In Belgium a man was convicted for incitement to racial hatred and discrimination because he publicly tore up a Koran, before the eyes of a small group of Muslims. The case fits within a wider development of increasing legal sensitivity to ‘Islamophobia’. This development, however, has several problematic aspects and implications, as is illustrated by a detailed analysis of the case.
AddisonN (2004) Divided Before the Law. Spiked, 17 November.
2.
AddisonN (2007) Religious Discrimination and Hatred Law. Abingdon/New York: Routledge Cavendish.
3.
BremsE (2006) Belgium: The Vlaams Blok Political Party convicted indirectly of racism. International Journal of Constitutional Law4(4): 702–711.
4.
Centre for Equal Opportunities (2012) Film ‘Innocence of Muslims’: Reactie Centrum [Film ‘Innocence of Muslims: The Centre’s Response]. Press release, 18 September.
5.
Centre for Equal Opportunities (2013) Uitspraken RTL-weerman Luc Trullemans: het Centrum reageert [Utterances RTL Weatherman Luc Trullemans: The Centre Responds]. Press release, 3 May 2013.
6.
FissOM (1985) Free speech and social structure. Iowa Law Journal77: 1405–1425.
7.
GilbeyR (2004) Rowan Atkinson: Mr Bean Shows His Serious Side. The Independent, 11 December.
8.
HallidayF (1999) Islamophobia reconsidered. Ethnic and Racial Studies22(5): 892–902.
9.
HareI (2009a) Extreme speech under international and regional human rights standards. In: HareIWeinsteinJ (eds) Extreme Speech and Democracy. Oxford: OUP, pp.62–80.
10.
HareI (2009b) Blasphemy and incitement to religious hatred. In: HareIWeinsteinJ (eds) Extreme Speech and Democracy. Oxford: OUP, pp.298–310.
11.
HolmesCB (2012) Quran Burning and Religious Hatred: A Comparison of American, International, and European Approaches to Freedom of Speech. Washington University Global Studies Law Review11(2): 459–481.
12.
KalvenH (1965) The Negro and the First Amendment. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
13.
JoppkeC (2009) Limits of integration policy: Britain and her Muslims. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies35(3): 453–472.
14.
LarvorBNormanR (2005) Free speech and incitement to religious hatred. Humanist Philosophers’ Group. Available at: www.humanism.org.uk(accessed 5 August 2013).
15.
LesterA (2007) Free speech and religion – The eternal conflict in the age of selective modernization. In: SajoA (ed) Censorial Sensitivities: Free Speech and Religion in a Fundamentalist World. Utrecht: Eleven International Publishing.
16.
LewisA (2007) Freedom for the Thought That We Hate: A Biography of the First Amendment. New York: Basic Books.
17.
MasschelinJFeysJ (2006) Vier maanden cel voor racistische uitspraken in frituur [Four months imprisonment for racist utterances in snack bar]. Het Laatste Nieuws, 16 May, 5.
18.
McGaffeyR (1973) The heckler’s veto: A re-examination. Marquette Law Review57(1): 39–64.
19.
RettmanA (2012) EU to Poland: Artists should be free to ‘shock’. EU-observer, 1 November.
20.
Runnymede Trust Commission on British Muslims and Islamophobia (1997) Islamophobia: A Challenge for Us All. London: Runnymede Trust.
21.
SadurskiW (1999) Freedom of Speech and its Limits. London: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
22.
SottiauxSVrielinkJ (2013) Activism at the admissibility stage: A threat to the subsidiary role of the European Court of Human Rights? In: AlenA. (eds) Liber Amicorum Marc Bossuyt. Cambridge: Intersentia (to appear).
23.
StoneGR (2007) War and Liberty: An American Dilemma: 1790 to the Present. New York: W.W. Norton & Company.
24.
The Week Staff (2012) Does the movie that provoked the Libyan slayings even exist?The Week.com, 13 September.
25.
ToynbeeP (1997) In defence of Islamophobia: Religion and the state. The Independent, 23 October 1997.
26.
Vossen S / Belga (2013) Man krijgt 4 maanden cel voor verscheuren Koran [Man gets 4 months for ripping up Koran]. Het Laatste Nieuws, 6 March.
27.
VrielinkJ (2010) Van haat gesproken? Een rechtsantropologisch onderzoek naar de bestrijding van rasgelateerde uitingsdelicten in België[Speaking of hatred? A Legal Anthropological Study of the Fight Against Race-related Speech Crimes in Belgium]. Antwerp: Maklu.
28.
VrielinkJSottiauxS (2004) De antiracismewet na het Vlaams Blok-arrest [The Antiracism Act after the Flemish block ruling]. Nieuw Juridisch Weekblad75: 718–733.
