Denationalisation and discrimination in postcolonial India

Abstract

With the recent National Register of Citizens updating process in Assam (a northeastern state in India) and the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA 2019), there have been significant changes to India’s citizenship laws and policies. This may create one of the world’s largest stateless populations in modern times. These changes manifest the government’s othering process of creating binaries of belonging and non-belongingness between the majority Hindus and minorities (especially followers of the Islamic faith).

In this article, taking these recent changes to citizenship as a case study, I discuss how India’s colonial past, the experience of partition, and the henceforth nation-building contributed to perceiving the ‘citizen’ primarily along Hindu majoritarian lines. I argue that the nation-building process in India was based on retaining and simultaneously re-establishing the ‘others’, thereby reinforcing colonial legacies in the structure and functioning of the postcolonial state. Consequently, this article deals with two questions, first, how the adoption of discriminatory citizenship laws and the risk of statelessness in India is rooted in its complex history, the impact of British colonial expansion and the postcolonial realities and second, what role ‘law’ has played in the process.

Keywords

Citizenship colonialism denationalisation discrimination India statelessness

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahmad

Venkatesh

(2020) Rewriting India: the construction of the ‘Hindutva’ citizen in the Indian state. TWAILR , 25 June 2020. Available at: https://twailr.com/rewriting-india-the-construction-of-the-hindutva-citizen-in-the-indian-state/ (accessed 10 July 2021).

Ahmed

(2020) Arbitrariness, subordination and unequal citizenship. Indian Law Review 4 (2): 121–137.

Amnesty International (2018) Between fear and hatred: surviving migration detention in Assam. Available at: https://issuu.com/aiindia/docs/assam_digest (accessed 5 June 2021).

Amnesty International (2019) Designed to exclude: how India’s courts are allowing foreigners tribunals to render people stateless in Assam. Available at: https://amnesty.org.in/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Assam-Foreigners-Tribunals-Report-1.pdf (accessed 20 October 2021).

Ajaz

(2018) How two police officers and RSS changed the script of the Assam agitation against outsiders in 1980s. Scroll , 18 January 2018. Available at: https://scroll.in/article/865199/how-two-police-officers-and-rss-changed-the-script-of-the-assam-agitation-against-outsiders-in-1980s (accessed 18 June 2021).

Arraiza

Aye

Shakirova

, et al. (2020) Fighting imagined invasions with administrative violence: racism, xenophobia and nativism as a cause of statelessness in Myanmar, the dominican republic and Assam (India). Statelessness and Citizenship Review 2(2):194–221.

Assam vision document

BJP

, 2016-2025 (2016) Available at: https://mmscmsguy.assam.gov.in/sites/default/files/swf_utility_folder/departments/mmscmsguy_webcomindia_org_oid_2/this_comm/vision-document.pdf (accessed 15 August 2021).

Azad

Parveez

(2021) Graveyards of the living dead: former inmates on life in Assam’s notorious detention centres, The Wire , 20 February, 2021. Available at: https://thewire.in/rights/assam-goalpara-detention-centre-nrc-citizenship (accessed 15 March 2021).

Bhatia

(2019) The troubling legacy of Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi. The Wire , 18 November 2019. Available at: https://thewire.in/law/chief-justice-ranjan-gogoi-legacy (accessed 3 August 2021).

10.

Chakravarty

(2017) Why was Assam’s Nellie massacre of 1983 not prevented, despite intimations of violence? Scroll , 18 February 2017. Available at: https://scroll.in/article/829682/why-was-assams-nellie-massacre-of-1983-not-prevented-despite-intimations-of-violence (accessed 1 June 2021).

11.

Chimni

(2018) Customary international law: a third world perspective. American Journal of International Law 112(1): 1–46.

12.

Costello

Foster

McAdam

(2021) The Oxford Handbook of International Refugee Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

13.

Dasgupta

(2001) Denial and resistance: Sylheti Partition ‘refugees’ in Assam Pages. Contemporary South Asia 10(3):343–360.

14.

Davies

Nandy

Sardar

(1993) Barbaric Others: A Manifesto on Western Racism. London: Pluto Press.

15.

Dembour

(2014) When humans become migrants: Study of the European Court of Human Rights with an Inter-American Counterpoint. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

16.

Doherty

(2019) Stripping people of citizenship makes the world less safe, not more. The Guardian ,12 October, 2019. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/oct/12/stripping-people-of-citizenship-makes-the-world-less-safe-not-more (accessed 3 June 2021).

17.

Ghoshal

(2021) Refugees, borders and identities: Rights and habitat in East and Northeast India. New York, NY: Routledge.

18.

Gibney

(2020) Denationalisation and discrimination. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 46 (12):2551–2568.

19.

Government of Assam (2012) White Paper on Foreigners’ Issue. Assam: October.

20.

Guha

(1976) East Bengal immigrants and Maulana Abdul Hamid Khan Bhasani in Assam politics, 1928-47. The Indian Economic and Social History Review 13(4):419–452.

21.

Haddad

(2008) The Refugee in International Society: Between Sovereigns, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

22.

Hazarika

(2019) Hindus aren’t our enemies’ — why final NRC is not what BJP promised and envisioned. The Print, 22 November, 2019. Available at: https://theprint.in/theprint-essential/hindus-arent-our-enemies-why-final-nrc-is-not-what-bjp-promised-and-envisioned/324713/ (accessed 19 June 2021).

