Hate crime and racial discrimination in Ecuador: The case of Michael Arce in ESMIL

Abstract

For the first time in Ecuador a hate crime was tried in court and led to a conviction. This was the case of Michael Arce, a young Afro-Ecuadorian former cadet who won the trial against Captain Fernando Encalada of the Eloy Alfaro Military School (ESMIL). ESMIL belongs to the Ecuadorian Armed Forces, a state institution considered to be of great prestige and a guarantor of citizens’ rights and democracy, but not for all. Arce suffered in ESMIL 2 months of humiliation and torture. Through a socio-legal analysis this article demonstrates the normalization of racial stereotypes and prejudices, and the sometimes subtle existence of structural and institutional racism in the education and judicial systems. This case represents a pioneering judicial action in Ecuador that legally established and defined new pretrial and trial proceedings in regard to litigation concerning violation of human rights, racial discrimination and hate crimes.

Keywords

Hate crime racial discrimination structural racism human rights social justice Armed Forces Afro-Ecuadorian

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andrade

Ávila

(2009) La transformación de la justicia. Quito: Ministerio de Justicia y Derechos Humanos.

Andrews

(2007) Afro-Latinoamérica 1800–2000. Madrid: Iberoamericana, Vervuert.

Antón

Moreno

(2013) Peritaje Sociojurídico sobre el delito de odio racial en Ecuador. Quito: Fiscalía General del Estado.

Antón

(2016) El delito de odio racial en Ecuador: El caso de una acusación de discriminación contra un cadete afroecuatoriano en las fuerzas militares. Contra Relatos desde el Sur 12(14): 39–48.

Araujo

(2009) Habitar lo social: Usos y abusos en la vida cotidiana en el Chile actual. Santiago: Lom.

CERD (2017) Report of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination. Quito: CERD.

CCE (2014) Constitutional Court of Ecuador. Sentence 13614SFE case 148-11P (17.09.14) . Quito: CCE.

CID (2016) Inter-American Court of Human Rights. Flor Vs. Freire Case. Sentence of 31 August 2016.

COIP (2014) Comprehensive Organic Criminal Code, Official Register Supplement N. 180. (10.02.14). Quito: LEXIS.

10.

DPE (undated) Concise Report on Situations Experienced by Mr. Michael Andrés Arce Méndez, cadet of the ESMIL. Quito: Ombudsman’s Office.

11.

DPE (2012a) Report of the Visit to the ESMIL (18.01.12) . Quito: Ombudsman’s Office.

12.

DPE (2012b) Resolution N. 006 DPE-DINAPROT-54708-HJCA-2012 (28.03.12) . Quito: Ombudsman’s Office.

13.

DPE (2012c) Interview Guide – Arce Case. Quito: Ombudsman’s Office.

14.

De la Torre

(2002) Afroquiteños: ciudadanía y racismo. Quito: Centro Andino de Acción Popular.

15.

De la Torre

Hollestein

(2010) Los medios de Comunicación y la Población Afroecuatoriana, Período considerado 1996–2009. Quito: PNUD.

16.

Díaz

Espinoza

Vizuete

, et al. (2016) Guía informativa, Discriminación hacía el pueblo afroecuatoriano y su representación en los medios de comunicación. Quito: Consejo de regulación y desarrollo de información y comunicación.

17.

Elias

Scotson

(1994) The Established and the Outsiders. A Sociological Enquiry into Community Problems. London: Sage.

18.

ESMIL (2011) Inform: Encalada under the Defensive Procedure N. 54708DN-Prt-DESC-HJCA-2011 . Quito: ESMIL.

19.

Espinosa

(1985) Psicología y sociología del pueblo ecuatoriano. Quito: Banco Central del Ecuador.

20.

FGE (2018a) Criminal Policy Directorate. Unpublished report. Quito: Attorney General’s Office.

21.

FGE (2018b) Automatic Judicial Procedure System and National Directorate of Legal Studies and Statistics of the Council of the Judiciary. Unpublished report. Quito: Attorney General’s Office.

22.

Joint Command of the Armed Forces (2018) Unpublished Report of the Joint Command of the Armed Forces. Quito: Joint Command of the Armed Forces.

23.

García

(2009) Prácticas judiciales, garantías de derechos y carrera judicial. In: Andrade

Ávila

(eds) La transformación de la Justicia. Quito: Ministerio de Justicia, Derechos Humanos y Cultos, pp. 221–252.

24.

Góngora

(2012) Transnational Articulations of Law and Race in Latin America. A Legal Genealogy of Inequality, Working Paper Series, N. 18. Berlin: desiguALdades.net Research Network on Interdependent Inequalities in Latin America.

25.

Góngora

Vera

Costa

(2019) Entre el Atlántico y el Pacífico Negro. Afrodescendencia y Regímenes de Desigualdad en Sudamérica. Madrid: Iberoamericana, Vervuert.

26.

Guillaumin

(1998) Rasse: Das Wort und die Vorstellung. In: Bielefeld

(ed) Das Eigene und das Fremde: Neuer Rassismus in der Alten Welt? Hamburg: Hamburger Edition, pp. 159–171.4.

27.

