. Industrial Law Journal27(4): 325–330.
22.
LewisD (2001) Whistleblowing at work: on what principles should legislation be based?Industrial Law Journal30(2): 169–193.
23.
LewisD (2005) Providing rights for whistleblowers: would an anti-discrimination model be more effective?Industrial Law Journal34(3): 239–252.
24.
LewisD (2010a) A global approach to public interest disclosure. What Can We Learn from Existing Whistleblowing Legislation and Research?Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
25.
LewisD (2010b) Ten years of public interest disclosure act 1998 claims: What can we learn from the statistics and recent research?Industrial Law Journal39(3): 325–328.
26.
LewisJBowersJ (1996) Whistleblowing: Freedom of expression in the workplace. European Human Rights Law Review6: 637–648.
27.
MiceliMPNearJPSchwenkCR (1991) Who blows the whistle and why?Industrial and Labour Relations Review45(1): 113–130.
28.
MiddlemissS (2017) Whistle-blowing and the equality dimension of victimisation in the workplace. International Journal of Discrimination and the Law17(2): 137–156.
29.
OlsenJ (2014) Reporting versus inaction: How much is there, what explains the differences and what to measure. In: BrownAJLewisDMoberlyR, et al. (eds) International Handbook on Whistleblowing Research. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 177–206.
30.
OmtzigtP (2009) La protection des « donneurs d’alerte ». Conseil de l’Europe. Strasbourg: Rapport de la commission des questions juridiques et des droits de l’homme.
31.
RobertsP (2014) Motivations for whistleblowing: personal, private and public interests. In: BrownAJLewisDMoberlyR, et al (eds) International Handbook on Whistleblowing Research. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 207–229.
32.
SavageAHydeR (2015) The response to whistleblowing by regulators: a practical perspective. Legal Studies35(3): 408–429.
33.
SkupieńD (2021) Towards a Better Protection of Workplace Whistleblowers in the Visegrad Countries, France and Slovenia. Losz: Lodz University Press.
34.
StephensonPLeviM (2012) La protection des donneurs d’alerte. Rapport d’étude sur la faisabilité d’un instrument juridique sur la protection des employés qui divulguent des informations dans l’intérêt du public. CDCJ(2012)9FIN. Strasbourg: Conseil de l’Europe.
35.
ToubonJLagasseP (2019) Le régime « général » de protection des lanceurs d’alerte est-il l’expression d’un droit fondamental. Semaine sociale Lamy1862: 7–12.
36.
Transparency International (2013) Whistleblowing in Europe: legal protections for whistleblowers in the EU. Brussels: Transparency International.
37.
TrebulleFG (2013) Alertes et expertise en matière de santé et d’environnement, les enjeux de la loi du 16 avril 2013. Environnement, p8–9: 21–36.
38.
ThüsingGForstG (eds), (2016) Whistleblowing – A Comparative Study. Cham: Springer.