23.

Jabeen

(2020) Denying the animosity: understanding narratives of harmony from the Nellie Massacre, 1983. Genocide Studies and Prevention: An International Journal 14(2): 2–19.

24.

Jamil

(2020) (Un)Freedom to criticize the judiciary in India: colonial origins and postcolonial realities. TWAILR 10 October, 2020. Available at: https://twailr.com/unfreedom-to-criticize-the-judiciary-in-india-colonial-origins-and-postcolonial-realities/ (accessed 20 October 2021).

25.

Jamil

(2021) India and customary international law. In Lee

Seokowoo

Babu

Rajesh

(India editor) Encyclopedia of public international law in Asia. Brill.

26.

Jones

(2012) Border Walls: Security and the War on Terror in the United States, India and Israel. London: Zed Books.

27.

Kapur

(2021) India’s citizenship (Amendment) act: a throwback to debates around the “long partition”. Statelessness and Citizenship Review 3(1) 208–235.

28.

Khan

(2021) India and statelessness: an introduction. Statelessness and Citizenship Review 3(1) 176–185.

29.

Foster

Khan

(2021) Citizenship (Amendment) Act 2019 and international law. Report, Melbourne: Peter McMullin Centre on Statelessness, April.

30.

Foster

Lambert

(2019) International Refugee Law and the Protection of Stateless Persons. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

31.

Foster

Roberts

(2021) Manufacturing foreigners: the law and politics of transforming citizens into migrants. In: Dauvergne

Catherine

(ed) Research Handbook on the Law and Politics of Migration. MA: Edward Elgar Publishing, 218–234.

32.

Lok Sabha (2019) Report of the joint committee on the citizenship (Amendment) Bill 2016. New Delhi, January.

33.

Ministry of External Affairs (2020) Press Note. 3 March, 2020. Available at: https://mea.gov.in/press-releases.htm?dtl/32449/press+note (accessed 18 February 2022).

34.

Murshid

(2016) Assam and the foreigner within. Asian Survey 56 (3): 581–604.

35.

Mustafa

(2018) Who is a citizen — in Assam, India? Indian Express, 6 June, 2018.

36.

OHCRH (2019) Letter from the working group on arbitrary detention, the special rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression, the special rapporteur on minority issues, the special rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance and the special rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief, to the Government of India. Geneva, May. Available at: https://spcommreports.ohchr.org/TMResultsBase/DownLoadPublicCommunicationFile?gId=24614 (accessed 15 July 2021).

37.

Pandey

(1999) Can a Muslim be an Indian? Comparative Studies in Society and History 41 (4): 608–629.

38.

Pegu

(2004) The line system and the Birth of a public sphere in Assam: immigrant, alien, and citizen. Proceedings of the Indian History Congress 65: 586–596.

39.

Pisharoty

(2019) Interview: ‘August 31 NRC can’t be final without the constitutional Bench’s Verdict’. The Wire, 3 September 2019. Available at: https://thewire.in/rights/final-nrc-assam-sanmilita-mahasangha-interview (accessed 12 May 2022).

40.

Price

(1997) The Assam movement and the construction of Assamese identity. PhD thesis. UK: The University of Bristol.

41.

Rahman

(2020) Identifying the ‘outsider’: an Assessment of foreigners tribunals in the Indian State of Assam. Statelessness and Citizenship Review 2(1): 112–137.

42.

Ratcliffe

(2019) “A nightmarish mess”: millions in Assam brace for loss of citizenship. The Guardian, 30 August 2019. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2019/aug/30/nightmarish-mess-millions-assam-brace-for-loss-of-citizenship-india (accessed 18 January 2021).

43.

Roy

(2010) Mapping Citizenship. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.

44.

Saikia

(2019) The highest Wicket-taker’: Assam’s tribunals are competing to declare people foreigners. Scroll, 19 June, 2019. Available at: https://scroll.in/article/927025/the-highest-wicket-taker-assams-tribunals-are-competing-to-declare-people-foreigners (accessed 3 June 2021).

45.

Seshadri

(2020) CAA and the Devaluation of Secular India. The Hindu Centre, 12 February, 2020. Available at: https://www.thehinducentre.com/the-arena/current-issues/article30789891.ece (accessed 26 October 2021).

46.

Shaheed

(2020) Institutional Discrimination and Statelessness in India. Report, Human rights organisations and professionals in response to the call for submissions by the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief, June.

47.

Sharma

(2011) Empire’s Garden. Durham: Duke University Press.

48.

Sharma

(2012) The immigration issue in Assam and conflicts around it, Asian Ethnicity.” Asian Ethnicity 13(3):287–309.

49.

Sinharay

(2019) To be a Hindu citizen: politics of dalit migrants in contemporary West Bengal. Journal of South Asian Studies 42(2): 359–374.

50.

Tewari

(2021) Not West Bengal, but it’s the Assam polls that is most crucial for Modi-Shah this year. The Print, 13 January, 2021. Available at: https://theprint.in/opinion/politricks/not-west-bengal-but-its-the-assam-polls-that-is-most-crucial-for-modi-shah-this-year/584299/ (accessed 16 June 2021).

51.

Tharoor

(2016) Inglorious Empire: What the British did to India. London: C. Hurst & C.

52.

Weiner

(1978) Sons of the Soil, Migration and Ethnic Conflict in India. Princeton: Princeton University Press.