Hall

(1996) New ethnicities. In: Morlex

Chen

(eds) Stuart Hall, Critical Dialogues in Cultural Studies. London and New York: Routledge, pp. 442–451.

28.

Hernández

(2012) Racial Subordination in Latin America: The Role of the State, Customary Law, and the New Civil Rights Response. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Kindle-Version.

29.

INEC (2010) National Institute of Statistics and Census. Population and Housing Census. Quito: INEC.

30.

Kilomba

(2010) Plantation Memories, Episodes of Everyday Racism. Münster: Unrast Verlag.

31.

Lawrence

Keleher

(2004) Structural Racism in Applied Research Center at UC Berkeley. For the Race and Public Policy Conference – Online.

32.

Meuser

Nagel

(1991) ExpertInneninterviews-vielfach erprobt, wenig bedacht: ein Beitrag von Methodendiskussión. In: Garz

Kraimer

(eds) Qualitative-empirische Sozialforschung: Konzepte, Methoden, Analysen. Westdt: Springer, pp. 441–471.

33.

Lema

(2009) El acceso a la justicia y derechos humanos en el Ecuador. Módulo autoinformativo. San José de Costa Rica: Instituto Interamericano de Derechos Humanos.

34.

Mila

(2020) Criminal liability of legal persons in Ecuadorian law. Ius et Praxis 26(1): 149–170.

35.

Nash

(2019) Cuadernillo de jurisprudencia de la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos. N. 7 Control de Convencionalidad. CIDH: GIZ.

36.

Ocles

(2009) Cuaderno de Etnoeducación. Quito: Municipio Metropolitano de Quito.

37.

Pila

(2011) El sistema de administración de justicia penal y los afroecuatorianos. In: Anton

Pila

Caicedo

(eds) Pueblos Afrodescendientes y Derechos Humanos. Del Reconocimiento a las Acciones Afirmativas. Una perspectiva jurídica, antropológica, social e histórica de los derechos humanos de los afrodescendientes en el Ecuador. Quito: Ministerio de Justicia, Derechos Humanos y Cultos, pp. 167–193.

38.

Rahier

(1998) Blackness, the racial spatial order, migrations, and Miss Ecuador 1995. American Anthropologist 100(2): 421–430.

39.

Rahier

(1999) Mami: qué será lo quiere el negro? Representaciones racistas en la Revista Vistazo, 1957–1991. In: Cervone

Rivera

(eds) Ecuador Racista: Imágenes e Identidades. Quito: FLACSO, pp. 73–111.

40.

Rahier

(2003) Racism stereotypes and the embodiment of Blackness: some narratives of female sexuality in Quito. In: Whitten

(ed) Millennial Ecuador – Critical Essays on Cultural Transformation and Social Dynamics. Iowa: University of Iowa Press, pp. 296–324.

41.

Rahier

(2008) Soccer and the (tri) color of the Ecuadorian nation: visual and ideological (dis)continuities of Black Otherness from monocultural mestizaje to multiculturalism. Visual Antropology Review 24(2): 148–182.

42.

Rahier

Antón

(2019) Anti-discrimination law in two legal cases in multicultural Ecuador: Afro-Ecuadorian organizations and individuals versus Bonil/El Universo, and Michael Arce and Liliana Mendez versus Lieutenant Fernando Encalada/Escuela Superior Militar Eloy Alfaro (ESMIL). Latin American and Caribbean Ethnic Studies 14(3): 270–293.

43.

Roitman

Oviedo

(2017) Mestizo racism in Ecuador. Ethnic and Racial Studies 40(15): 2768–2786.

44.

Robalino

(2013) La aplicabilidad judicial del delito de odio. Perfil Criminológico, Delitos de odio: Un reconocimiento a la igualdad y dignidad. N.7:3 .

45.

STFS (2004) Encuesta Nacional sobre Racismo y Discriminación Racial en el Ecuador, Secretaría Técnica del Frente Social. Quito: INEC.

46.

Stutzman

(1974) Black Highlanders: Racism and Ethnic Stratification in the Ecuadorian Sierra. Washington: Washington University Press.

47.

United Nations Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner (2019) Statement to the media by the United Nations’ Working Group of Experts on People of African Descent, on the conclusion of its official visit to Ecuador, 16–20 December 2019.

48.

Vera

(2015) Dinámicas de la negritud y africanidad. Construcciones de la afrodescendencia en Ecuador. Quito: Abya Yala.

49.

Whitten

(1981) Introduction. In: Whitten

(ed) Cultural Transformation and Ethnicity in Modern Ecuador. Illinois: University of Illinois Press, pp. 1–45.

50.

Walsh

(2010) Raza, Mestizaje y Poder: horizontes colonials, pasados y presentes. Revista Critica y Emancipación 3: 95–124.

51.

Walsh

(2015) Affirmative action(ing)s and postneoliberal movement in South America and Ecuador. Cultural Dynamics 27(1): 19–41.

52.

Wade

(1997) Gente negra, nación mestiza. Dinámicas de las identidades raciales en Colombia. Bogotá: Uniandes.

53.

Wade

(2006) Afro-Latin studies. Latin American and Caribbean Ethnic Studies 1(1): 105–124.